Never Die Villain · Contents

CHAPTER 277

Chapter 277: The Favor Ledger

8 min read·athex

By the following afternoon, Garen Vollbrecht had decided that the Thirteenth Society’s trust exercise was fundamentally unfair.

He had repaired the apparatus, corrected its calibration, and helped their group achieve one of the evening’s highest evaluations. Yet because he had accused the wrong person of sabotage, Tristan had spent the entire morning reminding him of his mistake.

"I was busy doing actual work!" Garen complained.

"An admirable excuse," Tristan replied. "Unfortunately, the saboteur was also doing his work."

Ilya found that difficult to dispute. Their opponent had managed to waste nearly half an hour through perfectly ordinary disagreements, and Garen had been too absorbed in the machinery to notice.

Nevertheless, Ilya thought the exercise had revealed something more interesting than their respective scores.

The society had demonstrated how easily cooperation could be manipulated when members lacked complete information. Yet its entire internal structure depended on exchanging favors, negotiating obligations, and trusting other students to honor their agreements.

It was an effective lesson.

Whether its organizers practiced what they taught remained another question.

That afternoon, Ilya received a message from Margarethe von Adlerheim requesting his assistance at the Old Astronomical Hall. The society’s secretary wanted to discuss his earlier review of committee expenditures, particularly several discrepancies involving the registration of reciprocal obligations.

He accepted, partly because the matter interested him and partly because he preferred examining actual records to enduring another afternoon of Garen and Tristan arguing.

Unfortunately, both insisted on accompanying him.

Garen claimed he wanted to understand how his workshop obligations were recorded. Tristan argued that his experience with aristocratic agreements might prove useful.

Both explanations were reasonable.

Ilya suspected they also wanted an excuse to avoid their remaining coursework.

Margarethe received them in the society’s records office, where several large ledgers occupied a table beside the window.

The documents contained records of exchanges between members, including equipment loans, academic recommendations, financial contributions, and assistance with private projects.

Most entries were unremarkable.

A student borrowed a specialized measuring instrument and agreed to assist with its maintenance. Another received access to historical documents in exchange for helping organize a scholarly discussion.

However, several agreements involved obligations whose values were difficult to determine.

One student had received an introduction to a distinguished researcher. In return, he had agreed to provide assistance with future academic activities whenever reasonably requested.

Another had accepted sponsorship for a competition, with repayment defined as services equivalent to the benefits received.

Neither arrangement specified an exact limit.

Tristan identified the problem immediately.

"These obligations could be interpreted quite broadly."

Margarethe acknowledged the concern. The society relied on its committees to evaluate unusual agreements, particularly when the original participants disagreed about their terms.

Unfortunately, several disputes had recently accumulated.

The secretary wanted Ilya’s opinion on whether the existing records provided enough information to resolve them fairly.

He examined the agreements.

The difficulty was obvious.

Without clearly defined terms, even honest participants could develop very different expectations.

Someone who arranged an introduction might consider the favor worth several weeks of assistance, while the recipient might regard it as a minor courtesy.

Both could genuinely believe their interpretation was reasonable.

"How often do these disputes occur?" Ilya asked.

"Most agreements are resolved without difficulty," Margarethe explained. "These are the exceptions."

That was reassuring, although Ilya wondered whether the exceptions shared any common features.

He began comparing the records.

Several disputes involved students who had received unusually valuable opportunities through society connections. In each case, the recipient had subsequently been asked to contribute to projects unrelated to the original assistance.

The requests weren’t necessarily unreasonable.

However, their scope had expanded considerably beyond what the recipients appeared to have anticipated.

Garen discovered something similar in the engineering records.

One student had borrowed equipment for a research competition and later agreed to provide maintenance assistance. The initial arrangement involved a few hours of work, but subsequent requests had accumulated until the student owed more than thirty hours.

"That’s ridiculous," Garen remarked. "You could repair half the workshop in that time."

Margarethe explained that the additional hours resulted from several separate agreements.

Garen examined them carefully.

The documents did contain the student’s signature.

However, each new agreement had been presented as an extension of the previous obligation, making it difficult to determine where one responsibility ended and another began.

Ilya understood the concern.

An agreement could be technically voluntary while still placing someone under pressure to accept additional conditions.

That didn’t automatically make it invalid.

Nevertheless, the society’s procedures ought to distinguish between obligations freely negotiated and those accepted because a member believed refusal would jeopardize an existing benefit.

Tristan proposed introducing fixed limits for future service agreements.

Margarethe considered the suggestion useful, although she explained that some members preferred flexible arrangements because their value couldn’t always be measured through money or working hours.

That was a legitimate objection.

Ilya suggested a compromise.

The society could permit flexible obligations while requiring both parties to agree on a maximum scope. Any additional work would need a separate agreement, and refusing it couldn’t alter the original terms.

The proposal preserved flexibility without allowing responsibilities to expand indefinitely.

Margarethe recorded the recommendation.

Their discussion continued until Garen encountered an entry that attracted his attention.

It concerned an engineering student who had withdrawn from a competitive research project after receiving assistance from the society.

The name appeared among the records Ilya had examined several days earlier.

According to the ledger, the student had accepted a valuable equipment sponsorship and subsequently transferred to a privately funded project.

However, the sponsorship hadn’t been recorded as completed.

Instead, the remaining obligation had been transferred to another committee.

"Can they do that?" Garen asked.

Margarethe examined the entry.

Under the society’s charter, certain obligations could be transferred with the recipient’s consent.

The relevant document contained a signed acknowledgment.

That made the transfer permissible.

However, Ilya noticed that the new committee possessed considerably broader authority to request academic assistance.

The student had originally agreed to help maintain equipment.

After the transfer, the obligation apparently included reviewing research materials and providing technical consultations.

The change was substantial.

"Did the student agree to the revised responsibilities?" he asked.

Margarethe searched through the accompanying records.

There was a transfer acknowledgment, but no separate document specifying the new terms.

The secretary frowned.

"That should have been included."

It was the first time Ilya had seen her openly dissatisfied with the society’s records.

She asked him to mark the entry for further review.

He complied.

However, the discovery encouraged them to examine several other transfers.

Most were properly documented.

A few contained similar omissions.

The pattern didn’t establish deliberate misconduct, but it demonstrated that the society’s procedures were less consistent than its leadership might have believed.

After another hour, Margarethe concluded the review.

She thanked them for their assistance and promised to raise the recommendations during the next committee meeting.

Tristan suggested that affected members should also receive copies of the proposed changes before any decisions were finalized.

Margarethe agreed.

As they prepared to leave, Garen asked whether he could obtain a copy of his own obligation records.

The secretary provided them without difficulty.

Fortunately, his agreements were straightforward.

He owed six hours of workshop assistance, with access to the fabrication bench provided in exchange.

Nothing more.

Garen appeared relieved.

Ilya found that somewhat amusing.

The fellow had entered the society dreaming of expensive equipment and influential connections. Now he was celebrating the discovery that nobody had secretly assigned him additional work.

A remarkable development.

Their conversation continued outside the Old Astronomical Hall.

Tristan believed the society’s procedures required improvement, although he remained reluctant to interpret the discrepancies as evidence of intentional wrongdoing.

Ilya agreed.

Margarethe had cooperated throughout their review, and nothing suggested that she intended to conceal the missing documentation.

However, several agreements had clearly placed students in positions where their obligations could be expanded through ambiguous terms.

That deserved correction.

Garen offered a simpler interpretation.

"Maybe some of the senior members are taking advantage of people who don’t understand the agreements."

"Possible," Ilya admitted.

"Then we should find out who keeps approving them."

Tristan considered the suggestion.

The society’s committees were responsible for reviewing obligations, and their officers possessed the authority to approve transfers.

Identifying which officers had handled the questionable agreements would be straightforward.

The more difficult question was whether the irregularities resulted from negligence or deliberate manipulation.

Ilya intended to find out.

He had no particular interest in destroying an organization that had provided genuine opportunities to talented students.

However, its usefulness didn’t excuse allowing members to exploit one another.

For now, the most sensible approach was to continue gathering information and determine whether the existing safeguards actually worked.

That evening, Margarethe submitted their recommendations to the society’s president.

He examined the marked agreements with considerable interest.

Several involved members whose academic contributions had been essential to the organization’s recent activities.

The proposed restrictions would make certain arrangements more difficult to maintain.

Margarethe understood that.

Nevertheless, she believed the changes were necessary.

The president eventually closed the ledger.

"An excellent review," he remarked. "Belozersky seems to have taken his responsibilities seriously."

"He has. Bellacourt and Vollbrecht also contributed useful observations."

"Three capable young men."

The president smiled.

Then he asked Margarethe to postpone presenting the recommendations to the full membership until the executive committee had examined their implications.

The request was procedurally reasonable.

She agreed.

However, after she departed, the president returned to the marked entries.

Several of the agreements had been approved under his administration.

And if the proposed restrictions were adopted, the society would lose access to a particularly convenient source of assistance.