The five of them met in the roof room the next morning, before the sun was up.
Brann Holloway came up the stairs first. He stopped in the doorway when he saw Mav, and for a moment, he didn’t seem to know what to do with his hands. Then he crossed the room and hit Mav on the shoulder, hard, the way that boys from the district hit each other when they couldn’t say what they meant.
"They told us that you were dead," he said. "Quill wouldn’t believe it. We thought that she had gone mad."
"She hadn’t."
"No. I can see that." Brann looked at the scar on Mav’s chest, where his shirt was open. "Where were you?"
"Somewhere with no arch," Mav said. "I’ll tell you one day."
Nell came in last, as quietly as always. She didn’t hit anyone. She only looked at Mav from the doorway, as if she were making sure that he was real. Then she gave him her small nod and went to sit in her corner by the window.
Mav thought that she looked relieved, but with Nell, it was hard to tell.
-----
Quill explained the rules once more, because she said that nobody ever listened the first time.
"Each match has five duels. Each duel is fought on the sand of the Great Arena, with Manifestations, like your first round. A duel ends when one fighter yields, when the Arbiter ends it, or when one fighter dies." She looked at each of them in turn. "Subjects die in these duels. Every year, so do a few students. Don’t be one of them."
Nobody laughed.
"Each captain gives the Arbiter the order of his five on the morning of the match. Nobody sees the other side’s order until the first two fighters walk onto the sand. You can’t change it after that." She tapped the table. "So the order is a guess. A good captain guesses well."
"Then I’ll need to guess well," Mav said.
"You won’t have to guess this time," Tamsin said.
They all turned to look at her. She had her slate in her lap, and it was covered with small, tight writing.
"I went to the hall of records last night while you were on Earth," she said. "I watched every match that Emberhall has fought in the last 10 years. Then I read the notes about the 20 years before that." She turned the slate around. "Emberhall is a soldiers’ school. It fights the way that soldiers fight, in a line. Their strongest soldier always goes first, to break the enemy. Their captain always goes last. In 30 years, they have never once changed it. They think that changing it would be cowardly."
"That’s stupid," Ronald said.
"It’s proud," Tamsin said. "It’s not the same thing, but it’s close."
"And the middle three?"
Nell spoke from her corner.
"Vane is fourth," she said quietly. "He asked for it. He wants to be the one who fights you."
Everyone looked at her. She didn’t look up.
"I heard their first-years talking in the yard of the Proving Grounds yesterday," she said. "They didn’t see me. Their first is a girl called Ilsa Brand. Their second is a boy called Osric Hale. Their third is Senna Rook. Then Vane. Then Cassian."
Brann was staring at Nell as if he had never seen her before. Mav looked at her for a while. It was the second time that Nell had brought them something that nobody else could have heard. He was beginning to think that she did it on purpose.
"Thank you," he said.
She nodded, once.
-----
He spent the rest of the day in the hall of records.
He watched every duel that Ilsa Brand, Osric Hale and Senna Rook had fought that year. He watched Edric Vane’s duels six times each. He watched them the way that he had once watched Dorian’s, slowly, again and again, until he could close his eyes and see what came next.
Ilsa Brand had red mantises as tall as a man, with forelegs like swords. She was fast and brutal, and she had never lost. Osric Hale had horned lizards that charged in a straight line, like Ronald’s boars, but heavier. Senna Rook had salamanders. They were small and black, with orange cracks along their backs, and they set fire to whatever they touched.
Edric Vane had improved.
He still fought with his plate lizards, but there were 30 of them now, not 24. They had learned to lock their plates together, side by side, so that 10 of them made a single wall that nothing could move. In his last duel, he had stood behind that wall for four minutes and waited. His opponent had thrown everything at it, and then simply given up.
’He watched my first round,’ Mav thought. ’He knows that my fish need to reach him. So he’ll make sure that they can’t.’
That evening, Mav gave Quill his order.
Tamsin first, against Ilsa Brand. Ronald second. Brann third. Then himself, fourth, against Vane. Nell last, against Cassian.
Quill read it. Then she looked at Tamsin.
"You’re putting her against their best," she said.
"Yes," Tamsin said, before Mav could answer. "I asked him to. I can’t beat Ilsa Brand. Nobody in our year can, except maybe Mav. So I’ll go out there, and I’ll yield before she kills my moths. We’ll lose that duel, but we’ll lose it cheaply." She lifted her chin. "Then we win the next three."
Quill looked at her without speaking. Something moved in her burned face that might have been respect.
"Very well," she said.
-----
Tamsin had one more idea, and she told it to Mav on the stairs.
"The wagers on the match opened this morning," she said. "Emberhall against Wildroot. Do you know what the odds are?"
"No."
"Nine to one." She looked at him over her slate. "Nobody thinks that we can win. Their captain is Cassian Pyrecrest, and ours was declared dead. Mav, your Heartstone is at 78%. A wager isn’t a sale. Goldmantle takes no tax on it."
He understood at once.
"If I bet 1,000 Essence," he said slowly, "and we win, then I get..."
"You get 9,000 back. That’s about a quarter of your stone." She paused. "If we lose, you lose almost 3%. It’s a bad bet for anyone who doesn’t know what we know."
He was confident in his team, so he placed the bet that night, through the Arbiter, without a second thought. The Essence left his Heartstone in a cold rush that he felt in his chest. Ronald placed one too, a smaller one, and grinned about it for an hour.
On his way out of the Proving Grounds, Mav passed the yard where the Emberhall first-years trained.
Edric Vane was standing at the gate. He was tall and square, with his shaved head and his dark red coat buttoned to the neck. He had his hands behind his back, as always. When he saw Mav, he nodded politely.
"Silkborn," he said. "I heard that you came back from the dead. I’m glad. I would have hated to win without you."
"You haven’t won yet."
"No." Vane looked past him, toward the high windows of the Emberhall hall, where a figure with long red hair was sitting alone. "But Cassian is fifth. I’ve told him that he can stay in his seat."
"Because you’ll have won before he needs to fight?"
"He won’t even have to stand up," Vane said.
He wasn’t boasting. Mav didn’t like him, but he couldn’t quite dislike him either. He could hear it in Vane’s voice. He was only stating a fact, the way that a soldier states the number of enemies on a field.