Aria’s expression softened further.
"That was a very mature way of looking at things for a child."
"Thank you." Nyx lowered her eyes. "Although, looking back, I sometimes wonder whether I should have spoken up more. There were occasions when I felt sad and uncomfortable, but I thought it would be selfish to make a fuss when everyone else seemed happy."
Livia’s face flushed.
There it was again. Nyx was making herself sound pitiful while dressing every accusation in words of understanding and forgiveness. She was implying that the household had been happy at her expense, that she had been forced to swallow her feelings while Camilla and Livia enjoyed their new position.
And Aria was eating it up.
"Nyx!" Livia snapped. "Will you stop pretending to be so generous? You don’t have to make yourself sound like some saint who sacrificed everything for this family."
The table fell quiet.
Nyx looked at her, apparently taken aback by the outburst.
"Livia. Have I said something wrong?"
"Don’t act as though you don’t know what you’re doing!"
"Livia," Camilla warned sharply, her voice low. "We’re guests here. Mind your tone."
"Why should I?" Livia shot back. "She’s the one sitting here making us look like monsters!"
Edmund’s face darkened.
"That’s enough, Livia."
But Livia was already beyond the point of listening. She had spent years resenting Nyx’s very existence, and seeing her receive sympathy from Aria had stirred every ugly feeling she had tried to contain since the beginning of the evening. Nyx had always been the legitimate daughter, the one whose position in the family could never be erased completely, no matter how thoroughly Camilla and Livia had taken over the household after her mother’s death.
Now Nyx was using that history to make them look cruel.
"I don’t know why everyone is acting as though she’s some poor, helpless girl," Livia continued, her voice rising. "She’s always been selfish. She gets what she wants, and if anyone dares to disagree with her, she acts as though she’s been wronged. That’s exactly what she’s doing now!"
Nyx remained seated, her hands resting neatly beside her plate.
"Livia, please don’t be upset. I never intended to make you feel that way."
The calmness of her reply only made Livia angrier.
"Shut up! Stop talking as though you’re the reasonable one here!"
"Livia!" Camilla’s face had gone pale. "Apologize to Mrs. Cross for your behavior."
"Why should I apologize? She hasn’t said anything wrong!"
"Then stop shouting!"
Livia swung towards her mother, her expression twisted with fury.
"You want me to stop shouting because you’re embarrassed! That’s all you care about! You don’t care what Nyx says as long as she makes you look bad!"
Camilla stared at her in horror.
For all her resentment, Livia had never been particularly good at controlling her temper. She could be spiteful and calculating when she had time to think, but once her emotions took over, she often forgot who was watching. Camilla had spent years smoothing over her daughter’s mistakes, making excuses for her behavior, and ensuring that the consequences fell on someone else. She had not expected Livia to unravel so spectacularly in front of the Cross family.
"Livia, sit down," Edmund ordered.
Instead, Livia turned back towards Nyx.
"You think you’ve won, don’t you? You think because you’re sitting there looking all sweet and innocent, everyone is going to believe you? You were never as helpless as you pretend to be! You always knew how to get what you wanted, and now you’re doing it again!"
Nyx looked at her with an expression of concern.
"I understand that you’re upset, but perhaps we should talk about this when we’ve all calmed down."
That was the final straw.
Livia shot to her feet so abruptly that her chair scraped violently across the floor. Her hand swept across the table, sending her plate crashing to the ground. Cutlery clattered against the tiles, and the sharp sound of breaking porcelain echoed through the private dining room. A glass toppled over, spilling water across the tablecloth.
"Don’t you dare tell me to calm down!"
Camilla rose halfway from her chair, anger spreading across her face.
"Livia! Have you completely lost your mind?"
But Livia no longer cared about her mother’s warnings. Her expression had become venomous, her eyes blazing with a hatred she had made little effort to conceal.
"You disgusting, manipulative bitch! You come here and pretend to be the victim, and everyone is supposed to feel sorry for you! You think you’re better than us because you’re the legitimate daughter? You think that makes you special?"
Nyx watched her without moving.
Livia’s chest heaved as she leaned forward, her fingers curling against the edge of the table.
"You should have stayed miserable and kept your mouth shut! Nobody asked you to sit here and tell your sob stories! If you hate this family so much, why don’t you get out of our lives instead of coming back to ruin everything?"
"Livia, that’s enough!" Edmund roared.
His voice finally penetrated the haze of her anger, but only for a moment. Livia looked at him, then at Aria, whose expression had changed from sympathy to unmistakable disapproval and anger. The realization that she had embarrassed herself in front of the Cross family should have been enough to make her stop.
Instead, she looked back at Nyx and found her still seated, composed and almost disappointingly indifferent.
That expression enraged her more than any insult could have.
"Wipe that look off your face!"
Nyx tilted her head slightly.
"What look?"
"Don’t play dumb with me!"
"I don’t understand what you want me to do, Livia. You’ve been shouting at me for several minutes, and I haven’t said anything to provoke you."
The statement was so calmly delivered that it sounded less like a defense than a simple observation.
Aria’s expression hardened.
"Miss Livia, I think you should sit down and apologize. This is a family dinner, not a place for such detestable behavior."
Livia stared at her in disbelief. Even now, Aria was taking Nyx’s side. The injustice of it burned through what little restraint she had left.
"Stay out of this! You don’t know anything about her!"
"Livia!" Camilla gasped.
Edmund’s face had turned an ugly shade of red. He had wanted Nyx to make a favorable impression on the Cross family, and now Livia was tearing apart that opportunity with every word she shouted. He could already imagine the questions Aria would ask afterward, the awkward explanations he would have to offer, and the damage this scene might do to the relationship he was trying so desperately to secure.
"Apologize," he said through clenched teeth. "Now."
Livia looked from her father to Nyx, searching for some sign that the situation had affected her. She wanted Nyx to look frightened, humiliated, or at least angry enough to reveal the malicious intentions Livia was certain lay beneath her innocent act.
But Nyx gave her nothing.
That composed expression seemed to mock her more effectively than laughter ever could.
With a furious cry, Livia snatched up the nearest glass.
"Since you want to act so innocent, let’s see how you look when I—"
She never finished the sentence.
Nyx moved.
Her chair scraped back as she rose, but the movement was so fast and fluid that nobody at the table properly registered what had happened. One moment, Nyx was seated beside Adrian, her hands empty and her expression calm. The next, she had crossed the small distance between the chairs and seized Livia by the hair.
Before Livia could react, Nyx forced her head down against the table.
The impact landed with a sickening crack.
The porcelain plate beneath Livia’s face shattered, scattering fragments across the tablecloth. A sharp edge caught her skin, and pain burst across her forehead and cheek. The glass slipped from her hand and crashed onto the floor, breaking into glittering pieces around their feet.
Livia screamed.
For a moment, nobody moved. The sudden violence had happened so quickly that the others were still struggling to understand what they had witnessed.
Then Livia began to thrash.
"AH! LET GO OF ME!"
She tried to lift her head, but Nyx’s hand remained tangled in her hair, holding her firmly against the broken plate. Her other hand caught the edge of the table as she struggled to push herself upright, only for Nyx to tighten her grip and press her down again.
"YOU BITCH! LET GO!"
Her scream turned shrill with pain and panic. She could feel something warm trickling down her skin, and the sight of broken porcelain beneath her face made her struggle harder.
Nyx did not budge.
She leaned forward, bringing her mouth close to Livia’s ear. Her hair fell over one shoulder, and her off-white gown remained almost immaculate despite the mess around her. Her expression was so calm that it was difficult to reconcile the woman holding Livia down with the young woman who had spent the last several minutes speaking gently about her childhood.
Nyx lowered her head, her lips curling up as she spoke; her voice was low enough that only Livia could hear it.
"I haven’t even received the apology Edmund promised me and you’re already acting crazy."