Nobody moved for a heartbeat.
Then everyone moved at once. Kofi was up the terrace before he knew he’d left the fire, with Clementine behind him and Titus behind her. Phibba swayed in her doorway with one hand clutching Quashie’s shoulder and the other clutching the doorframe. Up close, she looked even worse than she had the night before. Her lips had gone the color of ash, and the blanket around her shoulders shook with every breath.
"You should be lying down," Clementine said.
"I been lying down three days." Phibba’s voice was a dry rasp around the cold pipe. "Lying down don’t get the iron out of my water."
"Phibba—"
"Help me to the water, root woman, or get out my way so somebody else can."
Clementine looked at Kofi. Kofi looked at Phibba’s eyes, bright and fierce in that grey, sunken face.
He bent and lifted her.
She weighed almost nothing. He had carried planks heavier than her. She let her head fall against his shoulder, and her pipe dug into his collarbone, and he carried her down the terraces while the whole Hollow watched in silence.
He set her down on the ledge of wet rock where the passage met the lagoon.
The tide had come back up since morning. The passage was flooded to the roof again, black and still, and somewhere beyond all that water and stone, the chain lay across the mouth of the cave. Kofi could feel it even here. It sat in his chest like a stone in a boot.
Phibba leaned forward on her knees. Quashie held her shoulders so she wouldn’t fall. Slowly, she reached out one thin hand and laid it flat on the surface of the water.
Her face twisted.
"Lord," she breathed. "Lord, it’s cold."
"Can you lift it?" Yaw had come down behind them with Latch, faint and pale, pressed against his leg. "The fog. Can you push it through?"
"Through cold iron?" Phibba laughed. It turned into a cough that bent her double. When it passed, she wiped her mouth with the back of her hand. "Boy, nothing pass through cold iron. Not my fog. Not your dog. Not the old man below." She looked down at the water. "And he know it, too. Feel him."
Kofi felt him.
Somewhere under the lagoon, deep down in the black, something enormous was moving. Not the slow, sleepy turning of the last few days. Something sharper. Restless and coiled, like a dog circling at a closed door with its hackles up.
"He hate it," Phibba said quietly. "Cold iron in his water. In his house. He can’t cross it, he can’t touch it, and he can’t sleep with it there. Every hour it lie across that door, he get angrier." Her eyes narrowed. "And when a thing that big get angry enough, somebody going to suffer for it."
"It might be us," Titus said.
"Might be." Phibba turned her head and looked at him. "Or might be the man who put it there."
Nobody said anything.
Phibba took her hand out of the water and wiped it slowly on her blanket. Then she turned on the rock and looked back up into the cavern, past the terraces and the houses, to the far wall where the glowing water lapped against the base of the cliff. Three black openings showed there in the rock, low and ragged.
Theo saw where she was looking, and his face changed.
"No," he said.
"Yes," Phibba said.
"I’ve been in those tunnels. Twice. I went in one way and came out another and I swear on my father’s grave the walls were in different places when I came back." Theo’s voice had gone high. "I won’t chart them. Nobody can chart them. They move."
"For strangers," Phibba said. "They move for strangers."
She settled back against Quashie’s chest. Her breathing was very shallow.
"Every one of them lead somewhere," she said. "Most lead to nothing. Dead rock. Water. Places a body go in and don’t come out. But one of them go up. All the way up, through the island, to the top. Come out in the bush by the Boiling Hole, under the sky." She closed her eyes. "Thirty years ago, the island show me that road. It don’t show it to just anybody. It show it to the ones it trust."
"Then you can lead us," Kofi said.
"Me?" Phibba opened one eye. "Shipwright, I can’t lead my own feet to my bed."
"Then how—"
Phibba looked past him. Her one open eye settled on Yaw.
"Where the road won’t open," she said, "you need somebody who can open it."
Yaw stared at her. At his feet, faint and thin, Latch lifted his head.
"Legba open the door," Phibba said softly. "That’s all he ever do. Open the door and stand in it." She held Yaw’s eyes. "You can’t find the road, boy. Nobody can find it. But if you walk in there and you come to a wall, you put your hand on it and you ask. And maybe the wall remember it used to be a door."
The plan came together around the fire in the afternoon, piece by piece, out of the mouths of a dozen people.
Theo drew it. He had found a fresh scrap of sailcloth and a new stub of charcoal, and he knelt by the fire with it spread on the rock while everyone talked over him, and he drew as fast as they spoke. The cave mouth. The chain. The Morning Star. The sloop. The frigate. The cliffs above. A little circle for the Boiling Hole.
"The chain’s the heart of it," Kofi said. "As long as it lies there, none of us is worth anything. No fog. No roots. No dog. We’re a cave full of people with machetes against a frigate."
"So we get rid of it," Titus said.
"How?" Anne said flatly. She sat across the fire with her arms folded and her face hard. "It’s a hundred fathoms of cold iron. You can’t cut it. You’d need a forge."
"You don’t cut it." Kofi took the charcoal from Theo’s hand and drew on the cloth. A spike in the rock on each side of the arch. A ring on the head of each spike. The chain running between them. "They drove a spike into the rock on each side, and they made the chain fast to the ring on each spike. They didn’t weld it. They didn’t have time. They used a shackle."
He drew it. A curved iron U around the ring and the end link of the chain, with a pin through its two ends.
"Every ship I ever built has a hundred of these," he said. "The pin’s held by a little wedge or a lashing. Knock out the wedge, drive out the pin, and the shackle opens. The chain drops off the ring and goes to the bottom." He tapped the drawing. "One side’s enough. Get one end loose, and the whole thing sags to the sand. There’s nothing across the door anymore."
"Then who goes?" Ezinne asked. "Who swims out and knocks out the pin?"
Kofi looked around the fire.
"Not me," he said. "Not Yaw. Not Clementine. Not Anne or Mary. Not anyone with a spirit in them." He set the charcoal down. "Bell said it himself. A spirit can’t cross cold iron. We felt it this morning, just standing near it. If one of us tried to swim out and put our hands on that chain, we’d be lucky to get back alive."
The fire crackled.
"So it has to be somebody with nothing inside them," Titus said slowly. "Somebody with no spirit at all."
Every head turned.
Theo was still kneeling over the sailcloth. He looked up and found the whole circle staring at him. His mouth opened. Nothing came out.
"Oh," he said finally. "Oh. You mean me."
"You and me," Titus said.
"I’m a navigator. I steer things. I don’t..." Theo looked down at the drawing of the chain. "I don’t swim out at night under a frigate’s guns and pull pins out of iron."
"You talked the ship off the banks in a hurricane," Titus said. "You laughed the whole time. I heard you."
"That’s because I was terrified."
"Good," Titus said. "Be terrified. Just be terrified and swim."
Theo stared at him. Then at the drawing. Then around the fire at the faces watching him, the crew and the Hollow, Yaw with his fading dog and Clementine with her dead staff and Anne with her grey face.
For weeks he’d been the only one on the ship who’d come back from Saint-Domingue with nothing. No spirit. No fire or roots or hound. Just a cutlass and a throwing stick and a head full of numbers. He’d joked about it. He’d made it sound like he didn’t care.
He looked down at his own hands, plain and empty and stained with charcoal.
"All right," he said. His voice cracked. "All right. I’ll do it."
Titus nodded once, as if he’d never doubted it.
The rest fell into place after that.
Anne and Mary would swim out with Theo and Titus, past the chain, and make for the Morning Star. Their spirits would be useless that close to the iron, but they had been fighting Navy sailors for years with nothing but steel. They’d climb her side, find Toby, and take the ship.
"Without your powers?" Ezinne said. "Against how many?"
"A ship that size? Ten. Maybe twelve," Mary said. "Bell won’t waste more than that on a prize."
"And you can take twelve sailors? Just the two of you?"
Anne looked at her for the first time in an hour, and something of the old crooked grin came back into her face.
"Darling," she said, "we were taking twelve sailors before you knew our names."
Yaw would go up through the tunnels. Clementine would go with him, because once they were far enough from the iron, she might be able to reach the island’s trees again. Phibba would go with them too, carried on a litter of oars and sailcloth by two of the Hollow’s strongest men, Quamin and Barnaby.
"Up top," Phibba said, "there’s no iron. Just sky and bush and the Boiling Hole. Up top, I can make the fog."
"How much fog?" Kofi asked.
Phibba looked at him for a long moment.
"All of it," she said. "Every bit I got left."
Nobody spoke. Clementine reached over and took the old woman’s hand, and Phibba let her hold it.
"When the chain drop," Phibba said, "the fog come down off the cliffs over the whole cove. Frigate. Sloop. Your ship. Every one of them blind." She looked at Ezinne. "And then you tell the old man below."
Ezinne went very still. "Tell him what?"
"Cudjoe drum tell him we still here. Twenty years." Phibba’s eyes went to the broken breadfruit tree, to the drum standing beneath it. "That drum can tell him other things too. Tell him the door open. Tell him who put the iron in his water." Her voice dropped. "Tell him to come up and see."
Ezinne looked at the drum. Then at her own hands.
"I’ve never played it," she said. "I only heard."
"You heard last night," Phibba said. "Whole Hollow heard. Every beat. You got it in you, girl. Music is your whole life. You’ll find it."
Ezinne swallowed. Then she nodded slowly. Beside her, Obi sat up straighter.
"I can learn it too," he said. "In case."
Ezinne looked at him a long time. Then she put her arm around his shoulders and pulled him in against her side.
"Yes," she said quietly. "In case."
That left Kofi.
He sat with the cane across his knees and looked at the drawing of the cave mouth. At the little longboat Theo had sketched just beyond the chain, where Bell had sat that morning, waiting.
"Bell will be looking at the cave," he said. "At low water, after dark. Waiting to see if I come out." He turned the cane slowly in his hands. "So I come out."
"Kofi," Yaw said.
"Not to surrender. To be looked at." Kofi traced the line from the cave mouth to the longboat. "While he’s watching me walk out onto that ledge with my hands up, nobody’s watching the water below him. Nobody’s watching the cliffs. Nobody’s watching his prize ship." He looked up. "I keep his eyes. That’s all. As long as I can."
"And when he figures it out?" Titus asked.
Kofi didn’t have an answer for that. He looked back down at the drawing.
"Then I hope Theo’s fast," he said.
Theo made a small, strangled sound.
"He’ll want you unarmed," Anne said. "He said so."
Clementine reached over and laid one finger on the cane across Kofi’s knees, on the little bone skull with its tiny top hat.
"A cane isn’t a weapon," she said, "to a man who doesn’t know what it is."
On the Morning Star, Pockets came down out of the rigging an hour before sunset.
He had been up on the main yard since dawn, flat against the furled sail, not moving. He had watched the soldiers take the ship. He had watched them tie Toby to the mast. He had watched the captain with the cold eyes walk around the deck looking at everything. He had watched them eat Toby’s salt fish and laugh and throw the bones over the side. He had not made a single sound.
Now the sun was low and gold, and the soldiers left aboard to guard the prize had grown bored. There were nine of them. Two sat on the hatch cover playing at dice. Three leaned on the stern rail smoking. One slept in the shade of the longboat. One stood at the bow, looking at the cliffs.
Two stood guard over Toby.
They weren’t guarding very hard. They leaned against the mainmast on either side of him with their muskets propped beside them, talking in low voices about the girls in Port Royal. One of them had taken off his sword belt and hung it on a belaying pin. A knife hung from the belt in a leather sheath, its brass hilt catching the low sun.
Brass. Shiny.
Pockets came down the mast.
He came down the far side of it, away from the guards, hand over hand, his tail curled tight. He reached the belaying pin rail. He paused there, perfectly still, while the guard nearest him laughed at something the other one said.
Then he reached out one small hand, unsnapped the sheath, and lifted the knife out.
He didn’t run. Running would draw eyes. He crept around the foot of the mast on all fours, the knife clutched to his chest, slow and quiet, until he reached the place where Toby sat slumped against the wood with his head on his chest.
Toby’s eyes were open. He had been watching the whole time.
Pockets set the knife down in Toby’s lap, on top of his thigh. Then he looked up at Toby’s face with his bright black eyes, chattered once, very softly, and went back up the mast.
Toby looked down at the knife.
Slowly, he shifted his leg until the knife slid off his thigh and under it, out of sight. He let his head fall forward again onto his chest.
His lips moved, too quiet for anyone to hear.
"Good boy," he whispered. "Good little thief."
The sun was going down when they said their goodbyes. Nobody called them goodbyes. Nobody would have.
Titus and Theo knelt on the wet ledge by the passage and checked each other’s gear. Theo had stripped to his breeches and shirt. A marlinspike was thrust through his belt, and a small iron mallet hung from a lanyard at his wrist. Titus checked the lanyard knot. Then he checked it again.
"It’s fine," Theo said.
"It’s a granny knot."
"It is not a granny knot."
Titus retied it without a word. Theo watched him do it. When Titus was done, Theo reached out and tugged the strap of Titus’s machete sheath tighter across his back.
Neither of them said anything else.
Up on the terrace, Bess stood at the big fire with Tanty Abba, cooking the last of the salvaged yams with salt fish and peppers. They had made enough for everyone going out and everyone staying behind. They had done it in silence, side by side, the way they had cooked at the Nine Night. When it was ready, Tanty Abba ladled it into bowls and Bess carried them out, one to each person, and stood over each of them until they ate.
When she reached Kofi, she didn’t let go of the bowl right away.
"You come back," she said. "All of you. I counted you out, and I’m counting you back in, and if the number’s wrong I’ll never forgive any of you."
"We’ll come back."
"Don’t lie to me, Kofi Brook. I’m not Titus. I don’t need you to tell me the truth." She let go of the bowl. "I just need you to try."
Under the breadfruit tree, Ezinne sat behind Pa Cudjoe’s drum with Obi pressed against her side. She laid her hands on the split skin, closed her eyes, and found the rhythm. Boom. Boom. Slow and low, the way she had heard it the night before. It came out wrong the first time, too fast. Then right. Then wrong again.
"Again," Obi whispered. "I’m listening."
She played it again. He put his own small hands on the drum’s edge beside hers and felt it.
Anne sat alone on the rocks above the lagoon, sharpening her cutlass with long, hard strokes. She hadn’t spoken to anyone since the war council. Her face was set in a way none of them had seen before.
Mary came and sat down beside her.
"I could do it," Anne said, low and fierce, without looking up. "Leave the ship to you and the others. Swim out to that longboat while he’s watching Kofi. Put the blade in him myself."
"You could," Mary said.
"Then let me."
"No."
Anne’s strokes stopped. "Why not?"
Mary didn’t answer right away. She looked out across the glowing water toward the drowned passage and the black rock beyond.
"Because you’d do it for the wrong reasons," she said quietly. "And because if you did, you’d never come back from it. Not the you I know."
Anne stared at her. Then she looked away and began sharpening again, harder than before.
Mary sat beside her and didn’t leave.
Clementine found Kofi at the water’s edge as the light went from gold to red through the hole in the roof.
She stood beside him and didn’t say anything for a long time. Her staff was dead and black in her hand. The leaves tangled in her hair had withered to brown curls.
"I’ll be up on the island," she said finally. "With the old woman and Yaw. If the trees will answer me up there, I’ll make them answer."
"I know."
"And you’ll be standing at the mouth of that cave with your hands in the air, in front of a man who wants you dead."
"Yes."
She turned and looked at him. Her eyes were very steady.
"I know what you are," she said quietly. "I told you I wouldn’t ask, and I won’t. I won’t tell anyone, either. That’s yours to tell." She reached up and put her palm flat against his chest, over his heart, the way she’d done in the storm. "But the sea gave you back once, shipwright. I don’t think it’ll do it twice."
Kofi said nothing.
"So you come back up those terraces on your own feet," Clementine said. "Not carried. Not drowned. Walking. You hear me?"
"I hear you."
She held her hand there a moment longer. Then she pulled a leaf out of her hair, brown and dry and curled, and pressed it into his palm and closed his fingers over it.
"It’ll be green again by morning," she said. "When the iron’s gone."
She went back up the terrace to where Quamin and Barnaby were lashing Phibba onto her litter.
Yaw led them into the tunnels as the last light went out of the roof.
There were six of them. Yaw went first with a torch, and Latch trotted at his heels, still thin and pale but growing a little more solid with every step they took away from the cave mouth. Clementine came behind him. Then Quamin and Barnaby with Phibba on her litter between them. Last came a young woman from the Hollow named Cassia, carrying a coil of rope and a second torch.
The tunnel mouth swallowed them. The glow of the lagoon faded behind them.
The rock closed in. The passage was narrow and low and wet. Water dripped from the roof and ran in little streams down the walls. Their torches threw jumping shadows ahead of them, and the shadows made the walls seem to move.
At least, Yaw told himself it was the shadows.
They came to a fork. Two passages. One went left and down. One went right and level.
"Which?" Clementine said.
Yaw didn’t know. He stood at the fork with the torch raised and looked from one to the other. Behind him, Phibba’s breathing rasped from the litter.
Latch went right.
The dog didn’t hesitate. He trotted into the right-hand passage with his nose down and his floppy ear up, and stopped a few steps in, and looked back at Yaw.
Yaw followed.
They went on that way for a long time. Forks and turnings, rises and dips, places where they had to crawl, places where the roof climbed so high the torchlight didn’t reach it. At every choice, Latch chose. At every choice, the passage he chose went up.
Then the passage ended.
It ended in a wall. Solid rock, dark and wet and smooth, filling the passage from floor to ceiling. There was no crack in it. No gap. No way around.
Yaw stood in front of it with the torch raised.
"Dead end," Barnaby said behind him. His voice shook. "Lord. We’ll never find our way back."
Latch sat down at the foot of the wall and looked up at Yaw.
Phibba lifted her head from the litter.
"Here," she whispered. "This the place. Strangers always turn back here."
Yaw looked at the wall. Then he handed the torch to Clementine.
He laid his hand flat against the rock.
It was cold and wet and absolutely solid under his palm. He closed his eyes. He didn’t know what to do. Nobody had taught him. There was no chant, no ritual, nothing Grann Rose had ever shown him. There was only the old man on the flat rock at the crossroads, leaning on his cane, laughing softly.
Never close a door on someone seeking passage.
"Please," Yaw whispered to the rock. "We need to get through. All of us. There’s people behind us who’ll die if we don’t."
Nothing happened.
He pressed his palm harder against the stone. He thought of the gate on the fourth road. The family pressed against the bars. The woman’s hands rattling it.
Please. Somebody. Let us through.
"You used to be a door," he said. "I know you did. Remember."
Heat flared in his hands.
He gasped and opened his eyes. At his hips, the veves on both pistol frames were glowing orange, bright as coals. The light spread out from under his palm across the rock in thin lines, branching, crossing, curving. A staff. A gate. The same mark, drawn in light, as tall as he was.
The rock under his hand went soft.
Then it wasn’t there.
His hand was resting on empty air. Where the wall had been, a narrow opening stood in the rock, just wide enough for a man to pass. Beyond it, the passage went on, climbing steeply. And from somewhere far up ahead came a breath of air, cool and fresh and smelling of salt and green leaves and open sky.
Yaw’s knees buckled.
Clementine caught him under the arm. He was shaking all over. His face had gone grey and slick with sweat. He felt as though someone had reached into his chest and pulled out half of everything inside.
"I’m all right," he gasped.
"You’re not."
"I’m all right enough." He straightened up, slowly, leaning on her. At his feet, Latch was wagging his tail. The dog looked more solid now than he had all day. "Come on. Before it changes its mind."
They went through the door in the rock one by one. When the last of them had passed, Cassia looked back over her shoulder with her torch.
The wall was there again. Solid. Smooth. As though it had never moved.
Out on the water, Bell stood at the Morning Star’s rail and watched the sun go down behind Cat Island.
He had moved his flag to the prize. The Vigilant was too badly hurt to lie close in under the cliffs, and the Morning Star sat in the perfect place, a cable’s length from the cave mouth, with a clear line on the arch and the chain. Her deck was solid under his feet. Brook had built her well.
Cross stood beside him. He had been counting since dawn, under his breath, without stopping. The gulls on the cliffs. The ledges. The waves breaking on the rocks. His lips never stopped moving.
"He’ll come out," Sterling said behind them. He sat on a stool somebody had brought up from below, his cane across his knees. "He’ll come out. He’s a fool. He went back for a girl in Trelawny. He’ll come out for the rest."
"Perhaps," Bell said.
"You don’t think so?"
Bell didn’t take his eyes off the cliffs.
"I think," he said, "that a man who has stayed alive this long, with every hand in the Caribbean turned against him, is not going to walk out of that hole simply because I asked him to." He was silent a moment. "I think he’ll come out. And I think he’ll come out because he wants me looking at him."
Sterling frowned. "Why would he want that?"
"Because then I’m not looking at anything else." Bell turned to Cross. "Mr. Cross."
Cross’s counting stopped. "Captain."
"When he comes out, I want you on the cliffs. Not watching him. Watching everything else." Bell looked up at the long dark line of the clifftops against the reddening sky. "If anyone on that island so much as cuts their finger tonight, I want to know where."
Cross’s eyes glittered. He lifted his face to the land breeze coming down off the island and breathed in, long and slow, through his nose.
"Yes, Captain," he said.
"And double the guard boat at the chain."
Low water came two hours after dark.
The tide drew back out of the passage slowly, the black roof of the tunnel rising inch by inch above the water. Kofi stood on the wet ledge inside the arch and watched it go. The cold of the chain lay across his chest. The cane in his hand was dead and cold and ordinary.
Behind him in the dark, he heard the others moving. Theo and Titus slipping into the water without a splash. Anne and Mary behind them. Four heads, low and black on the black water, gliding toward the arch, toward the chain, toward the open sea.
He didn’t look at them. He couldn’t afford to.
Above, somewhere on the clifftops, Yaw and Clementine and Phibba were waiting. Behind him, in the Hollow, Ezinne sat behind the drum with her hands on its skin and Obi pressed against her side, listening for the signal. Tanty Abba and Quashie and Bess stood guard over the children on the highest terrace with machetes and a cleaver.
Everything was in place.
Kofi took a breath. He thought of Phibba lying grey on her litter. Of Toby tied to the mast. Of Bess saying I counted you out, and I’m counting you back in.
He put the dry, curled leaf Clementine had given him into his shirt, over his heart.
Then he stepped out of the shadow of the arch onto the ledge at the mouth of the cave, into the starlight, where every man on the water could see him. He raised both hands above his head, the cane hanging from one of them like an old man’s walking stick, and he began to walk slowly forward toward the chain.
Out on the water, on the deck of the Morning Star, Captain Edmund Bell stood up.