THE LUNEFABLE REVIEW
Why the Swordswoman Leaves Out the Pictures
A stranded man has a whole continent to ask for help. The best joke in Got a Gallery in the Wild is how often a genuinely qualified stranger has misunderstood the question.
THE SHORT TAKE
Worth reading for the people on the other side of the screen. An abrasive comment can come from the first person to send supplies, and an impeccably polite expert might be hiding from her mother.
The least useful photograph in the world
A man wakes up under enormous trees and posts a picture of them. Can anyone tell him where he is? It takes him a moment to appreciate what he has asked. The joke would work almost anywhere with trees and an internet connection. Then somebody objects to the elves' idea that every forest belongs to them, a dwarf complains about firewood, and an embarrassingly bad question has acquired something like a local history. The hero's most useful skill at this point is his willingness to try asking again.
He does better with a close-up. A plant with crescent-shaped petals brings offers from strangers who know what it is worth. One of the rudest suddenly sounds like a salesman at an expensive counter. The hero goes through the posting history of the woman who answered first. She writes so often, and in such grand language, that she looks like a role-player. She also sounds unwell. I liked his grounds for dealing with her. He knows what it feels like to get there first and still lose out, a small courtesy on which two lives will shortly depend.
Read chapter 1 · Compare the responses to the forest and flower photographs ↗Her last three minutes online
On the other side of the trade window sits Yu So-Wol, a martial ruler in serious physical trouble. The irreverence of the gallery has been her favorite relief from the respectful silence of her own followers. Its disadvantages emerge when she genuinely needs help and her regular audience takes a grave-sounding post for another joke. The book lets us see her dying in a cave while the strangers keep typing. That switch of viewpoint lends real weight to how lightly we've been reading her messages.
The private window closes after three minutes. She can send food and a sword now. She will have to owe him a compass and a way to start a fire. After the trade she is too busy taking the herb to answer his question about whether it arrived. Later she takes his own silence for possible offense. At his end of the conversation something with teeth has turned up. The little interval before we find that out is funny because we have just spent several pages with a person who desperately wants to say thank you.
Read chapter 2 · Sit in on Yu So-Wol’s first private trade ↗A bedroom above the level cap
Ash writes wonderfully careful swordsmanship lessons. A reader of the forum notices her punctuation before he has the faintest idea who she is. In person she is a thirty-five-year-old former guard captain, on the bed with a banana and a messy bun, hoping her mother will believe she is heading out to exercise. The account's polished manners help disguise a blunt speaker. Pictures and video would give too much away. Knowing that, I went back in my head to the painstaking written instructions she offered a man running from a walking hill.
Ash has professional reasons for keeping the lessons anonymous. Knights in a rival kingdom have improved by reading them. The emperor would dearly like to know who taught them. Her first motive for teaching is far more private and rather silly, and the novel does let the joke about her marriage prospects run on. The lovelier detail is how making the next installment has become an ordinary part of her day. Whatever got her started, she now takes trouble over describing a parry for people she will never meet.
Read chapter 4 · Meet the writer of the fifteenth advanced sword lesson ↗What the dwarf actually sends
There is a reason the forum hesitates over a photograph of a wound. Someone once raised money there with a picture of a suffering child for whose suffering he was responsible. The gallery has learned a terrible lesson, and now the person paying for it is a stranger alone with a badly bitten arm. Ash quietly sends medicine. To her, the emperor has provided so many bottles that they get in the way at home. The man trying to work the cap with one hand has an entirely different measure of its worth.
I found the aftermath almost as convincing. He needs toilet paper. The dwarf offers worn underwear, ostensibly as a joke, and sends the real article when the man agrees to take it. It is a gloriously undignified way to earn the gallery's trust. A picture of a serious injury can be staged, they have discovered. The sheer embarrassment of this second appeal seems to carry more conviction than the first. No narrator has to declare that these people are beginning to care about one another.
Read chapter 5 · Watch the gallery answer two very different emergencies ↗The man who knows her username
Eventually the compasses agree on one thing. Nobody in the forest is going to get a useful bearing. Several readers have sent their own, and all the needles spin. A video from the bank of a stream, with trees on one side and desert on the other, makes a much better case for the hero's location than his first photograph. He has learned how to show this audience something. Whether the audience can help him get home is a harder question.
The most interesting holdout is Yu So-Wol's adviser. He understands how the forest can rebuild the barriers that defeat an intruder. He also knows his employer's username and has excellent reasons for keeping his own quiet. After a bruising audience with her, he opens the same forum to complain about his job. Someone asks about the pay. It is a welcome glimpse of an ordinary working relationship in the middle of wildly extravagant fantasy. By the eighth chapter I could recognize several people here from what they would rather a colleague never saw them write.
Read chapter 8 · Read the adviser’s private thoughts and his public complaints ↗Based on chapters 1–8 of the English edition. The first eight catalogue entries each contain one complete story chapter. This is an opening impression, not a full-series verdict. No later plot developments are discussed.
MAKE UP YOUR OWN MIND
The first chapter is waiting.
Read freely, or keep this story on your shelf for later.
Your shelf is saved in this browser. No account needed.