Admiral Kao came ashore the way he did everything: without hurry, without ornament, and without once looking at anyone who might have wished to be looked at.
The Council packet slid up to the glass pier on the morning tide, a narrow gray boat with a patched topsail and a crew of six, who stood along her rail in the pale light with the stunned faces of men who had been told, three days ago, to sail somewhere that did not exist. The Admiral stepped over the side onto the island with a single stride. He wore the same long blue greatcoat he had worn on the Seventh Wave’s deck. He carried his cap in his left hand. His silver hair lay flat and neat. His face, like a hatchet buried in a plank, did not move.
He stopped.
It was a very small stop. A man who had not been watching would have missed it. But Kao Xia, running down the glass toward him with her heart hammering in her throat, saw him look past her shoulder at the island, at the drifts of tiny dim lights, at the glow of the great star lying golden on the horizon. She saw his mouth open, a quarter of an inch, and close again.
Then he looked at her.
They stood three paces apart. She had a hundred things to say. She had rehearsed all of them for six days on the cutter and every night since, in a variety of tones. Not one of them came.
"You came," she said.
"I was passing."
She stared at him. "It is a thousand miles from anything."
"I take long walks."
A laugh nearly escaped her. She clamped her jaw on it. Behind her, on the deck of the Seventh Wave, someone made a muffled noise that might have been Brine.
"Father," said Kao Xia.
"Captain," said Admiral Kao.
He did not say anything more.
He walked past her, down the pier, onto the glass, and stopped again at the place where the little lights lay thickest. He stood there for a long time, in the thin morning wind, with his cap in his hand. A faint blue spark lifted from the ground and drifted across his boots. He looked down at it. And then, slowly, with the stiff, painful care of a man who had not knelt for anything since the dock at Pearl Key, he went down on one knee, and held out his hand.
The spark landed on his palm.
He did not say a word. His gray eyes were fixed on the light, and his face was wet, and he did not seem to know it.
Kao Xia turned away, because she could not stand to watch.
The fight came that afternoon, on the north reef, and it was short.
She had known it would come. She had gone out to the black rock at the end of the island to be alone and had barely sat down when the tread behind her told her she was not. She did not turn.
"You stole a Tide-Warden vessel," said her father.
"I stole my own ship."
"You were relieved of command. You took twelve men with you. You crossed a line that your grandfather and I have held since before you could walk, in direct defiance of Council orders and the written instructions of a Vice-Commander who, I may add, has submitted a very long report in which he does not mention you at all." His voice was flat as a ruled page. "It is a remarkable document. I have read it four times. I believe it is the first lie he has ever told in his life."
She did turn then.
"He lowered the lantern," she said.
"I am aware."
"You said you could not send me. You said you could not order me to stay."
"I was hoping," said the Admiral, "that you would have the sense to stay."
She stood up.
She did not mean to shout. She had decided that on the cutter. But the old voice rose in her like a bad tide, and she heard it coming out, loud and wild and shaking: "You gave me the letter!"
"I gave you the letter so that if you went, you would have a reason I could stand to."
The words hung between them in the warm wet air.
He had not meant to say them. She saw that at once. His face had not changed. But a muscle had jumped in his jaw, and one hand had closed on the brim of his cap, and for the first time in her life she saw her father look like a man who had walked into a room and found all the furniture moved.
"Why?" said Kao Xia. "Why can I not go? Why have I been on a picket for six years? You had the best-reading Warden in the Southern Sea at your command, and you put me where the water is dull. You kept me at the edge of every chart. You never once let me do anything that was..." Her voice cracked. "Real."
"I kept you alive."
"I know! I know that is what you called it! I want to know why!"
He was silent.
It went on so long that she began to hear the sea again: the slow, warm, endless wash of it against the rock. She thought, in a great weary rush, he is not going to answer. He will stand there. He will fold his hands behind his back and wait for me to apologize, and I will, because I always do.
"Your mother," said Admiral Kao.
She went still.
"She read the water. As you do." His eyes were on the sea. "She was a fisherman’s daughter from the Ao-Port shallows. I met her when she walked into a Warden’s office and told the duty clerk that the weather glass was wrong. It was. She was seventeen. I married her at twenty-four, and she told me on our wedding night that she would never stay ashore."
Kao Xia did not breathe.
"In the ninth month of the year you were sixteen, a typhoon came out of the southeast. It was the worst in forty years. She felt it a week before the glass did. She told me. I told the Squadron." His voice did not change. "The Council said it was a squall. They held the fishing fleet out. Four hundred boats. She said they would die."
"I remember," whispered Kao Xia.
"I was on the line. I could not leave it. It was the first time in my life I wished that I could." He closed his eyes. "She took a skiff. Alone. She went out ahead of the storm and read it, boat by boat, and turned every one of them for harbor. She got four hundred men home. She did not come home herself."
The sea washed.
"I stood on my deck," said the Admiral, "and held the line, while my wife drowned eighty miles south of me. I was the Admiral of the Southern Squadron. I could have taken a cutter. I did not, because the line was my duty, and my father’s, and I did not know what was behind it, and I had been told it mattered more than anything." He opened his eyes. "For twelve years, I have wondered whether I was right."
He turned his head. His gray eyes were very bright.
"You are her gift and her face. I looked at you, and I thought, no. I thought, I will not stand on that deck again. I will not watch another Kao go out into the dark because she can feel what nobody else does. I thought, I will put her somewhere the water is dull." He swallowed. "I thought I was protecting you."
"You were holding a line," said Kao Xia.
It came out very quietly. It did not sound like her voice.
"You were holding a line, Father. In front of me. The way you held it in front of her." She was crying now, and she did not care. "I have been standing on that picket for twelve years, waiting for you to look at me and see someone who could do something. And you saw Mother. You saw Mother, and you stood in front of me so that I would not be her."
He flinched.
"I am not her," she said. "I am not going to drown. I read the Star-Tide. I got a thousand lights out of the dark. I counted nine breaths and a man held back the sea. And I was good, Father. I was so good. I have been waiting my whole life to be that good, and the only person who would not let me was you."
The wind blew. A gull went over, crying.
Admiral Kao stood quite still. His mouth had gone white. His hands, at his sides, were shaking, very slightly, for the first time she could remember.
"You were," he said.
She stared at him.
"I heard," he said, hoarsely. "On the pier, before my second boot was on the glass. The Seventh Wave’s boy, Fin, told me. He had it in order. The tide, the count, the lights." His throat worked. "He said you stood at the edge of the island with your hands on the glass and told a man to hold the sea for nine breaths, and the man did."
"He did."
"Your mother," said the Admiral, "would have been insufferable about it."
A sound came out of Kao Xia that was not a laugh and not a sob.
"She would have said, told you," he went on. "She would have said it for a year. She would have said it at the supper table in front of the Squadron’s wives." His face did a strange thing. It softened, and cracked, and settled again into something almost unrecognizable. "I would have deserved it."
"Father..."
"Go," said Admiral Kao.
"What?"
"Go. Read the water. Do the thing you are for. I have no right to stand in front of it." His voice wavered, very slightly, and held. "But I would ask one thing."
"Anything."
"Do not stand in front of what comes." He took a step. He was a head shorter than she was, and he had never seemed so small, and she thought her heart would break. "Stand beside it. That is all I did wrong. I stood in front. I should have stood beside."
She did not decide to move. She crossed the rock in two strides and put her arms around her father, a stiff, narrow, silver-haired man in a blue greatcoat who smelled of tar and old paper and sea-salt, and held on.
He did not return the embrace at once. His arms hung at his sides. He stood rigid, like a mast, for the space of three heartbeats.
Then, very slowly, one hand came up and settled on the back of her head.
"Xia," he said, in a voice she had not heard since she was nine.
That was all.
It was enough.