The first thing Ilya requested after the malfunction was that nobody touch the damaged apparatus.
The second was a written account of everyone who had operated it that evening.
Unfortunately, the supervising student seemed more concerned about the possibility of disciplinary action than preserving evidence.
"There’s no need to make this such a serious matter, Belozersky. The emergency was resolved, and nobody was injured."
"That’s fortunate. I’d prefer to keep it that way."
Ilya understood the student’s anxiety. An unauthorized experimental device malfunctioning inside an academy training facility could result in severe consequences, particularly if the administration discovered that its safety mechanisms had been modified.
However, concealing the incident would be foolish.
The apparatus had accumulated enough mana to overwhelm its ordinary containment system. If Garen hadn’t recognized the problem, several students might have been injured before anyone understood what was happening.
The supervising student eventually agreed to preserve the equipment.
Tristan then insisted that the incident be reported through the academy’s established safety procedures. The student objected, explaining that the society’s engineering committee could conduct its own investigation.
That was where Tristan drew the line.
"Your committee can investigate its equipment. The academy is responsible for the facility and everyone inside it."
His argument was difficult to dispute.
The demonstration had taken place on academy property, using protective formations maintained by Holy Trinity. Any failure involving those defenses deserved attention from the appropriate instructors.
Garen, meanwhile, was examining the regulator’s external controls without disturbing their settings.
He had already identified the altered safety limits, but another detail troubled him.
The modifications hadn’t been made through the apparatus’s ordinary operating panel.
Someone had adjusted the secondary regulator directly.
That required technical knowledge and physical access to the mechanism.
Furthermore, the changes were subtle enough that an ordinary inspection might not detect them.
"Whoever did this knew how the regulator worked," Garen explained. "The safety threshold was increased, but the warning indicators were left unchanged."
Ilya understood the implication.
The apparatus could continue accumulating mana after reaching its intended limit without immediately alerting its operators.
That was dangerous.
However, the alteration didn’t establish that someone intended to injure the participants. An engineer attempting to increase performance might have made the same modification, albeit recklessly.
They needed to determine when the adjustment had occurred.
Fortunately, the apparatus maintained a record of its recent calibration settings.
Garen retrieved the relevant measurements and compared them against the specifications supplied before the demonstration.
The altered threshold appeared in the latest configuration.
The previous one had been normal.
That narrowed the possibilities.
Someone had modified the regulator after its most recent calibration.
The supervising student admitted that several committee members had worked on the apparatus during the previous two days.
He couldn’t identify who had changed the setting.
Ilya accepted that answer for the moment.
There was no benefit in demanding certainty from someone who genuinely lacked the information.
Instead, he requested copies of the calibration records and the names of students authorized to access the equipment.
The supervisor agreed.
By the time they finished documenting the incident, the western training grounds had become considerably quieter.
Most participants had departed, leaving the three companions with a problem none of them had anticipated when they accepted the invitation.
Garen seemed particularly disturbed.
"I checked that machine before we started."
"You checked the visible components," Ilya reminded him. "The secondary regulator wasn’t part of your inspection."
"I still should’ve noticed."
"Then next time, we’ll know to check it."
Tristan agreed.
The responsibility belonged primarily to whoever had authorized the demonstration and prepared the apparatus. Garen had attended as a guest, and he’d reacted quickly enough to prevent the situation from becoming dangerous.
That didn’t make the malfunction acceptable.
It simply meant blaming himself would accomplish nothing.
Garen eventually accepted the reasoning, although he insisted on reviewing the technical records again the following morning.
Ilya had no objection.
In fact, he intended to join him.
The matter had become far more interesting than the society’s ordinary disagreements over equipment access.
The next morning, the academy’s safety office suspended use of the experimental apparatus pending an inspection.
The supervising student received a formal warning for conducting a demonstration without properly documenting its modifications.
The society’s engineering committee was instructed to provide its maintenance records.
Those were sensible responses.
However, the investigation encountered an immediate difficulty.
The committee’s records indicated that the apparatus had been calibrated correctly before the demonstration.
The altered settings weren’t included in the approved configuration.
Someone had changed them afterward.
That established the malfunction’s cause more clearly, but it didn’t identify the person responsible.
Ilya met Tristan and Garen in an empty study room after their lectures to review the available information.
Garen had obtained a copy of the maintenance schedule through ordinary committee procedures.
Six students possessed authorization to work on the apparatus during the relevant period.
Three had participated in the demonstration.
The remaining three were absent.
Unfortunately, the maintenance schedule recorded assigned responsibilities rather than actual access times.
Anyone possessing the appropriate authorization could have approached the equipment without leaving an individual record.
Tristan considered the situation.
"Then we should determine who benefited from the demonstration."
Garen frowned.
"Nobody. The machine nearly exploded."
"Precisely. If the malfunction was deliberate, what was the intended result?"
Ilya had been considering the same question.
The demonstration had originally been organized to evaluate a battlefield-control apparatus. Inviting three recently controversial members was unusual, but their participation also provided an opportunity to observe how they performed under unfamiliar conditions.
The combat exercise itself had been legitimate.
Their opponents had fought competently, and nothing indicated that they knew about the altered regulator.
That suggested the malfunction might have been independent of the fight.
However, another possibility deserved consideration.
The altered safety limits might have been intended to produce a more demanding demonstration, with the resulting danger underestimated by whoever authorized the modification.
That explanation was less sinister.
Unfortunately, it was also more plausible than assuming someone wanted to injure three students inside a protected academy arena.
"We shouldn’t jump to conclusions," Ilya said. "The person responsible might have been trying to improve the apparatus."
"Without telling anyone?" Garen asked.
"That would make them irresponsible. It doesn’t automatically make them malicious."
Tristan agreed.
Nevertheless, he suggested keeping their investigation separate from the society’s executive committee until the academy completed its inspection.
The distinction was important.
The committee had already restricted their privileges following their earlier inquiries. Approaching its leadership with accusations based on incomplete evidence would only worsen their position.
Ilya supported that approach.
They could cooperate with the academy’s investigation while continuing to examine information legitimately available to them.
Their opportunity came that afternoon.
One of Garen’s acquaintances from the engineering committee requested a private conversation.
The student had helped maintain the apparatus before the demonstration and was troubled by the investigation’s findings.
According to him, the regulator’s secondary threshold had been adjusted during an earlier experiment conducted under the authority of a senior committee member.
The modification was intended to increase the device’s operational capacity.
However, the experiment had produced unstable results.
The committee subsequently ordered the apparatus restored to its original configuration.
That restoration appeared in the maintenance records.
Unfortunately, the student suspected the adjustment hadn’t been completely reversed.
Garen examined the explanation.
"Then someone might’ve restored the main settings but forgotten the secondary regulator."
"That’s what I’m afraid of," the student admitted.
Ilya considered the possibility.
It explained the altered threshold without requiring deliberate sabotage.
However, it also suggested that the committee had failed to verify its own safety procedures after experimenting with dangerous equipment.
That was serious enough.
"Who authorized the earlier experiment?" Tristan asked.
The student hesitated.
Then he explained that the project had received approval through the society’s executive committee.
Its technical supervision had been assigned to a senior engineering member.
The name was unfamiliar to Ilya, although Garen recognized it immediately.
The individual belonged to the same restricted project mentioned in the society’s financial records.
That was interesting.
The apparatus had apparently been developed using resources allocated through the confidential expenditure they’d previously examined.
Its modifications were therefore connected to a project whose details the president had declined to disclose.
Ilya understood why the society might wish to keep that information private.
However, confidentiality couldn’t excuse inadequate safety procedures.
He requested that the student provide his account directly to the academy’s investigators.
The student agreed, although he appeared anxious about the possible consequences for the engineering committee.
Tristan assured him that cooperating with a legitimate safety investigation was the most sensible course of action.
By evening, the academy had received the additional information.
Its inspectors expanded their review to include the earlier experiments and the committee’s procedures for restoring equipment after modifications.
Ilya considered that satisfactory progress.
However, the incident had also revealed something troubling about the Thirteenth Society’s internal arrangements.
Several senior members had been conducting experiments using equipment funded through restricted accounts, with limited oversight from ordinary committee participants.
The arrangement might have been entirely legitimate.
Nevertheless, the people responsible had apparently allowed an unsafe configuration to reach a public demonstration.
That was difficult to excuse.
Later that evening, Margarethe von Adlerheim approached Ilya outside the Magic Department.
She had learned about the investigation and wanted to speak with him privately.
The society’s secretary appeared unusually troubled.
"I understand you’ve been assisting the academy’s inspectors."
"We provided the information they requested."
"Of course."
She explained that the executive committee had begun conducting its own review of the incident.
The president was concerned that the society’s reputation might suffer if the investigation revealed serious failures in its engineering procedures.
Ilya understood the concern.
However, reputational damage was a consequence of the underlying problem, not a reason to conceal it.
Margarethe seemed to agree.
After a moment, she asked whether he’d discovered anything connecting the malfunction to the restricted project.
Ilya explained what he knew.
The apparatus had been developed using resources associated with that project, and the earlier experiments appeared to have involved modifications similar to those responsible for the malfunction.
Margarethe listened carefully.
Then she revealed something he hadn’t expected.
The restricted project hadn’t originally belonged to the engineering committee.
It had been established under the president’s personal sponsorship.
Only later had its technical responsibilities been transferred to the engineers.
Ilya considered the information.
That explained why the expenditure had appeared under a restricted designation.
It also suggested that the president possessed a more direct connection to the apparatus than he’d previously acknowledged.
Margarethe seemed aware of the implication.
However, she cautioned him against assuming the president had personally authorized the dangerous modification.
Ilya agreed.
There was still insufficient evidence.
Nevertheless, he now had a clearer understanding of where the investigation should lead.
The society’s president had sponsored the project.
The engineering committee had developed its equipment.
And somewhere between those responsibilities, someone had allowed an unsafe modification to remain in place.
Ilya intended to discover which explanation was correct before deciding what to do next.