Arthur sighed. The breath cost him something on the left side, and he let it out anyway.
"Not really," he said. "Some of them are interesting. There’s a boy in 1-B that’s named Hiro. Fights like he already knows the camera’s on him, which sounds like a flaw and might not be. Another one in the same class, Percy. Blue hair, notebook, reads a room faster than the room knows it’s being read. There’s a girl in 1-A named Sloane who commits to everything the way you’d commit to a decision you’d already lost sleep over. And Gia, also 1-A, who solves problems before anyone else notices there’s a problem."
Ashby waited.
"None of them?" he asked.
"None of them are ready to have a river shoved into a cracked pipe."
The tea steamed between them. Arthur turned the cup a quarter turn on the blotter and watched the surface settle.
"Although, I have become interested in one of them," he said.
Ashby’s expression didn’t change, which meant he’d been waiting for exactly this and had chosen not to reach for it.
"The Belmont boy."
Arthur didn’t answer right away. Down on the track the kid finished another lap and slowed to a walk with his hands on his hips. Somewhere below them a door opened and closed and opened again. The building had its own life at this hour, indifferent to the two men deciding things on the top floor.
"I don’t like saying his name," Arthur said finally. "Which is stupid. It’s a name. But every time I put it in my mouth it feels like I’m putting something into the world I don’t want circulating yet." He looked at the ruined shoulder of the hoodie instead of at Ashby. "So we’ll say the boy. Reina’s boy."
"Marcus’s as well."
"Marcus’s as well." A muscle worked in Arthur’s jaw. "I watched the entrance footage. I watched it four times, which is more than I watch anything, and I don’t watch things four times, because I don’t have four hours in a day. I have a lot fewer. He pulled a girl out of a zero-pointer engagement zone when the smart play was to walk. He set up two other kids for kills he could have taken himself. He fought a Legendary-class Conjurer’s barrier and it came apart, which it shouldn’t have, because his file says fifteen feet and twenty pounds and a late manifestation that showed up this spring out of a clear sky."
Ashby said nothing.
"That’s the part I keep circling," Arthur said. "Someone awakening that late, that clean, out of nowhere. Seven years of negative scans and then a Rare-tier Channeler at eighteen. That doesn’t happen. All right, it happens, in a fraction of a fraction of the population, and even then it doesn’t come out looking the way his did. You don’t think there’s something under it?"
"I think," Ashby said, "that you have already decided there is something under it, and you have come to my office to be talked out of it, and I am not going to do that."
Arthur huffed a laugh that turned into a cough and cost him. He caught it in his sleeve this time and left the handkerchief in his pocket where it belonged.
"He’s the child of two Heroes," he said, once the fit passed. "Reina and Marcus. Mid-tier and respected, killed in the Eastside ten years ago buying time. Then Diane Fitzgerald took him in three weeks later, on the day of the funeral, and Diane Fitzgerald has spent two decades building the public image of every Hero worth photographing in California, and her daughter is trying to be one. That boy grew up in a house where the profession was the wallpaper." Arthur shook his head slowly. "If you wanted to grow a Hero from seed, you couldn’t design a better greenhouse. He’s got a name that opens doors and a guardian who knows how every one of them is hinged. Down the hall there’s a girl who trains at six-thirty in the morning and drags people along whether they want it or not."
"You are describing reasons to like him."
"I’m describing reasons to be suspicious of how easy the story is." Arthur set the cup down. "Everything about that kid fits together too well, Caelum. The tragedy and the timing. The manifestation and the house he grew up in. It reads the way a costume reads. Somebody put thought into the silhouette."
Ashby moved away from the window. He crossed to the corner where the wooden training staff leaned against the plaster and ran one finger along the new crack in its lower third without looking at it, the way a man touches a scar he has stopped explaining.
"You are the only person alive," he said, "who inherited a power he did not manifest, and you are sitting in my office telling me that a boy whose power arrived strangely cannot be trusted on the strength of the strangeness alone."
Arthur went quiet.
"That’s not fair," he said.
"It is exactly fair. That is why it landed." Ashby turned around. "I am not telling you the boy is clean. I am telling you that the shape of your suspicion is the shape of your own history, and a man who cannot separate the two makes bad choices about whom he tests and whom he protects. You looked at his file and saw a costume with too much thought in the silhouette. You should have watched the entrance footage a fifth time and asked yourself why a boy with every reason to take the easy score walked into a zero-pointer’s kill radius for a girl he had known for four minutes."
"Because it looks good on camera."
"Because it does not." Ashby’s voice didn’t rise. It never had to. "The cameras were never the point of that exam. Isabelle Crane designed it. She tests what students do when they believe the scoring rewards the opposite. He lost points saving that girl. He knew it, and he did it anyway. You cannot fake that with a guardian and a greenhouse, Arthur. That is no silhouette."
The smoke under the ceiling had begun to thin. Arthur watched the last of it flatten and go, and he thought about a boy he’d never met, and about a woman half his size who had never once been slower.
"Reina would have decked me," he said, "for talking about her kid like a threat assessment."
"Reina would have decked you for a great many things. She showed considerable restraint while she was alive." Ashby set the staff back against the plaster. "You feel a responsibility to that boy. You have felt it for ten years and expressed it exactly once, through a scholarship you instructed your agency never to publicize."
Arthur’s head came up.
"You knew about that."