THE LUNEFABLE REVIEW
The Yellow-Haired Villain in Soaring Phoenix's Novels Also Desires Happiness
The Yellow-Haired Villain: an unhelpful book and tomorrow’s disastrous banquet
Muen knows the villain’s ending and wants out. His frantic reading of fate supplies sharp comedy—and a troubling excuse for repeating the harm he fears.
THE SHORT TAKE
A funny, uneasy antagonist-survival opening with good social scenes and a serious moral failure in its chosen survival plan.
The worst appointment is already on the calendar
Muen Campbell recognizes the handsome person in the mirror and immediately understands that the apparent good fortune has conditions. He has become an early antagonist in a novel he remembers, and his comfortable aristocratic life is approaching the event that destroys it. The Yellow-Haired Villain in Soaring Phoenix's Novels Also Desires Happiness makes tomorrow's coming-of-age banquet feel less like a celebration than an appointment he would desperately like to cancel.
The appeal is the mismatch between his elaborate genre knowledge and his very limited room to act. He knows enough to fear the protagonist, but not enough to explain every danger around him. His first sensible plan is to avoid behaving like the original villain. The opening then introduces a reason to make even that modest decision frightening.
A cheat that mostly records the embarrassment
The mysterious black book is the best comic device in these chapters. Muen calls for every kind of supernatural assistance he can imagine, receives something apparently important, and discovers that it is remarkably good at describing his gestures after he makes them. His grand hope for a solution becomes an unwanted commentary track.
That device also gives the story an unsettling second register. A disturbing vision and the book's sparse instructions do not provide a reliable explanation of what awaits him. Muen tries to turn them into a usable theory, but the text leaves room between what he knows and what he assumes. The comedy benefits from that uncertainty: this is a reader of fiction struggling with a text that will not give him the clarification he wants.
Condemning privilege is easier before the steak arrives
The dinner with his parents provides an enjoyable puncture of his new principles. Muen can denounce aristocratic parasitism in private and still discover excellent reasons to regret losing the household's comforts. The food makes his supposedly settled willingness to become an ordinary citizen look wonderfully provisional.
His parents' affection supplies a less comfortable version of the same contradiction. They regard their son as a treasure, and their praise reveals the indulgence that helped make the original Muen dangerous. He wants to preserve their support while becoming somebody different. The scene gives him a resource that is also part of the problem, rather than a family that can simply be classified as either oppressive or safe.
A servant’s mistake changes the scale of the story
The encounter with an ill maid is more revealing than another declaration that he is no longer the old villain. She expects punishment for spilling tea. He notices her condition, orders rest, and then has to confront the staffing problem that makes rest difficult. Hiring additional help is a small administrative decision with a more immediate benefit than his abstract arguments about destiny.
The effect on Anne matters too. She has known the version of Muen whose reputation he has inherited, and gentleness becomes something she must interpret rather than instantly trust. His fear of future enemies partly motivates the change, so the kindness is not presented as entirely uncomplicated. The scene is strongest when another person's expectations make his new behavior consequential.
The banquet is a performance everyone reads differently
Formal clothing turns public importance into an exhausting physical object. Muen's ceremonial outfit is heavy enough to become another item on his private list of threats. He stands beside his father, smiles with the body's practiced manners, and tries to keep prospective disasters from multiplying before the main event has begun.
His greeting to Ariel, the original protagonist, develops that performance nicely. A would-be supporter starts the familiar confrontation, and Muen stops him before the old routine can take hold. Courtesy then produces suspicion rather than gratitude. Ariel has reasons to distrust him, and the scene is more engaging because she does not discard those reasons merely because the person wearing his face has acquired a different internal monologue.
Surviving the script cannot excuse repeating its harm
The serious limitation is Muen's decision to prepare an attack on Celicia because he thinks following the doomed plot is safer than changing it. Fear explains his reasoning without making the planned violation acceptable. His expectation that somebody else will interrupt it is a dangerous substitute for responsibility. Sexualized appraisals also intrude on otherwise effective comedy, while embedded promotional text occasionally disrupts the translation. The story is more persuasive about anxiety than about the moral permissions anxiety supposedly grants.
Readers who enjoy unreliable foreknowledge and a panicked antagonist can still find a lively opening here. Its best moments involve an unhelpful book, a very comfortable dinner, and a greeting whose politeness creates new trouble. The question worth following is whether Muen can stop treating other people's safety as a detail already guaranteed by someone else's plot. A genuinely different life would require more than arranging a less painful version of his own downfall.
Based on chapters 1–8 of the English edition. This is an opening impression, not a full-series verdict. No later plot developments are discussed.
MAKE UP YOUR OWN MIND
The first chapter is waiting.
Read freely, or keep this story on your shelf for later.
Your shelf is saved in this browser. No account needed.