Mav slept for most of a day after the salt, in the first air hall, on his old bed of dry weed. Nobody woke him. When he finally opened his eyes, his head didn’t hurt anymore, and he could see properly again. There was one of every light.
For a while, he lay there feeling the points in his head, and a slow, warm relief spread through him. Cedar was resting on the rock beyond the broken wall, with Birch asleep on his back. The young were back in the dens, in clean water. Twelve was with them. Sela’s builders were already cutting new blocks for the wall.
Then he got up and went to Wildroot, because Quill had sent for him.
-----
She was waiting in the roof room with a letter on the table in front of her. It was sealed with green wax, the color of the sea.
"Tidecaller," she said, before he could ask. "It came this morning. Sit down."
Mav sat. Tamsin was already there, in her corner with her slate. Ronald was standing at the window with his arms crossed. He didn’t turn around, but Mav could tell that he was listening.
Quill opened the letter and read it out to him.
It was short and very polite. House Tidecaller praised the courage of the World called Submerged and the skill of its master. It regretted the losses on both sides. Then it offered to end the trial of tides by the old way, which the law allowed once in any trial if both sides agreed: a single duel between a champion of each side, in water, in the Flooded Arena of House Tidecaller, in five days.
If Tidecaller’s champion won, Mav would swear at once.
If Mav’s champion won, the claim would fall for one year.
Quill put the letter down. "There’s more," she said. "The letter doesn’t say it, but the old law does. A house that loses a claim pays the winner with one thing from its treasury. The winner chooses."
"Any one thing," Tamsin said slowly, as if she was tasting the words.
"Any one. That’s the law." Quill almost smiled. "Nobody has collected it in 100 years. Nobody has ever beaten Tidecaller."
Mav sat very still. He was thinking about salt water, and in spite of everything, part of him was already looking forward to it.
"How is their arena?" he said.
"Their arena," Quill said. "It’s a big dome of salt water, behind walls of glass. Your fish can only live inside your dome there, and the dome is the first thing that their champion will try to break. Water Jet is almost useless under water. Your eel can’t use Discharge without killing your own fish." She looked at him over the letter. "And their champion has fought in that water all his life. They’ll send someone of your World’s rank, because the law says that they must. But they’ll send the best one they have."
"Do you know who?"
"No. But I can guess." Quill folded the letter. "So can Thalia Sunspire, I imagine."
-----
Tamsin had already filled half a page of her slate.
"Think about the numbers," she said. "There are still 17 days left in the trial. Every raid so far has cost you something. In the first one, you lost 40 young fish. The third cost you Five. The fourth would have cost you every young fish in the dens if my moths hadn’t learned what they learned." She looked up. "Do you think the fifth one will be easier?"
"No."
"Neither do I. Tidecaller never does the same thing twice. Thalia said so, and she was right every time." Tamsin put down her slate. "A duel is one fight. You know when it is, and you know where it is. And if you win, you get something from their treasury." Her eyes were bright with excitement. "Anything you want, Mav. From the treasury of House Tidecaller."
"And if he loses, he swears," Ronald said from the window.
It was the first thing that he had said since Mav came in. He still didn’t turn around, but Mav could hear how worried he was.
"Yes," Quill said. "He swears. That day, in front of the judge. And then everything that he has belongs to Marek Tidecaller."
Nobody said anything for a moment.
"I’ll talk to Two," Mav said.
-----
He went home and found Two in front of the dome, where he always waited.
Mav told him everything. The arena, the salt, the champion, the five days. Two listened without moving. Behind him, the city went on with its work. A line of young needlefish swam past with bundles of weed for the larders, herded by an old one. They were still a little slow from the salt, but they were alive.
"One fight," Two said when Mav had finished.
’One fight, in salt water, in their home. Against someone who has done it all her life.’
"Or 17 more days of raids." Two turned slowly in the water. "Every raid costs us the young. A duel costs only the ones who fight, and the ones who fight are the ones who chose to." He paused. "I would rather it was me than the young."
Mav felt a rush of pride in him, so strong that he couldn’t answer at once. He felt Twelve listening in the dens. She didn’t say anything, but he felt her agree. Then he felt another point turn toward him, old, cold and pale, from the top of the dome.
"I will come," Seven said.
That was all. She didn’t say anything else.
Mav sat on the roof of his cabin until the lights of the city dimmed, thinking. He thought about salt and fresh water, about Cedar, who didn’t care which one he was in, about Sela’s currents and Twelve’s Vortex. Then there was the champion, whoever she was. He didn’t have a plan yet. But he had the beginning of one, and five days to finish it.
-----
The court of House Frostmere met the next morning.
It was the same high cold room as before, with the same judge behind the same desk. This time, the gallery was full. Somebody had told the Row what was happening, and half of it had come to watch. Mav saw students from every school, men and women in the colors of a dozen houses, and two of Sunspire’s glass eyes floating near the ceiling.
Marek stood on the left side of the hall, smiling. He looked exactly the same as he had at the first hearing. He wore the same clean sea-green coat. If he had lost anything in the past two weeks, it didn’t show on his face.
"House Tidecaller offers a duel of champions under the old law," the judge said. "Maverick Silkborn, you have heard the terms. Each side names a champion. Tidecaller’s champion must be of your World’s rank. You may be your own champion. The duel ends when one champion yields or can no longer fight." She paused. "Subjects that die are dead. If Tidecaller’s champion wins, you swear the same day. If yours wins, the claim falls for one year, and House Tidecaller pays one thing of water from its treasury, chosen by you." She looked at him with Isolde’s pale eyes. "Do you accept?"
Mav looked across the hall at Marek.
He thought about the 40 young fish, and about Five, and the old grief came back. He thought about the salt creeping up the slope toward the dens in the dark. Every day that the trial went on, Marek could send something new into his sea. In a duel, there would be only one champion, and Mav would be standing in front of her. The only fear that he felt was for the young, and a duel would keep them out of it.
"I’ll be my own champion," he said. "I accept."
The gallery broke into noise. The judge waited for it to die down, then wrote something in her book and closed it.
Marek’s smile grew wider. He bowed to Mav, very slightly, as if they had just agreed on the price of something small.
"I was hoping you would," he said.