The silence around the dining table continued for a little while before James finally broke it.
He had been quiet since Sophie and Nora went upstairs, occasionally exchanging glances with Elena as though the two of them had silently agreed on something. Now, he straightened in his seat and turned his attention towards Ethan.
"Ethan, there’s something your mother-in-law and I would like to say to you." His voice was calm, without the usual stiffness or concealed displeasure that had characterized their previous conversations. He paused briefly, seemingly choosing his words carefully before continuing. "We’ve treated you unfairly in the past. Some of the things we’ve said and done were unreasonable, and I won’t pretend otherwise. As your wife’s parents, we should have treated you with more respect instead of making things difficult for you."
Ethan looked at him quietly, allowing him to finish.
James took a breath before adding, "I’m sorry for that. I know an apology won’t erase what happened, but I hope you can accept it."
Beside him, Elena lowered her gaze for a moment. She had remained unusually quiet throughout James’s speech, but she eventually turned towards Ethan, her fingers lightly clasped together.
"I also owe you an apology, Ethan." Her voice wasn’t particularly loud, but there was no trace of the earlier awkwardness in it. "I’ve said and done things I shouldn’t have. I was unfair to you, and I shouldn’t have treated you the way I did. I’m sorry."
Ethan remained composed as he listened to both of them. He didn’t interrupt, nor did he display any particular reaction to their words. Once they had finished, he gave a small nod.
"It’s alright. I accept your apology."
His response was simple, without any unnecessary remarks or attempts to make them feel worse about their past behaviour. He wasn’t particularly interested in dragging old disagreements into the present, especially when they were making an effort to put things right.
However, the person sitting beside him was having a much harder time processing what had just happened.
Evelyn stared at her parents, momentarily unsure whether she had heard them correctly. She had expected the visit to be awkward, especially considering how things had gone during their previous encounter. Even after hearing them welcome Ethan earlier, she hadn’t imagined they would go this far.
Her father had just apologized to Ethan.
And her mother had done the same.
For a brief moment, she wondered whether she was dreaming. These were the same parents who had once insisted that Ethan buy them an outrageously expensive car, then became furious when he refused to play along with their demands. She knew they weren’t bad people, but their pride had often made it difficult for them to admit when they were wrong.
Yet here they were, calmly acknowledging their mistakes without making excuses.
Evelyn lowered her eyes, trying to hide the surprise on her face. She wasn’t sure what had prompted the change, but seeing her parents behave this way brought an unexpected warmth to her chest.
James seemed satisfied with Ethan’s response. He relaxed slightly in his seat before continuing, his attention briefly shifting towards Evelyn.
"There’s something else I want to thank you for. I’ve heard about what you’ve done for Cole, especially concerning his position in the company. I understand that you helped him secure a much better role and gave him the opportunity to manage the agricultural project." He paused, giving Ethan an appreciative look. "I know he has been working hard, but I also know your support played a significant part in that. Thank you."
Cole, who had been listening quietly, shifted in his seat. He hadn’t expected his father to bring up his work, but he didn’t interrupt.
James continued, "And there’s Evelyn. She’s been doing much better lately. The shop is growing, and she doesn’t seem to be carrying the same burden she used to. I can see that her life has become easier, and I’m grateful you’ve been taking care of her."
Evelyn’s fingers tightened slightly against her lap.
She had heard her father express gratitude before, but rarely in a manner like this. He wasn’t demanding anything or attaching some expectation to his words. He was simply acknowledging what Ethan had done for their family.
Her lips parted slightly, and she turned towards him. "Dad..." The word escaped almost like a quiet whisper, carrying more emotion than she had intended.
James glanced at her, and a faint smile appeared on his face. He seemed to understand what she was feeling, but he didn’t make a big deal out of it.
Ethan, meanwhile, gave another small nod. "There’s no need to thank me. They’re my family, too. I’ll always take care of them, regardless of the situation."
He said it casually, as though it were the most natural thing in the world. There was no attempt to impress anyone, and he didn’t seem to expect any recognition for it.
James smiled in approval. He glanced at Elena before returning his attention to the couple, his expression noticeably more relaxed than it had been earlier.
"That’s good to hear. Well, I hope you all feel at home while you’re here. There’s no need to treat this like a formal visit. You’re family, after all."
Ethan nodded, accepting the invitation without saying much more. Evelyn, however, was still looking at her father. She had never expected their conversation to turn out this way, and she was quietly pleased that things were finally taking a better direction.
After a short while, she pushed her chair back and stood up. "I’ll go upstairs and spend some time with Sophie and Nora. I haven’t seen them properly in a while."
James nodded, encouraging her to go ahead. Elena also stood up, telling Evelyn that she would join them later if they needed anything. However, rather than following her daughter upstairs, she turned towards James and suggested that they return to the living room.
The couple left the dining room together, leaving Ethan and Cole behind.