My Step-Daughters Are The Villainesses · Contents

CHAPTER 284

Chapter 284: Was it out of Kindness?

9 min read·Rumlake

“There is no need to keep apologizing,” Ulrich said, watching Monika still crying apologies.

Monika looked up a little.

“I explained what happened. That is all.”

She nodded, though it took her a moment to trust that he meant it.

There was no promise in his explanation. She understood that. He had not said anything that changed the distance between them or invited her to imagine a future he had never offered. He was simply making certain she did not continue believing something untrue.

Yet the fact that he had chosen to do so mattered.

He had noticed that she was hurt. Rather than dismiss it as a servant’s foolish concern, he had put down his pen and spoken to her about it. Monika could not mistake that for more than it was, but neither could she pretend it meant nothing.

Perhaps that was why she found the courage to ask another question.

It was one she had carried for years, sometimes bringing it close to her lips before deciding that there was no reason to trouble him with it. She had always believed she knew part of the answer. She had never heard it from him.

“My lord… may I ask you something?”

Ulrich nodded.

Monika pressed her hands together. Asking permission had been easy enough. Now that she had it, the question seemed much harder to say.

“Why did you choose to take me as your maid that day?”

His gaze remained on her.

She looked at him through eyes still bright with tears.

“At my uncle’s house,” she added. “Was it out of kindness, or—”

“No.”

The answer stopped her.

Ulrich did not soften it, and for a brief moment Monika wondered whether she had been foolish to ask. She had built so much gratitude around that day that hearing him deny the word kindness agitated her.

Then he continued.

“What I saw was unsightly. Especially from nobles.”

Monika remembered the corridor at once: Aronn’s hand in her hair, his friends holding her against the wall, and the voice that had made all three boys stop. She had never forgotten how quickly their confidence disappeared when they recognised Ulrich.

He had not asked her to explain what they were doing. He had seen enough.

“As for why I asked to take you into my service…”

Ulrich paused.

He had given his father practical reasons at the time. Monika was educated, could read and write, and had been raised to understand the conduct expected in a noble household. She would be useful. Those things had been true, and the years since had proved his judgment sound.

They were not the whole reason he had spoken.

He looked at her now and remembered the thirteen-year-old girl on the floor, trying to gather herself while tears still ran down her face. He had understood without being told that she had little reason to feel safe in the house. Her father was dead, her uncle had secured the territory, and the boy who would inherit after him had already begun treating her as though she belonged to him.

Her tears had brought someone else to mind.

Ashara.

Monika looked nothing like her. There had been no resemblance he could reasonably point to, no shared manner or expression that explained it. Yet he had recently made Ashara cry again, and the memory had remained with him more strongly than he wished.

Seeing another girl in tears had stirred the same discomfort.

With Ashara, he had caused it himself. In that corridor, he had arrived after someone else had done the damage. He could stop Aronn, but once he and his father left, Monika would still be in the same house with the same people.

Ulrich had known she would not want to remain there.

When the documents were signed, he had seen an opportunity to take her away without making an argument of it. He gave Eurich a reason that suited the household, and Heron a question he would find difficult to oppose.

At the time, the impulse had been sudden. Looking back, it was no harder to understand.

He had seen her crying, thought of Ashara, and found that he did not want to leave her there.

“It was personal,” Ulrich said. “Do not mistake it for an act of kindness or compassion.”

He wanted that distinction understood. Monika had carried her gratitude for years, and he had no wish to let it rest on an image of him that was not true. He had not gone to the Becker mansion intending to rescue anyone. Seeing what happened in the corridor had stirred something he preferred not to examine, and he had acted on it when an opportunity presented itself.

That did not make him a compassionate knight in shining armor who had arrived to deliver her from every misfortune.

Monika understood what he was trying to say. To his surprise, she gave a small chuckle.

There was no disappointment in her face. If anything, the bluntness of his answer seemed to restore some of the ease she had lost since the previous night. She had known him too long to expect him to accept praise merely because someone offered it sincerely. His insistence on correcting the reason for her gratitude was so characteristic of him that she found herself smiling.

“Personal as it may have been, my lord, you saved me,” she said. “You gave me another life. I will always be grateful for that.”

Her usual brightness had begun to return.

He could call the decision personal, practical, or anything else he wished. Monika did not believe the name he gave it changed what followed. She had left a house where she no longer felt safe and come to one where there was a place for her.

The Rubenhart Estate had become her home.

She had found friends among the maids, women with whom she could work, complain over a difficult task, or laugh when no one important was nearby to hear. Fabian had treated her with a patience she had not expected from a man responsible for keeping the household in order. In time, his concern for her had become so familiar that she no longer felt quite so alone whenever she remembered her father.

And she had found a duty she loved.

There had been frightening days at the beginning, when she knew little of what Ulrich expected and worried constantly about displeasing him. Those had passed. She learned his habits, became useful to him, and discovered satisfaction in doing the work well.

More than that, she had been allowed to remain close to the man she admired most.

Ulrich’s reasons did not make any of those things less precious to her.

He looked at her for a moment, then gave a slight nod.

“As long as you understand that nothing happened last night.”

Monika’s cheeks flushed immediately.

“T—That was shameful of me, my lord! You are the Count. I should not concern myself with your private affairs…”

It was the proper answer, though it did not describe everything she felt. If what she imagined had truly happened with Shana, she knew she would still have been hurt. Hearing the explanation had brought far too much relief for her to pretend otherwise to herself.

She could not tell him that.

Doing so would make it sound as though her years of service had earned her a right to question whom he chose to spend time with. He owed her no such explanation. That he had given one anyway was something she would remember, not something she intended to turn into an expectation.

“Let us end the subject,” Ulrich said. “Bring Shana here.”

“Yes, my lord.”

Monika nodded. The instruction gave her something ordinary to do, and she was grateful for it. She turned toward the door with none of the hesitation she had shown when entering, opened it, and left.

Ulrich watched the door close behind her.

Once again, he had done something he would scarcely have considered before.

He had interrupted his work to explain himself. Not because Monika’s misunderstanding affected her duties, although her absence that morning had been inconvenient but because he disliked remembering the way she looked when she left his office.

That was harder to dismiss.

He had always considered her important to the household. Unlike some of the other maids, she did not become so flustered by a simple instruction that she forgot what he asked for. There had been awkwardness when she first entered his service, but she had learned. Now she knew his routines well enough that much of what he needed was ready before he thought to request it.

Her feelings for him had not made her careless.

She was devoted, competent, and familiar with habits he seldom bothered to explain. Those were good reasons to value her. They were also the reasons he had relied upon whenever he considered why he preferred having her attend to him rather than someone else.

Now he had to admit they did not account for all of it.

Monika had remained loyal through years in which he offered little warmth. She had served him when his father still ruled the estate, stayed when Ulrich became Count, and accepted changes in the household that others found difficult. When he gave an order, she carried it out. When something troubled her, she usually tried to resolve it without making it another matter he had to consider.

He had grown used to that loyalty.

Somewhere along the way, being used to her had become affection.

Ulrich frowned slightly.

Did that mean he liked her?

The question was imprecise enough to annoy him. He liked having her in the household; that much was obvious. He trusted her work, preferred her presence, and did not want her to leave. None of those things required the sort of conclusion his thoughts were now approaching.

Yet he could not quite dismiss the question either.

Since Silas’s memories became part of him, he had begun considering his relationships with women in ways he once would have avoided. Feelings he might previously have treated as an inconvenience had become harder to set aside merely because they complicated his life.

Ashara had never truly left his thoughts. Meera had made certain she could not be ignored. Louise had spoken plainly enough that even he had been forced to take her seriously.

And now Monika.

He looked down at the document still waiting beneath his hand.

There was work he could finish before Shana arrived, provided he stopped turning one conversation into a problem that had no immediate answer. Ulrich set the thoughts aside, picked up his pen, and returned to the line he had interrupted.