The shock on Esme’s face morphed into a mask of disbelief and confusion. "What are you talking about?" she blurted, squinting at Silas with a furrowed brow. "How could he not be your father?"
Silas remained silent, his throat constricting. A torrent of emotions choked him, rendering him speechless. Finally, after a tense pause, he rasped, "There’s a secret I recently found out. The truth has been hidden for years. Ewan Sullivan isn’t my biological father. My real dad... he’s David, my mom’s ex-husband."
Esme felt a fresh wave of chills cascade over her. Her ears rang, and her mind reeled, momentarily slipping from her grasp. In a flash of clarity, a horrifying realization dawned on her. It was only at this point that she realized why he had been so disturbed last night. The image of his vulnerable demeanor, the miserable cry that night when he brought her back to the penthouse forcefully resurfaced vividly.
The thought that he might have been shouldering the pain all by himself these past days tore at her heartstrings. Without hesitation, she pulled him into a comforting embrace, her own body wracked with choked sobs.
"I met him," Silas mumbled muffled against her shoulder. "My biological father. He said my mom left him while she was pregnant with me."
He then recounted his encounter with David and the paternity test results that confirmed the devastating truth.
"Mom hid the truth for all those years," he added, his voice thickening with sadness. "She never spoke of my real father. How could she be so cruel?"
Esme absorbed his words, her brow furrowing further with each bombshell revelation. While she readily acknowledged Victoria’s sharp tongue and harsh demeanor, Esme couldn’t reconcile that with the level of heartlessness Silas was attributing to her.
Could she be as heartless as Silas claimed? She wondered.
A beat of hesitant silence stretched between them. "Silas," she began cautiously, "there might be more to this story. We only have David’s perspective. What about your mother’s side? What struggles did she endure during their marriage? What truly compelled her to leave? You don’t know anything."
"The reason is clear. Money..." Silas scoffed, a sneer twisting his features. "She wanted money, a luxurious life that David couldn’t provide. She used him, then discarded him for a richer man. Heartless, that’s what she is. She separated a father from his son, then kept the truth buried for years."
A torrent of emotions - disdain, resentment, and raw anger - flooded his heart. "She cut David out completely, even threatened him, and made sure I never knew him."
His fists clenched into tight balls on his lap, knuckles stark white against his reddening skin. Veins bulged on the backs of his hands, betraying the simmering fury. His eyes, usually so bright and full of life, were now darkened with pain and disillusionment.
Esme reached out, gently placing her hand over his trembling fists, trying to calm the storm raging inside him. "Silas, I understand your anger. But don’t start blaming her before you know what exactly happened between them. A marriage doesn’t crumble just like that. Maybe there’s more to the story than we know. There have to be reasons why Victoria left him back then. We need to find out the truth, all of it."
Silas’s response was immediate and sharp. "I told you why!" he barked, jerking his hand away in a defensive motion. "You’re still on her side? Are you implying David is lying? Are you saying he fabricated this whole story?"
"Silas, that’s not what I’m saying at all. Please, let me explain..." Her words were cut short as Silas launched into another tirade.
"He suffered all those years while she lived a life of luxury!" he roared. "He yearned for me, wanted to reach me. But all this time, I was completely oblivious to his existence."
A bitter laugh escaped his lips. "It makes me sick! All these years I lived a carefree life, blissfully unaware of the struggles my real father endured. And here I was, calling another man ’Dad.’ Can you believe the irony of it all?"
Esme bristled. "Silas, stop talking nonsense! Are you saying you regret having Ewan as your father? What is wrong with you?" A scowl etched itself onto her face as she stared at him, bewildered by his sudden hostility.
Silas stood up abruptly. His face twisted with conflicting emotions. "Ewan Sullivan was there for me, but that doesn’t change the fact that I’ve been living a lie. Everything I thought I knew about my life was a lie. Do you have any idea what that feels like?"
Esme’s eyes softened with empathy, but her resolve remained firm. "I understand how painful this must be for you, Silas. But Ewan raised you, loved you as his own. Don’t let your anger towards Victoria cloud your judgment about the man who has always been your father."
Esme stood up and approached him, her hand reaching out to touch his arm gently. "You have every right to feel betrayed and hurt, but don’t let it consume you. We need to understand the whole story before making any judgments. Maybe there are reasons we don’t know yet."
Silas’s expression wavered. The fire in his eyes flickered and died, replaced by a mask of dawning realization. Shame flooded his cheeks as he recognized the truth in his outburst.
He would never, could never, regret having Ewan as his father. Blood may not bind them, but the love and care Ewan showered upon him cemented their bond as true as any. No one could replace Ewan’s place in his heart, not even David.
Yet, a potent cocktail of sadness and anger churned within him. A gnawing sense of injustice clawed at his gut, a yearning to right the wrongs of a past he wasn’t a part of. He desperately wanted to make things right with David, to somehow bridge the chasm of lost years. But a heavy cloak of hesitation settled upon him.
He had always known Ewan as his father, and the thought of accepting someone else as his biological father felt like a betrayal. At the same time, he couldn’t ignore David’s existence or abandon him.
This agonizing internal conflict fueled his anger, leaving him lost and grasping for solutions. In this state of confusion, he had said things that he had not meant literally. Regret gnawed in his throat.
Esme, however, saw through the haze. "Producing a child doesn’t make someone a father," she continued. "It’s the love, the unwavering support, the presence in your life that defines a true father. When you were sick, David was not there. He wasn’t there to guide you in every step. He didn’t congratulate you when you graduated and became the CEO of such a massive business empire. It was Ewan, Silas. Remember that."
Silas tilted his head, Esme’s words sinking in. His gaze flickered, mulling over her points, recognizing the truth in them.
Esme continued, her tone firm yet compassionate. "It was always Ewan who was by your side—in sickness and happiness. He loved you unconditionally, raised you, and shaped you into the man you are today. He was the one who stayed up all night when you were ill, who taught you to ride a bicycle, and who celebrated every achievement with pride and joy. He did everything a father does for his child."
Silas’s eyes softened, the storm of emotions within him beginning to calm. He felt a surge of gratitude towards Esme for helping him see things more clearly. The confusion and anger started to dissipate, replaced by a renewed sense of appreciation for Ewan.
Esme grabbed his shoulders, trying to make him see reality. "Despite knowing you weren’t his by blood, he loved you unconditionally. Ewan never saw you as anything but his son. David, on the other hand, kept himself away from you."
Her tone grew colder, and her eyes hardened. "If David had missed you so much, he could have found a way to be in your life. But he didn’t. He took money from your mother and chose to stay away."