I really love these characters as they are in canon, so as much as possible I try to avoid OOC and stick to their personalities. But I still can’t avoid being biased sometimes, so I decided to follow my own interpretation of their characters — though researching fandoms, forums, and popular character analyses also helped a lot.
I’ve chosen these men not because they’re popular or deemed the HOTTEST men in anime. It’s because they don’t have any official love interest. As much as I love handsome guys, I also dig CPs. If you ask me to add Kirito to the harem, I’ll go berserk! Kirito is Asuna’s, no debates there. Does that make sense?
Except for Jinwoo, of course. Some fans said the romance in Solo Leveling was forced just so a new generation could carry Part 2 (don’t fight me, that’s what I also think!).
The harem so far:
Levi — Ari thinks he’s "delicate." Though he’s a bit of a tsundere, he’s the most vulnerable of them. He knows where he stands, and when he acts possessive toward Ari, he does it in a way that isn’t intrusive — he’s like a green tea white lotus. He’ll look at Ari with tears in his eyes, and she just... melts. (I find this character contrast veeerrry charming, sigh...) But he’ll still call the other men "pieces of shit."
Gojo — He’s the most vocal and expressive about jealousy and possessiveness. (He’s my favorite son-in-law. Favorite to torture cough)
First off, he was born privileged — he’s the "Strongest," the "Honored One" — and finding interest in Ari wasn’t just because she’s very beautiful, but because seeing someone more "honored" than him sparked his interest at first. Then it went deeper. Like Levi, he’s not the kind to say "I love you." To him, that goes without saying, and honestly, Ari doesn’t care.
Second, he thought he had her in the bag, never expecting much competition and never thinking his self-confidence could handle sharing. But what can he do? He can’t kidnap her, and the other men are stronger than the other. Acting like a spoiled child is his way of getting attention (though it backfires).
Lastly, he’s busy getting power-ups, training, teaching the kids, and finding ways to solve curses without relying on his very powerful rivals (I haven’t written any details about this yet — there will be, in due time), so romance really isn’t his top priority.
Laxus — Same tsundere vibe, same born-privileged streak, but he’s more grounded. He can’t act vulnerable like Levi, and he doesn’t think he’s strong enough or favored enough to act willful like Gojo, so he’s the most relaxed of all these men. His starting point with Ari (a one-night stand) mostly contributes to that — he figures whatever he’s been given, he’ll accept. He struggles to find his position, but at the same time, his inaction is what catches Ari’s attention when she’s tired of the other men’s antics (lectured and advised by Lucy’s Palace Intrigue 101).
Illumi — Ugh, imagine if this guy said "I love you" — everyone would think he’s possessed. Illumi’s main reason for being in the harem is to take advantage and get more opportunities for his family. So he doesn’t care if she has more and more men. He’s clear-headed — he knows it’s impossible to be the only one, so he plays his cards right. He knows Ari likes his face and the variety he brings to the harem, so he sticks to it. He knows that though Ari doesn’t promise anything, her actions show she cares a little bit. Besides, whatever slips through her fingers is still a huge boost for his family. He’ll take whatever he can get.
White — I struggled a long time to bring this guy into the harem. Though he was introduced early, his smut came a bit later — I researched really hard for this. In canon, he’s asexual, with no real desires, so the "feeling human" he experiences with Ari is a low-quality deus ex machina (we listen, and we don’t judge). His attraction to Ari is like finding something interesting — like an experiment — since "love" is a foreign thing to him. But feeling human with Ari is already the most intriguing thing he’s ever encountered.
Jinwoo — This guy is simply the sweetest thing (hehe). Anyway, I selected the Demon Castle Arc to insert my AU because he wasn’t that high-level yet, not yet a full-fledged Shadow Monarch, and his encounter with Cha Hae-In (Jeju Island arc) hadn’t happened yet (ugh, I made it sound like stealing someone else’s man is very systematic, lol). No, tbh, he’s the most normal among all of Ari’s men. His confession, his feelings — I really enjoyed writing them. The smut isn’t simply a quick fuck, it’s... err, I can’t find the right words, but anyway — he deserves Ari’s tenderness.
Before Jinwoo, I found the men in the harem all had a domineering CEO persona, which I feel isn’t a good thing. So Gilgamesh will have to take a backseat for now. Anos? Ugh, this guy has his own ambiguous harem trope, so I may not add him — maybe... who knows.