When the barge had disappeared beneath the bridge, Lucien folded the paper he had been holding and slipped it into his coat.
"I would like you to come with me to the landing tomorrow," he said. "Not as anything official. Arlen will handle security. I would like someone in the room who watches faces while I look at hands."
Cassian glanced at him. "Why hands?"
"People often reveal what they can afford with their hands. They grip a hat, pull at a sleeve, or hold on to someone beside them. It took me years to notice."
"That sounds like a strange way to judge people."
"It is not a way to judge them. It is a way to notice when they are worried."
Lucien turned from the rail. "It will probably be dull, and you may not find anything useful to do."
"I’ll come."
They returned to the estate together. Edric was waiting in the library with the financial folder under his arm. He had already prepared the final figures for the following morning and wanted Lucien to confirm them before the seal was carried to the landing.
"The approved discount applies to the smallest berth holders, those with three barges or fewer," he explained. "It covers the winter quarter only. The total number of eligible families is forty. Their individual reductions are calculated according to the berths they hold, not according to the number of people in each household."
Lucien looked over the figures. "And the funding?"
"Three-fifths of the cost comes from the household reserve. The remaining two-fifths comes from the ordinary rental income collected from the lower quay this quarter. Those receipts are already included in the calculation. There is no provision for an extension."
"And the vault?"
"Still postponed until spring. The money set aside for the vault has not been touched."
Edric closed the folder. "If the quarter runs over by a week, the house cannot pay for that week. I would ask you to remember that when somebody asks you to make an exception."
"Somebody will."
"Yes. I should be sorry if you could not say no."
Lucien gave him a tired smile. "You make it sound as though you expect me to fail."
"I expect people to ask for more than you are authorized to give. That is not the same thing."
Cassian watched Lucien sign the final page. The young lord seemed comfortable with the figures, but he read each line carefully before handing the folder back.
"Have the treasurer present tomorrow," Lucien said. "I want the berth holders to see that the money is there."
Edric nodded. "I have arranged it."
The hall at the Old Landing was fuller than it had been at the first meeting. Word had spread that Lucien would bring the official seal in person, and several berth holders who had stayed away before had come to see whether the offer was genuine.
The benches were packed. Others stood along the walls or sat on the gallery steps, their coats still damp from the river air. Arlen stood beside the street entrance with one guard near the water door. He had chosen a position from which he could see both the hall and the narrow passage leading to the quay.
Cassian took his place against the back wall. He had expected a gathering of merchants, but most of the people in the room looked like workers. Their clothes were worn, their hands rough from rope and wood, and several had brought children with them.
Lucien stood behind the table and read the agreement aloud. He did not rush through the conditions, even when a few people began shifting impatiently. The discount, its duration, the eligible households, and the financial limits were all stated plainly.
When he finished, the guild treasurer stepped forward. He was a lean man in a black coat, with a narrow face and a habit of adjusting his cuffs. He looked uncomfortable with the attention, but he followed Edric down the back stair to the strongroom.
A dozen berth holders went with them. Cassian followed as well.
The chest stood on a stone shelf behind an iron grate. Edric unlocked it with one key and the treasurer with another. Inside lay several canvas bags filled with silver. The treasurer checked the seals and counted the bags against his own record before confirming the amount.
The gray-bearded man from the first meeting stood near the doorway, holding his cap in both hands.
"So it is there," he said.
"It is," Lucien replied.
The old man leaned forward to look at the chest. "I’ve never seen so much money put aside for people like us."
"It is not a gift," Lucien said. "It is the amount the house has agreed to provide. You can count it, and you can hold us to the terms."
The man studied him for a moment, then gave a short nod.
Upstairs, Lucien broke the wax over the candle and pressed the Vaelthorne ring into it. The thorned circle left a sharp outline in the dark wax. A murmur passed through the hall.
The broad woman who owned three barges came forward first. She signed with a firm, square hand and returned to her seat without saying anything. Others followed. For nearly half an hour, the room was filled with the scrape of pens and the quiet discussions of people checking the terms with their relatives.
Cassian watched their hands as Lucien had asked him to.
Some signed immediately. Others held their papers for a long time, folding and unfolding the corners before approaching the table. One young man signed, crossed out his name, and wrote it again. His older companion had to point to the correct line twice before he finally put the pen down.
Most seemed relieved, but not all of them.
Cassian noticed two women sitting beside each other near the wall. Each held a brass berth tag in her lap. When they turned the tags toward the light, the numbers were identical.
He looked farther along the benches. A man sat beside his brother’s widow, two sisters shared another tag, and a woman had brought her nephew. Each pair held a single berth tag.
Cassian waited until Lucien had finished speaking to a family before approaching him.
"Those people share their berths," he said quietly. "They are not all separate owners."
Lucien looked toward the benches. "How many?"
"At least seven pairs."
Edric came over with the ledger. He checked the list and frowned.
"That accounts for seven shared berths," he said. "The register lists forty households but only thirty-three berth tags. Twenty-six tags belong to one household each. The other seven are shared by two households apiece."
Lucien looked at the ledger. "So the count of families is right, but the number of individual berths is lower than I thought."
"Yes, my lord. The discount was calculated per berth, not per household."
"Then the shared households receive less individually," Cassian said.
"They receive the same reduction for their berth," Edric replied. "But they have to divide its benefit between them."
Lucien looked back at the women. "We should have accounted for that."
"The total was calculated from the berths, my lord, not as a separate payment for each family. The approved sum cannot be expanded today."
Lucien did not argue. He called the seven shared-berth households forward and explained the arrangement himself. He told them that the discount would be divided according to their existing agreements and that he would bring their situation to his father. He made no promise that the amount would change.
Two of the families signed anyway. Another woman folded her berth tag into her palm and left without signing.
Cassian watched her go. He had seen the same expression in Westwood when people accepted help that they knew would not be enough.
The gray-bearded man was among the last to approach the table. He did not take the pen.
"I have four barges," he said. "So I am outside the agreement."
"Yes," Lucien replied. "I am sorry. The terms were approved for smaller operators."
"You brought the seal, and you showed us the money. I won’t say you haven’t done what you promised."
The old man put on his cap.
"But I’ll still hear what Corvane offers."
Lucien nodded. "That is your decision."
The man left through the street entrance. Several others followed him.
By the time the hall had emptied, most of the eligible berth holders had signed, though not all. Edric collected the agreements and began checking the names against the list. Lucien remained by the table, speaking with the people who had questions about the shared berths.
Cassian waited until they were outside before speaking.
"You knew some people would refuse."
"I did."
"Does it bother you?"
"Of course." Lucien adjusted his coat. "But I cannot make the agreement larger simply because I dislike the answer it gives."
Cassian considered that. "Then why bring the seal yourself?"
"Because they should not have to take my word for something the household has formally approved."
He looked back at the hall. "And because I wanted them to see that I was willing to stand there when they disagreed with me."
The meeting with Corvane’s representative took place around midday in the long room above the trade office. Madam Brandt chaired the discussion, with two clerks seated near the windows. Alaric had asked Lucien to attend.
"You will have to live with whatever agreement comes out of this," Alaric had told him that morning. "You should hear how it is made."
The representative was a compact man of about forty-five, with a clipped silver beard and a dark sealskin collar. His name was Brae. He sat across from Alaric with a secretary at his elbow and listened without interrupting as the proposal was presented.
"The renewal clause is the heart of our offer," Brae said when Alaric finished. "It allows us to reduce the rates this winter. Without it, we would be accepting a loss without any guarantee of future business."
"I am not asking you to work at a loss," Alaric replied. "I am offering you something more predictable."
He placed a second sheet on the table.
"Exclusive supply contracts for the east landing. Rope, tar, caulking, and chandlery. Two years, with a price cap of ten parts in a hundred each year. In return, you remove the renewal clause from the winter agreement."
Brae studied the sheet.
"Two years is a short commitment. Three would be more reasonable, with a cap of fifteen."
"Three years would be convenient for you," Alaric said. "It would also make it difficult for the berth holders to change suppliers if your prices became less competitive."
"Then perhaps we should discuss what makes the arrangement worthwhile for both sides."
Alaric leaned back slightly. "You have wanted the east bay of the lower quay since autumn. Half rent for two years, beginning with the spring quarter, alongside the supply contracts. That is a substantial concession."
Lucien moved in his chair.
"The east bay is part of the lower quay’s income," he said. "The winter discount has already been calculated against this quarter’s rents. Are you proposing the lower rent to begin now?"
"No," Alaric replied. "At the start of spring. This quarter’s calculation remains intact, but the concession would reduce what the house retains afterward."
"I see."
Alaric turned back to Brae. "The arrangement would leave a shortfall in the spring, and Father would have to decide whether the household could cover it. I would rather put that question before him than leave forty families tied to a clause that allows Corvane to change their fees."
"And the suppliers?"
"Eleven are included in the proposed contracts," Alaric said. "They would lose some of their trade or sell to Corvane under the new terms. I would rather be honest about that than pretend there is no cost."
"They are people as well," Lucien said.
"Yes. Which eleven should we spare?"
Lucien opened his mouth, then stopped. The question was not fair in every respect, but it was not an empty one either. He could not protect every business and every berth holder with the money available.
Cassian had been listening without speaking. He remembered the lane behind the Old Landing. He had passed it several times while accompanying Lucien and had noticed the small shops along its length.
"There are fourteen," he said.
Alaric looked at him. "Fourteen what?"
"Shops selling rope, tar, and supplies for the barges. Not eleven."
Lucien turned toward him. "Are you certain?"
"I counted them when I walked the lane."
Brae folded his hands. "The eleven in our proposal are the established suppliers with regular contracts. The others are smaller operations."
"Then what happens to them?" Lucien asked.
"They remain free to trade."
"Free to compete with a supplier who has exclusive contracts and can buy in larger quantities," Lucien replied. "The agreement may not include them, but it still changes the market they depend on."
Brae glanced at his secretary. For the first time, he seemed less certain of his answer.
"The market will determine whether they can remain competitive."
"Which market?" Lucien asked.
Alaric remained quiet for a moment. Then he looked at Brae.
"That is a fair concern. We should not pretend those three shops are unaffected simply because they are absent from the contract."
Brae tapped the edge of the paper.
"I cannot guarantee that every small supplier will remain profitable."
"Nor am I asking you to," Lucien said. "But I want the agreement to account for the possibility that the eleven contracts could leave the other three with no meaningful market."
After further discussion, Brae agreed to take the revised terms back to Corvane. The proposal would include two years of exclusive supply contracts, a ten-part price cap, and half rent on the east bay beginning in spring. The renewal clause would be removed if Corvane accepted the final arrangement. The position of the three independent shops would be reviewed before the agreement was signed.
No one signed anything that afternoon.
Still, the original offer had changed. Alaric had secured a serious concession, and Lucien had identified a problem that could not be ignored.
When the meeting ended, Alaric gathered his papers.
"You noticed something useful," he said to Cassian. "Most people would have accepted the number because it was written down."
"I had walked past the shops."
"That is often enough."
There was no particular warmth in his voice, but neither was there mockery. He gave Cassian a brief nod before leaving with his secretary.
Tull had stood against the wall throughout the meeting, his warhammer resting beside his leg. He had said nothing. When Brae’s secretary dropped a stack of papers near the end, Tull bent down, collected them, and placed them squarely on the table.
The secretary thanked him. Tull nodded once.
Across the room, Arlen watched him for a moment before turning back to Lucien.
On the stairs, Edric caught up with them.
"If the east bay goes to half rent in spring, the lower quay will bring in less than we planned to retain," he said. "The discount itself remains funded for the winter quarter. The problem is what happens afterward. We would have one-tenth less than expected for maintenance and future expenses."
"Could the difference be covered?" Lucien asked.
"Possibly. But that would require your father’s approval. The reserve authorized for the winter discount cannot simply be used again."
Lucien nodded. "And the three independent shops?"
"We should speak to them before the office votes. Their position may change how we assess the supply contracts."
The three of them stepped outside. A line of lizard carts passed along the street, carrying crates toward the river. Cassian watched them until they disappeared around the corner.
Lucien turned to him.
"You found those shops because you were paying attention. I would like you to come with us tomorrow."
"To speak to them?"
"To see what they actually do. Edric can explain the financial side. I want to understand whether they have customers beyond the east landing and whether the proposed contracts would leave them with anything."
Cassian shrugged. "I can come."
"Good. Arlen will join us."
Edric was already thinking ahead. "I will prepare the contract figures and ask Madam Brandt for the names of the three owners."
Lucien looked back toward the trade office. "Alaric has made a serious proposal. I won’t reject it simply because I dislike the consequences, but I won’t approve it without knowing what those consequences are."
He started down the street.
Cassian followed. The day’s work had not settled the dispute, but it had changed its shape. Lucien had brought the seal to the landing, Alaric had found a way to challenge Corvane’s original terms, and the next decision would depend on three small businesses that had not even been included in the first proposal.
For once, Cassian had something useful to do that did not involve searching through old records. He was not sure whether the three shopkeepers would welcome their questions, but he intended to find out.