Never Die Villain · Contents

CHAPTER 276

Chapter 276: The Trust Game

8 min read·athex

The Thirteenth Society’s next gathering began with an unexpected announcement.

"Tonight, one of you will be a traitor."

Garen Vollbrecht, who had been enjoying a particularly expensive pastry, nearly choked.

Ilya found the announcement interesting. Given the society’s recent emphasis on trust and cooperation, he had expected another exercise involving agreements or negotiations. Apparently, the organizers had decided to make things more entertaining.

The society’s president stood beneath the Old Astronomical Hall’s domed ceiling, addressing twenty-four participating members.

Each would receive a sealed envelope containing a role and a private objective. The participants would then be divided into four groups and tasked with completing a collaborative exercise involving several academic problems.

However, one member of each group would secretly receive instructions to interfere with its progress.

The saboteurs weren’t permitted to destroy equipment, steal materials, or endanger anyone. Their task was to influence decisions, conceal information, and encourage their companions to make unfavorable choices.

At the end of the evening, each group would identify its suspected saboteur.

Successful completion of the academic assignment would earn points, while correctly identifying the saboteur would provide an additional reward.

The saboteurs would receive points according to how effectively they obstructed their groups without being discovered.

It was a rather elaborate game.

Garen looked delighted.

Tristan seemed interested as well, although he immediately raised a question concerning the rules.

"If the saboteur is discovered before the exercise concludes, may the group exclude them from subsequent decisions?"

The president smiled.

"Certainly. However, an incorrect accusation will result in a penalty."

That complicated matters.

A group that accused the wrong person could lose valuable points while allowing the actual saboteur to continue operating freely.

Ilya approved of the arrangement. At least the organizers understood that distrust should carry consequences.

Unfortunately, their group assignments were announced shortly afterward.

Ilya, Tristan, and Garen had been placed together again.

"Excellent!" Garen declared. "We’ll win this easily."

Tristan regarded him with suspicion.

"That’s exactly what a saboteur would say."

"We haven’t even received our roles!"

"Then you’ve begun remarkably early."

Ilya decided that their greatest obstacle might be surviving the evening without the other two accusing each other of treason.

The attendants distributed the envelopes.

Ilya opened his.

His assignment was straightforward.

[Role: Investigator]

[Objective: Assist your group in completing its assigned task. Identify the saboteur before the final evaluation.]

He returned the card to its envelope and examined the room.

Their group included three additional students, all established members of the society. Ilya recognized two from previous gatherings, although he had spoken with neither at length.

The six were directed toward a table containing a small mechanical apparatus, several technical diagrams, and a collection of documents.

Their objective was to restore a malfunctioning mana distribution system using limited resources.

Garen immediately became enthusiastic.

"Finally, something useful."

Tristan examined the diagrams.

"You’re assuming the equipment is actually broken."

"Of course it’s broken. That’s the assignment."

"Then perhaps you should determine what’s wrong before attempting to repair it."

Ilya agreed with Tristan.

The society had deliberately introduced a saboteur into the group. It would be foolish to assume that every document and instruction reflected the actual condition of the apparatus.

He suggested beginning with an independent inspection.

Garen accepted the responsibility for examining the mechanism, while Tristan reviewed the technical instructions and Ilya organized the available resources.

The remaining members divided the supporting tasks.

Their initial progress was encouraging.

Garen discovered that one of the mana conductors had been installed incorrectly, producing an unstable output whenever the apparatus operated above a particular threshold.

Correcting the problem would require replacing a damaged component and recalibrating the regulator.

Unfortunately, their available resources were insufficient.

One of the society members suggested requesting additional materials from another group.

That was permitted under the rules, although doing so would require surrendering part of their evaluation score.

Tristan opposed the proposal.

They possessed enough components to construct a temporary replacement, provided the design could be simplified.

Garen agreed.

The discussion continued until Ilya noticed something unusual.

One member had repeatedly encouraged them to purchase additional materials despite the availability of cheaper alternatives.

That was suspicious.

However, accusing someone merely for suggesting an inefficient solution would be unreasonable.

The student might simply lack the technical knowledge necessary to recognize the alternatives.

Ilya decided to observe further.

He asked Garen to explain which components could be substituted without compromising the apparatus’s performance.

Garen provided a detailed answer.

The student listened attentively and acknowledged that the cheaper approach might work.

That response reduced Ilya’s suspicions.

A saboteur could certainly pretend to cooperate, but the student had abandoned the original proposal without attempting to introduce another obstacle.

Meanwhile, Tristan discovered a discrepancy in the technical documents.

Two diagrams described different arrangements for the same mechanism.

One appeared to be outdated.

The other contained a minor correction that would improve efficiency.

Unfortunately, neither document indicated which version was authoritative.

The group debated the discrepancy.

Ilya recommended using the arrangement supported by their own measurements.

The others agreed.

Their decision proved correct.

Within another half hour, the apparatus was operating normally.

However, the exercise had not yet concluded.

The supervising attendant informed them that their final objective required demonstrating stable operation under several changing conditions.

That introduced a new difficulty.

The repaired system performed well under ordinary loads, but sudden increases in mana demand caused temporary fluctuations.

Garen began adjusting the regulator.

Tristan assisted with controlling the external supply, while Ilya monitored the output and compared the results against their calculations.

The remaining members provided support.

Then one of them made a suggestion.

They could eliminate the instability by reducing the apparatus’s maximum output.

The proposal was technically valid.

However, it would also prevent the mechanism from satisfying the exercise’s performance requirements.

Ilya recognized the problem immediately.

"That would stabilize the system," he acknowledged. "But we’d lose points for failing the output threshold."

The student accepted the objection and proposed another solution.

This time, the suggestion involved increasing the regulator’s sensitivity.

Garen examined the calculations.

"That’ll make it respond faster, but it might overcorrect."

"Only if the disturbance exceeds the expected range," the student replied.

The answer was reasonable.

Nevertheless, Ilya noticed that the proposed adjustment would place additional strain on the replacement conductor.

If the apparatus failed during the final test, their group would lose most of its accumulated points.

He began suspecting that the student was their saboteur.

However, the conclusion wasn’t certain.

The suggestions had been plausible, and each could have succeeded under different circumstances.

A genuinely ambitious engineer might have proposed the same adjustments.

Ilya needed a better way to distinguish deliberate interference from ordinary disagreement.

He proposed testing the regulator at a lower output before making any permanent changes.

The group agreed.

The experiment revealed that increasing sensitivity produced the predicted instability.

Garen immediately recommended abandoning the adjustment.

The student accepted the result without complaint.

That was interesting.

If the fellow was attempting sabotage, he was doing so with remarkable patience.

Ilya considered another possibility.

The actual saboteur might be someone who had contributed very little to the discussion.

While everyone concentrated on questionable technical suggestions, another member could influence the group’s decisions through subtler means.

He reviewed their progress.

Their materials had been accounted for, the equipment functioned properly, and nobody had attempted to conceal information.

However, one student had repeatedly supported whichever proposal attracted the strongest opposition.

The behavior had prolonged several discussions without producing any meaningful contribution.

Ilya decided to test his suspicion.

He proposed a deliberately inefficient adjustment, presenting it as a possible solution to their remaining instability.

Tristan immediately objected.

Garen examined the proposal and also identified its weakness.

The suspected student, however, supported Ilya’s suggestion.

He argued that the adjustment deserved consideration despite the objections.

Ilya listened carefully.

The explanation was weak.

More importantly, the student appeared eager to prolong the disagreement even after the technical problem had been explained.

That was enough.

Ilya withdrew his proposal and recommended proceeding with the existing arrangement.

The final test began shortly afterward.

Their apparatus maintained stable operation throughout the required conditions, earning the group an excellent technical evaluation.

Then came the accusation phase.

The supervising attendant instructed each member to submit the name of their suspected saboteur.

Ilya wrote his choice.

Tristan submitted his own answer without hesitation.

Garen appeared troubled.

He had spent most of the evening concentrating on the apparatus and hadn’t paid particular attention to the surrounding discussions.

Eventually, he selected the student who had proposed increasing the regulator’s sensitivity.

The results were announced several minutes later.

Ilya had identified the saboteur correctly.

Tristan had also succeeded.

Garen, unfortunately, had accused the wrong person.

The actual saboteur was the quiet student who had repeatedly prolonged their discussions.

His objective had been to waste the group’s limited time rather than damage the apparatus directly.

The strategy had nearly succeeded.

However, the group’s technical competence had allowed them to complete the assignment despite the delays.

Garen seemed deeply offended.

"I spent the entire evening fixing that thing!"

"And you did an excellent job," Ilya assured him.

"Then why am I being punished?"

"Because you accused the wrong person."

"That’s beside the point!"

Tristan laughed.

For once, Ilya didn’t bother intervening.

The exercise concluded with their group receiving one of the highest overall evaluations.

Although Garen had failed to identify the saboteur, his technical contribution had been indispensable.

The president praised their performance and reminded the participants that successful cooperation required both competence and judgment.

However, Ilya found another aspect of the evening more interesting.

The saboteur hadn’t needed to lie, steal, or openly oppose anyone.

He had merely encouraged unnecessary arguments until the group wasted its available time.

It was an effective strategy precisely because every individual disagreement had appeared reasonable.

As the gathering dispersed, Ilya found himself considering how easily similar methods could be employed outside a controlled exercise.

In an organization built around favors, obligations, and competing interests, a talented manipulator might accomplish considerably more than delaying a mechanical repair.

And unlike tonight’s game, there wouldn’t necessarily be an instructor announcing the culprit afterward.