If... if that really was the case, then a great many things suddenly made sense.
Maria Hill fell silent, lost in thought.
Umbrella and Hydra might both have originated from ancient secret societies, organizations with histories stretching back thousands of years. At some point, their ideologies had diverged, splitting them into rival factions that had spent centuries fighting each other.
There was nothing particularly unusual about that. Even religious movements that worshipped the same God could eventually become bitter enemies. Catholics and Protestants were a perfect example.
Their conflict might have erupted repeatedly throughout history. There could even be historical records of those encounters, but without reliable intelligence, reconstructing the details would be nearly impossible.
The most recent major confrontation, however, might have taken place during the Third Reich.
The Red Skull had emerged from within Hydra as an unusually ambitious leader, establishing a radical new faction with an entirely different ideology. Umbrella had already been at odds with Hydra, and the Red Skull’s faction was considered unorthodox even by Hydra’s standards.
To Umbrella, he must have been an extremist among extremists.
The Red Skull had hidden within the Third Reich, using its resources to build his power in secret. It was remarkably similar to how modern Hydra had infiltrated S.H.I.E.L.D.
Umbrella must have learned about his activities and infiltrated the Third Reich as well, attempting to stop him.
That would explain the rumors connecting Umbrella to Nazi Germany, including the claim that the corporation itself had originated there.
Judging by the outcome, Umbrella’s original plan hadn’t been entirely successful.
The Red Skull had nearly launched an attack that would have devastated the entire world, using the Tesseract’s energy weapon aboard an aircraft.
But perhaps Umbrella’s efforts had succeeded in another way.
After the war, Hydra was no longer a secret organization. Its existence had been exposed to the world, and its name had become synonymous with terrorism and evil.
Umbrella, meanwhile, had vanished into obscurity.
Who even knew it existed?
It was difficult to determine what strategic objective Umbrella had pursued during the war. Nevertheless, its efforts had clearly been substantial.
Hill’s thoughts drifted to Captain America.
Dr. Abraham Erskine. The Super Soldier Serum...
Perhaps Erskine had been an Umbrella operative. Or perhaps Umbrella had assisted him at some point during his research.
The Red Skull had received an early version of the Super Soldier Serum, but the results had been disastrous. It had transformed him into something monstrous.
Steve Rogers, on the other hand, had received the serum and emerged without suffering any comparable mutation.
Why?
Why had the same treatment produced such radically different results?
Was it because the Red Skull had been evil at heart, while Steve had possessed a good and noble spirit?
That was absurd.
Genetic enhancement was science. It followed scientific principles, not some mystical system that rewarded good people and punished the wicked.
Differences in their genetics would be a far more reasonable explanation than the idea that the serum somehow judged a person’s morality.
Which raised another possibility.
Perhaps Umbrella had helped Erskine improve the Super Soldier Serum sometime between the Red Skull’s transformation and Steve’s successful enhancement.
It wasn’t an entirely baseless theory.
Erskine possessed knowledge of the serum that made him invaluable to both Hydra and the Third Reich. Yet Europe had practically fallen under Nazi control. How had a relatively frail scientist managed to transport such valuable research and materials from German territory all the way to the United States?
The Red Skull wasn’t an idiot. Neither was Hitler. And the intelligence services of the Third Reich and Hydra certainly weren’t incompetent.
Was Hill seriously supposed to believe Erskine had simply walked across Europe because God had personally decided to protect him?
One could argue that American intelligence agents had carefully arranged his escape, with four exceptionally capable operatives escorting him all the way to safety while repeatedly outmaneuvering Nazi intelligence.
But there was one rather inconvenient detail.
Where had Erskine died?
And when?
He had been murdered inside the United States, within a heavily guarded military installation, on the very day Steve Rogers received the Super Soldier Serum.
A Hydra assassin had infiltrated the facility as though security didn’t exist, killed Erskine on the spot, and destroyed the remaining serum.
If Steve hadn’t intervened, the assassin might even have escaped.
After something like that, could anyone seriously claim American intelligence had been flawless? Could they still insist Hydra’s operatives were incompetent fools?
Their intelligence had been remarkably accurate. Their agents had been frighteningly capable.
But with the information now available, perhaps that incident deserved a second interpretation.
The assassin had already been inside the facility before the experiment began. Yet he had waited until after Steve’s transformation had succeeded before making his move.
What if he hadn’t been a Hydra operative at all?
What if he had belonged to Umbrella?
Perhaps Umbrella wanted the American government to possess a successful Super Soldier. But it didn’t want its improved version of the serum spreading beyond its control.
So it had sent an operative to eliminate Erskine and destroy the remaining samples immediately after the experiment succeeded.
Whatever the truth, one thing seemed certain.
The two organizations had fought fiercely throughout the Second World War.
The conflict had ended with the Red Skull’s defeat, but Umbrella had hardly emerged unscathed. It might have become too deeply involved with the Third Reich and suffered collateral damage during the Allied victory.
After the war, both organizations had been forced into hiding to recover their strength.
Only in recent years, once they had regained enough influence, had their conflict resumed.
This time, however, Hydra had struck first.
It had placed intelligence about Umbrella directly on Nick Fury’s desk, taking advantage of S.H.I.E.L.D.’s position as the world’s foremost security organization.
The plan had been straightforward: use the authority of S.H.I.E.L.D. to crush Umbrella in the name of justice.
And Hydra hadn’t stopped there.
Before Evenson had even joined S.H.I.E.L.D., someone had already planted the story that Umbrella originated from the Third Reich.
Now that Hill thought about it, how had Evenson actually entered S.H.I.E.L.D. and gradually earned Nick Fury’s trust?
It had all begun with him exposing Hydra.
A small-time Hydra operative had supposedly attempted to recruit Evenson. The man had pushed too hard, provoked Evenson into killing him, and shouted Hydra’s distinctive slogan just before dying.
That revelation had caused an uproar.
It suggested that Hydra operatives might be hiding inside S.H.I.E.L.D. itself, while simultaneously infiltrating positions within the American government.
Everyone who learned about it had been shocked.
Naturally, all attention had shifted toward the possibility of Hydra’s infiltration.
And in doing so, everyone had overlooked something rather suspicious about the incident itself.
Would a Hydra operative really be stupid enough to shout his organization’s slogan while dying?
If Hydra had been filled with people like that, it would never have survived underground for so long.
The truth was obvious.
Hydra had deliberately sacrificed one of its own to drag an otherwise unrelated outsider into its conflict.
Evenson had been the bait.
And as soon as he made contact with S.H.I.E.L.D., Hydra had conveniently arranged another incident: the mysterious transaction that supposedly exposed Umbrella’s existence.
Evenson had then naturally repeated what he’d supposedly heard about the corporation’s origins in the Third Reich.
That had given Nick Fury the final piece he needed to classify Umbrella as an evil criminal organization.
So that’s what happened.
Hill almost laughed.
Evenson might have seemed mysterious and occasionally displayed an impressive understanding of the supernatural, but in the end, he’d simply been another pawn in Hydra’s game.
Wait.
There was another possibility.
Hydra wasn’t a unified organization. Its ancient factions and the Red Skull’s followers had never been entirely compatible.
Perhaps the scheme hadn’t been orchestrated by Pierce’s faction at all.
Other Hydra members might have deliberately arranged for both Umbrella and the Red Skull’s faction to be exposed, hoping the two would destroy each other.
But Pierce had managed to smooth things over before the situation spiraled out of control.
Umbrella, meanwhile, had proved exceptionally skilled at remaining hidden. Apart from its name, almost nothing about the organization had been exposed.
And S.H.I.E.L.D.?
Everyone else had been playing their own game while S.H.I.E.L.D. took the beating.
Hill looked up at Evenson and let out a deeply frustrated sigh.
"We’ve been manipulated this entire time..."
"Huh?"
Evenson blinked.
He had absolutely no idea what Hill was talking about or what chain of reasoning had led her to that conclusion.
"Nothing... Nothing."
Hill shook her head.
Apparently, he still hadn’t figured it out.
Well, there was no reason to enlighten him. It wasn’t exactly good news.
The rest of the puzzle was beginning to fall into place.
Hydra’s repeated attempts to frame and undermine Umbrella must eventually have attracted the corporation’s attention. Naturally, Umbrella would have wanted to retaliate.
And its response had probably involved Dottie Underwood.
Dottie had a complicated history with Peggy Carter, one of S.H.I.E.L.D.’s founding figures. She had suddenly appeared aboard the S.H.I.E.L.D. Helicarrier shortly before the Battle of New York, after being recruited and enhanced by Umbrella.
Her stated purpose had been to establish an alliance with S.H.I.E.L.D. against the approaching alien invasion.
Interestingly, she hadn’t once bothered to defend Umbrella against the accusations Hydra had planted.
Her explanation had been remarkably simple.
Whatever Umbrella intended to do with the world, that was an internal human affair. With an alien invasion underway, humanity should put aside its differences and stand together against the external threat.
It was an inspiring sentiment.
Unfortunately, humanity wasn’t exactly famous for its ability to cooperate.
People could have a knife pressed against their throats and still find time to argue over who had put it there. Suspicion and distrust didn’t simply disappear because someone declared that everyone should unite against a common enemy.
The principle was perfectly sound.
Putting it into practice was another matter entirely.
Umbrella’s representatives probably weren’t quite that idealistic.
Which raised another question.
Why had Umbrella sent Dottie?
She was a recently recruited operative who knew little about the corporation’s deepest secrets. Yet she also had an unusually complicated relationship with Peggy Carter, giving her an easy way to approach S.H.I.E.L.D.
Perhaps her real mission hadn’t been to establish an alliance at all.
It had been to repair Umbrella’s reputation in Nick Fury’s eyes.
And it had worked.
After that encounter, Fury had begun reconsidering his opinion of the organization.
Umbrella might indeed have been a dangerous criminal enterprise, but perhaps it had certain lines it wouldn’t cross.
What a move.
Hydra had spent years constructing an elaborate scheme to discredit Umbrella, only for the corporation to undo much of that damage with a single, seemingly harmless gesture.
The resulting confrontation had looked like a series of defeats for Umbrella.
In reality, it had suffered very little.
Hydra’s plans had largely failed, and Pierce’s faction had come dangerously close to exposing itself.
After that, Hydra had stopped provoking Umbrella so openly. Information about the corporation became increasingly scarce.
The uneasy peace continued until shortly before the Insight Program.
Pierce had apparently been sufficiently unnerved by the previous clashes that he decided to concentrate entirely on his grand project.
He believed that once the Insight Program succeeded, he could eliminate Umbrella and the other troublesome factions within Hydra in one stroke.
Unfortunately, he seemed to have forgotten a rather important principle.
You couldn’t provoke a tiger, walk away, and expect it to politely forget the encounter.
Umbrella had every reason to retaliate.
"Jill Valentine."
Hill suddenly turned toward Natasha.
"Natasha, that woman belongs to Umbrella, doesn’t she?"
Natasha froze for a moment.
Then her expression darkened.
"Yes. She does."
Her voice was cold enough to cut glass.
Of all the people Natasha had encountered, Jill Valentine was the woman who had cost her the most dearly.
"Let me see her again, and I’ll break every bone in her body."
Sarah, who had her arms wrapped around Natasha, suddenly stiffened.
"What’s wrong?" Natasha asked.
"Nothing!"
Sarah quickly arranged her expression into something suitably furious.
"Sounds like that woman has a serious history with you. Next time you go after her, take me along. I’ll kick her teeth in."
"Hold on."
Tony looked between them.
"Who exactly are we talking about?"
He had never heard this story.
"Jill Valentine," Natasha replied, practically grinding the name between her teeth. "She’s the only Umbrella representative S.H.I.E.L.D. ever officially met face-to-face."
She paused.
"She claimed to be Umbrella’s head of security. Our meeting took place at Hammer Industries."
"Hammer Industries?"
Tony frowned.
He hadn’t thought about that company in ages.
Then the name finally clicked.
"Justin Hammer’s company?"
He considered the connection.
"Umbrella was doing business with Hammer Industries?"
Tony’s mouth twisted.
"Well, that’s disappointing. Their standards seem to have dropped considerably. Unless they’re planning to rename themselves Bieber Industries."
Evenson quietly turned his head away.
Don’t insult Hammer Industries.
At the time, Umbrella hadn’t even been as wealthy as Justin Hammer.
Besides, Hammer Industries had been an enormous benefactor to the corporation. That initial sixty-billion-dollar investment was something Evenson would never forget.
"Umbrella’s cooperation with Hammer Industries took place around the same time you fought Whiplash," Hill explained.
She narrowed her eyes.
"According to our subsequent investigation, Umbrella may have been using Hammer Industries’ facilities to conduct biological research. Justin Hammer also contacted the Department of Defense, mentioning that after the Iron Man armor deal, he had another, much larger business opportunity worth discussing."
"That opportunity was probably Umbrella’s attempt to use Hammer as an intermediary and establish a biological weapons deal with the American government."
Hill paused.
"It was likely another attempt to counter Hydra, though it wasn’t particularly successful."
"At the time, Hammer was enjoying the height of his popularity. The government was using him to pursue ownership of the Iron Man armor, and he was receiving more attention than ever. Working with him would have saved Umbrella a great deal of trouble."
"Besides, he was an easy man to manipulate."
She gave Tony a dry look.
"Though I doubt even Umbrella expected him to be quite that incompetent. Whiplash practically led him around by the nose. Once Hammer’s plans collapsed, Umbrella’s arrangement fell apart with them."
Tony didn’t argue.
He remembered that entire affair rather well.
"Natasha infiltrated Hammer Industries to help you at the time," Hill continued. "That’s when she encountered Jill Valentine, who was preparing to leave the facility."
Natasha snorted.
"Calling it a minor setback would be generous."
She rolled her eyes.
"Anyway, after that, I thought I’d never see that woman again."
Her expression shifted as another memory surfaced.
"But, Captain, do you remember the battle aboard the Moria’s Star?"
"Of course."
Steve nodded.
"That was quite an encounter. I still remember fighting Noriko Ashida. It was a close one."
He sighed.
Even now, he wasn’t particularly fond of remembering that battle.
"There’s something I never properly explained afterward," Natasha continued. "The pirates who initially hijacked that ship were actually hired by Nick Fury. By that point, he’d already begun to suspect something was wrong with the Insight Program."
She looked at Steve.
"But you saw what happened. By the time we boarded, the pirates were already dead."
"The people we encountered afterward weren’t pirates at all. They belonged to Umbrella."
Natasha’s eyes narrowed.
"Jill Valentine was aboard that ship."
Everyone listened closely.
"I encountered her in the ship’s command room. But unlike our previous meeting, we didn’t fight. She simply stood there and watched while I copied all the information about the Insight Program."
"That confirms it."
Hill nodded.
"Umbrella had been watching Hydra closely for a long time. They understood what was happening, but instead of making a reckless move, they struck directly at Hydra’s greatest weakness."
She looked around the group.
"Pierce’s precious Insight Program."
"Exactly. Once Umbrella became involved, Nick Fury’s suspicions about the Insight Program grew even stronger. Pierce panicked and eventually abandoned all pretenses, forcing the project into operation before he was ready."
Hill shook her head.
"Umbrella’s interference played a significant role in the program’s eventual collapse."
Tony suddenly raised his hand.
"I propose that we award Umbrella Corporation the Nobel Peace Prize."
He looked around the group.
"Who’s with me?"
Evenson lowered his head, feeling a little embarrassed.
No, no. That award really belongs to Mephisto.