← All reading notes

THE LUNEFABLE REVIEW

Diary of Guarding Monster Girls

Diary of Guarding Monster Girls: Herbert brings earplugs to a dragon’s argument

A novice paladin inherits a dangerous prison job and an unwanted supernatural correspondent. The best jokes turn grand power into awkward conversation, while a restrictive oath proves less simple than it first appears.

Diary of Guarding Monster Girls cover

THE SHORT TAKE

A distinctive supernatural workplace comedy, strongest when observation and practical wit challenge unequal power.

The promotion comes with prisoners, vows, and very little authority

Herbert has become a prison warden in an ancient monastery, but the title is considerably more impressive than his position. Diary of Guarding Monster Girls begins with a newly sworn paladin trying to understand a job whose inmates could overwhelm him even while restrained. His immediate complaint concerns a restrictive oath; his more interesting problem is that everyone around him seems to understand the institution's rules better than he does.

The opening turns that disadvantage into a fantasy workplace comedy. Herbert brings the habits of a skeptical legal professional to a world where promises carry supernatural penalties and a polite conversation can become a threat. He does not initially possess the strength to command obedience, so his useful skills are observation, irritation, and the ability to ask an inconvenient question. The strongest scenes let those smaller tools disturb an apparently settled hierarchy.

Revenge can wait when the monastery contains a better opportunity

A court scandal explains how Herbert reached the monastery, but he declines to make immediate vindication his entire purpose. His earlier self tried to prove innocence through a costly vow. With recovered memories, he sees more value in learning what the institution can teach him before returning to the people who arranged his disgrace. That choice gives the opening room to develop its unusual workplace instead of rushing back toward familiar noble-family retaliation.

The assigned task is hardly an easy training placement. The prisoners have histories of catastrophe, and reforming them is supposed to earn access to a valuable inheritance. Herbert's official role therefore puts him between two kinds of power: a monastery setting the conditions of advancement, and inmates who have little reason to accept its definition of improvement. The story has not yet explored that ethical tension deeply, but it provides a useful foundation beneath the banter.

Walking away is sometimes the only victory available

Valentina, the imprisoned dragon, offers Herbert an extravagant solution to his problems: release her and let her settle his grievances. Instead of accepting the invitation to rehearse his humiliation, he redirects the exchange toward dinner and leaves her furious. The joke depends on refusing the emotional script she has prepared. Her terrifying reputation cannot force him to supply the anger she wants to use.

Importantly, the narration later admits that this apparent composure has required effort. Without the archbishop's protection, even conversation under her presence is physically difficult. That admission makes the exit more entertaining than effortless dominance would have been. His later return with earplugs is another good piece of practical comedy: Valentina has prepared an impressive supply of insults, and he has prepared a way not to hear them. The contest is petty, but its unequal participants make it memorable.

A supernatural visitation becomes a very inconvenient correspondence

The night's intrusion gives Herbert a problem he cannot solve by leaving the room. His left hand begins writing messages, while his right hand struggles to reply and his dictionary becomes necessary equipment. An encounter that could have relied entirely on ominous spectacle instead becomes an argument conducted through paper. The mismatch between the visitor's grand claims and its enjoyment of provocation supplies much of the humor.

Herbert's first response is sensible: he tries to summon people better qualified to help. Only when that fails does the conversation become unavoidable. This preserves some of the danger beneath his sarcasm. He can mock a question without being able to control the situation, and a playful tone does not establish benevolent intentions. The opening is strongest when the reader can enjoy the verbal contest while remembering how little freedom he had in agreeing to participate.

The prisoners make a useful test of what has changed

Returning to work after that encounter, Herbert notices that Valentina's presence no longer affects him in the same way. Her own reaction suggests a change she finds difficult to conceal. The resulting exchange is funny because neither participant wants to admit curiosity first. His teasing meets her determined refusal to turn around, reducing a conversation with a legendary dragon to the stubborn body language of an everyday quarrel.

The sea siren introduces a different performance. Her invitation expects him to respond according to a familiar pattern, but he answers with an absurdly practical concern about accommodation. The scene is more effective as a collision of assumptions than as a display of flirtation. It also gives Herbert something to investigate. The oath he resents and the new influence he distrusts may offer different kinds of protection, and separating those effects becomes more useful than simply congratulating himself on unusual immunity.

The negotiating table is more promising than the easy joke

The opening eventually returns to the question of terms: what does an interested power want, what can it offer, and what does its conduct reveal about its limitations? Herbert's shift from joking to questioning gives his professional background a purpose. He studies the interaction rather than accepting a title as proof of unlimited knowledge. That is a promising direction for a protagonist whose main ambition is to recover control over his own life.

There are considerable rough edges. Crude sexual speculation and shock humor interrupt more inventive scenes, while repeated interjections and internet references can make different exchanges sound alike. The prisoners' histories are initially handled as colorful credentials rather than deeply examined actions. Still, the earplugs, contested correspondence, and uncertain protections give this opening a distinct comic identity. Readers who enjoy irreverent supernatural negotiation may find a worthwhile partnership taking shape, provided later chapters let the questions of trust and responsibility matter as much as Herbert's next clever reply.

Based on chapters 1–8 of the English edition. This is an opening impression, not a full-series verdict. No later plot developments are discussed.

MAKE UP YOUR OWN MIND

The first chapter is waiting.

Read freely, or keep this story on your shelf for later.

Your shelf is saved in this browser. No account needed.

About the author

Bahrain

Explore this author’s books ↗