The tunnel swallowed them the same way it had the first time, the settlement’s grief-heavy quiet giving way to the shortcut’s older, deeper silence, and Ostrand set the same rotating watch he’d insisted on before.
"Same discipline as the way in," he said, his voice carrying none of its earlier calm now — not fear, exactly, just a weight that hadn’t been there before Hollowmere. "Stay close. Call out anything."
Nobody argued. Nobody had the energy to.
The mood had inverted entirely. Where the trip in had carried tense, focused anticipation, the trip back carried something heavier, slower, grief pressing hard against bodies already worn thin from two days of hard travel and a horror none of them had properly processed yet.
Hesper broke first, at their first rest stop, the earth mage’s composure finally giving way all at once. She didn’t sob loudly. She simply sat down hard against the tunnel wall and put her face in her hands, shoulders shaking in silence.
"Sorry," she managed, after a long moment, wiping at her eyes with the back of one sleeve. "I don’t — I keep seeing it. Every time I close my eyes."
"Don’t apologize," Ketterin said, settling beside her without hesitation. "Nobody here is judging you for that."
"I keep thinking about the children," Hesper said, voice cracking. "Shaleford had children. Hollowmere probably did too."
Nobody had an answer for that. Arlen found himself thinking of the same thing, the memory of Shaleford’s own children chasing each other between the buildings surfacing uninvited, and pushed it away before it could properly take hold.
Urzhak sat apart from the group during the rest, his heavy axe resting across his knees, saying nothing at all. It struck Arlen as strange, the orc’s usual loud, easy humor entirely absent — not sullen, just quiet in a way that felt wrong on him, like a held breath that hadn’t found its release yet.
Ketterin prayed during the pause as well, murmuring something low and steady in a language Arlen didn’t recognize, her eyes closed, hands folded, unbothered by the others resting around her. Nobody commented on it. Nobody needed to.
Miravel and Pip kept their usual watchful silence, the catkin’s eyes tracking every shadow with the same quiet precision she’d shown the entire trip, Pip’s constant chatter from the journey in entirely gone now, replaced by careful, deliberate quiet.
They pressed on once Hesper had steadied herself, the group’s pace slower now, exhaustion and grief both working against them in equal measure.
Arlen walked near the back, close enough to Essa that neither of them needed to speak, and found his own thoughts circling back, again and again, to the same fragmented images — the wrong-colored lake, the chitinous dead scattered everywhere, the guild outpost’s torn door and the thick cluster of fallen attackers before it.
They fought. Properly, to the very end. And it still wasn’t enough.
He didn’t try to push the thought away this time. He let it sit, turning it over the same careful, honest way he turned over everything worth understanding, even when understanding offered no comfort at all.
I don’t know what did this. Nobody does. That’s the part that sits worst — not the horror itself, but not knowing what to actually be afraid of.
The tunnel’s oppressive quiet pressed in around them as they walked, and somewhere in the second hour, Arlen caught it again — the same low, long shape he’d glimpsed on the way in, pressed flat against the stone at the very edge of his vision.
He went still, the old instinct sharpening despite his exhaustion, and this time he didn’t turn to look directly at it. He simply tracked it from the corner of his eye, patient, and watched it remain utterly motionless, waiting.
"There," he said, quiet, nodding slightly rather than pointing.
Ostrand’s gaze followed without any sudden movement, the same calm, practiced control he’d shown the whole trip. "I see it."
Nothing happened. The group simply kept moving, steady and unhurried despite the shape’s continued, watching presence, and after a long, tense stretch, Arlen glanced back properly and found nothing there at all.
"Gone," he said.
"It’ll come back," Ostrand said, unbothered. "It always does. Doesn’t matter, so long as it keeps choosing not to engage."
Nobody found that especially comforting, but nobody argued with it either.
They made their second camp in the tunnel’s narrowest, most defensible stretch, the same careful precautions as before, Ostrand taking first watch without being asked.
Arlen lay awake a long while that night despite his exhaustion, listening to the tunnel’s watching silence, his thoughts refusing to settle into anything as simple as sleep.
He thought about Yveth, about the Foxglove’s warm kitchen, about how strange it would feel to walk back through that familiar door carrying something this heavy. He thought about Eldrin’s old letters, about the quiet, patient mystery that had followed him since Millbrook, and wondered, distantly, whether any of it connected to what he’d just witnessed.
No way to know yet. Maybe no way to ever know.
He slept eventually, shallow and fitful, and woke to find the group already stirring, considerably more subdued than the morning before, the shared weight of Hollowmere’s memory settling fully into everyone now that the initial shock had worn thin enough to let genuine grief properly through.
The final stretch of the tunnel passed in near-total silence, nobody finding much worth saying, the whole group simply putting one foot in front of the other with the particular, hollowed-out determination of people who had nothing left to do but keep moving.
The passage finally opened, late in the day, into the same narrow exit they’d entered through two days earlier, Shaleford’s distant lantern-light visible once more through the gap ahead.
Nobody celebrated the sight this time. Ostrand simply nodded once, confirming it, and the group filed through the opening in the same heavy, exhausted silence they’d carried the whole way back.
Arlen stepped out into Shaleford’s familiar square, physically spent and emotionally wrung thin in a way he hadn’t fully felt until the tunnel’s oppressive weight finally lifted, and found himself simply standing there a moment, breathing the settlement’s ordinary air, before any of them had the strength left to say what needed saying next.