Five minutes passed in a flash.
The tension in the conference room was thick enough to cut with a knife. Zeke Campbell looked around and spoke in a deep voice, "Time’s up. Let’s hear everyone’s thoughts, starting with Owen Carter."
Called out first, Owen jolted and hastily stood up. His dismissive attitude from last night contrasted sharply with his current nervousness. Looking somewhat embarrassed, he braced himself and spoke.
"I—I think we should adopt a defensive public relations strategy," Owen started. "We immediately issue an official statement clarifying that the original intention of the ad was to praise the greatness of a mother’s love, with absolutely no intention of discriminating against women.
"Then, we temporarily disable the comment sections on all official accounts and give it the cold treatment. As for those inflammatory videos and posts online, we can mass-report them to get them taken down.
"Kotex itself is a small brand with very low online visibility. Internet trends change daily. In a few days, when netizens’ attention is drawn to other things, this matter will naturally blow over."
After he finished speaking, he carefully glanced at Zeke. This was indeed the most commonly used and safest approach in the industry.
"Next," Zeke said, noncommittal.
"I suggest an offensive PR strategy," said another colleague in charge of media channels, standing up. "It’s obvious that someone is playing tricks behind the scenes. Since someone paid for a troll army, we can trace these trolls to find the mastermind.
"Once we find out which competitor is smearing us, we can expose their dirty laundry too. If we muddy the waters, everyone’s attention will naturally shift."
This proposal made many people’s eyes light up. Giving them a taste of their own medicine sounded incredibly satisfying. A low murmur of discussion echoed through the conference room.
Zeke shook his head gently. "It’s a good idea, but we don’t have enough funds.
"The client only provided a PR budget of 200,000 yuan. Even if I apply for the maximum, it’d probably cap out at 300,000. I’m afraid this little money isn’t enough to launch a counterattack."
Following that, a few other colleagues put forward their own ideas. Zeke’s fingers tapped absently on the tabletop, but he didn’t adopt any of them. His gaze passed over the crowd and finally settled on the girl in the corner who had remained quiet from the very beginning. The entire conference room instantly fell silent as everyone followed the team leader’s line of sight and looked at Wendy Lynch.
"Wendy." Zeke’s voice wasn’t loud, but it clearly reached everyone’s ears. "You were the first to spot the problem. Tell us, what are your thoughts?"
SWISH! All eyes converged on Wendy, full of scrutiny and curiosity.
Owen, in particular, felt his cheeks burn as if he had been viciously slapped by an invisible hand. He felt somewhat fortunate that the others didn’t know what happened last night. Otherwise, he would be trying to figure out how to dig a hole in the floor and bury himself right now.
Wendy stood up, her expression calm. She didn’t immediately propose her own plan. Instead, she analyzed the previous two suggestions.
"I don’t agree with the defensive strategy," she said, her voice crisp and firm. "There’s a clear driving force behind this sudden public outcry. If we choose to give it the cold treatment, the opposing side will only invest more resources and create more topics to fan the flames. By then, we’ll completely lose the chance to control the situation."
She paused and turned to the colleague who advocated the offensive approach.
"An offensive strategy is equally inappropriate. First, we have no evidence. Finding out who is pulling the strings takes time, but public opinion won’t wait for us.
"Second, even if we do find out, publicly brawling with a competitor online will only turn the battlefield into a total mess, ultimately damaging Kotex’s brand image. Consumers don’t care about the dirty tricks between businesses; they’ll only see a brand riddled with negative press."
Her two points were well-reasoned and grounded, directly shutting down all the mainstream opinions presented earlier. The conference room was dead silent. The colleagues who had thought the previous two plans were good were now lost in thought.
A glimmer of approval flashed in Zeke’s eyes. Sure enough, this girl was anything but simple.
"Then what do you think we should do?" he pressed.
Meeting everyone’s gaze, Wendy clearly articulated her plan. "I believe we should immediately adopt a conciliatory PR strategy."
"Compromise?" a male colleague instinctively retorted. "We didn’t do anything wrong, so why should we compromise? Wouldn’t that be admitting that we’re actually engaging in gender discrimination?"
"Exactly! Wouldn’t apologizing just validate their accusations?" someone immediately chimed in.
Wendy ignored the doubts. Looking straight at Zeke, she continued her explanation.
"Netizens’ emotions have already been ignited. What they need isn’t an explanation, but an attitude. The more we try to explain, the more they’ll think we’re arrogant and making excuses.
"Therefore, we must retreat to advance. Before the situation spirals completely out of control, we need to take the initiative to admit our mistake and use the most sincere attitude to appease the users’ anger.
"I suggest immediately executing a three-step plan.
"First, issue a sincerely worded apology letter under Kotex’s official name. We shouldn’t make any excuses in the letter; we just admit that the ad’s content was poorly thought out, that it offended women, and offer a profound apology for it.
"Second, promise to immediately conduct an internal review and rectification of all the company’s promotional materials, and invite some user representatives as supervisors to participate in future ad creative reviews.
"Third, to show our sincerity, Kotex can make a public donation to a relevant women’s development foundation. The amount doesn’t need to be huge; the key is the gesture.
"Our core objective is not to win an argument. Public opinion is already completely one-sided. What we need to do is provide an outlet for the users’ negative emotions as quickly as possible, and then regain control of the narrative. As long as we apologize fast enough and are sincere enough, those who want to attack us will lose their biggest weapon."
After Wendy finished speaking, the conference room was so quiet you could hear a pin drop. Her plan completely subverted traditional PR thinking. No making excuses, no shifting blame, and no dragging it out. It was a total surrender—owning up to the mistake and taking the hit without resistance.
Moira Tate was the first to react. She immediately stood up and added, "I completely agree with Wendy’s plan! Right now, public sentiment is extremely sensitive when it comes to topics involving gender antagonism. Whoever acts high and mighty loses. A sincere apology is the only way to quickly cool things down right now."
Zeke looked at Wendy, a myriad of thoughts swirling in his mind. Just yesterday, he had thought this girl was making a mountain out of a molehill and blowing things out of proportion. But now, he only felt glad. Glad that Troy Lynch had transferred someone like her to his team. Although this plan wasn’t absolutely flawless, it was the most appropriate course of action for their current situation.
BAM! He slammed his hand on the table, the loud noise jolting everyone to attention.
"That’s exactly what we’ll do!"