The courtroom smells like polish and old paper, and it is considerably smaller than Ren had imagined. A raised bench for the judge, a witness box, two long tables, and three rows of public benches.
The benches are crowded, as is the corridor outside, along with the court steps stretching down to the street, where photographers have been camping for hours. The Silent Unbonded is in court, and everyone is eager to see what happens.
Ren sits at one of the tables in a borrowed suit, with his arm in its sling and his back aching against the hard chair. Beside him, Imran Shah is reading three documents at once, and on his other side, Elara sits upright in her green coat, her logbook resting on the table before her. Between pages 30 and 35, there is a gap in the binding where four paper stubs protrude. She submitted it to the clerk at 4:50 yesterday in its current state.
Between the two tables, in the court’s well, Vesper is lying with her wings folded.
The court requested the beast involved, so Ren brought her forward. Almost filling the space between the tables, black and silver, she curls her tail around the witness box.
Mr Aubrey Fenwick sits by himself at the other table, well-dressed and composed. Magnus Vance sits behind him in the front row of the public benches.
***
Ren has never been this near to Magnus Vance before.
He is tall and bulky, dressed in a charcoal suit, sporting a short grey beard and very pale eyes. He doesn’t glance at Ren or Elara. With both hands resting on a cane with a silver handle, he stares at the judge’s unoccupied chair, as if he’s waiting for a train.
Adrian is not with him. Next to him sits a young woman wearing a simple grey dress, her blonde hair neatly pinned at the nape of her neck.
"Who’s that?" Ren whispers.
Shah keeps his eyes on his papers without looking up. "Lysandra Vance," he says softly. "Elder daughter, two years older than Adrian. She handles the Guild’s finances and never agrees to interviews." He turns a page over. "She rarely smiles."
She isn’t paying attention to the judge’s chair, Fenwick, or Ren. Since the moment she sat down, she hasn’t taken her eyes off Vesper.
Ren, says Vesper, very quietly.
What?
That one, beside the grey man. She pauses. She smells of lamp oil.
Ren casts a glance at the woman and then shifts his eyes back to Vesper.
Lamp oil?
Never mind, says Vesper. She places her head down on her front feet without uttering another word.
***
"All rise."
Appearing about sixty years old, Judge Harrowgate is small and round, sporting half-moon glasses. Sitting down, she sees the drake lying in the middle of her courtroom and arches her eyebrows.
"Well," she remarks. "That’s new."
She lifts a big brown envelope off the bench.
"This morning, before we begin, I received a postal delivery addressed to me specifically under the name of this case. There is neither a letter, a name, nor a return address." She pulls out four sheets of paper and places them on the bench. "Mr Shah, Mr Fenwick, come over and have a look."
The two men move forward. Ren holds his breath, and beside him, Elara grips the edge of the table.
Fenwick examines the four pages, his composed face unmoved, though his fingers press harder against the bench’s edge.
Shah does likewise. Afterwards, he turns to Ren, his face showing utter innocence.
"I don’t want to know how they got into the post," he murmurs quietly.
Judge Harrowgate does not look up.
"Mr Shah, no one ever does," she says.
***
Fenwick summons his witness.
Wearing a brown suit that’s a size too small and carrying a tin of mints that bulges squarely in his jacket pocket, Desmond Pike takes his place in the witness box. His face appears grey. He avoids looking at Elara or Ren, only casting a brief glance at Magnus Vance before quickly diverting his eyes.
He takes the oath.
Fenwick asks how long Pike has managed the Pen, and Pike tells him twenty years. He asks Pike if he knows Miss Voss, to which Pike replies yes, she is among his junior wardens. Then, with a gentle and sorrowful tone, Fenwick inquires if Miss Voss ever visited his office to request adding an entry to her log after its intended date.
"Yes," says Pike.
He has a steady voice—one that is well-rehearsed.
"It was about a week after the drake went missing," he says. "She was crying and in a terrible state. She said she got into trouble and had to write a backdated entry in her log so that it looked like it was written at the right moment. She pleaded with me." Pike shakes his head. "I clearly said no, of course. And I apologise, but I can’t lie while under oath."
Elara grips her pen so tightly that it was threatening to snap.
Liar! You absolute liar!
"Thank you, Mr Pike," Fenwick replies. "Nothing further."
He takes a seat. The courtroom is quiet, and Magnus Vance sits motionless in the front row.
Shah gets up.
***
"Mr Pike," he says pleasantly. "Good morning."
"Morning."
"Twenty years at the Pen is a very long time." Shah approaches the witness box at a leisurely pace. "You must know the building very well."
"I do."
"Every room, every door and every key?"
With a slight hesitation, Pike answers, "Yes."
"Miss Voss tells me that you enforced a new rule at the pen recently," Shah mentions. "Wardens are no longer allowed to take their logs home and must secure them in their lockers within the warden room." He smiles. "Is that right?"
"For security," says Pike. "Yes."
"Very sensible. Who holds the keys to those lockers?"
"Each warden has a key to their own lockers."
"Only their own?"
"Yes."
"So suppose something was taken from a warden’s locker without the warden herself doing it..." Shah widens his hands. "Who could have done it besides them?"
Pike opens his mouth but quickly closes it again.
"Mr Pike?"
"Nobody," says Pike.
Shah waits. He doesn’t say a word. He just stands politely with his hands clasped, waiting as the silence lingers.
Someone sitting on the public benches coughs. The clock on the wall ticks, and Pike tugs at his collar. His eyes shift to the bench, resting on the brown envelope and the four sheets of paper set before the judge.
Then a part of his face collapses inward.
"A master key exists," he confesses, in a very low voice. "In my office."
"Thank you, Mr Pike."
Got you!
***
Shah faces the bench.
"My lady, may I approach?"
Judge Harrowgate nods.
He takes Elara’s logbook, carefully spreads it open at the four stubs, and places it flat on the bench. He then grabs the first loose page, which has the printed number 31 on the corner, and sets it beside the first stub.
"In the old days," Imran Shah says casually to everyone, "when a child in Norhaven was apprenticed to a trade, they duplicated the contract on a single sheet. After that, they sliced it in half with a wavy line, and each side retained one half. It was referred to as an indenture. Whenever anyone alleged the contract was fake, you combined the halves to see if the cut matched."
Fenwick has risen to his feet.
"Objection, my lady. These pages came through anonymous mail, and their origin is completely unknown. Anybody could have..."
"Anyone could have cut them out of a bound book serialised with numbers on every page?" Judge Harrowgate doesn’t even glance at him. "Mr Fenwick, please sit down. I want to take a look at this."
Fenwick sits.
Shah aligns the loose page alongside the stub.
The cut isn’t even. The person who made it was rushed, causing the blade to stray. Close to the top is a minor curve, a nick midway down caused by the knife snagging, followed by a slight deviation toward the base. The loose page matches the same curve, nick, and drift, and the two parts fit together like jigsaw pieces.
Leaning over her half-moon glasses, Judge Harrowgate scrutinises it for an extended period. Then she grabs the next page, aligns it herself, followed by the next and the last, each fitting perfectly.
"Hm," she says, and looks up at the witness box.
"Mr Pike, I must remind you that you are currently under oath."
Pike’s face has gone ghastly white.
"I would also like to remind you," Judge Harrowgate says calmly, "that perjury in this court is punishable by a sentence of up to seven years." She takes off her glasses. "Would you like to reconsider any part of your evidence?"
Pike glances at Magnus Vance, but Magnus Vance avoids eye contact. Pike reaches into his jacket pocket and clutches the tin of mints.
He admits, "I could have been mistaken."
A gasp spreads through the public benches, and someone at the rear laughs loudly and is quickly silenced. Pike gets off the box but falters on the bottom step, so the usher grabs his arm and directs him back to his seat. He doesn’t make eye contact with anyone.
***
Judge Harrowgate dismisses the claim in just four minutes, using very few words.
The warden’s log is authentic, and the entry was recorded at the moment. The statute is in effect, and Mr Calder owns the drake.
Regarding the griffin, the injury took place in a regulated bout after the claimant’s son broke rule nine, thus it is under the jurisdiction of the Bowl and not her court.
She is forwarding Mr Pike’s evidence transcript to the prosecutors’ office and would appreciate if someone could remove the drake from her courtroom without it toppling the witness box.
Elara covers her face with her hands. Ren has lost sensation in his legs.
We won... We actually won!? Hahahah!
Vesper, it’s done. You’re mine. A judge declared so, and it’s recorded in writing.
Vesper lifts her head off her front feet.
I was always yours, she says. Now, they know it too.
***
The photographers go crazy on the court steps.
Ren steps into the light with Elara on one side, Shah on the other, and Vesper standing behind him with her wings folded. Flashes burst like hailstones, while people yell questions and call out his name.
The crowd then splits as Magnus Vance descends the steps toward him.
With a wide, warm smile for the cameras, he holds out his hand.
Ren is reluctant to take it, yet with every camera on the steps focused on that hand, he decides to take it.
With a slow, steady handshake, Magnus turns a bit to ensure the photographers have the perfect view of him and Ren. He appears completely like a gracious loser applauding a courageous young man. After that, he leans in, seeming ready to say something nice.
"Enjoy your drake, boy," he murmurs, his smile unwavering. His breath carries the scent of coffee and cigars. "Enjoy her while you can."
His hold becomes firmer until Ren’s knuckles press against each other.
"Your beloved Pen won’t survive the term," declares Magnus Vance.
He releases him, gives Ren’s sore shoulder a hard slap, and walks down the steps toward a long black car.
Behind him, a young woman dressed in grey pauses on the step above Ren. She remains silent and avoids looking at Ren entirely. She gazes at Vesper, who stands on the court steps with her black wings folded, their silver edges gleaming in the sunlight, and Vesper raises her head to meet her gaze.
Ren thought she was about to say something, but she turns around, descends the steps following her father, and enters the black car without glancing back...