(Sunday, at 2 in the afternoon...)
Imran Shah reads the letter from Pargeter and Lowe standing in the middle of the living room at Tanner’s Row. When he gets to the end of it, he laughs out loud.
"Livestock," he says, delighted. "Oh, that’s lovely. That’s really lovely. Mr Fenwick has been very busy." He holds the letter up to the light from the window, as if he might find something written on the back of it. "236 heads of livestock. He’s worded it as though you’d driven off with a lorry full of sheep."
"Is that bad?" asks Dex, from the floor, where he is sitting with his back against the sofa and Grumble’s head in his lap.
"It’s wonderful," says Shah. "It means he’s frightened."
He sits down at the kitchen table, which somebody has pulled over into the living room so that everyone can fit around it. He spreads the letter out in front of him, beside a stack of papers so tall that it has a mug of tea on top to stop it from falling over.
There are a great many people round the table, and Ren is not entirely sure how they all got there.
Elara sits on one side of him in her green coat, with Sorrel on her knee and the kitten with one white paw asleep in her collar.
Mia sits on the other side with her small black notebook open and her pencil ready. She has announced that she is taking the minutes, and nobody has had the courage to argue with her.
Ranger Fenn is standing at the stove with her back to all of them, making more tea.
Dex is on the floor with Grumble, and Shah sits at the head of the table in his navy suit, with his tie already loose and his sleeves pushed up.
Cressida Ashcombe sits very upright at the foot of the table, with her long ash-coloured plait over one shoulder and her gloves folded neatly beside her teacup.
She arrived ten minutes after Shah in a long black car, which is still parked at the bottom of Tanner’s Row with its engine running. She has not yet explained why she is here.
"Before we begin," she says now, in a voice like a pane of glass, "House Ashcombe will be meeting Mr Shah’s fees. All of them. For as long as this takes."
"Cressida, you don’t have to..."
"I’m aware of that, Calder." She does not look at him. She is looking out the window. "I paid my debt on Thursday night, with two fire engines on Morrow Bridge. We’re even. This isn’t a debt." She picks up her teacup, finds it empty, and puts it down again. "This is an investment."
Her heart jumped, says Hush, from the curtain rail. She is lying about the investment.
Hush, not now.
I am only reporting, says Hush. You said I was your lookout.
Ren keeps his face very still, which is harder than it sounds...
***
"Before we start on the Pen," says Shah, "there’s something else. It came on Friday morning, to the Academy and to me, as Mr Calder’s barrister. I don’t think anybody noticed it arrive." He takes a single sheet off the top of his stack, thinner than the rest, with the Covenant’s crest at the head of it. "I’m afraid nobody was meant to."
He reads it out.
Inquiry into the destruction of the heart of the Greywater rift, Hollin Moor. Reopened at the request of the Board of Kingsgate Academy.
The Authority finds that the equipment reported on level four was survey and extraction equipment, lawfully installed by V.G. Materials Ltd under clause nine of the Greywater licence as renewed in August, and lawfully removed after the surge for reasons of safety.
The Authority finds no fault on the part of V.G. Materials Ltd, its employees or any student of the Academy. The inquiry is closed.
For the Director, Covenant Authority.
There is a silence round the table.
"Lawfully," says Dex, from the floor. His voice has gone strange. "Bro. Lawfully. There were 30 of us down there when the gate closed up on us."
"I know, Mr Okoro."
"Pell pulled the lever. Sabine saw him do that, and she told them four times."
"I know." Shah puts the sheet down. "It doesn’t mention Miss Rourke. It doesn’t mention Mr Pell. It doesn’t mention the bolt with the Guild’s stamp on it, which Professor Holt pulled out of the floor in front of two of the Authority’s own inspectors. It doesn’t mention the statement they signed either." He taps the paper. "It’s dated the 28th of November. That’s the morning after the fire, when every newspaper in the country was looking at the Morrow Canal."
"No fault," says Elara quietly. "On the part of any student." She looks at Ren. "That’s you. They’ve cleared you too, so that you can’t complain."
"They’ve cleared everybody," says Shah. "That’s the point of it. If nobody’s to blame, nobody can be charged." He spreads his hands. "The Covenant reopened an inquiry into a machine that drained a rift for the Guild, and the Covenant found that the Covenant’s licence allowed it. I’m afraid that’s the end of it in the criminal courts. No prosecutor in Norhaven will touch it now."
"Then we shall not bring it up in the criminal courts."
Everybody turns round.
"There were 30 of us trapped in that rift," she says. "My brother and I were two of them. Lark’s paw was cut to the bone." Her voice is like a pane of glass, and there is a crack running all the way through it. "Somebody at that Guild decided that 30 first-years were an acceptable price for a rift’s heart." She looks at Shah. "House Ashcombe does not need a prosecutor, Mr Shah. It needs a writ."
Shah looks at her for a long moment.
"A civil claim," he says slowly. "Against V.G. Materials. For the 30..."
"For the 30 families. Every one of them that will put their name on it. House Ashcombe’s name first, and House Ashcombe’s purse with it." Cressida picks up her empty teacup, looks at it, and puts it down again. "A civil court doesn’t need the Authority’s permission to look at a bolt."
Her heart, says Hush, from the curtain rail, very quietly. It is not jumping. It is the steadiest I have ever heard it...
"It’ll take a year," says Shah. "Possibly two. The Guild will fight every page."
"Then it’ll take two," says Cressida. "We pay our debts, Mr Shah. We also collect them."
Shah writes something on the back of the Covenant’s sheet. Then he puts it to one side, under his mug, and pulls the next paper off the stack.
***
"Right," says Shah. "Let’s talk about what they’ve got, and what we’ve got."
He holds up a typed sheet. It is a copy of the notice that was pinned to the gate of the Pen, the one Ren read so many times that he knew it by heart.
"The property known as the Norhaven Beast Reclamation Centre, Morrow Canal, together with its cellars and all subterranean rights, has been sold to V.G. Holdings Ltd," Shah reads. "The Centre will cease operation and be decommissioned on 27 November. Any remaining contents will be disposed of by the purchaser." He puts the sheet down and taps it. "That’s their case. They bought the building, and the building came with its contents, and the contents had legs. So the beasts were theirs, and you walked off with them, and they want them back."
"That’s not fair," says Mia.
"It’s not about being fair, Miss Calder. It’s about paper." Shah smiles at her. "So let’s look at the rest of the paper."
He picks up another sheet.
"This is a copy of the permit for the controlled demolition burn at the Morrow Canal, issued by the city council on the 26th of November and countersigned by the Covenant. Mr Hale’s friend at the Canal Street fire station very kindly obtained it for me yesterday, in exchange for a promise that I would never tell anybody where I got it." He puts it down beside the first one. "Under Purpose of Burn, somebody has typed, Disposal of building and remaining contents."
He picks up a third sheet.
"This is a transcript of Mr Pike’s statement, taken from the recording Mr Okoro so heroically made on a burning floor." On the rug, Dex goes pink. "Mr Pike says, quite clearly, that he was told to light the fire, and that the Guild took his own dog to make sure he did as he was told."
Shah lays the three sheets side by side on the table, very neatly, and looks round at them all.
"They promised in writing to dispose of the contents," he says. "Then they applied for a permit to burn the contents. Then they paid a man to set the contents on fire." He sits back. "An owner who sets out to burn its own property, Mr Calder, has given that property up. The law has a very old word for it. Abandonment. You can’t abandon something on Thursday night and then write a stiff letter demanding it back on Friday morning."
There is a short silence round the table.
"So they’re not theirs," says Ren slowly.
"They’re not theirs."
"Then whose are they?"
Shah looks at him for a long moment.
"That," he says, "is the interesting question. Under the Rehoming Statute, a beast whose owner has abandoned is a released beast, like any other beast that’s been signed out at the front desk of the Pen. Section 14 says that a released beast which chooses a new tamer, freely and in front of a licensed warden, is rehomed to that tamer." He spreads his hands. "Your 236 haven’t chosen anybody, as far as I understand it. You didn’t contract them. You sheltered them. So until they choose, they belong to nobody but themselves. They’re released beasts in a safe place."
"Then that’s our case," says Elara quietly.
"That’s our case."
"And theirs?"
"Theirs is that you broke into their building through a coal door," says Shah cheerfully, "which you did. They’ll also say you took things that didn’t belong to you, which you didn’t, because the beasts didn’t belong to anyone. Trespass is a fine, Mr Calder. Theft needs an owner." He picks up his tea, finds it cold, and drinks it anyway. "If we can show that the beasts were abandoned, Mr Fenwick has no owner. And if he has no owner, he has no case."
***
Mia has been writing very fast. Now, she stops, puts her pencil down and looks at Shah across the table.
"If they don’t belong to anybody," she says, "can they choose families?"
Everyone turns to look at her.
"I mean real families," says Mia. "Not Ren. Not all of them want Ren, do they? Some of them must have had people before, people who sent them to the Pen because they were moving or because they got old. Some of them might want people again." She looks down at Pip in her lap. "If they’re released, can’t they choose somebody? In front of a warden? Like Tansy did. Like Thorn."
Shah opens his mouth and closes it again.
"In front of a licensed warden," he says slowly, "a released beast can choose anyone it likes, Miss Calder. That’s what the Statute is for."
"Then why don’t we let them?"
Nobody says anything.
Ren looks at his sister and thinks about the valley. He thinks of the dogs sitting alone in the long grass, the mastiff that is afraid to sleep, and the cats on the grey rock who cannot bear to be more than a whisker apart. He thinks about the residents of the Sanctuary passing words along between him and the 236 sheltered beasts like buckets in a fire line. He thinks about Tansy and her one-eyed badger.
Some of them would, says Ember, very quietly, inside the bond. Some of them have been asking me where their people went. The little brown dog by the gorse. A ginger cat on the rock. They don’t want a valley. They want a lap.
"Yes," Ren says aloud. "Some of them would."
Shah is looking at Mia with an expression that Ren has never seen on his face before. It is somewhere between respect and alarm.
"Miss Calder," he says, "have you ever considered a career in the law?"
"No," says Mia. "Lawyers are always cold. Look at your tea. That is a prime example of it."
***
It is Cressida who finds the weak point, and she finds it so quickly that Shah looks almost disappointed.
"There’s a problem," she says.
They all look at her. She has been quiet since her announcement, sitting very straight at the foot of the table with her hands folded. Now, she leans forward and puts one gloved finger on the notice from the gate.
"Mr Fenwick will say that you’ve made them up," she says. "Not the beasts. The numbers. 236. He’ll say there were 30, or 50, and that the rest are beasts you’ve collected from somewhere else and hidden in your... wherever it is that you keep them." She does not look at Ren. "He’ll say that some of them were never in the building at all, and so they were never abandoned but stolen. He’ll make you prove every single one." She sits back. "That’s what I’d do, if I were him."
Shah sighs.
"Miss Ashcombe is quite right," he says. "Section 14 doesn’t only need a warden for the choosing. It needs a record of the releasing. We’d have to show that every one of those beasts was inside that building on that night. We’d need a cage and a date for each of them, in somebody’s book, or Fenwick will pick them off one by one." He rubs his eyes. "The Pen’s own intake books will be in the Guild’s hands by now, or under the rubble. I doubt we’ll ever see them."
"I’ve got one."
Elara says it so quietly that for a moment, nobody hears.
Then they all turn around.
In her hands, she is holding her warden’s logbook, the slim black book that every licensed warden has to carry. She opens it on the table in front of Shah.
"Mrs Abernathy made me write every single intake in it," she says. "Every single one of them, for a month. The cage number, the floor, the date and where they came from. She told me to make sure I’d done it properly." She turns the pages. They are covered in her small, careful handwriting, line after line after line. "I didn’t know why. I thought she was just being fussy. She was crying, the morning she said it, and I didn’t know why that was either."
Shah stares at the logbook.
He turns one page very slowly, and then another. Then he runs his finger down a column of cage numbers, and his lips move as he counts.
"Floor two," he says. "Forty, from four shelters, between the 30th of October and the 25th of November." He turns another page. "Floor one. Carthorses from the Tanner’s Lane stables. Hill ponies, twelve, from a farm sale in the Weald." His voice has gone very quiet. "Miss Voss, there’s every single one in here."
"236," says Elara. "I counted them. Tobin counted them on the night itself with a torch. We got the same number."
On the far side of the table, Cressida lets out a long, slow breath.
"Then you haven’t got a weak point anymore," she says.
"Not quite." Shah has not looked up from the logbook. "This proves that they were in the building. It doesn’t prove the Guild meant to burn them, not on its own. Pike’s confession says so, but Fenwick will say that Pike is a liar, which he is." He closes the book very gently and hands it back to Elara as if it were made of glass. "What I need is somebody from inside. Somebody who was told what was going to happen to the Pen, and when, and by whom."
He looks up at Elara.
"Why did Mrs Abernathy make you write it all down?" he says. "What did she know?"
Elara does not answer for a moment. She looks down at the logbook in her hands.
"I don’t know," she says. "I haven’t seen her since Wednesday. Tobin said she went home in tears, and nobody’s heard from her since."
Shah is already on his feet, reaching for his coat.
"Then find her, Miss Voss," he says. "Find her before Mr Fenwick does..."