(Alash Vortex POV)
Five minutes.
I had crossed the kingdom twice. I had been on a ridge with something that had no name and too many joints, and stood inside four other people’s heads, and gone up two stages in an afternoon without asking to. I had spent the best part of a month being supervised by two of the most stubborn healers alive.
And now there was a building at the end of a courtyard, and a man in it who wanted to talk to me.
I would rather have gone back up the ridge.
I looked at my chest, thoughtfully. It still hurt when I breathed in too far. A man with a chest like that, I reasoned, could quite properly ask for a day’s rest before any conversation that mattered.
Then I looked up, and Valerian was standing four feet away, watching me think it.
He didn’t say anything. He didn’t need to. I had tried arguments like it on him for five years, and I remembered exactly how every one of them had gone.
"I wasn’t going to," I said.
"I know," said Valerian.
***
Sorel wasn’t finished with the handover. None of the five of us were going anywhere near our residences until she was, so Renn found the others a room off the infirmary with beds in it, a fire and somebody to bring food, and told them to wait there. Sorel told them to lie down while they did.
He would walk me across himself.
Elizabeth stopped me at the door.
"He’ll ask you about my consent," she said. "He should. But my part of it is mine to give an account of. It goes in separately, and I’ll give it myself." She held my eyes. "I want it written down while I’m in the room."
"I wasn’t going to ask you to defend me."
"I know. That’s why I’m telling you."
James looked like a man hunting for something encouraging to say and finding only lies. In the end he clapped me very gently on the shoulder, on the side away from my chest, and sat down.
"Good luck," said Sophie.
Daphne said nothing at all. She looked at me from the window, and then back out of it.
I found that more comforting than anything else in the room. Anyone else might have reminded me I had this coming. Daphne didn’t need to. We both already knew.
***
Zenith was exactly as I’d left it.
That was the strange part. We walked through the gate court and along the colonnade toward the administrative wing, and there were students on the steps, and a professor I half recognised hurrying past with an armful of papers, and two second-years arguing outside a lecture hall about whose turn it was to have the east practice yard. Somebody laughed in an upper window.
None of them looked at us twice. Why would they? An Academy commander and a first-year with a pillow under his arm.
The place had gone on without us. Lectures had happened. Timetables had been fought over. People had eaten breakfast and been late for things. I had come back with a stronger core and a weaker chest and a disciplinary problem, and none of it changed the plain fact that I was a student, walking down a corridor, toward the Headmaster’s office.
Renn knocked once and opened the door.
"Lord Vortex, Headmaster."
"Thank you, Commander. See to your escort, if you would, and come back when you’ve handed it over. I’ll want your report after."
Renn went.
***
The office looked as it always did. Books on every surface. Papers in the gaps between the books. The cane leaning against the desk, and the pot of tea that remained proof that age did not automatically produce wisdom.
Theoran was behind the desk. He looked older than when I’d left. That might have been me.
He didn’t look angry. I had prepared for angry. I had a version of myself ready for angry, the same one I’d had ready for the hearing over James.
"Sit, Vortex."
I sat. I put Dream Haven between my back and the chair, out of habit, and he watched me do it and said nothing.
That was worse.
"I have Healer Sorel’s relays," he said. "All of them. I know Her Highness is alive. I know all five of you are C-Black.
"I know you used Healing Bond on the ridge, and I know what I had told you about Healing Bond." He folded his hands over the head of the cane. "I’m not going to pretend I’m hearing any of it for the first time. But I would like to hear it from the person who decided it."
He paused.
"The last time you sat in front of me over a bond, I told the room it was not a disciplinary hearing. I wanted that established before anyone became creative."
"I remember."
"This one is."
"I know," I said.
***
He started with the order.
"After James Vellaroux," he said, "I gave a ruling. Tell me what it was."
"No new bonds. Not one. Not for any reason. Not on anyone, until we understand what this is."
"And?"
"It was yours personally. You said you’d treat a breach as a breach of your authority, not of a rule."
"Do you dispute any part of that?"
"No."
"Did you understand it, before you went west?"
"Yes."
He nodded, as though I had confirmed the date.
"Then tell me why."
I had rehearsed this. I’d had a long road to rehearse it on. Every version I’d prepared had been longer than what I said.
"She’d lost a great deal of blood," I said. "Her shoulder was badly hurt, her ribs were broken and she was cut at the hairline. I closed what could be closed and set the ribs. That’s what Healing does. But her channels were overdrawn from palm to shoulder, and nothing I have heals channels. And I couldn’t put back the blood. Healing doesn’t."
"Go on."
"Healing Bond doesn’t heal either. It makes the body do its own recovering faster, for an hour. I thought that hour, then, on that ridge, might matter. That the first hours decide how a thing sets." I made myself keep going. "I knew what it had done to James.
"It let him go on past the point where his body should have stopped him. That was exactly why you’d forbidden it. But she couldn’t go on. She had nothing left. She’d promised to stop using anything for the rest of the day, and she did stop. I judged the risk of waiting as worse than the risk of the hour."
I stopped, and made myself say the rest.
"And I was frightened. She was grey. Sophie was bleeding from the nose, holding that thing in her ice, and I didn’t know how long any of us had. I’d like to tell you it was all reasoning. Some of it was fear. I can’t separate the two now, and I don’t think I could then."
Theoran’s pen stopped for a moment. Then it went on.
"And were you right?"
"I don’t know."
He waited.
"I can’t prove it either way," I said. "Master Alzette has told me there was a real argument for acting, and that he can’t say whether I was right. Neither can I. I’m not going to pretend I knew something then that he and Healer Sorel still don’t know now."
Theoran wrote something down. His pen was the only sound in the room.
"When you activated it," he said, "did you know you were disobeying my order?"
"Yes."
"If Her Highness had refused?"
"I wouldn’t have done it."
"You’re certain."
"Yes."
He looked at me for a long moment, and I think he believed me.
"That matters," he said. "I want you to understand that I think it matters. You explained what you knew, and you asked, and you would have accepted no." He set the pen down. "But a patient’s consent to a treatment and a healer’s authority to give it are two separate questions.
"Her Highness could agree to the risks she understood. She could not overturn my order. Neither could you."
"I know."
"Then here is a harder one." He didn’t change his tone. "Healer Sorel’s notes mention gold. Under all five of you, on the ridge. They also record that you told Her Highness afterwards you had seen something like it once before, under James Vellaroux." He looked at me over his folded hands. "When you asked Her Highness for her consent, did you tell her about that?"
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because I didn’t think of it. Not until afterwards." That was true, and it wasn’t enough, so I said the rest. "I didn’t know it could do what it did.
"I didn’t know it could spread, or move our cores, or anything that came after. But I’d seen something unexplained happen with that skill before, and she hadn’t, and she was the one deciding. I’ve told her so since."
I could have stopped there. He had asked about the bond.
"There’s one more," I said. "At the Crucible. Under the Guardian Seals, when the five of us reached them, before we fed them. Gold lines, for a moment, where there shouldn’t have been any. Five points. I told Her Highness about that as well, at Halden."
I took a breath.
"And I told one other person, on the road home, in front of Commander Renn. He’ll tell you who. I’d rather you heard the rest of it from me first."
Theoran looked at me for a long moment. His face didn’t change, but his eyes did, for a moment, and then went still again. He wrote it down, and didn’t ask who.
Theoran didn’t treat that as a confession of anything worse. I watched him decide not to.
"Then the record will say that," he said. "What you knew. What you didn’t. What you’d seen and didn’t say. I’m not going to write down that you foresaw what happened, because I don’t believe you did. I’m also not going to write down that you’d told her everything, because you hadn’t."
"That’s fair."
"It isn’t meant to be fair. It’s meant to be accurate. Sometimes they’re the same thing."
He let that sit, and asked the question I had been dreading since Halden.
"Do you regret it?"
I didn’t answer straight away.
I wanted to. There was a joke right there, ready, as there usually is. I could feel the shape of it. I left it where it was.
"I regret that she was in danger," I said. "I regret not telling her about the light.
"I regret making a decision I couldn’t fully explain, and putting her into consequences neither of us understood." I looked at my hands. "But if you’re asking whether I wish I’d sat on that platform and watched her get worse when I had something that might help, I can’t tell you that. I’d be lying, and you’d know."
"I’m not asking you that."
I looked up.
"I’m asking you to tell the difference," said Theoran, "between regretting what you were faced with, and admitting what you did about it."
It took me a moment.
"It seemed to help," I said slowly. "She’s alive. Neither of those things changes the fact that I chose to disobey you. Knowing I was doing it. I did."
"Yes," said Theoran. "You did."
He didn’t say it unkindly. He didn’t say it kindly either. He just said it, the way you put a weight down on a table, so that everyone can see how much it weighs.
I didn’t make a joke. I couldn’t think of one. For once I didn’t look very hard.
***
He sent for Valerian first.
Valerian came in and stood, because nobody had offered him a chair and he wasn’t the kind of man who sat in a Headmaster’s office uninvited.
"Master Alzette." Theoran looked at him with real interest. "I’ve read a great deal of your writing."
"I apologise for the length."
"Don’t. For five years it was the only accurate account of this boy I had." Theoran’s mouth moved very slightly. "Your medical opinion, please. Of the decision on the ridge."
Valerian gave it exactly as he had given it to me on the wall at Halden. There had been a real argument for acting. He couldn’t say whether it had been right.
"I can tell you what I’d have advised if I’d been there," he said. "I can’t tell you I’d have been right either. Nobody on that ridge had a second healer. That was most of the problem."
"Thank you."
Valerian inclined his head and went to stand by the wall.
***
Sorel brought Elizabeth in a quarter of an hour later.
She had her arm in its sling, and Sorel put her in the chair beside mine without asking anyone, and stood behind it. Elizabeth didn’t stand to speak, and Theoran didn’t ask her to.
"Your Highness."
"Headmaster." She sat very straight. "I’d like my account taken as my own. Not as a note on his."
"It will be."
"Then here it is."
She gave it the way she gives everything that matters: in order, without colour, and without leaving anything out.
"Lord Vortex told me four things before I agreed. That the skill would make my body recover faster at its own rate, for an hour, and then stop. That a connection would remain afterwards, and that as far as anyone knew, it couldn’t be undone.
"That it had let James Vellaroux damage himself, and that it would only help me if I stopped using anything for the rest of the day. And that you had forbidden it, personally, and that if I said yes, I would be part of breaking that." She paused. "I understood all four. I said yes."
"You were badly hurt at the time."
"I was frightened, and I was badly hurt, and I didn’t know whether I’d walk off that ridge." Her voice didn’t change. "I still made the choice. I’d like it written down that I made it. I won’t have it described as something Lord Vortex did to me."
Theoran nodded slowly.
"And the rest?"
"I didn’t consent to the rest," said Elizabeth. "Because nobody knew there was a rest. The light, and what came with it, and the cores, and whatever it is that’s still there now.
"Nobody offered me those, so nobody could ask me." She looked at him steadily. "That doesn’t make the choice I did make into nothing. And it doesn’t make what I made it about into everything."
There was a short silence.
"I’m not asking you to excuse him," she added. "I’d think less of the Academy if you did. I’m asking you to put my part where it belongs."
"It belongs in the confidential record, beside his and separate from it," said Theoran. "Signed by you. You’ll read it before it’s filed, and you may correct it." He looked at her for a moment longer. "You’ll also be examined weekly, with the others who were bonded before you. Arkwright will be glad of the data. You may find her difficult to discourage."
"I’ve met Lena," said Elizabeth.
"Then you know." He turned to Sorel. "Healer."
Sorel gave him the medical part in five sentences. The hour had lasted an hour. The faster recovery had stopped when it should. In Elizabeth she had found something else besides, not strain and not the bond as far as she could see one, which she couldn’t identify. Master Alzette, examining her separately, had found something there he couldn’t account for either.
In all five, the cores had moved together, two stages, and held, and no Healing Bond she had read of or observed explained that. She had written down that she couldn’t explain it, every day, and she still couldn’t.
"Can you tell me it’s harmless?" said Theoran. "Whatever is still there."
"No."
"Can you tell me it isn’t?"
"No."
Theoran looked at Elizabeth. "Then I can’t promise you that either. The Academy will need to understand what happened to you, Your Highness, and to the other four. That may mean further examination."
"I accept that," said Elizabeth. "With my agreement, each time. Being investigated doesn’t mean I stop being asked."
"No," said Theoran. "It doesn’t."
He wrote for a while. When he spoke again, he spoke to the room, not to any one of us.
"So there are three matters, and I will not have them confused. Lord Vortex disobeyed my order. That is his. Her Highness made an informed choice about the risks she was told of. That is hers.
"And something happened afterwards, to all five of them, that nobody in this room can explain. That belongs to all five, and to the people treating them, and it is a medical question, not a disciplinary one."
He looked at me.
"I won’t punish you for the third. I won’t excuse you because of the second. And the first is still the first."
Elizabeth looked at me sideways, once. It wasn’t sympathy. It was something more like solidarity, from one person who had been made to sit still and be accurate to another.
Sorel took her out.
***
"Now," said Theoran.
He drew a sheet of paper toward him that had clearly been written before I arrived, and read it through once more, and changed a word.
"I’m not expelling you," he said. "I’m not taking your class from you.
"Class Five didn’t break my order, and it would be a poor lesson to teach them that it’s their fault when you do." He set the pen down. "And I’m not going to give you something arbitrary to scrub, so that we can both feel that justice has been done. That would be easier for both of us, and it would be useless."
"What, then?"
"What happened with James hasn’t been resolved. We still don’t understand the bond. And you’ve now deliberately done again the one thing I told you not to do while we didn’t." He turned the sheet round so I could read it. "So until I say otherwise, someone else stands between you and the decisions you’ve been making alone."
I read it.
It was a written order, signed already, with a space for my name under his.
Ordinary Healing I could still use, within the usual medical limits. Beyond that, until further authorisation, I was not to undertake active Barrier work, cultivation, or any Healing beyond the ordinary, except in an exercise my supervising healer had approved beforehand, with its output limits written down, and with him, or a healer he named, present while I did it.
I was not to create a new Healing Bond, on anyone, for any reason, without his express authorisation, renewed in writing.
Master Valerian Alzette was named as my supervising medical specialist for the present. Healer Sorel and the Academy’s healers might supervise in his place where he directed. Core cultivation, once it was medically allowed, would be Professor Selene’s to teach, not his.
The order would be reviewed after seven days, or sooner if the healers found something that changed it.
"Read that one twice," said Theoran, watching me. "A healer being in the room doesn’t make a thing allowed. The exercise is approved, its limits are written, and somebody watches. All three, every time."
I read it twice.
"Each of those is for something," he said. "I’d like you to know what. The Barrier and the cultivation are for your chest and your channels.
"Master Alzette tells me the Barrier strain from Merrow’s and the ridge is still in you, and that your body is carrying two stages more than it was built for, and that pushing either would teach it the wrong thing. That isn’t punishment. That’s your healer, written down where you can’t argue with it."
"And the Healing?"
"Is for your patients, as much as for you. We don’t understand what you can do beyond ordinary Healing, and neither do you. Until we do, somebody watches." He tapped the last line. "And the bond is the bond. That’s mine. That’s the order you broke, made into something you sign."
"Seven days," I said.
"A review is a review. It isn’t a promise that anything will be lifted. If your chest has mended and Master Alzette says so, some of it may change. If it hasn’t, none of it will."
"And if somebody’s dying in front of me?"
He had expected that. I could see he had.
"Then I’m not ordering you to let them die," said Theoran. "I couldn’t, and I wouldn’t, and you wouldn’t obey me if I did." He held my eyes. "If there is a genuine emergency, one that can’t wait for anybody, you do what is necessary to keep that person alive until help comes.
"Only what is necessary. Then you report it to me, immediately, and it will be examined medically and judged on whether it was truly necessary."
He let that settle.
"That is not permission," he said. "It isn’t a door I’m leaving open for you to walk through whenever you’ve decided something might help. It’s the recognition that a door may get broken, and a statement of how it will be judged afterwards. The difference matters. I’d like you to show me you understand it."
"I understand it."
"Then show me."
He slid a second sheet across. It was blank, except for a heading.
"Your own account of the ridge. Everything you did with the bond, what you knew of its risks, why you went ahead, and what happened after that you can’t explain. Signed.
"It goes with Her Highness’s statement into the confidential record." He looked at me over the cane. "And your weekly reports continue. I told you once that I knew they wouldn’t be everything. I would still like them to become more than nothing."
I looked down at the order.
It wasn’t detention. It wasn’t scrubbing anything. It was worse, and I understood exactly why he’d chosen it.
Every useful thing I did when somebody needed help went through my hands. Healing. Barrier. Deciding, on my own, what someone needed, and doing it before anyone could tell me no. That was what I had been for, since I was ten years old.
He had taken all of that and put another person in front of it. I couldn’t declare myself well enough. I couldn’t decide that a bigger core meant I could put out more. I couldn’t go looking for another bond because I had a reason I couldn’t explain to anyone.
And I had one.
’System.’
[Yes.]
’Healing Path.’
[Sub Quest 1. Healing Bond Path. Six of seven.]
’One more.’
[One more bond completes the objective.]
’And this order says I can’t.’
[The order does not change the objective.]
’It changes whether I do it.’
There was a pause.
[Yes.]
I didn’t tell Theoran. I didn’t tell him about the System, or the quest, or that there was a seventh bond waiting somewhere at the end of a Path I couldn’t explain. I couldn’t, and I hadn’t been asked, and I wasn’t sure it would have helped.
But I knew it was there, and now there was a sheet of paper with his signature on it standing between me and it.
I signed under his name.
Theoran took the sheet back, looked at my signature, and blotted it.
"You haven’t argued," he said.
"No."
"I don’t mistake that for agreement."
"It isn’t, entirely," I said. "Not every part."
"I know." He set the order aside. "I don’t need you to agree with all of it. I need you to obey it."
"I will."
He looked at me for a long moment. Then he nodded, once, and that was that part done.