On Wednesday morning, for the first time since the ridge, I was given permission to do something.
I had begun to suspect the Academy meant to keep me indefinitely, like an unusually valuable piece of furniture: dusted, admired, and never sat on. So when Valerian put a folded sheet in front of me at breakfast and said, "Ferran’s yard, before first lesson," I very nearly sat up straight.
Then I read the sheet.
Exercise: one ordinary Barrier pane, no wider than one hand-span on any side, formed at a marked position.
Interception: if the object leaves its expected path inside the marked square, the same pane may be formed at another point inside the square to stop it. Same size. Same duration.
Duration: dismissed on contact, or at a count of three, whichever comes first.
Attempts: no more than four.
Stop at once: on any return of pain behind the breastbone; on any pane larger than specified; on the word of Professor Ferran or the undersigned.
Present throughout: V. Alzette.
Not authorised: cultivation, Healing beyond the ordinary, any use of Barrier outside the marked square.
It was signed, and dated, and initialled in the margin by Theoran’s office.
"It’s longer than the pane," I said.
"Most things worth doing are," said Valerian.
"I used to make these without thinking."
"Yes," said Valerian. "That’s rather the point."
***
Ferran’s yard is a field of sand patches behind the practical halls, each with its own little collection of things designed to show you what you do badly. Ferran himself was standing in the middle of it when we arrived, reading, as he always is.
He looked up long enough to see who we were.
"Vortex. Alzette." He turned a page, and glanced at Cedric. "And you."
Cedric had come because the drop post needed someone on the cord, and because, when he heard I was being allowed to do Barrier, he had made it plain that the alternative was finding out about it from Roland. He was carrying his practice shield, which nobody had asked him to bring.
The drop post stood at the edge of our patch: a wooden upright twice my height, with a pulley and a catch at the top, and a cord you pull from the ground to release whatever’s hanging there.
In ordinary lessons it’s an iron weight. Ferran had taken the iron off this morning and hung a sandbag about the size of a loaf. Underneath it, on the sand, sat a clay tile.
Somebody had painted a white mark on the upright, a little above head height.
A square three paces on a side had been raked into the sand round the post, and a pace back from its far edge was a line, with a ring pegged into it. The release cord ran from the catch, down through the ring, to the line.
"The pane goes there," said Ferran, still reading. "The cord is pulled from the line, not from inside the square. The bag comes down. The tile doesn’t break. That’s all." He finally looked at me properly. "Small. I am not interested in how large you can make it. I’m interested in whether you can make it the size you mean."
"I can."
"Then this will be very dull for all of us."
He went to stand a few paces off. Valerian came and stood in front of me.
He put his palm flat against my breastbone, over the place where the pull lived, and left it there for a while. I breathed for him, in and out, slowly, as he likes. He watched my face while I did it.
"Anything?"
"No."
"You’d tell me."
"I’d tell you."
He looked at me a moment longer, because for five years at the border it hadn’t been true, and we both remembered. He took his hand away and stepped back to where he could see the post and me together.
Ferran closed his book, put it under his arm, and watched the post. "Whenever you’re ready," he said.
***
Cedric took up the cord.
I looked at the white mark. I reached for the Barrier, as I’ve reached for it for years, and found the first strange thing before I’d done anything at all.
Before Halden, a hand-span of Barrier was a hand-span’s worth of reaching. I didn’t measure it. It was like picking up a cup; your hand knows how heavy a cup is.
Now there was a great deal more behind the reach. The core I was reaching into was bigger than the one I’d learned on, and fuller, and it leaned towards the opening as soon as I made one.
I made the opening smaller. Then smaller again.
"Now," said Cedric, and pulled.
The bag dropped. A pane of gold the size of my hand came up at the white mark, the bag struck it with a soft thump, and I let the pane go. The bag fell the last foot onto the sand beside the tile. The tile didn’t break.
Cedric looked at the tile, and at me, and grinned.
"Dull," said Ferran, without opening his book.
Valerian didn’t say well done. He came back and put his hand on my chest again.
"Tell me what that was like."
I thought about it honestly, which is still not my first instinct.
"Harder than it looked," I said. "I had to keep making it smaller. It’s like pouring from a full barrel when your hand’s used to a jug. I got it right. I had to think about getting it right the whole time."
"Did it pull?"
"No."
He nodded slowly and didn’t say anything else. He took a small notebook from his coat and wrote in it, and put it away.
"Again," said Ferran. "If Master Alzette agrees."
"Once more," said Valerian.
***
Cedric reset the bag on its short rope from the catch. He put the tile back under it, square in the sand, and went back to the line to take up the cord again, his shield slung on his back.
I looked at the white mark. I found the opening, and made it small, and held it small.
"Now."
Cedric pulled.
The cord snagged in the catch. Instead of opening cleanly it dragged half open and sideways, and the bag’s rope caught on its lip. The bag dropped a foot, came up short on its own rope, and swung.
It came out round the side of the post in a short, fast arc, away from the mark, across the square towards the line, where Cedric was standing with the cord in his hand and his head tipped up to see what had gone wrong.
It was a sandbag. It might have knocked him over. It might have given him a headache he’d complain about for a week.
I didn’t think any of that. I didn’t think anything.
I saw something moving fast towards somebody I was responsible for, from a direction I hadn’t expected, and I put a Barrier in its way.
It was the right Barrier. That’s what I want recorded. An ordinary pane, between the bag and Cedric’s head, exactly where it needed to be, as fast as I have ever made one.
It wasn’t Aegis, which sits on me unseen and takes what hits me. This was a Barrier, made on purpose, inside the square, the kind the sheet allowed.
It was the size that was wrong.
I reached for a hand-span, the way my body has always reached for a hand-span, and my core answered with what it had.
The pane came up small at the point where the bag would cross, and then it kept coming.
It spread. A hand-span, then the width of a door. The gold ran out along the sand on either side of Cedric and up past the top of the post, like water finding the edges of a floor, and I felt it draw on me as it went.
I saw it was too big before the bag reached it, and let go.
It didn’t go.
There was too much in it, and the opening was still wide, and the core behind it was still pouring. The bag hit the pane and dropped, and the pane went on spreading for another heartbeat, as if I’d never let go of anything.
Behind my breastbone, the pull woke up all at once and dragged. It wasn’t the dull ache of the last fortnight. It was the old thing from the ridge, sharp and deep, as if something behind my ribs had been hooked and tugged.
"Stop," said Ferran.
He didn’t shout it. He didn’t need to.
"Alash," said Valerian, very level. "Close the opening first. Then let it go."
I closed it, hard, and let go again, and this time it went.
The gold went out of the air between one breath and the next. The yard was a yard again: sand, a post, a clay tile, a sandbag lying on its side a foot from Cedric’s boots, and Cedric staring at the place where a wall had been.
Nobody was hurt. The tile hadn’t even cracked.
I had meant to make something the size of my hand. For about two heartbeats, I had made something the size of a room.
***
Ferran moved first. He took Cedric by the shoulder and walked him five paces off the patch, quite gently, and left him there. After that he went and looked at the catch on the drop post, and frowned at it, and made a note.
Valerian was in front of me before I’d finished breathing out.
"Sit."
I sat down on the sand. It seemed easier than arguing.
He put his hand back on my chest, and two fingers on the inside of my wrist, and watched my face again. I could feel him counting. I could feel my own heart, too fast, and the pull under his palm, hot and tight.
"Tell me."
"It pulls," I said. "Like the ridge, only less. Worse than yesterday."
"Breathe in."
I breathed in. It caught halfway.
"All the way."
I did, and it hurt, and I didn’t hide it, because there was no point hiding anything from that hand.
He kept his fingers on my wrist for a long time. Long enough that Cedric, five paces away, started to look worried, and Ferran said something to him I didn’t catch, and he stopped.
"You’re grey," said Valerian eventually.
"I’m always pale."
"You’re grey. That isn’t the same." He took his hand away. "Your pulse has settled. Your breathing hasn’t. The pull’s back where it was four days ago, not where it was on the ridge." He took out the notebook. "That’s the good news."
"I meant to make it small," I said.
"I know."
"I did make it small. At first. It was the right size when I made it."
"I know," said Valerian again. "I watched you make it."
He wrote for a while. I watched him do it, upside down: the time, the attempt, the swing of the bag, the size of the pane, how long before I let it go, what my pulse and breathing had done since.
"I’m putting down that the exercise was authorised," he said, without looking up.
"That the bag left its path inside the square, and you made the pane the sheet allows for that, where the sheet allows it. That the pane went over the limit. That you tried to dismiss it at once, and it took you another heartbeat and my word to finish." He finished the line. "All of that is true."
"It’s not another breach."
"No," said Valerian. "It’s not a breach. It’s a finding."
That should have made me feel better than it did.
***
Ferran took Cedric away to the far end of the yard to look at something else. I think he did it on purpose. Valerian sat down on the edge of the next patch, beside me, which he doesn’t often do; he prefers to stand where he can see everything.
For a while neither of us said anything.
"I’ve watched you do that since you were ten," he said at last.
"Do what?"
"Put a pane in front of someone before you’ve decided to." He looked out across the sand.
"It was the fastest thing about you. On the border it was the most useful thing you had. You had a Barrier up between a man and whatever was coming at him before most people had turned their heads."
"It’s what it’s for."
"It is." He didn’t argue with it. "And you did it at Merrow’s, and on that ridge, and both times somebody’s alive because you did. I’m not going to tell you to stop caring whether people get hit."
"Then what’s the problem?"
"The problem," said Valerian, "is that you learned it on a different body."
I didn’t say anything.
"Every one of those reflexes was trained on the core you had at ten, and twelve, and fourteen. Your hands learned how much to reach for. Your channels learned how much to carry. Then, less than three weeks ago, your core went up two steps in an afternoon, and nothing else did."
He turned his head to look at me. "Your reach is still the old size. What’s behind it isn’t."
"I tried to let it go," I said. "As soon as I saw."
"You did. That was right. I’d like you to hear that I said so."
He held my eyes. "But trying to let it go once it’s too big isn’t the same as not making it too big. And today it didn’t go when you told it to. Today it was a sandbag, and a field with nothing in it, and me standing next to you. One day it won’t be."
I looked at the clay tile, still sitting there in the sand, perfectly whole.
The trouble wasn’t that I’d done something wrong. I’d done exactly what I’d been trained to do, as well as I’ve ever done it.
The trouble was that less didn’t mean what it used to. I couldn’t fix it by deciding to use less next time, because my sense of how much less was the thing that had gone wrong.
"Oh," I said.
"Yes," said Valerian.
***
"No more Barrier," he said, when we stood up. "Not until this has been looked at properly. That’s mine to say, and I’m saying it."
He put his pen away. "I’ll write to the Headmaster this morning, with everything: the paper, the exercise, the swing, what you made, how fast you tried to let it go and how long it took, and what your chest did after. What you meant and what happened go in separately."
"And then?"
"Then he decides whether he wants anything else before he lets you near it again."
He looked at me. "And I examine you properly, all of you, and we find out what your body can actually do now, rather than what you remember it doing." He tucked the notebook away. "Nobody’s going to make you train harder to catch it up. That’s how bodies set wrong."
"I know."
"You knew at thirteen. You still tried."
I couldn’t argue with that either.
"I was finally allowed to do something," I said. "One thing. A pane the size of my hand. And the result is that I’m allowed to do even less."
"The result," said Valerian, "is that you saw it was too big and tried to put it down at once. In the middle of a reflex, with your chest pulling. That’s the part I’ll be keeping." He looked at me. "The size was never the good part."
He went to talk to Ferran about the catch.
***
I sat on the bench at the edge of the yard while Ferran’s first class of the morning arrived and got on with it.
Cedric went off to his own lesson. He looked back twice on his way to the gate. I raised a hand to tell him I was fine, which was mostly true, and the second time he waved back.
On the nearest patch, somebody from Brightvale was catching iron discs on a tile and missing.
I thought about the bag coming round the post, and how quickly I’d put something in front of it.
I’d have been just as quick if it had been a blade. Quicker, probably.
A month ago, that would have comforted me.
I had more behind the reach than I’d ever had in my life, and I didn’t know any more how much of it my hands would take when they reached.