The Thirteenth Society’s executive committee had been discussing Ilya’s recommendations for four days.
For an organization that prided itself on efficiency, that was a rather impressive amount of time to spend deciding whether students should be allowed to accumulate unlimited obligations.
Ilya wasn’t particularly concerned. Administrative discussions often took longer than expected, especially when proposed changes affected several committees.
However, Garen had grown impatient.
"Four days! They could’ve rebuilt the entire engineering workshop by now!"
"With you supervising?" Tristan asked.
"Obviously."
"Then perhaps four days isn’t enough."
Ilya allowed the argument to continue while reviewing the society’s latest correspondence.
Margarethe had informed him that the executive committee was examining the recommendations and would provide a response once its review concluded. She hadn’t offered a specific date, although she assured him that the matter hadn’t been forgotten.
That was reasonable.
Unfortunately, something else had happened during those four days.
The engineering committee had suspended Garen’s access to its fabrication equipment.
According to the notice, several workshop privileges were being reorganized while the society reviewed its internal arrangements.
The suspension applied to multiple members, and Garen hadn’t been singled out.
Nevertheless, the timing was inconvenient.
He had already arranged to use the fabrication bench for an upcoming assignment, and the interruption forced him to reconsider his schedule.
"Can they just do that?" he complained.
"According to the charter, yes," Tristan answered. "Access remains subject to committee approval."
"Wonderful. I spent six hours helping them repair equipment, and now I can’t use the equipment."
Ilya examined Garen’s agreement.
The document promised access to the fabrication bench in exchange for six hours of assistance. However, it also specified that equipment use remained subject to ordinary workshop regulations.
The committee could temporarily suspend access for legitimate administrative reasons.
That made its decision technically permissible.
Unfortunately, the agreement contained no provision concerning compensation when access became unavailable.
Garen had fulfilled his obligation.
The promised benefit had been delayed indefinitely.
Ilya considered the situation before offering a suggestion.
"Ask them to provide an alternative date. If they can’t, request a refund of your contribution in equivalent workshop hours."
Garen found the proposal reasonable.
Tristan agreed that it would establish whether the committee intended to honor its original agreement.
They drafted a brief request and submitted it through the appropriate channels.
The response arrived that afternoon.
The committee acknowledged Garen’s concern but declined to provide an alternative date until the administrative review concluded.
It also refused to compensate him, explaining that his access privileges remained valid and would resume once the suspension ended.
That answer was less satisfactory.
Still, Ilya didn’t recommend escalating immediately.
The committee might genuinely require time to reorganize its equipment policies. Demanding disciplinary action over a temporary suspension would be excessive.
Instead, he suggested documenting the exchange and requesting a definite review date.
Garen agreed.
However, the incident had changed his opinion of the society’s generosity.
Apparently, free access to expensive equipment became considerably less impressive when the equipment wasn’t actually available.
Their next discovery came from Tristan.
The southern nobleman had recently requested access to several historical documents through his sponsor. The materials concerned an Imperial military campaign, and he’d intended to use them for an academic presentation.
His request had initially been approved.
Then the historical committee informed him that the documents were temporarily unavailable.
Tristan would ordinarily have accepted the explanation.
Unfortunately, another student had borrowed the same materials the previous evening.
That student’s sponsor belonged to the executive committee.
"Interesting coincidence," Ilya remarked.
Tristan wasn’t amused.
The society’s rules permitted senior members to receive priority access under certain circumstances. However, the documents had already been reserved for Tristan’s use, and nobody had informed him that his reservation could be overridden.
He had consequently submitted a formal inquiry.
The historical committee replied that the arrangement was an administrative oversight.
Tristan accepted the explanation but requested clarification concerning the priority system.
That request remained unanswered.
Garen found the situation suspicious.
Ilya agreed that the timing deserved attention, although neither incident established deliberate retaliation.
The committees possessed legitimate authority to manage their resources.
However, both had recently exercised that authority in ways that disadvantaged members involved in reviewing the society’s internal procedures.
That was worth remembering.
The more important question was whether similar incidents had occurred before.
Fortunately, Garen knew someone who might provide an answer.
During his earlier workshop activities, he’d become acquainted with several engineering students who had belonged to the society for multiple terms.
One had previously complained about losing access to specialized equipment after disagreeing with a committee officer.
At the time, Garen had dismissed it as an ordinary administrative dispute.
Now he wanted to know more.
Ilya encouraged him to ask, provided he didn’t pressure anyone into discussing matters they preferred to keep private.
Garen agreed.
He returned the following afternoon with an account that was considerably more interesting than expected.
The engineering student had received equipment sponsorship during his first year of membership. In return, he’d agreed to assist with several society projects.
Initially, the arrangement had worked well.
However, after declining an additional assignment, he discovered that his access privileges had been reduced.
The committee explained that its resources were limited and that active contributors received priority.
The decision was permitted under the society’s rules.
Nevertheless, the student believed the reduction had been intended to punish him for refusing additional work.
He hadn’t filed a formal complaint.
Doing so would have required appealing to the same leadership responsible for approving the committee’s decisions.
Garen found that particularly troubling.
"He didn’t even think complaining was worth it."
Tristan considered the account.
"That doesn’t prove the committee acted improperly."
"I know. But if it happens every time someone refuses a favor, that’s different."
Ilya agreed.
The distinction mattered.
An organization could legitimately reward members who contributed more frequently. However, reducing previously promised benefits to pressure someone into accepting additional obligations would undermine the entire arrangement.
They needed evidence showing whether the decisions followed consistent rules.
Ilya proposed comparing several cases.
Garen could examine workshop access records available to ordinary members, while Tristan reviewed the historical committee’s published regulations and reservation procedures.
Ilya would continue examining the society’s obligation records.
They agreed to avoid requesting confidential information or making accusations before understanding the circumstances.
Their investigation remained informal.
Nevertheless, it was the first time the three had deliberately coordinated their activities to examine the society itself.
Over the next two days, they discovered several inconsistencies.
The engineering committee frequently granted priority access to members assisting with its current projects. That was understandable.
However, the definition of an active contributor varied between supervisors.
Some counted previously completed obligations, while others considered only current assignments.
The historical committee maintained similarly flexible procedures concerning reservations.
Senior officers could override ordinary requests, but the criteria for doing so weren’t clearly documented.
Neither arrangement was automatically improper.
However, both gave committee officers considerable discretion.
And discretion could become a convenient tool when personal disagreements entered the picture.
Ilya organized their findings into a short report.
He intended to submit it to Margarethe once they had verified the relevant details.
Unfortunately, someone else had apparently noticed their activities.
On Friday afternoon, the three received invitations to attend a private discussion at the Old Astronomical Hall.
The letters came from the society’s executive committee.
Unlike previous invitations, they contained no ceremonial language or elaborate explanations.
The committee wished to discuss several concerns regarding the interpretation of membership privileges.
Attendance was requested before the next general gathering.
Garen examined his letter.
"Are we in trouble?"
"Possibly," Tristan replied.
"For what?"
"Apparently, asking questions."
Ilya smiled.
That was an interesting development.
They had followed the society’s procedures, submitted their requests through ordinary channels, and avoided publicly accusing anyone of wrongdoing.
If the executive committee wanted to discuss their concerns, that was perfectly reasonable.
However, summoning all three simultaneously suggested the leadership had recognized their activities as connected.
Ilya considered whether they should attend separately.
Tristan disagreed.
The committee had invited them together, and refusing would accomplish little beyond creating unnecessary suspicion.
Garen supported attending as well.
He wanted an explanation for his suspended workshop access.
That settled the matter.
They arrived at the Old Astronomical Hall shortly before the appointed hour.
Margarethe welcomed them at the entrance, although her expression was more reserved than usual.
She explained that the executive committee intended to clarify several misunderstandings concerning their recent inquiries.
The discussion would be informal.
Ilya appreciated the reassurance.
Nevertheless, he noticed that the meeting room contained several senior members he hadn’t previously encountered.
The society’s president occupied the central seat.
He greeted the three warmly.
"Belozersky, Bellacourt, Vollbrecht. Thank you for coming."
The others remained seated as they entered.
Ilya recognized several committee insignias among them.
Apparently, the society had decided their concerns deserved considerable attention.
The president gestured toward the available chairs.
"I understand you’ve been asking questions about our internal arrangements."
"We have," Ilya replied.
"Good. Curiosity is one of the qualities we value most."
The president smiled pleasantly before continuing.
"However, I believe there’s something you should understand about how our society operates."
He explained that the Thirteenth Society’s privileges existed because generations of members had invested time, resources, and personal influence into maintaining its network.
Those benefits couldn’t be distributed without regard for contribution.
Members who actively supported the organization naturally received greater consideration than those who participated only when convenient.
Tristan acknowledged the principle.
However, he pointed out that previously agreed benefits should remain enforceable regardless of later disagreements.
The president accepted the distinction.
Then he raised a more difficult question.
"What happens when a member uses our resources to challenge the judgment of the people responsible for maintaining them?"
Garen looked offended.
"Are you saying we shouldn’t question committee decisions?"
"Certainly not. But privileges come with responsibilities."
Ilya understood the direction of the conversation.
The president was framing their inquiries as a potential conflict between individual entitlement and collective obligation.
It was an effective argument.
Unfortunately, it didn’t address the actual concern.
"We’re not asking for special treatment," Ilya explained. "We’re asking whether the rules are applied consistently."
Several committee members exchanged glances.
The president remained composed.
"And if you discover that they aren’t?"
"Then I’d recommend correcting them."
A brief silence followed.
The president considered his answer before smiling again.
"An admirable position."
He then informed them that the executive committee would conduct a formal review of their recent activities and the agreements associated with their memberships.
Until that review concluded, certain discretionary privileges would remain suspended.
The decision was permitted under the charter.
Ilya recognized that immediately.
The society had chosen to exercise its authority without openly violating its own regulations.
That was rather clever.
However, as he examined the expressions of the committee members, he began to suspect that their little investigation had become far more interesting than any of them originally intended.