South Block
16 October 1950
The new ministers came in at ten, each by a different door. The Cabinet Room had been cleared of maps and filled with chairs, and a plain wooden table in the centre held a tray of tea and a heap of folders. Radhakrishnan stood by the window with his hands behind him. Patel sat in his high-backed chair, Nehru at the end of the table with a pencil, and Shroff, by the door, with the air of a man who has found a cheque on his desk and is looking for the pen.
Ram rose.
"Gentlemen, Kamaladevi-ji. I shall be brief. You have been named by Dr. Radhakrishnan to carry three ministries that did not exist last month. I am grateful to each of you for accepting. I know that two of you did so against your better judgment, and I do not blame you."
Guru Dutt Sodhi, the tall former athlete, was seated near the window with a folder on his knee. N.V. Gadgil, stout and watchful, sat at the table with a notebook. Kamaladevi Chattopadhyay, a handsome woman of forty-seven in a plain handloom sari, with silver in her hair and a direct, unhurried gaze, had taken the chair nearest the Prime Minister and was looking at him with frank curiosity.
"Let me begin with Professor Sodhi, since he has already got his mandate."
"Prime Minister," Sodhi said, rising.
"Sit. You have your mandate: the National Games, the Asian Games, the Olympics. That you have done, and done well. I wish to add some things to your plate."
Sodhi took out a pencil.
"First, leagues. Our footballers play for a medal once in four years and for nothing in between. A man cannot become good at a sport he plays once in a while. I want semi-professional leagues in football, hockey, and kabaddi, organised by region, with a national championship at the end of each season. Clubs funded by municipalities, factories, and the Railways, with a small wage for the players. Not a fortune. Enough to live on. Raman at Nice is a pioneer. I do not want him to be the only one."
"The wages?"
"The sponsoring body pays. Shroff-ji will not look pleased, but the Railways and the Ordnance Factory Board already spend more on tea. If you can attract the industrial houses to field teams, the players can be employed by them, with the sole expectation of playing sports, a loophole that will not bar our players from competing for glory in the Olympics"
Shroff, by the door, did not look pleased, but he nodded.
"Second, athletics. Track and field meets at the provincial level, every year, for every age group from twelve upwards. Rebello did not come from nowhere. He came from a school in Bangalore with a sand pit and a master who noticed. There are ten thousand Rebellos in India who have never been seen. I want them found.
"Third, in the same vein, a talent identification programme. Scouts in every district, trained by the Sports Authority, looking for children with the build and speed for particular disciplines. A boy who can run three miles at the age of fourteen should be told so, and offered a place at a state academy with a coach. Swimming, wrestling, boxing, archery, weightlifting, shooting, cycling, the whole Olympic programme. Our eighteen medals in sixty years should not be the measure of what we can do."
"Four?" Sodhi said, smiling.
"Infrastructure. Not just in Delhi. Every province. A stadium in each capital, a swimming pool in each large city, a running track in every district headquarters, a gymnasium in every school. The Seva Vahini already has halls. Use them. The Public Works Department has crawler tractors. Use them. And I should like the first stadium built outside Delhi to be at Rangoon."
"For the 1951 Games," Sodhi said. "I have the plan."
"Then it is settled."
Sodhi sat down with the expression of a man who has been given more than he asked for and is determined to deserve it.
"Kamaladevi-ji."
She inclined her head.
"You have the Ministry of Arts. I have thought for some time about what it should do, and I have a vague idea that I would like to offer you, for what it is worth. I do not wish to tell you how to run your ministry. I wish you to tell me where I am wrong."
"That would be a pleasant change, Prime Minister."
"I am told it is frequently necessary." Ram smiled slightly. "The first concerns the princely states. In 1947, we promised the princes a fixed annual payment in return for the surrender of their states. We promised it because it was the cheapest way to avoid fifty civil wars. There is a growing murmur in the House that the payments should be ended. That a Republic ought not to pay a pension to a Maharaja. I understand the feeling. I do not share it. We gave our word, and I will not break it. A government that revises its promises when they become inconvenient has no right to the word."
"I agree," Patel said gruffly.
"But I think we can do something gentler." Ram turned to Kamaladevi. "A prince with an income and no kingdom has two choices. He can spend it on himself, which is very expensive, and which the newspapers will not forgive. Or he can do what his ancestors did, which is to be a patron. A palace is a museum. A court is a school.
"A great house, in the old days, supported the musician, the weaver, the miniature painter, the poet who wrote in the dialect of the region. When the kingdoms fell, the patrons fell with them. The princes should be given a reason to spend the money well." He leaned forward. "I should like your ministry to approach them. Not as a command. As an invitation.
"Every princely house has a palace, an armoury, a library, a collection of paintings and jewels, a court that once supported musicians, dancers, poets, craftsmen. Those courts are gone. The craftsmen have scattered. The dancers dance in cinema halls. The languages in which the court poets wrote, Maithili, Rajasthani, Bundeli, Braj, Tulu, are being pushed out by Sanskrit in the schools, and I do not regret it, but I do not want them lost.
"Let the princes become patrons. A maharaja who spends a lakh a year of his purse on a museum, a school of miniature painting, a troupe of folk dancers, an annual festival of verse in his region’s tongue, will have made himself something to be remembered. He will have left a legacy. And the nation will have a living record of what it was."
"They may not wish to," Kamaladevi said.
"Some will not. Some will be glad. Many are wounded by the loss of their position and would be glad of a new role that does not involve a throne." Ram looked at her. "You have dealt with them. You know which are men of taste. I should like you to talk to them."
"I shall," she said. She had taken out a small notebook and was writing quickly. "It is a good idea. I will go to Jaipur first. The Maharaja has a gift for it. And Mysore. And the Gaekwad of Baroda, who has been collecting since before the war."
"Do not tell them it was my idea."
"I shall tell them it was mine, Prime Minister, and if they find out, I shall say they were mistaken." Her eyes were dry and amused. "And the second?"
"The second is less respectable. India makes the finest textiles and jewellery in the world. We always have. The Americans and Europeans buy them in small quantities, as curiosities, from dealers in Calcutta and Bombay who take a very large commission. They do not know what they are buying. They cannot tell a Banarasi brocade from a bad copy. And they have, if I am any judge, a hunger for something royal."
"The cinema has taught it to them," Kamaladevi said.
"The cinema has taught them what a palace looks like. It has not taught them what a prince’s wardrobe was like. I have been told that in New York and Paris, the great houses of fashion are in difficulty, that the war has emptied the workshops, that they are looking for novelty. I think we have something to sell.
"Brocades, silks, shawls from Kashmir, jamawar, bandhani, zardozi, kalamkari, and the jewellery, the kundan, the polki, the meenakari. And I think the most effective salesmen would be the people who actually wore them. Princes and princesses, in their own garments, in their own jewels, on a catwalk in Paris or in a ballroom in New York. Show it as a spectacle. A hundred pieces from the wardrobe of a maharani of Jaipur, worn by her own descendants. It would be the talk of the season."
Kamaladevi laid down her pencil. A slow smile spread across her face.
"You want to put the princes on the catwalk."
"I want to put the clothes there, and the princes to wear them. They need a purpose. They need an income. The old ones may blush. The young ones will not." Ram’s tone was light. "And a gown worn by a real maharani will fetch ten times the price of one worn by a model. The money would come to the craftsmen first, and I should insist on it. A weaver in Benares has not been paid fairly since the Mughals."
"I shall need to know the market."
"Which is why I propose to send someone with Dr. Mookerjee to Europe. He will be buying other things, but there is room for one of your people. A young person with an eye. To see the fashion houses, the jewellers, the department stores. To learn what is bought, and by whom, and at what price."
"I know exactly who," she said at once. "A girl of twenty-six named Pupul Jayakar. She runs a small handloom exhibition in Bombay. She has been to Paris. She has a gift for seeing what will sell."
"Then Pupul Jayakar it is."
Gadgil, at the table, cleared his throat. He was a heavy, slow-spoken man with the air of a retired schoolmaster, and he had not yet said a word.
"Gadgil-ji. The Ministry of Urban Development."
"Prime Minister." Gadgil laid his notebook flat. "I have had the architectural commission’s plans for three months. I find them excellent as far as they go. They go too slowly."
"Say what you mean."
"They are for individual buildings. A school, a railway station, a post office. We have a design for each. But a country is not a collection of buildings. It is a pattern of streets, drains, lights, water mains, markets, and gardens, and no one has ever planned them. The British laid out Delhi and a few cantonments. The rest of India grew like a weed. We have cities of three million with no sewer, towns of fifty thousand with no water except from a well that is fed by their own latrines."
"Then what do you propose?"
"A programme for every town of more than twenty thousand people. A standard plan. Municipal water, from a protected source, piped to every street. A sewer, underground, laid before the street is paved. I should like it in the ground within ten years in every city of any size." Gadgil looked up. "I know it is costly."
"It will be less costly than a cholera epidemic," Ram said. "Go on."
"A mixed-use zoning code. Shops on the ground floor, houses above, workshops behind. The British separated everything: the cantonment, the civil lines, the bazaar. It made them easy to police. It makes our cities hell to live in. A man who works in a shop should live within a mile of it, and a woman who sells vegetables should have her house above her stall."
"That is how our old towns were laid out," Kamaladevi said.
"It is, Kamaladevi-ji. It is how every great city was laid out before the engineers got hold of it. I wish only to bring it back." He turned a page. "And parks. A green space in every ward. A hundred feet by a hundred, with trees, benches, watering spots, the works. It costs almost nothing and does more for a city’s health than a hospital."
"Utilities," Ram said.
"Prime Minister?"
"You have not mentioned them. May I?"
"Please."
"I should like the plan to include a utility corridor." Ram rose and went to the blackboard. He drew a line, a street, and under it, a long rectangle. "In every new street, and in the main streets of old towns, a tunnel beneath the carriageway. Concrete, three metres high, wide enough for a man to walk. In it, the water main, the sewer, the electricity cable, the telephone line, the gas pipe when we have gas. All in one place, accessible by manhole. When a pipe breaks, a man goes down and mends it. The street is not dug up. The traffic does not stop. In the old way, every department digs its own trench, and no one knows where anyone else’s pipe is. In a monsoon, the water main and the sewer share a puddle."
Gadgil had stopped writing and was staring at the board.
"I have seen it only in a drawing," Ram said, "in a book about London. They have built a few such tunnels, and Paris has the égouts, which are a kind of utility corridor, though not planned as one. I do not know of any city that has done it systematically. I think we should."
"The cost would be great."
"The cost of digging up a street thirty times in fifty years is greater. I do not ask that it be done everywhere at once. Begin with the new towns: the colonies at Hirakud, Bhilai, and the enclave at Bangalore. Build the corridors from the start. Learn on those. Then do it in the old cities, a street at a time, when a street has to be rebuilt anyway."
"It will take machines, or huge amounts of manpower," Gadgil said slowly. "For the old towns."
"Which brings us to Shroff-ji." Ram turned. "I can see you pursing your lips."
"I am not pursing them, Prime Minister. They have set in that shape."
"I know what is in your mind. I have just handed out two ministries’ worth of expense. The leagues, the stadiums, the princes, the water mains, the sewers, the utility tunnels. I know the figure, and I know that you are about to say that we are borrowing against a future we cannot see." Ram came back to the table. "I will tell you what I think.
"We are at the beginning. The first ten years of a country’s life are the cheapest to invest in and the most expensive to neglect. A sewer laid today costs one rupee. A sewer laid in thirty years, through a built-up city, costs twenty. A stadium built when the land is empty costs a tenth of one built after a slum has arrived. If we want to grow, we must spend. And I am prepared to absorb debt, to run a deficit for a decade, if it buys us cities in which people can live and a population that is healthy enough to work."
"The Reserve Bank will not like it," Shroff said, with melancholy.
"The Reserve Bank liked the Urja Bond, which it said was impossible. It will adjust."
"I do not doubt that, Prime Minister. I merely wish it recorded that I was horrified."
"It is recorded. I should be disappointed if you were not." Ram’s eyes were gentle. "I need one more thing from you."
"I knew you would."
"Tunnel boring machines. As many as you can find. The bigger, the better."
Shroff looked at him for a long moment. "May I ask what for?"
"For everything. Utility tunnels, as we have said. Subways, in the great cities, in thirty years. Road and rail tunnels through the Himalayas, where the passes close for seven months. Hydroelectric tunnels for the Damodar and Koyna. Irrigation tunnels, to carry water through the Western Ghats into the Deccan. The machine does a man’s work in a day, and does it without a single death from a rock fall. Every serious engineering nation will have them within twenty years. I wish to have them before them."
"Who makes them?"
"The Americans. The Robbins Company in Ohio has built a few for dam tunnels, and the Germans had some before the war, the English, for the London subway. I do not know the details. Shroff-ji, I leave you to find the manufacturers. Check the companies we hold shares in first; I should like four, to begin with."
"Four?" Shroff said, aghast.
"Two to use, two to take apart." Ram almost smiled. "I have already drafted a proposal for three government corporations to build such things at home. Bharat Earth Movers Limited, for the bulldozers, graders, and excavators. Bharat Heavy Electricals Limited, for turbines, boilers, and transformers. Bharat Heavy Engineering Limited, for pressure vessels, presses, and the large castings. Between them, they would make everything a modern country needs to dig, lift, and power. I have also sent a note to the Bangalore enclave, asking whether the Germans and the Japanese would care to design a tunnelling machine of their own. I imagine they will find it a most agreeable puzzle."
"I shall be reduced to a footnote in the Bangalore accounts," Shroff said.
"You shall be reduced to a monument, if the thing works."
"I do not want a monument. I want a surplus."
"You shall have both, in the fullness of time."
Patel, who had been listening with his chin on his hand, laughed softly. "He means it, Ardeshir. I have known him for fifteen years. When he says in the fullness of time, he has a calendar."
Shroff sighed. He took off his spectacles, wiped them, and put them on again. "Four machines. I shall find the money. I shall find it in the budget for something I should rather have bought."
"Thank you."
"And I wish to say, as Finance Minister, that if this Cabinet continues to spend at the present rate, I will resign."
"You said that in April."
"I did, and it was true."
"You said it in August."
"That also was true. It is why I say it with such conviction."
Ram laughed, openly this time. Then he became serious.
"Dr. Mookerjee."
Syama Prasad Mookerjee, who had slipped in during the discussion and was sitting by the door with his hands folded on his stick, looked up.
"I need you to go to Europe."
"With pleasure, Prime Minister. For what?"
"The first is the hydraulic forging presses. The ten-thousand-ton Mannesmann from Düsseldorf, which Dr. Ghatage needs for the jet turbine discs, and the twenty-thousand-ton Loewy from the United States, which I propose to order through the Americans on the way home. You will see the Germans, inspect the machines, and sign the contracts. Shroff-ji will give you the authority.
"The second is the tunnel-boring machines. You will visit the manufacturers, in Germany and in the United States, in England if you have time, and choose the four that seem most promising. I do not wish to buy the wrong ones.
"The third is potash. The Green Revolution will need it. Wheat and rice take nitrogen and phosphorus, and nothing grows long without potassium. India has almost none. The great deposits are in Germany, at Stassfurt, and in Russia, in the Urals, at Solikamsk. I should prefer the Russian. We have a barter arrangement already: jute, cotton, leather. We pay in goods and save our dollars. Mr. Molotov told Sardar Patel that the Soviets would be glad to sell. You will see their trade delegation in Moscow."
"And scrap, buy up every piece of scrap you can in Europe, America and East Asia, have it brought to our ship-breaking yards in Gujarat and Burma, along with every single gram of spent catalysts from their refineries, and be as stingy with the dollars as you can."
"I shall need a mandate."
"The potash, up to two hundred thousand tons a year, for five years, at a price to be fixed by barter. If they ask for dollars, refuse. If the Germans offer a better bargain, take it, but tell the Russians first, so that they do not think we are playing them off, the scraps, as much as you can, from everyone."
"That is exactly what we are doing."
"It is, Dr. Mookerjee. Let us not insult them by saying it aloud."
Mookerjee smiled in his slow, grave way. "I shall be a model of discretion."
"Kamaladevi-ji, if you would like to send Pupul Jayakar with him, he will be in Paris and London for three days. She can visit the fashion houses and the jewellers. She might see Dior, who Menon tells me has just opened and is all the rage in America. She might see what a Parisian ballroom wears this winter. It would be of use to the Ministry of Arts."
"She will be on the train tonight," Kamaladevi said.
Radhakrishnan, who had been silent by the window throughout, turned now. His face had a look that Ram had seen on it only once before, in a courtyard in Allahabad, when a small boy had asked him why Sanskrit had so many words for the same river.
"Prime Minister. I wish to say a word."
"Please."
"I came into this room an hour ago thinking I was handing out ministries. I find I have been handing out Chapters. A man who builds a stadium is writing the story of what we do with our bodies. A man who lays a sewer is writing what we do with our water, and a woman who dresses a prince is writing what we do with our past." He paused. "I think that in a hundred years, a historian may find our Ministry of Culture the strangest of all of them. It will have been the one that did not build a thing. It only asked, over every other ministry’s shoulder, whether we should be proud of it."
"That is its work," Ram said.
"I hope I am equal to it."
"I do not doubt it."
The meeting ended at noon. The ministers gathered their folders and filed out, talking in low voices. Gadgil stopped at the door to look once more at the drawing on the blackboard, the street, and the long rectangle beneath it, and then, as if remembering something, he took out his notebook and copied it carefully, line by line, into the margin of a page.
A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.