Mav kept his promise to the beast the next morning.
He took it up through the water, past the city and the new depths, to the island in the middle of his sea. It was the only place in his World where there was a real sky. The beast climbed out of the water onto the black rock, slowly, shaking its long silver legs one by one. Then it lay down in the sun and looked up.
The sky of Submerged was pale blue that morning, with a few thin clouds. The hawks were circling high above the ridge, where their three gray chicks were shrieking in the nest.
The beast looked at it for a long while without speaking.
"It’s a small sky," it said at last.
"It’s the only one I’ve got."
"Yes." The beast closed its pale gold eyes, as if the light were too much after so long. "It will do."
Mav sat down on the rock beside it. Below them, the sea went on to the edge of the World in every direction, flat and bright. Far down, he could feel the city at work: the Reefkin cutting stone, Twelve’s needlefish hunting in the new depths, Pip and Puddle’s young chasing each other through the larders. Sela had come up with him, annoyed. The beast had arrived in her city in the middle of the night, without warning, and it had walked straight through her new gate and lain down in the main street. It hadn’t even looked at her. She stood a little way off now, with her arms folded, watching it suspiciously. The gray egg was the other new arrival in her city. It had appeared in her best store room the same night, wrapped in its green thread, and it hadn’t moved since.
"I need to call you something," Mav said.
"Call me what you like. I won’t answer to it."
Mav thought about it. All his beasts with names had the names of trees and plants.
"Yew," he said.
The beast opened one eye.
"A tree that outlives everyone who plants it," it said, "and poisons whatever eats it." It closed the eye again. "That will do too."
-----
Ronald came that afternoon.
He came through his arch into the second air hall, but he didn’t bring any goat this time. Mav came up out of the pool to meet him. Ronald said hello, but one look at his face told Mav that this wasn’t a visit.
They sat on the edge of the pool, as they had so many times before. Ronald didn’t say anything for a while. He looked at the water, and at his own big hands, and at the wolves asleep in the corner.
"I have to say something," he said at last. "And you’re going to listen to all of it, because I’ve been thinking about it since the Vault, and I’m only going to say it once."
Mav waited.
"What you did on the third floor was wrong," Ronald said.
He said it simply, the way that he said everything, without raising his voice. To Ronald, it was only a fact, like the weather or the price of bread.
"They yielded," he went on. "Both of them. You heard them. You kept going until there was nothing left in the water, and then you told Jory that it was because he’d have come again." Ronald looked at him. "And on the seventh floor, you let him die. You were 10 steps away. I saw your face, Mav. You knew how to save him. You didn’t even move."
Mav said nothing for a moment. Something in his chest had gone tight and cold. He was angry, and under the anger was something else that he didn’t want to look at.
"He tried to throw me into a pit," he said.
"I know."
"With you and Tamsin on the other side, watching. If he’d done it, what do you think he’d have done to you two next?"
"I know what he did." Ronald’s voice didn’t change. "That doesn’t make what you did right."
-----
"Dead enemies don’t come back," Mav said.
It came out of him harder than he had meant it to. But once it was out, he realized that he believed it, so he went on.
"They don’t come back with their friends at night. They don’t push you into pits, and they don’t tear holes in your sky. Dorian came back. Aldric came back. Every one of them that I let go came back, Ronald, every single one, and every time, somebody of mine died for it." His voice was rising now. "Log died for it. Six died for it. Quill died for it."
"Don’t," Ronald said.
"Why not? It’s true."
"Because you’re using her." Ronald stood up. He was shaking, but his voice was still low. "Quill went into your sea to stop a man from doing what he wanted to a boy who couldn’t fight back. You know what she’d say about the seventh floor. You know it better than I do."
Mav stood up too.
For a moment, they faced each other across the edge of the pool, very close. Mav had never seen Ronald look at him like that, and he didn’t have a word for it.
"You told me once, after Five died," Ronald said. "Nobody gets spent."
"Nobody of mine."
"Jory Kell was somebody’s," Ronald said.
Neither of them spoke after that. The water of the pool moved softly against the stone. In the corner, one of the wolves lifted its head and looked at them, then put it down again.
At last, Ronald turned toward his arch.
"I swore to you," he said, without looking back. "My boars follow you before they follow me. That’s what the oath means." He stopped at the edge of the pale light. "So promise me one thing. You’ll never use them for something like the third floor. Never."
Mav wanted to argue, but he only looked at Ronald’s back for a long while.
"I promise," he said.
Ronald nodded once. Then he stepped into the light, and he was gone.
-----
That night, Ronald couldn’t sleep.
He sat on the highest of his gray hills with his back against a rock, the way that he used to sit as a boy on the roof of his father’s house, when something was wrong. Below him, his boars were asleep in a great heap, the old ones and the young ones together. The oldest of them snored like a cart going over stones.
He went over the pool, Mav’s face and every word that they had said. He was sure that he had been right. But Mav had been right too, about some of it, and Ronald hated that. For the first time in his life, he felt lonely on his own hills.
A little after midnight, it happened.
He felt it first in the ground under him, a long, deep tremor that went through the whole of his World. Then the sky over his hills grew wider. The hills themselves stretched, as if they had taken a deep breath. Far off, at the edge of his land, new hills rose out of the dark that hadn’t been there before.
His Status opened by itself.
[Your World has reached Rank D.]
[A new species has been granted.]
Ronald stared at the words. On the rocks below the top of his hill, something was moving. They were big black birds, a dozen of them, with gray beaks and clever eyes, shaking out their new wings in the dark. One of them looked up at him and made a low, rough sound, like a question.
Rank D. For a moment, Ronald felt pure joy, then guilt for feeling it. Months ago, he would have run all the way to Mav’s World in the middle of the night to tell him. He would have shouted it into the pool until Mav came up.
But tonight, he only sat there.
Ronald opened his Status again and looked for a long while at the line with Mav’s name on it.
He didn’t tell Mav.