A paddle rose near the front.
"Six hundred thousand."
Reinhard lifted his own. "Seven hundred thousand."
Several guests turned toward the newcomer. Among them was a silver-haired collector in his fifties, dressed in an immaculate suit and accustomed to dominating auctions.
"People often confuse an expensive illusion with a genuine historical artifact," he remarked to his companion, loud enough for nearby bidders to hear. "Mystery makes an excellent sales pitch for inexperienced buyers."
Reinhard smiled but didn’t answer immediately. He wanted to know whether the man possessed any actual knowledge of the artifact or was simply offended by his interest.
"Serious collectors understand provenance," the man continued. "Amateurs chase whatever looks mysterious and hope the price makes it valuable."
"An excellent point," Reinhard replied. "That’s precisely why I intend to examine the evidence before deciding what something is worth."
The collector’s expression stiffened.
Archon watched the exchange with quiet amusement. Reinhard, meanwhile, had decided the man might be useful. Arrogant people often revealed more than they intended when they believed they were teaching someone a lesson.
"Since we’re discussing provenance," Reinhard said, gesturing toward the catalogue on the collector’s lap, "perhaps you could help me understand something."
The catalogue described an ancient ceremonial artifact attributed to a celebrated civilization.
"I noticed you purchased this piece. An impressive acquisition."
"Indeed. It came from a respected private collection, and I paid a considerable sum for it."
"May I ask how its original origin was authenticated?"
"The auction house’s specialists verified it."
Reinhard activated Provenance Appraisal.
The artifact’s ownership records were extensive. It had passed through several recognized collections, and each transfer was documented. However, the earliest recorded owner had acquired it long after the civilization supposedly produced it.
The attribution might be correct, but the records didn’t establish where the artifact had originally been discovered or how its connection to that civilization had first been confirmed.
"Did the specialists examine the original discovery records," Reinhard asked, "or rely on the ownership history and its resemblance to known artifacts?"
"The piece has been examined by qualified experts."
"I’m sure it has. But those are two different things, aren’t they?"
The auctioneer approached after noticing the discussion.
"The attribution reflects the available evidence, including expert examination and similarities to established examples," he clarified. "We don’t claim every artifact has a complete record extending to its creation."
Reinhard nodded. "A reasonable distinction. Thank you."
He recorded the catalogue’s claims, ownership history, and the auctioneer’s clarification in the Merchant King’s Black Ledger.
He hadn’t proved the artifact was fake. He had established that its ownership history didn’t fully support its claimed origin.
Nearby guests began examining their own catalogues. The collector noticed, and his expression darkened.
The collector noticed, and his expression darkened. "You’ve mistaken a technical limitation for evidence of wrongdoing," the collector said.
"Have I?"
"There’s nothing suspicious about an incomplete record. Many historical artifacts have uncertain origins."
"Agreed."
The collector paused, apparently expecting an argument.
Reinhard smiled. "I haven’t accused anyone of wrongdoing. I merely asked you a question about provenance, which you insisted was important."
"That is different. I know the market."
"Then perhaps you can explain why you’re so eager to dismiss the very gaps you expect other people to examine."
The collector opened his mouth, then closed it again.
"Please, don’t let me interrupt," Reinhard added. "I’m learning a great deal."
Several guests laughed, and the collector turned away.
Archon leaned closer. "You’re enjoying this."
"I’m educating the public."
"You called him an expensive mistake without using those words."
"Then my education methods are improving."
"You’re impossible."
"That’s what people say when they can’t find a convincing argument."
She shook her head, hiding a smile.
The auctioneer returned to the podium.
"Before we continue with the undocumented memory medium, we need to clarify a detail in its catalogue entry. The available documentation doesn’t establish an original recording source or reliable historical attribution. Our description has been amended accordingly."
The auctioneer temporarily suspended the lot while staff reviewed the amended documentation and proceeded with another offering: a ceremonial weapon associated with an ancient military order.
The silver-haired collector straightened.
"This is what a serious acquisition looks like."
Reinhard glanced at the catalogue. "How many authenticated examples remain?"
"Very few. Perhaps three, including this one."
"And its provenance?"
"Excellent. The records are extensive."
"Then I imagine it’ll attract considerable interest."
The bidding began.
"Two hundred thousand," the collector announced.
Another guest offered two hundred and fifty thousand. The collector immediately raised the price to three hundred thousand.
Reinhard watched him for a moment before lifting his paddle.
"Three hundred and fifty thousand."
The collector turned toward him.
"Four hundred thousand."
"Four hundred and fifty thousand," Reinhard replied.
The man’s jaw tightened.
"Five hundred thousand."
Reinhard examined the catalogue as though reconsidering the weapon’s value.
"Five hundred and fifty thousand."
The collector’s eyes narrowed.
"Six hundred thousand."
Reinhard hesitated, then lowered his paddle.
The collector stared at him. Reinhard offered a small, apologetic smile.
"Please, continue. I wouldn’t want to stand between you and such a magnificent acquisition."
The man’s expression suggested he would rather throw the weapon at Reinhard than accept his sympathy.
But the room was watching to see who would yield first.
"Six hundred and fifty thousand," the collector declared.
The auctioneer acknowledged the bid.
Reinhard said nothing.
For the first time, the collector seemed to realize he was bidding against himself.
"Six hundred and fifty thousand going once."
The collector glanced around. Nobody challenged his bid.
"Going twice."
He could still stop, but that would mean abandoning the performance he had started. His fingers tightened around the paddle. He had already driven the price far beyond his original bid, yet backing down now would mean admitting that Reinhard had manipulated him.
"Seven hundred thousand!"
The auctioneer’s expression brightened. "Seven hundred thousand. Do I hear seven hundred and fifty?"
Reinhard raised his paddle.
"Seven hundred and fifty thousand."
The collector’s eyes widened.
"Eight hundred thousand!"
Reinhard lowered his paddle.
Silence settled over their section.
"Eight hundred thousand going once. Going twice. Sold!"
Applause filled the gallery.
Reinhard applauded enthusiastically. "Congratulations. A magnificent purchase."
The collector glared at him. "You stopped bidding."
"Of course."
"You were trying to make me pay more!"
"I thought you said you could afford the finest offerings available."
"You deliberately provoked me!"
"I asked about the weapon’s rarity. You told me it was exceptional. You decided to purchase it. Was I supposed to stop you from making your own decisions?"
Several guests laughed. The collector had no answer that wouldn’t make him look worse.
Archon leaned toward Reinhard. "You’ve turned his pride into an expensive hobby."
"Hobbies are important for personal development."
"Apparently, so is financial loss."
"It’s not a loss if he enjoys the experience."
Archon shook her head as Reinhard turned back toward the podium. "I hope your future investigations are less expensive."
"Then they won’t be nearly as educational."
...
The auctioneer returned to the undocumented memory medium. "Thank you for your patience. We will now resume the bidding for the unidentified city experience."
The display showed the strange metropolis once more, its curved towers connected by bridges that folded through impossible angles.
Reinhard glanced at the amended catalogue. Provenance Appraisal offered no new information, so he recorded the limitation in the Black Ledger and returned his attention to the bidding.
He knew the artifact’s origin remained unknown. That uncertainty was precisely why he wanted it.
"Due to the catalogue amendment, all previous bids on this lot are void. We will restart the bidding at six hundred thousand dollars. Do I hear six hundred and fifty?"
A paddle rose across the room.
"Six hundred and fifty thousand."
Reinhard lifted his own. "Seven hundred thousand."
The collector looked at him. His hand hovered near his paddle, and for a moment, Reinhard thought the man might start another contest.
"Seven hundred and fifty thousand," the collector declared.
"Eight hundred thousand," Reinhard replied.
The collector glanced at the protective case, then at Reinhard. He had already spent far more than intended on the ceremonial weapon. The sensible choice was to stop, but several guests were still watching him after his earlier humiliation.
His grip tightened around the paddle.
Then he lowered it.
The auctioneer looked around the room.
"Eight hundred thousand going once. Going twice. Sold!"
The gavel fell.
"Congratulations, sir. The undocumented memory medium is yours."
Reinhard leaned back with a satisfied smile. He had secured the artifact without allowing the collector to dictate his spending.
The staff transferred the protective case to his table. Reinhard ensured the final price and amended catalogue description were recorded in the Merchant King’s Black Ledger.
Archon watched the collector sit rigidly in his chair.
"You could have purchased it immediately."
"And deprive everyone of the entertainment?"
"You’re bullying rich people."
"I’m supporting the local economy."
"By making one man miserable?"
"I’m supporting it selectively."
...
Reinhard checked the seals on the protective case before accepting the transfer documents. The artifact remained enclosed, its display showing the unfamiliar city exactly as it had during the auction.
He had no intention of opening it before understanding how the memory medium worked.
The auctioneer returned to the podium.
"Ladies and gentlemen, our next lot is a reconstructed experience recovered from—"
A faint light spread across the surface of Reinhard’s case.
He stopped listening.
The glow ran along the display’s edges before gathering around the city. Then the image changed.
A section of the metropolis that hadn’t been visible during the original presentation appeared on the screen. The view moved down a long avenue lined with towering structures.
Lights began illuminating the road, one after another, moving toward a distant building.
Reinhard looked at the Black Ledger’s recorded description, then back at the case.
This wasn’t the view he’d examined during the auction.
The auctioneer faltered as the glow became more noticeable. Several guests turned toward Reinhard’s table, and a murmur spread through the gallery.
Archon rose from her seat, her attention fixed on the case.
"Reinhard, look at the edges."
He followed her gaze. The light wasn’t spreading inward from the display’s surface. It was gathering beneath it, as though something inside the sealed medium were illuminating the image from within.
"It’s coming from inside the case," she observed. "Not from the projection."
Reinhard’s expression sharpened. "So the change isn’t just a display effect."
"Can you tell what’s causing it?"
"No. And I’m not opening it until we understand what we’re dealing with."
He kept his hands away from the case, watching for another change. He couldn’t determine whether the activation had been triggered by the next auction lot, by his acquisition, or by some unknown condition.
Then the image shifted again.
At the end of the avenue, a figure appeared beneath the distant structure.
It stood perfectly still as the lights continued moving toward it.
Reinhard stared at the display. The memory medium was revealing something that hadn’t appeared in its original presentation.
He checked the Black Ledger once more. The new view wasn’t part of the image he’d recorded, and nothing in the auction’s documentation explained why it had appeared.
The figure at the end of the avenue lifted its head.