The stretch between the tunnel’s exit and Hollowmere itself passed in under an hour, Ostrand setting a hard, driving pace that left no room for the exhausted group’s accumulated fatigue to slow them.
They smelled it before they saw it — something acrid and wrong, carried on air that should have smelled of nothing more than damp stone and distant water.
"That’s not right," Haldric said, low and grim.
The passage opened into Hollowmere’s basin all at once, and Arlen’s steps faltered, the whole group slowing involuntarily at the sight that greeted them.
The lake was wrong. Where Arlen had expected clear, standing water, something dark and faintly, sickly luminescent spread across its surface instead, an indescribable color that seemed to shift when he tried to look at it directly, as though his own eyes refused to properly register it.
"Spread out," Ostrand said, his voice carrying none of its earlier calm now, something harder and colder replacing it. "Carefully. Call out anything you find."
They moved into the settlement’s ruins in a loose, careful formation, and the devastation revealed itself in pieces, each worse than the last.
Buildings stood half-collapsed, scorched and torn in ways that spoke of genuine, sustained battle rather than simple catastrophe — defensive barricades still standing in places, arrow shafts embedded deep in doorframes, the unmistakable marks of a fight that had been fought properly, desperately, by people who hadn’t simply fled.
"They held here," Essa said quietly, crouching beside a collapsed barricade reinforced with whatever furniture and stone the defenders had managed to gather. "This wasn’t a rout. Someone organized a real line."
Arlen crouched beside her, and found, scattered across the ground in every direction, the first of the dead — not human, not any race he recognized at all. Chitinous, elongated things, their proportions subtly, disturbingly wrong, limbs bent at angles that belonged to nothing natural he’d ever catalogued. Dozens of them, scattered in the particular, telling patterns of creatures cut down mid-advance rather than simply fallen.
"These are the attackers," Ostrand said, studying one of the fallen creatures with grim, professional focus. "Whatever they are. Nobody’s logged this species before, as far as I know."
"There’s so many of them," Toren said, voice tight, turning in a slow circle to take in the scale of it. "Dozens here alone. More further in, probably."
They pressed deeper into the ruins, and the pattern held — more fallen creatures, more evidence of a defense that had clearly been fought with everything the settlement possessed. A collapsed section of wall showed scorch marks from what had to have been a mage’s desperate, repeated casting. A cluster of broken spears lay where they’d fallen, snapped clean in the kind of close, brutal fighting that left nothing standing afterward.
"Where are the people?" Mira asked, her voice carrying a thin, fraying edge. "Three hundred lived here. There should be—"
She didn’t finish the sentence. Nobody needed her to.
They searched for hours, methodical despite the horror, and found nothing. No bodies beyond the attackers’ own fallen. No survivors hiding in collapsed cellars or sealed rooms. No wounded crying out from beneath rubble.
Just the enemy dead, scattered everywhere, and a settlement that had fought with everything it had and still, somehow, simply ceased to exist.
"This doesn’t make sense," the earth mage — Hesper, Arlen had finally learned her name somewhere in the tunnel’s long, grim passage — said, kneeling beside another cluster of the chitinous dead, her voice unsteady. "Where did everyone go? You don’t just fight this hard and then vanish entirely."
"I don’t know," Ostrand admitted, and something in his flat, controlled tone told Arlen plainly that the Grandmaster found that admission as unsettling as anyone else present. "I’ve seen battles. I’ve seen massacres. I’ve never seen anything leave this little behind."
Arlen moved through the ruins alone for a stretch, unable to simply stand still, and found himself pausing at the remains of what had clearly once been a modest guild outpost — its door torn entirely from its hinges, a defensive line of fallen attackers thick enough near the threshold that whoever had held that doorway had clearly done so for a considerable, costly while before finally being overwhelmed.
He crouched there a long moment, studying the scene, and felt something heavy and sick settle into his chest that had nothing to do with physical danger.
They fought. Properly, desperately, to the very end. And it still wasn’t enough.
He thought of the children he’d seen in Shaleford two mornings earlier, chasing each other between the buildings with the same easy, careless joy any child anywhere might show. He thought of the cartographer’s fond description — proper town, three hundred people, good folks make it work — and found the memory considerably harder to carry now than it had been when she’d first offered it.
Ketterin, the paladin, moved past him with slow, deliberate care, murmuring something low and reverent over each cluster of wreckage she passed — not for the attackers, he understood, but for whatever faint, unrecoverable trace remained of the people who’d once lived here.
"There’s nothing left to bury," she said, when she finally reached him, her voice carrying genuine, controlled grief rather than detachment. "Nothing at all. Just this."
Arlen didn’t have an answer for that. Nobody did.
They gathered back near the ruined settlement’s center as the search finally, exhaustively concluded, the whole group bearing the particular, hollowed-out weight of people who’d found exactly what they feared and nothing they could actually do about it.
"No survivors," Ostrand said finally, his voice flat and final, carrying across the gathered group with none of its earlier commanding strength. "None. Not one."
Nobody spoke for a long moment, the settlement’s wrong, luminescent lake lapping softly against its ruined shore, the only sound in the whole devastated basin.
"What do we do now?" Urzhak asked eventually, the orc’s usual loud confidence entirely absent.
Ostrand didn’t answer immediately. He stood there a long while, surveying the wreckage with the same grim, careful attention he’d brought to everything since the shortcut’s entrance, and Arlen understood, watching him, that even a Grandmaster’s steady, unshakable composure had limits this devastation pressed hard against.
"We report this," Ostrand finally said. "Properly, thoroughly, to people who can actually decide what happens next. This is considerably beyond anything I’m equipped to handle alone."
He turned to face the gathered group, something resolute settling back into his expression despite everything they’d just witnessed.
"We’ve seen what we came to see. Now we go back, and we make sure the right people understand exactly what that was."