My Step-Daughters Are The Villainesses · Contents

CHAPTER 269

Chapter 269: Shana’s Dream

9 min read·Rumlake

Shana had been sitting on the grass with the sisters for nearly an hour, answering questions about Anna-Maria.

At first, she had chosen her words carefully, conscious that Airam and Hermione were still watching her with suspicion. That caution had gradually given way to enthusiasm. Every answer brought another question, and Shana did her best to respond, though much of what she knew had come from stories rather than anything she had witnessed herself.

She was only in her early twenties. When Anna-Maria had still been active within the Crimson Garden, Shana had been around the sisters’ age, a young witch attending lessons and doing as she was told. She had possessed little freedom to go anywhere beyond the parts of the Coven permitted to students, much less seek out its Matriarch.

There had been no opportunity for her to approach Anna-Maria and speak with her. Most of what she knew had been gathered from older witches, from whispers exchanged after lessons, and from conversations among girls who had admired the same woman without ever expecting to meet her properly.

The sisters soon realised just how deeply Shana shared that admiration.

Whenever she spoke of Anna-Maria, her face brightened. The nervousness with which she had entered the courtyard receded, and her eyes shone as she repeated stories she had evidently remembered for years. Occasionally, she seemed to catch herself becoming too enthusiastic and tried to speak with the restraint expected of their new tutor. It rarely lasted beyond the next question.

She looked younger when she smiled like that. Even Hermione found it difficult to keep regarding her solely as one of the witches who had tried to take them away.

Neither she nor Airam was inclined to object to someone speaking so warmly about their mother. They listened with a pride they made little effort to conceal, exchanging glances whenever Shana described how much Anna-Maria had been respected. The woman they remembered had never needed to tell them how important she was. Hearing it from someone outside their family pleased them more than either sister would have admitted at the beginning of the morning.

Shana’s admiration was also plainly sincere. She was not choosing compliments merely to win their favour; sometimes she became so absorbed in what she was saying that she seemed to forget she had reason to seek it. That did more to soften Airam and Hermione’s opinion of her than a carefully prepared apology could have done.

They were, after all, Anna-Maria’s beloved daughters and very much mommy-girls. Anyone who loved speaking about their mother had found a rather easy way past their defences.

Esther was enjoying herself even more openly. She leaned forward whenever Shana began another story, listened with wide eyes, and interrupted only when a question became too pressing to keep to herself. Her excitement encouraged Shana, who answered her with the same eager smile.

Esther had always known their mother was a powerful witch. Airam and Hermione had told her so, and she had memories of her own. But her sisters’ accounts belonged to the familiar world of their family. Hearing another witch speak of Anna-Maria as someone admired throughout the Crimson Garden made that greatness feel different, something that had existed long before Esther was old enough to understand it.

For Airam and Hermione, the stories were less of a revelation. They already knew how impressive their mother had been. What they wanted was to learn more about the part of her life they had barely seen: the years when she had ruled as Matriarch, before she lost her powers and took them away.

As their questions became more precise, Shana’s answers became less certain. She could repeat what people had said about Anna-Maria, but she could not describe many occasions when she had seen her use her power. More than once, she admitted that she did not know whether a particular story was entirely true.

Eventually, Hermione sighed.

"You don’t know much in the end."

She sounded disappointed rather than hostile. She had enjoyed listening, but an hour of praise had not answered quite as many of her questions as she had hoped.

Shana’s smile faltered. She lowered her gaze briefly, embarrassed to have offered so much excitement and so little firsthand knowledge.

"Unfortunately, the Matriarch had many duties," she said. "Anna-Maria did not visit the branch covens unless there was a reason for her to come. I belonged to one of those branches, so I rarely had any chance to see her."

The Crimson Garden was one of the greatest witch covens and one of the Original Covens. Its name covered far more witches than could reasonably live together in a single place. It had therefore been divided into several branches, each with its own members and a Mother responsible for them.

Shana had been born and raised in one of those branches. It was hidden in the south of Skargardia, and its Mother served under the current Matriarch. For Shana and the other young witches studying there, that branch had been the whole of their everyday world. They heard news from elsewhere in the Crimson Garden, but hearing about other witches was very different from being allowed to visit them.

"The Matriarch lives in the main Coven," Shana continued. "Ordinary witches are not even told where it is. The Mothers know, but they keep that knowledge to themselves."

She had grown up knowing there was a main Coven without knowing how to find it. It had been spoken of as a real place and the distance of somewhere she might never be permitted to enter. Anna-Maria had ruled from there, which explained why Shana knew her chiefly through the words of others.

The sisters were already familiar with the way covens were organised, but Shana’s explanation filled in details they had never had much reason to consider. Their experience of the Crimson Garden had not been that of an ordinary student in a branch. They had lived there when they were small children as Anna-Maria’s daughters, watched closely and treated as children whose power held particular importance.

Airam and Hermione had seen the main Coven themselves.

They remembered a place of extraordinary size and beauty, so big that calling it merely a coven hardly seemed sufficient. To children, it had felt almost like a kingdom, with far more to see than they could take in during their stay. Even now, Hermione could remember being impressed by it despite the unease the memory carried.

Airam remembered its grandeur too. She had never doubted that their mother had once belonged at the heart of something powerful. Shana’s account made clearer just how far removed that place had been from the lives of most witches who bore the Crimson Garden’s name.

But neither sister felt any wish to return. Whatever they remembered of its beauty, their mother had been the part of it that mattered to them. Without Anna-Maria, the main Coven was simply a magnificent place they had once seen, and one to which they felt no attachment at all.

"I suppose you have been there yourselves, as Anna-Maria’s daughters?" Shana asked hesitantly.

She sounded a little bolder now. The sisters had listened to her for nearly an hour, and Hermione no longer seemed ready to challenge every word she said. Speaking about their mother had made it easier for Shana to forget, for a moment, how uncertain her place among them remained.

Esther glanced toward her older sisters. She had no memory of the main Coven and could offer nothing to the conversation. Until now, she had been listening to Shana describe what other witches thought of it. The possibility that Airam and Hermione remembered being there made her curious all over again.

"We have," Hermione replied with a nod. "It was very big, and beautiful. It certainly deserved to be called the main Coven."

Shana’s eyes brightened.

"Amazing... I wish I could see it one day."

The words escaped before she had considered them. She looked away with a small, longing smile, remembering how often she had said the same thing as a student.

For witches raised in the secondary branches, admission to the main Coven was something to dream of. It meant that the Mothers had noticed them, that their abilities had earned recognition beyond the place where they had been born. Girls spoke about it during their lessons and imagined what they would do if they were ever summoned there. Shana had listened to those conversations eagerly and taken part in more than a few.

The witches born within the main Coven had advantages that those in the branches could only envy. They grew up in the place others hoped to reach, with no need to spend years wondering whether they would ever be considered worthy of entering it. For a witch like Shana, raised in a secondary branch and known chiefly to the people who taught her there, such an invitation was far harder to obtain.

The main Coven had stood for 3000 years, since the birth of the Original Covens. That age alone had made it difficult for Shana to imagine. Everything she had heard described a place carefully preserved, still beautiful despite the centuries that had passed over it. She had tried to picture its halls and grounds so many times that hearing Hermione confirm its beauty brought back an old excitement she had almost forgotten.

Yet even before her imprisonment, Shana had possessed little prospect of going there. Wanting to see it had never been enough. She had been a young witch in a branch Coven, still learning, with nothing to suggest that an invitation would come.

And now she had even less reason to hope.

Her smile slowly faded. She had spoken as though she still belonged to the Crimson Garden, as though she could return to her lessons and perhaps distinguish herself enough to be admitted one day. But her own Coven had left her beneath Rubenhart Estate for two years. No one had come for her. Whatever place she once held among them had been abandoned as surely as she had.

Now she had agreed to serve Ulrich. She had given him her obedience and her loyalty, and he had brought her out to teach Anna-Maria’s daughters under his authority. Even if her former Coven learned that she was alive, would it welcome a witch who had accepted a place in the Count’s household? Would it let her return to the branch, much less grant her entry to the main Coven?

Shana could not believe that it would.

She lowered her gaze to the grass and let out a deep sigh. The dream had come back so easily while she spoke with the sisters. Accepting that it no longer belonged to her was much harder.