Lucien did not wait for dinner. He went to his brother’s study with the folded sheet in his hand and asked Cassian to come along, which surprised Cassian enough that he said yes before asking why.
"I would like someone in the room who is not family," Lucien said on the stairs. "Afterward you can tell me whether I sounded reasonable. I am not sure I will know."
Alaric’s study was a neat room on the second floor, with a desk, two chairs, and shelves of ledgers squared along the edges. Alaric sat behind the desk with Brae’s draft open in front of him and a pencil in his hand. He did not look surprised to see them.
"I wondered when you’d come," he said. He took the sheet, read it once without any change of expression, and set it down. "Credit, an audit, a hearing for the three. Those are the right three."
"You knew about the sticks."
"I had heard there was a problem with the credit terms. Marrow mentioned it to one of my men on Tuesday." Alaric tapped the draft. "I raised the matter with Brae on Wednesday. He told me the contract was the contract, and that extending credit without a limit would leave the suppliers carrying too much risk."
"You did not tell me."
"I had no solution to offer you. Knowing that something was wrong and knowing how to fix it are different things." He leaned back slightly. "I also had no reason to believe you had seen the problem for yourself."
"You could have told me what Marrow said."
"I could have. But I would rather you understood the problem than simply repeated someone else’s complaint." His tone remained matter-of-fact. "And now you have something concrete to bring to the table."
Alaric glanced at Cassian. "You saw the sticks, I understand. A good eye."
"Yes," said Cassian.
Lucien let a moment go by. Then he said, evenly, "Next time, say so."
"Next time, I will." Alaric pulled a sheet of paper toward himself. "Now the difficulty. I’ll be plain, since you’ve been plain with me. Brae will not sign open credit. If a crew can run up any sum on a stick through the winter, he is lending money without knowing how much, and he will price that risk into everything else. The cap will rise by some other door. A ceiling is the honest price."
"What ceiling?"
"Eighteen silver per household, tallied by the supplier and reported quarterly. Anything outstanding at the end carries no interest for sixty days." He wrote the figure down. "It is less than the need. Edric will tell you thirty."
"Twelve silver short per household, across forty-one berths."
"Yes. I can’t make Brae lend what he refuses to lend. If you ask for the whole sum, he walks, and the renewal clause comes back to the table." Alaric looked up. "I would rather take eighteen than lose the lot."
Lucien turned the sheet over, as if the answer might be on the back. "The audit?"
"The trade office and the guild treasurer, jointly. It costs perhaps eight silver a month, and the office can bear it." He wrote that down too. "The hearing is harder. The eleven have an exclusive arrangement. I cannot give three more suppliers a contract without breaking it. A standing hearing, and a first right of consideration in the second year, I think Brae can swallow."
"That is not a place at the table."
"It is a chair near it." Alaric did not smile. "It is more than they had yesterday."
Cassian watched Lucien work through it. He could see the point where his friend wanted to argue and the point where he decided not to, and he thought, not for the first time, that it was a harder thing to do than it looked.
"Eighteen," said Lucien at last. "And the cap applies to credit sales as well. No charge for tallying, no extra on the price for taking a stick."
"Agreed."
"And the hearing goes first on the next agenda."
"I can promise to ask for it."
"Then we have a compromise," said Lucien, and reached for the pencil.
The long room above the trade office was full by the second bell. Twenty-three factors sat along the benches in their dark coats, with their ledgers open on their knees, and Madam Brandt presided from a high chair at the end with a gavel she did not appear to need. Cassian stood against the back wall. He could see Ostle near the front, in his black sleeve guards, looking at his hands.
Alaric spoke first. He moved that the office recommend a modified arrangement: the renewal clause removed, winter credit permitted up to a ceiling, the cap audited jointly, and the excluded suppliers given a standing hearing. He did not use notes. He gave the figures, answered the first two objections before anyone could raise them, and then took a folded letter out of his coat and laid it on the table in front of the chair.
"Master Brae has signed," he said. "This morning. The terms are as I have described them."
A murmur went along the benches. It was a different sound from the one Lucien’s speeches had drawn, and Cassian understood the difference after a moment. Nobody had been asked to trust anyone. There was a signature.
Lucien rose when Madam Brandt called him. He said that he had visited the three suppliers who had been left out of the arrangement, and what he had found there was the winter credit that kept the east landing fed, which the original contract would have ended. He did not make a speech about it. He said what Clause Nine had meant, and what it now meant, and that he would be satisfied if the office wrote the hearing into its minutes before it adjourned.
"Lord Lucien raised the credit term," said Madam Brandt, when he had sat down. "Lord Alaric obtained it. I would like the minutes to say both."
"I would be grateful," said Alaric, with a slight bow toward his brother.
There was one objection, from a heavy factor near the middle who thought the guild treasurer had no business in the office’s books. Alaric answered it by agreeing that the treasurer’s access should be limited to the cap’s records, and the man sat down looking almost cheated of an argument. Another asked whether giving three tar-boilers a hearing would encourage every shop in the city to demand one.
"It will encourage them to bring their figures to a table where we can see them," Lucien said. "I think that is better than the lane."
The vote was nineteen to three. Ostle voted yes without looking at anyone, and Cassian saw his shoulders drop as the gavel came down.
They went out into the stairwell together, Lucien, Edric, and Cassian, and stopped on a landing out of the stream of departing factors. Lucien leaned his back against the wall.
"He brought Brae’s signature," he said.
"He did," said Edric.
"I brought the idea. It is a good idea." He rubbed his face with his hand. "I could have talked for an hour, and they would have nodded, and nothing would have happened. He laid down a letter and it was over."
"The credit term is in the contract because you asked for it," said Edric. "I have read the minutes. They say so."
"They say that I raised it. They say that he obtained it." Lucien shook his head, not bitterly. "Both true. I am only learning which one counts."
Cassian did not say anything. He had been thinking about it since the study. Lucien had walked into that room with arguments and left with part of what he wanted, and Alaric had walked in with a letter and left with the rest, and the factors had known exactly which of them to follow. It was not the same as the forest, where the one who saw the track first led. He was not sure yet what it was.
"It’s still true," he said. "About the sticks."
"Yes." Lucien looked at him. "That is something."
Edric had taken a small notebook from his satchel. "Eighteen silver per household against the thirty they would normally need leaves a gap of twelve. Across forty-one berths, that could amount to four hundred and ninety-two silver over the period. The independent suppliers can extend smaller amounts of credit on lamp oil and nails, but I would not count on them covering the whole difference. We will know more once the first accounts come in."
"Thirty days?" said Lucien.
"The audit’s first report is due then. It will show how much of the credit ceiling is actually being used and how much remains uncovered. If the gap is still significant, the house will have figures to support a further request."
"Then we wait for the report."
"And the hearing for the three at the next sitting. I will see that it is entered."
"Thank you, Edric."
"It is only the minutes."
Footsteps sounded on the stairs below them. Alaric came up, alone, with his coat over one arm and the look of a man who had slept well. He stopped on the landing and nodded to Lucien, to Edric, and then to Cassian.
"A good morning’s work," he said. "Well done, Luc."
"Thank you."
"Cassian. If you have an hour tomorrow, I should like to talk. It has nothing to do with the quay."
"All right," said Cassian.
"Good." Alaric went on up the stairs toward the office, with his coat still over his arm, and the sound of his steps faded into the murmur of the room above.
Lucien watched him go. "I am not going to tell you what to say."
"Good," said Cassian.
"I only ask that you tell me afterward." He pushed himself off the wall. "I would rather hear it from you than from the household."
"I’ll tell you."
They went down the stairs into the street, where the drizzle had stopped and the lane behind the Old Landing was loud with the morning’s work, and nobody spoke much on the way back up the hill.