The Arbiter said nothing about the broken wall that night.
House Sunspire’s show said that it had been an accident, a fault in the old stones of the Great Arena. The boy with the cats said that he had seen his captain in danger and that he hadn’t been thinking. House Thornwald sent a letter of apology to Wildroot, signed by Linnea herself. Evergrove took the boy off its team for the rest of the year.
Nobody asked why the Arbiter hadn’t stopped the duel. Mav asked the next morning, in the quiet corner behind the pillar.
“The wall broke during my duel. A second fighter came onto the sand. Why didn’t you end it?”
[That answer is not given.]
He had expected that. It still made him so angry that his hands shook.
He stood behind the pillar for a while, breathing slowly, until the anger went somewhere that he could keep it. The Arbiter had refused him three times now. It had refused to tell him who held his father’s World. It had refused to tell him why he had no third species. Now it had refused to explain why it had let a boy try to kill him on its own sand.
He was beginning to think that the Arbiter wasn’t one thing. Some of it was fair. Some of it answered to someone.
He wanted to tell Quill, but he didn’t. Quill had enough to carry.
—–
Thalia found him that afternoon in the yard of the Proving Grounds.
She didn’t come to the hall of records this time. She didn’t turn up her collar or hide from the glass eyes. She walked straight across the yard in her white coat with the sun of nine rays on the chest, with Perrin and two of her friends trailing behind her, and she stopped in front of him. Everyone in the yard turned to watch.
“Silkborn,” she said.
“Sunspire.”
“You look terrible.” She looked him up and down with her eyes half closed, as if she were judging a horse at the market. The gold dust on her eyelids caught the light. “Did you sleep at all last night?”
“No.”
“Good. Neither did I.” She turned to her friends. “Go away, Perrin. All of you. I want to talk to him.”
Perrin opened his mouth to argue. Then he looked at her face, closed it again and went. The others followed him.
Thalia sat down on the low wall beside Mav, very straight, with her hands folded in her lap. The whole yard was still watching.
“Everyone can see you,” Mav said.
“Yes. That’s the point.” She didn’t look at him. “Last time, I came to you in the dark, where nobody could see. That was cowardly. I decided that I wasn’t going to do it again.”
Mav didn’t know what to say to that. Thalia seemed to expect it.
“You’re supposed to say something kind now,” she said. “Like ‘that’s very brave of you, Thalia,’ or ‘I’m honored, Thalia.'”
“That’s very brave of you,” Mav said.
“That was terrible. Never say anything kind again. It doesn’t suit you.” But she was almost smiling. “You say it the way that other people read a list of the dead.”
“I’m not good at this.”
“I can see that. It’s almost charming.” She smoothed her coat over her knees. “Almost.”
Across the yard, two first-years had stopped pretending not to stare. One of them was writing something down. Thalia looked at them, and they both found something very interesting to look at on the other side of the yard.
“That will be in my mother’s show tonight,” she said calmly. “‘The heir of Sunspire seen with the Silkborn enigma.’ She’ll be furious. Then she’ll be delighted, because it’s a story.”
“Does that bother you?”
“Everything that my mother does bothers me.” She shrugged. “I’ve stopped letting it decide what I do.”
Mav thought about that. He had spent eight years letting other people decide what his name meant. He was only now starting to stop, and it was harder than it sounded.
—–
She told him about the wall first.
“It wasn’t an accident,” she said quietly. “My mother’s people looked at the stones last night. The wall was cut. Someone paid a guard of the arena to open it at the right moment, and the guard is gone this morning. Nobody can find him.”
“Who paid him?”
“A clerk of House Ashgrove.” She said it in a flat voice, without looking at him. “He works in Aldric Ashgrove’s office in the Nexus. He paid the guard 3,000 Essence through two different names, but he didn’t hide it very well.” She paused. “My mother knows. She won’t say anything. She says that it isn’t a story yet.”
Mav sat very still. He thought about Aldric in the box, sitting so still, not looking at him, then standing up to leave.
“And the boy with the cats?”
“Stupid. He saw the wall fall and thought that he could win the match for his school.” Thalia shrugged. “He didn’t know anything. Ashgrove only wanted something to go wrong. They didn’t care what.”
“Why would Ashgrove…” Mav stopped. He knew why. He didn’t need to ask.
Thalia glanced at him sideways. She didn’t ask either. But she was quiet for a moment, as if she were deciding how much she wanted to know.
Then she reached into her white coat and took out a small, folded paper.
“This is how Isolde Frostmere fights,” she said. “My house films every official duel. I watched all of hers last night, every one, since the first round.” She put the paper on the wall between them. “She’s never been beaten. She’s never used her whole pack. She’s never shown her talent. Nobody knows what it is, not even my mother, and my mother knows everything. Her World reached rank D 12 days ago, and her third species came the same morning. She hasn’t shown it to anyone yet.”
Mav picked up the paper. It was covered with small, neat writing, in green ink. It was much better organized than he would have expected. There were drawings of wolves, with arrows. There was a list of every skill that Thalia had seen, and how long each one took to come back.
He read some of it aloud, quietly. “Her wolves have two skills. Rime, a bite that freezes the flesh around it. Whiteout, a howl that fills the air with snow.” He turned the paper. “Her builders have one. Glaze. Ice appears wherever she points, on the ground or in the air.”
“She has 30 wolves,” Thalia said. “In every duel this year, she has used 12 at most. The rest stay behind her, in a line, and they don’t move.” She frowned slightly. “I think that she’s waiting for something. Or for someone worth the rest.”
“Me?”
“Don’t flatter yourself.” But she glanced at him sideways. “Perhaps.”
Mav folded the paper and put it inside his shirt, beside Juno’s letter. His hands weren’t quite steady. He was grateful, and he wanted to thank her properly, but he had already been told never to say anything kind again.
“You did all this last night,” he said.
“I told you that I didn’t sleep. I was busy being useful.” She lifted her chin. “It’s a new thing that I’m trying.”
He looked at her. She was still looking straight ahead, across the yard, at all the people who were pretending not to watch them.
“Why are you helping me?” he asked.
Thalia turned her head and looked at him for the first time. There was gold dust on her eyelids, and there was something in her eyes that he couldn’t read at all.
“I bet on you,” she said. “Don’t tell my mother.”