The Morning Star:Chains of the Deep · Contents

CHAPTER 56

Chapter 55: The Brook’s Boys

16 min read·David_B_

The water came up to Kofi’s waist, then his chest, and the surf slapped the cold back against his ribs as he waded out from the cove. Behind him the Maroon children had stopped shouting. Ahead, the Morning Star’s longboat lay on the swell with her oars shipped and her crew leaning over the gunwale to take his hand.

Titus had come down the side himself. He stood in the stern of the boat with his arms folded, and he did not reach for Kofi’s hand. He waited until Kofi had hauled himself over the transom, and then he sat down on the thwart beside him and looked at the reef.

"Akosua gave you a pencil," Titus said.

"She gave me a count."

"She gave you a rope." Titus jerked his chin toward the coat. "You’re wearing the thing the Maroons kept for you. It’s the first time I’ve seen you look like you’d rather wear it than sell it."

Kofi glanced down at the brass buttons. They were dark with sea-spray now. "It’s the only warm thing I own."

"Then keep it warm." Titus was quiet for a stroke of the oars. Then he said, flat and without looking up, "The drivers on that Company road. The branded men on the reins."

"Cubbena says they go into the cockpits."

"Some of them will want to fight," Titus said. "I’ll be the one who tells them what it costs. I know what the brand feels like when the iron goes on. I’ll talk to the drivers first. You can have the silver." He turned his head, and his eyes were hard. "I’ll take the men. That’s my Law now, Kofi. Not yours."

Kofi held his gaze across the boat until Titus looked away first. Then he nodded once.

"Then you talk to them first," he said. "And if a driver won’t walk away, you don’t carry him. You give him a choice and let him make it."

Titus’s mouth moved, not quite a smile. He turned back to the reef, and for the rest of the pull to the ship he said nothing at all. But when the boat bumped the Morning Star’s side and the crew began to haul, he took the line with his good arm and pulled with the men until the boat was snug against her hull.

They sailed east along the Bahama banks with the trade wind on the beam and the sea running green and clear over white sand. Kofi kept the helm for most of the first day, because he did not trust the new pintle strap until he had seen it take a full day’s strain. Theo took the watches. Obi and the Salt Pan men handled the sheets. Han slept through the daylight hours in the forward hold, his hat over his face and a crock of buckwheat jelly tucked under his arm like a child’s doll, and woke each evening with his eyes already bright.

Quashie came up on deck on the second morning. He came up the companionway slowly, one hand on the rail and the other on a crutch Bess had carved from a spar, and when he reached the top he stood for a while with his face turned to the sun. His ankle was wrapped in clean linen. The yellow had gone out of the wound. He had lost weight, and his cheeks were hollow, but his back was straight.

"Where are we?" he asked.

"Heading for Hawk’s Nest," Kofi said. "Cat Island’s south shoal. It’s where Cuffy’s exile ended."

Quashie closed his eyes. "Then take me there."

Kofi did not ask why. He knew.

They raised the cay in the late afternoon, a low hump of sand and scrub with a white crescent of beach on its western side and the shoal breaking grey beyond it. A boat lay drawn up on the sand. A lean-to of driftwood and palm stood above the tide-line, and a thin smoke rose from a fire of mangrove roots. A man sat beside the fire with his back to the sea.

He did not turn when the Morning Star came in under her topsails. He did not stand. He sat with his hands folded on his knees, the way Kofi had seen men sit in the Company’s cells when the iron had worn them down past caring.

Quashie had Obi and Titus carry him ashore in the longboat. He would not be left on the ship. When they set him down on the sand, he balanced on his good leg and his crutch and looked at the man by the fire for a long time.

"Cuffy," he said.

The man lifted his head. He was thinner than he had been in the Hollow, and his shoulders had gone bony under his shirt, and his face was grey with sun and sleeplessness. He looked at Quashie, and then at the crutch, and then at the wrapped ankle. His mouth worked.

"You’re alive," Cuffy said.

"No thanks to you."

Cuffy bowed his head. Kofi saw his hands twist on his knees.

"I have water," Cuffy said, in a voice that barely carried over the surf. "Six days’ worth, the Hollow gave me. I’ve been catching fish off the shoal and drying them on the rock. The boat’s sound. I patched the seam with pitch from the mangroves." He stopped. "I don’t ask for anything. I’ve been waiting for someone to come and tell me what it costs."

"It costs the rest of your life," Quashie said. "You know that."

"I know it."

Quashie stood a moment longer on his crutch. Then he reached into the pocket of his coat, the one Kofi had mended for him in the Hollow, and drew out a short length of cord. It was the rope Tanny had been practising on, the bowline’s loop still tied in one end.

He held it out.

Cuffy stared at it, and then his eyes filled. He did not reach for it at first. Quashie let it hang in the air between them.

"I’ll never call you brother," Quashie said. "I’ll never sit at your fire again. But you’ll take this, and you’ll tie your boat to that stake with a proper bowline, every night, so the tide can’t carry it off. That’s what I taught your boy. You’ll teach yourself the same thing, or I’ll know."

Cuffy took the rope in both hands. He held it against his chest and bent over it, and Kofi looked away, out to sea, where the Morning Star’s sails stood white against the blue.

Titus came up beside him, wrapped in sailcloth, with the stitches under his ribs showing a faint red through the linen.

"He’ll live," Titus said. "The cay’s dry and the water’s sweet. Quashie’s given him a rope and a reason. That’s enough for one man."

"For one man," Kofi said.

Titus did not answer. He had gone still. He was looking east, past the shoal, to where the sea met the sky, and his face had gone the colour of old paper.

Kofi followed his gaze. A sail stood on the horizon. Then another. Then a third, smaller, shaped like a sloop with her mainsail patched in three colours, and a flag at her masthead that had been sewn from what looked like a cut-down ship’s ensign. It showed a painted skull above two crossed cutlasses, and beneath the skull, in black stitching, a line of uneven capitals.

BROOK’S WAY.

"Hornigold," Titus said.

The sloop came on fast, with her sails trimmed close and a dozen men crowding her rail. They wore a mix of coats and shirts and sailcloth, and some of them had their hair tied back in the Akan fashion, and a few had shaved their heads like the Ironbound men. They were young. Kofi could see that even at a mile. They waved their cutlasses over their heads and shouted something that carried thinly over the water.

They were singing.

Kofi caught the first lines through the wind. It was the song from the Hollow, the one the sisters had sung at the old spring: We see you, we say your name. But the tune had been changed. It had been put into the rhythm of a sea-shanty, with a stamping chorus that rang out over the water like a drum. Brook’s way. Brook’s way. Hang the Crown and hang the Navy, Brook’s way.

"They’ve got a gallows," Anne said from the Morning Star’s rail. She had come up from below with her cutlass in her hand and the black rooster on its blade already catching the light. "Look aft, Kofi. Look at the boat."

Kofi looked. The sloop’s boat had come off her stern and was rowing hard for the cay, and in its stern sheets, roped to the thwart with his hands behind him, sat a young man with a bloody face. He was not one of the Company’s men. He wore no uniform. He had a torn shirt and a bare chest and the marks of a rope burn around his throat.

"That’s Ellis," Mary said. She had her hand to her eyes. "The Eleuthera boy. He ran from the Company’s storehouse three weeks ago and came to the Hollow asking for work. Lightbourn’s wife sent him off in the Good Intent with a sack of corn." Her mouth tightened. "Hornigold’s men have got him. They’ve taken him for a Company spy."

"Then they’ve taken the wrong man," Kofi said.

The sloop’s boat grounded on the beach beside the fishing boat. The Brook’s Boys came over the side in a rush, cutlasses drawn, and a tall, lean man in a ragged blue coat strode up the sand to the lean-to with a pistol in each hand. He had a long jaw and dark hair going grey at the temples, and a grin that never reached his eyes. He was English, Kofi could tell from his vowels. He had the bearing of a man who had once been a sailor on a royal ship and had been thrown off for drinking.

"Brook," the man called. He did not lower his pistols. "Benjamin Hornigold. Your name’s been spreading faster than my ships can sail. I thought I’d come and see the face behind the poster."

"You’re hanging a boy on my cay," Kofi said.

"Your cay, is it?" Hornigold looked around the beach as though he were measuring it for a sale. "The Crown’s sand, Brook. Every inch of it. I’m only enforcing the law of the sea. This man sold your shoal, didn’t he? Sold your route to the Navy’s pay-brig, sold the people sheltering under your name. A Company trader on Eleuthera bought fish off him for silver, and he got drunk on my rum and bragged about the price. Cuffy, of the Hollow. Twelve Spanish dollars." His grin widened. "Brook’s justice says a traitor hangs, and my boys have been waiting a long time to see it done."

Cuffy had risen to his feet beside the fire. He stood with the bowline rope still in his hands, and his face had gone white under the grime.

"Brook’s justice," Quashie said quietly from the sand. He had not moved from his crutch. "You’ve got the words of it, Hornigold. You don’t have its meaning."

Hornigold turned his head. He looked at Quashie for a moment, at the crutch and the wrapped ankle, and then he laughed.

"And who are you? The Keeper’s cripple?"

"I’m the man who taught that boy in the Company’s boat the bowline," Quashie said. "And the man who has to live with the knot."

The Brook’s Boys had gathered on the sand behind Hornigold. They stood with their cutlasses drawn and their faces shadowed under their hats, and Kofi saw a few of them glance at each other, uneasy. A boy near the back, no older than sixteen, had his hand on the hilt of his blade and his eyes on the cay’s gallows. The gallows was a crude frame of ship’s timber lashed together with rope, and it stood at the top of the beach, and beneath its crossbeam a noose hung down, swaying a little in the breeze.

The boy’s lips moved. Kofi heard him whisper to the man beside him. Is it real?

The man beside him did not answer.

"Ellis," Kofi called across the sand. "Can you hear me?"

The young man in the boat lifted his head. He had been crying, and his face was a mess of blood and dirt, but he looked up with the look of someone who had given up hope and was surprised to find it still there.

"Keeper," Ellis croaked. "I never told them nothing. They say I’m a spy. I swear it on my mother."

"I know you didn’t," Kofi said.

Hornigold turned on the sand. "Brook, you can’t do a thing for him. You can’t do anything for any of them. You’re a name on a poster now. The Navy owns your face. And I own the name." He lifted one pistol, not at Kofi, but at the boat. "Stand aside, or I hang him from your Hollow’s own door."

Kofi walked forward until he stood at the edge of the surf. He did not raise his sword. He let his hands hang at his sides, the cane-sword in the right and the grave-cross sheath in the left, and he looked at Hornigold with the sea-wind on his face.

"You’re not the first man to take my name," he said. "The Navy took it first. The Company took it before that. They branded it on men’s arms and wrote it in their books. You’ve only learned to sell it on a wharf." He pointed at the gallows. "That rope is not Brook’s justice. It’s the Company’s, with a new flag."

Hornigold’s jaw tightened. "Then you’ll explain it to the Navy."

"I’ll explain it to the boys," Kofi said.

He turned toward the young men on the sand. He did not raise his voice. He spoke to them in plain English, the words chosen one at a time the way a shipwright chooses timber.

"Who here was a runaway?" he asked.

For a moment nobody moved. Then, slowly, a dark-skinned boy near the back raised his hand. Then another, a man with the Ironbound brand burned into his shoulder, pale against his dark skin. Then a woman in a torn skirt, holding her cutlass like a stick. Kofi counted them. Eleven hands rose from the Brook’s Boys, out of twenty-two.

"And who here was sold by a Company man?" Kofi said.

More hands rose, slower, uncertain. Seven more.

"And who came to these islands in chains?" he asked. "Who knows what a rope feels like when it’s pulled tight, because they stood at the foot of a tree and watched someone else hang from it?"

Silence. Even Hornigold had gone quiet, his pistol lowered a few inches.

"That’s the Brook’s Boys I know," Kofi said. "And I know the Hollow. We take in the people the Navy throws away. We don’t hang the people the Navy hates, because the Navy hates everyone who isn’t theirs. If you want to be the Keeper’s men, you start by putting down that rope."

The boy at the back, the sixteen-year-old with the uneasy hand, lowered his eyes.

Then the boy beside Hornigold, a stocky man with a shaved scalp and a scar across his lip, spoke up. He had not raised his hand before.

"Benjie," he said to Hornigold, quiet and clear. "The Keeper’s right. I don’t want to hang a man for money."

Hornigold rounded on him. "You’ll do as you’re told, Thomas, or you’ll walk the plank yourself."

Thomas did not step back. He stood with his shoulders squared and his cutlass at his side, and beside him three others shifted their feet, looking at each other.

Titus stepped down onto the sand. He had his cutlass in one hand and his other arm pressed to his ribs, and the sea was rising behind him. It came up the beach in a glassy swell, lapping at the gallows’ feet. Kofi could hear the water hiss against the timber.

"You don’t want to see what the sea does when it’s angry," Titus said. "Agwé isn’t a man who likes to be disobeyed."

Hornigold looked at the water. He looked at the Coromantee, at the salt white in his hair, and for the first time his grin faltered.

Anne spoke from the Morning Star’s rail. "Benjie, you’ve got fire on your sloop, but you don’t have a pepper-rum cutlass. Don’t make me show you."

Hornigold opened his mouth, and then closed it. He lowered his second pistol and stood there for a moment, breathing hard through his nose. Then he turned and strode toward the boat, stopped halfway, and called back over his shoulder without looking round.

"Keep your rope, Brook. It was never going to be the last one."

Kofi walked up the sand to the boat and cut Ellis’s bonds with his knife. The young man fell out of the stern sheets onto the beach, weeping, and clutched at Kofi’s coat as if it were a rope.

"You’ll come with us to the Hollow," Kofi said. "Lightbourn’s wife will feed you, and nobody will hang you for being born."

Ellis nodded, sobbing, and he could not say anything at all.

The Brook’s Boys sailed away at dusk with their sloop low in the water and their flag hauled down. Some of them went with Hornigold. Some did not. Kofi saw the stocky man called Thomas stand on the beach a long time, watching the sloop’s lanterns go out on the darkening sea. Then Thomas walked up to the Morning Star’s longboat and asked, very quietly, if the Keeper would take a man who had not yet decided what he was.

Kofi told him yes.

Cuffy stood at the fire with the bowline rope in his hand. He had not spoken since the rope came up the beach. Now he set it down on a rock, carefully, and pressed his palm flat against the stone beside it. His eyes were wet.

"I’d have hanged for him," Cuffy said to nobody. "For a boat’s worth of silver. I’d have let them."

Quashie, sitting on a driftwood log with his leg propped up, looked at him for a long time in the firelight.

"You didn’t," Quashie said. "That’s the only thing you’ve done right since the Hollow. Don’t waste it."

Cuffy turned away and stared at the dark sea.

Kofi stood at the edge of the surf. The coat hung heavy on his shoulders, the brass buttons catching the last of the firelight. Beside him, Titus came up with his cutlass sheathed and his face grey with fatigue.

"Hornigold will talk," Titus said. "He’ll tell every wharf in the Bahamas that the Keeper spared a traitor and let his boys go."

"Let him talk."

"He’ll sell it as weakness."

"Then he’ll sell it badly," Kofi said. "A man who sings my name over a gallows deserves nothing better."

Titus looked out to sea, where the last lantern of the Brook’s sloop was disappearing toward the south-east. Then he looked back at the cay, at the lean-to and the boat and the small figure of Cuffy turning the bowline rope over in his hands.

"Kofi," Titus said. "Hornigold knows the Pedro Bank. He told me so when the sloop closed. He said he’d be waiting there for the pay-brig on Lady Day, same as the Navy."

Kofi felt the cold settle in his chest. Lady Day. The Bountiful. The Pedro Bank in the dark, and a lead line going over the side every hour.

"Then the Navy will have company," he said.

Out past the shoal, under the rising stars, something moved in the water. It was too far to see. Kofi did not wait to find out what it was. He turned toward the longboat, and his boots sank into the wet sand, and he did not look back at the sea.