(Theoran Vale POV)
The last time those five names had been laid before me, they had been on five separate sheets, around a table full of people arguing. Each had the word *Potential* on it, and under it three letters. SSS.
This time there was one sheet, with all five names on it. The word beneath them was Assessment.
It had come by the Crown’s relay on Monday, under the royal seal and a second seal I knew from the palace’s household guard, and it had sat on my desk since, with a stone on it to stop it reading itself aloud. On Friday morning I took the stone off.
It asked, courteously, for two things. A confidential briefing on the simultaneous advancement of Her Highness Elizabeth Aurelius, Lord Alash Vortex, Lord James Vellaroux, Lady Sophie Trohan and Lady Daphne Spinster to C-Black, following the unidentified attack at Halden.
And an assessment, to be conducted at the Academy, of whether their increased capacities presented a risk to Her Highness or to others.
The Crown’s assessor would arrive that afternoon.
I poured my tea, which was as bad as it has been for forty years, and read the letter a fourth time.
I could not fault the reasoning. The First Princess had very nearly been killed. Whatever had tried to kill her had not been caught, or named, or found. Five young people had walked off that ridge two steps stronger than they walked onto it, and nobody in the kingdom could say why.
If I had been responsible for her guard, I would have written the same letter.
What I disliked was the shape of it. It treated the five as one thing. One question, one assessment, one answer.
Beside it on the desk lay five rehabilitation plans, written the day before, in Hale’s hand and Valerian’s. The rank at the top was the same. The instructions underneath were not.
***
Before anyone else came, I separated the letter into the three questions it had folded together.
What happened at Halden? That, the Crown already had, from Commander Renn and the magistrate, and could have again.
Were the five truly C-Black? Yes. I had Sorel’s records, and Valerian’s, and Hale’s, to say so.
Could they use it safely?
That was the question the letter actually wanted answered, and the honest answer was no. Not because they were dangerous in the sense the household guard meant. Because a stable core says nothing about the body that has to carry it.
I had Valerian’s report from Wednesday on top of the pile. An authorised exercise, a pane the size of a hand, a sandbag that swung the wrong way, and a boy whose Barrier had grown to the size of a room before he could put it down.
His chest had paid for it, and was still paying.
I would not tell the Crown the five were harmless. I didn’t know that.
I would not let anyone describe them as suspects either, for the crime of having survived something nobody understood.
***
I sent for Valerian, Hale and Selene before noon.
They came together and sat in a row across my desk, three people who between them had more cause to dislike outside interference than anyone in Zenith, and none of them said so.
"Five plans," said Hale, before I had finished asking. "Five different restrictions, because five different injuries. None of them cleared for anything at full output. I’ll sign a statement to that effect for whoever you like."
"And the records?"
"Stay in my infirmary, unless the proper permissions come through. I’m not posting five children’s charts to anybody because they asked nicely under a seal."
Valerian had read the letter while she spoke. He put it down.
"If they want to see what a C-Black core can release," he said, "I can tell them what happened on Wednesday, in general terms. A controlled exercise, at the smallest output we could write down, went over its limit in a heartbeat, and the student paid for it. I won’t give them his chest, or anyone else’s."
"Would wards make it safe? A warded hall, shields, my staff on the walls?"
"Wards protect the people standing near the student," said Valerian. "They don’t protect the student from himself. The danger isn’t only in what comes out. It’s in what it costs to let it out."
Selene had said nothing. She was looking at the five names.
"They’re C-Black," she said. "That’s real, and I’ve told Sanctuary as much. It isn’t a method. Nobody can reproduce it, least of all them. And I can’t clear any of them to cultivate because somebody outside would find it informative to watch."
I made a note of each of them, word for word. Then I went through the forms the office had been gathering since Monday.
Five guardians, or what stood for guardians. Duke Anthony Vortex for Alash, with Miss Declair entered underneath, for injury only, in the boy’s own hand. The rest much as I had expected.
For each of them, letters went out that morning asking what, if anything, they were prepared to see released. I did not expect replies before the assessor arrived, and I did not intend to pretend I had any.
***
The assessor arrived at the second hour after noon, on time to the minute.
She was a woman of about fifty in a plain grey coat, with the household guard’s seal on the case she carried and a written commission she laid on my desk before she sat down. I read it. It was in order.
"Headmaster," she said, "I’ll be plain. Five students advanced together during an attack on Her Highness. The assailant is unidentified. My office has to consider whether whatever did that to them could happen again, harm them, or harm someone near them. A letter telling us they are recovering doesn’t establish that they’re in control of what they now have."
"No," I said. "It doesn’t."
"Then how do you propose we establish it?"
I told her. Five students under active medical restriction, by my order and their healers’. Supervised by a specialist from the western command and the senior healer of this Academy. Monitored daily.
Not permitted to cultivate, demonstrate or train at any output their bodies had not been cleared for. What we knew, what we didn’t, and the difference.
She listened to every word, and wrote some of them down.
"That tells me you’re supervising injured students," she said. "It doesn’t tell me what they can do."
"That’s because nobody yet knows what they can do safely."
"Then let us find out." She folded her hands on the case.
"A supervised demonstration. Enough output to assess what those cores can actually do. All five, in a warded hall, under your oversight, with your healers present and whatever precautions you set. My office observes, and assesses what it sees. That’s the Crown’s request, Headmaster, and I think it’s a reasonable one."
It was. That was the trouble with it.
***
"No," I said.
She waited for the rest. I gave it to her.
"I can’t arrange it, because I’d be ordering five patients to break their own medical restrictions in front of you. A demonstration at that output wouldn’t show you what they can safely control. It would show you what their cores can release under pressure, which is a different thing, and what their bodies can survive, which nobody here can promise you."
"Your wards..."
"Would keep you safe, madam. Not them." I put Valerian’s report face down on the desk, so that she could see I had it and not what it said.
"On Wednesday one of the five carried out a fully authorised exercise at the smallest output any of us could write down. It went over its limit in a heartbeat, through no fault of his, and he’s still paying for it. That’s what a small one did."
"And the risk to others? If you can’t show me they’re safe, how is my office to know they aren’t a danger?"
"It can’t," I said. "Neither can I. That’s precisely why they’re restricted. What I can give you is evidence that the risk is understood, that the restrictions are real and enforced, and that qualified people are watching them every day. Your office can assess that. It can’t be offered a dangerous experiment and call it reassurance."
She looked at me for a long moment.
"My report will record that the Academy declined the assessment."
"It should."
"It may be referred for further review."
"Then I’ll answer the review," I said. "In writing, through the same channels."
She wrote it down. I don’t think either of us enjoyed it.
***
My secretary knocked before she could ask her next question.
"Headmaster. The lower hall."
He looked unhappy, which in my secretary is a serious sign. Monday’s letter, it emerged, had come through his office before it reached mine, and when he saw an assessment, to be conducted at the Academy, he had very sensibly held the lower hall for Friday afternoon, provisionally, in case it was needed.
Nobody had told him otherwise. That was my fault, not his.
Ferran had given that hour to Sanctuary’s shield line on Thursday, out of his own allocation, after he heard how their Wednesday had gone in a sloping yard.
Nobody had told him the office had a hold on it. Sanctuary had begun at the second hour after noon, and had been on the floor some minutes when someone from my office arrived to enforce the hold.
The turns stopped, and the line was sent to wait along the wall.
I took my cane and went down. The assessor came with me.
The lower hall is underground and reinforced, and it was full of first-years with nothing to do.
Penelope Declair had them in order along the wall, and was explaining the situation to them with considerably more patience than it deserved.
Cedric had his practice shield on his arm and the expression of a young man watching his Monday disappear.
At the far end, on a bench, sat Lord Vortex, with his pillow behind his back and a slate and a sandglass on his knee. He was not casting anything. He was not even standing.
He had, I learned afterwards, been timing the line’s turns for Cedric until the hall was closed, as Thursday’s plan allowed him to.
He saw me, and started to get up.
"Sit down, Vortex."
He sat.
I looked at the hall, and at the thirty-odd students who had lost a quarter of their hour already over a demonstration nobody had authorised.
"Release the hall," I said to my secretary. "Now. For Sanctuary’s use, as booked."
"Headmaster," said the assessor quietly, "if the assessment..."
"There is no assessment to hold it for," I said. "Nothing has been medically authorised. There’s nothing to keep the floor for."
I didn’t ask Lord Vortex to show her anything smaller instead. I didn’t ask any of them to show her anything at all.
Penelope had the line back on the floor before I’d reached the door. Cedric was already calling turns. The boy on the bench turned his sandglass over.
They had lost a quarter of an hour, and I could not give it back to them. I could only stop it costing them any more.
***
Back in my office, Hale and Valerian were waiting, and the assessor sat down again with the air of someone who had not changed her mind but had at least seen something she would have to write down.
"What can you give me?" she said.
I had it ready. Two things, kept apart.
The first was an institutional report from the Academy, under my seal. That Her Highness was attacked at Halden by an unidentified assailant. That five named students survived and advanced together to C-Black.
That the cause of that advancement was unknown. That all five were under active medical restriction and supervision. That nobody had established that unrestricted output was safe for any of them.
And that the Academy would report any finding bearing on the Crown’s security through proper channels, as soon as it had one.
It said nothing about how. It said nothing that anyone in this building didn’t know.
The second was a signed statement from each of the two healers, separately.
Hale and Valerian both put down that, in their professional judgement, high-output demonstration was not medically justified for any of the five at present, and that any future assessment would require individual evaluation of each student, not a single test of all five.
"Their charts?" said the assessor.
"Remain with their healers," said Hale, "pending permissions from the patients and their guardians, where those are required. Letters went out this morning."
"That may not be enough for my final report."
"It may not," I said. "If your office needs more as matters change, and the permissions exist, we’ll arrange it, properly, one student at a time. That’s not a refusal. That’s a procedure."
She considered that, and then, for the first time that afternoon, she nodded.
***
Her Highness had been asked to come at the third hour. She came at it exactly, with her arm in its sling and her captain of guard at the door.
The assessor rose. She explained the Crown’s request, and the demonstration, and asked Her Highness directly whether she would support it.
Her Highness didn’t answer straight away. She looked at Hale, and at Valerian.
"I want to be clear about something first," she said. "Healer Hale permitted me to ride again on Thursday. At a walk, within the grounds. I had asked my captain whether, from next week, I could ride escorted on the river road, beyond the walls."
She glanced at the door. "He said he would recommend it once the Crown’s assessment was filed."
"That’s correct, Your Highness," said the assessor. "Without an assessment, my office can’t endorse a widening of your escort’s routes. The captain will want our report first."
"Then I understand what I’m deciding."
She turned back to the assessor.
"The attack on me hasn’t been solved. My guard is entitled to everything that bears on my safety, and I’ll give them anything of my own that does. I’ll authorise a statement on my own condition and my own restrictions, prepared by my healers. Not my chart."
She paused. "And I won’t support a demonstration that the people treating me say is dangerous. Not for me, and not for the other four."
"Your support would help the assessment considerably, Your Highness."
"I know. That’s why I won’t give it." Her voice didn’t rise. "If I ask them, they’ll do it, because I asked. Their records are theirs, and what they do with their bodies is theirs. I don’t speak for them, and I don’t intend to start because I’m the one who was hurt."
The assessor looked at her for a while.
"Then the river road will have to wait, Your Highness."
"Yes," said Her Highness. "I know."
She had wanted that ride. I had seen it in her face when she mentioned it. She let it go without another word about it, and asked Hale whether Thursday’s shoulder exercise could be done standing.
I didn’t thank her, or praise her, or speak for her. It was hers.
***
The assessor left a little before the fourth hour, with my report under seal, the two healers’ statements, a copy of Her Highness’s authorisation for her own statement, and a note in her own hand that the high-output assessment had been declined on documented medical grounds.
She didn’t pretend the Crown was satisfied. I didn’t ask her to.
Before she went, I added one line to my covering letter. Her Highness had consented to a statement concerning her own condition. That consent covered nothing else, and nobody else.
When the door had shut, I sat for a while with the original letter in front of me.
Five names on one sheet. I had given the Crown one report about one attack. I had not given it five children’s bodies on a single page, and I didn’t intend to.
It wasn’t finished. Their cores were still too large for them. Nobody knew why. The Crown would write again, and it would be entitled to.
I looked out of the window instead.
From my office you can see the steps down to the lower hall. Sanctuary’s line was coming up them in twos, loud, with Cedric arguing about the second turn and Penelope Declair counting heads at the top.
Last, slowly, came the boy with the pillow, one flight at a time, stopping on the landing exactly as his healer had told him to.
Nothing about this afternoon had given him back his Barrier. Nothing would have.
But nobody else’s lesson had to stop for it.
I picked up my pen, and wrote to the Crown’s household guard to thank them for a courteous assessor.