Rajpath, New Delhi
26 January 1951
The morning came up cold and clear, with a thin mist lying along the Yamuna and the red sandstone of the Secretariat turning pink as the sun cleared the dome. By seven, the avenue from Rashtrapati Bhavan to India Gate was lined twenty deep. People had slept on the lawns. Schoolchildren in white shirts sat on the kerbs holding paper tricolours, and vendors moved along the crowd with trays of roasted gram and steaming tea.
On the saluting dais, Dr. Rajendra Prasad, the first President of the Republic, sat in a plain white achkan with a shawl over his shoulders. Ram sat at his left, Patel at his right, wrapped against the cold with a rug across his knees, a thermos of dal-water beside him that he had pointedly declined to hide. Nehru, Radhakrishnan, Shroff, and the Cabinet filled the rows behind. In the front of the diplomatic enclosure, in a long dark coat and a black karakul cap, sat the chief guest, Sardar Mohammad Naim, the Foreign Minister of Afghanistan, who had come in place of the King, with a retinue of thirteen.
At half past nine, a single gun fired from the Purana Qila, and the parade began.
The Army came first, a column of Shermans, Stuarts and half-tracks rolling past with a long iron rumble, then the guns, the 25-pounders and the Soviet 76s, then infantry in ranks of twelve, the Sikh Light Infantry in saffron turbans, the Gorkhas with their slouch hats, the Rajputana Rifles, the Madras Sappers. Katari’s sailors marched in white, the Air Force flew over in a long V of Tempests, and last, low and slow, a single prototype of the Kiran trainer, silver in the winter sun, which drew a roar from the crowd that startled even the pigeons.
Then the tableaux.
They came on flatbed lorries drawn by tractors, each a moving stage, each dressed by the province it represented. A great paper-and-cane Hirakud dam, with a stream of silver tinsel pouring from its sluices, was followed by Rajputana, a camel-borne troupe of Kalbelia dancers with a miniature stepwell on a trailer behind them. Travancore sent a Kathakali dancer in full crimson and green, standing absolutely motionless on a boat, a figure so fierce that the children on the kerb fell silent.
Burma’s tableau, drawn by the Hill Councils, carried a full-size Shan longhouse and a dozen men and women of the Kachin, Chin, Karen and Shan in their festival dress, turbans and silver and woven jackets, with a Mandalay drummer at the front. Behind them, a lorry banked in green and gold carried a Ceylonese tea plantation and a line of Sinhalese and Tamil girls in white, singing. Mauritius and the Seychelles came together, a sugar-cane field and a schooner under sail, with old Devraj from Port Louis, ninety years old, seated in a chair at the prow with his granddaughter at his side, waving a small flag with a hand that trembled. The Maldives sent a dhoni on a trailer, and Socotra, a model Dragon’s Blood tree.
The Himalayan tableaux were last. Nepal’s, drawn up on a flat lorry between two Gurkha pipers, bore a model of the Pashupatinath temple, and the crowd, which had been quiet, began to clap. Bhutan’s carried a dzong of wood and painted canvas and a troupe of masked monks, who’s slow, whirling dance brought the whole Rajpath to a standstill. Last of all came Tibet.
It was a single, simple lorry. On it stood a copper prayer-wheel the size of a man, turned by two monks in maroon, and a small, silent group of lay Tibetans in their long woollen robes. At the front, seated cross-legged on a low platform, was a boy of fifteen in a saffron and maroon robe, with a shaved head and round, serious eyes behind his spectacles. He did not wave. He looked at the crowd for a long moment, and then at the dais. He bowed his head, once, very slightly, to the Prime Minister.
A hush ran down the avenue. Then, from somewhere near the India Gate, a single voice called out the name of the Dalai Lama, and the whole crowd took it up and cheered until the pigeons wheeled.
Ram did not move. He sat with his hands on his knees and watched the lorry go by, and Patel, beside him, said very low, "He is only a child."
"He was a king, Vallabhbhai, who renounced his throne to save the way of life of his kingdom."
At noon, Dr. Rajendra Prasad rose and spoke for twenty minutes, in a small, clear, scholarly voice. He spoke of the Constitution as a covenant, not a code; he spoke of Gandhi, whom he had known for thirty years, and whose absence, he said, was the only reproach the day carried. He also spoke of the young Republic’s debts to the soldier, the farmer, the schoolteacher, and the woman in the relief kitchen, and said that no one in the stands should leave without remembering that the dais itself had been paid for by labour they would never see.
When he sat down, everybody cheered, though not loudly. Ram, watching the old man’s hands shake slightly on the arms of his chair, thought it was the best speech he had heard that year.
The signing took place that afternoon in the Durbar Hall of Rashtrapati Bhavan, beneath a chandelier that had once lit a Viceroy’s ball. The long table had been covered in green baize. Two documents lay on it, bound in Morocco leather, one in Persian and one in English and Sanskrit, with the seal of each state in red wax.
Naim signed first. He did so with a slight stiffness, like a man laying down a card he had not entirely made up his mind to play. Ram signed second. Nehru and Menon witnessed for India; two Afghan secretaries and the colonel witnessed for Kabul. The thin young man with the notebook, whose name Ram had learned was Daoud Shah, stood at the back and wrote down everything, including the sound of the pens.
The first instrument, the Free Trade Corridor Treaty, was exactly what had been described in October. A ninety-nine-year lease, renewable by mutual consent. A road through the Wakhan, to be built by Indian engineers at Indian cost, from Gilgit to the Pamirs, open to Afghan traders without toll. A million dollars, paid on signing and every year thereafter. Afghan governor, Afghan flag, Afghan garrison at Sarhad.
The second was a surprise. Naim had mentioned in Delhi that his government would welcome a shorter instrument of mutual reassurance, and the draft had been brought forward in the last week. It was a Treaty of Peace and Non-Aggression between India and Afghanistan, with a ten-year term and four clauses. Neither would attack the other. Neither would permit its territory to be used for an attack on the other. Any dispute would be referred to arbitration by a commission of three, one chosen by each and one by the two together. And a final clause, written in Naim’s own language and translated afterwards, said that the two high contracting parties affirm that their peoples are linked by mountain, river, and faith, and shall endeavour to keep the road between them open to the end of time.
Ram read the last clause twice before he signed it. He had not expected it to move him, and it did.
At the reception afterwards, in the long gallery hung with old portraits of Viceroys, Naim took Ram aside near a window. The light was going. Beyond the glass, the lamps along Rajpath were being lit one by one.
"Prime Minister," he said, in French. "I have not forgotten what you said in October. That the Indian Army is not a danger to its friends."
"I meant it."
"I know. I should like to say something in return, and I would ask you not to repeat it." Naim looked at the street. "There are men in Kabul who dream of a greater Afghanistan. Of the Pathan lands across the Durand Line. Of Peshawar, and Quetta, and the Indus. I am not one of them. But I know they exist, and I know that you have been very patient. I should like to tell you that when the day comes that Pakistan breaks, as I think it will, you will find the Afghan Government sensible."
"I hope the day is far off."
"It is not far." Naim smiled thinly. "You and I know that."
When the instruments had been sealed and exchanged, Ram handed Naim a small package wrapped in brown paper.
"A gift for His Majesty. Not from the Government. From me."
Naim opened it. Inside, wrapped in cotton, lay a slim volume bound in dark blue cloth: a Sanskrit-Persian dictionary, hand-copied in Allahabad, with the Persian equivalents set beside the Sanskrit roots in red ink. On the flyleaf, in Ram’s neat script, was a single line in each language.
"What does it say?"
"It says that two languages that share a root can share a road."
Naim closed the book and held it for a moment against his chest. "I shall give it to him myself."
He did not smile again that afternoon, but when he left the hall, he walked a little more slowly than he had come in.
Nirvachan Sadan, New Delhi
30 January 1951
Sukumar Sen’s office was not at all what Ram had expected. It occupied two rooms in an old annexe of the Home Ministry, with a worn linoleum floor, a metal filing cabinet, and a desk covered in neat stacks of paper that seemed to have been arranged by a ruler. On the wall hung a hand-lettered map of India, pinned with coloured flags, and under it, in a corner, a single bicycle leaned against the wall.
The Chief Election Commissioner rose when Ram came in. He was a slight, bald, bespectacled man of fifty-two with a worn grey suit and a manner of mild, almost apologetic precision, and he did not seem in the least awed by his visitor.
"Prime Minister. You have come yourself."
"I wanted to see where it was being done."
"It is not being done here. It is being counted here." Sen gestured at the stacks. "I have forty-one staff, of whom nine can type. I have been told by the Finance Ministry that I may not hire more until I produce a plan. I have therefore produced a plan."
"I have been looking forward to it."
"It is not interesting." Sen sat, folded his hands, and began, without referring to a paper. "Prime Minister, you asked in October what I would require. I have thought about it for three months, and I find that the whole matter reduces to a single question: who are the voters? We do not know. We have no list. The last census was in 1941, taken by the British, with a methodology I do not trust, and since then, we have had a war, a famine, a partition, the arrival of six million refugees, and the acquisition of three new provinces. A voter who does not exist on a list cannot vote. A name that appears twice can vote twice. A dead man who is still listed can vote after his funeral."
"So, the first step?"
"A census. A real one. In March. Every household in the Union, enumerated by hand, by a trained clerk who has walked to the door and written down who lives behind it. Name, age, sex, caste if the household wishes it recorded, religion, language, occupation, literacy, and whether the person has voted before." He tapped the desk. "It is the largest administrative undertaking in the history of the subcontinent. It will require two million enumerators. I propose to use schoolteachers on their summer leave, with the Seva Vahini and the Army to supervise. A month of training, a month in the field. I have a draft questionnaire."
"And then?"
"From the census, the electoral rolls. Every person over twenty-one, in every village, in a printed list posted on the door of the school or the panchayat house, so that anyone may see whether his name is there. Corrections may be filed for three months. Claims, objections, fresh additions. It is slow. It is the only way to be sure." Sen leaned forward. "In a country where the landlord may say who is allowed to vote, a public list is the first defence of the poor man. I have asked the Census Commissioner to add one column: the name of the polling place the voter is likely to use. It will cost nothing."
"What is your timetable?"
"I have it here. A moment." He did turn, then, to a long sheet pinned inside the filing cabinet door. "March 1951: the census. By October, the figures. By December, the first draft rolls, posted in the villages. March 1952, final rolls. September of 1952, the deadline for registration of political parties. Any group wishing to field a candidate in the general election must register with this office by that date, with a constitution, a list of members, and a declaration of its funding."
"And the symbols?"
"Allotted in October of 1952. Each party, a symbol. A plough, a lamp, a bullock, a sheaf of wheat, an elephant, a hand. We shall have a list of eighty, from which they may choose. Symbols cannot be religious. They cannot be national emblems. They cannot, I am told by a legal friend, be the cow." Sen permitted himself a thin smile. "I have already received eleven applications for the cow."
"I imagine so."
"From the census, the electoral rolls. They will be drawn up by the Commission between April and December. Each village will post its list at the school or panchayat office. Any man or woman who finds a name missing, or a dead man listed, may claim or object. There will be a claims period of ninety days. This will take until early next year. I will not promise it will be perfect. There will be mistakes. I should like to know that they are found by the people they affect."
"In November or December 1952, and I consider this the most important of all, a pilot poll, in three or four constituencies chosen to represent the country. A hill district, a delta, a desert, a city. Five or six thousand voters in each. We shall run the full process, from the registration of the voter to the sealing of the box. We shall find what breaks. I have no doubt a good many things will. It is far better that they break on a small scale, where we can mend them, than in the spring of 1953 before three hundred and fifty million."
"What do you expect to break?"
"Everything," Sen said it without humour. "The ink. The ballot papers. The transport. The polling officers, who will be schoolteachers and have never done it before. The boxes themselves. I have asked for a thousand wooden prototypes to be built in our Skill Training Institutes. "
"And the general elections?"
"April to June of 1953, in rotation. A different region each week, so that the staff may move and the police may be concentrated. The count will be at the end, in every constituency on the same day, so that no one may know the result in one province and influence another." He paused. "It will take eleven weeks of polling and three million men to run it. I do not say it is possible. I say it is necessary, and I am a civil servant, and it is the habit of my profession to say that the necessary is possible until it is proven otherwise."
Ram listened with his chin on his hand. When Sen had finished, he said, "It is a very clean plan."
"It is clean on paper."
"What do you fear?"
Sen did not answer at once. He took off his spectacles and polished them on his sleeve, an old, slow gesture.
"Several things, Prime Minister. First, the rolls. I do not worry about the enumerator who makes an honest mistake. I worry about the headman who tells the enumerator, in a village where I cannot be present, that the Harijans on the east side of the stream do not count. I should like a rule that every list be read aloud in the village square before it is posted, by a man not employed by the headman, so that the people can hear their own names."
"That is easily done."
"Second, the ballot. A ballot box is a wooden crate with a slot. It must be sealed. It must be carried through a hundred miles of country, in a bullock-cart, in the monsoon, to a place where a man can count it. I have asked the Army to provide a guard on every box, and I should like the Prime Minister to be informed that I intend to refuse any box that is delivered unsealed." He put the spectacles back on. "It is a matter on which I shall not be accommodating."
"I should be disappointed if you were."
"Third, and last. The power of a Commission is the power to refuse." He spoke very quietly now. "A court can only say what the law is. An Election Commission can say that the election is void. If a booth is captured, a roll is forged, a candidate is intimidated, I must be able to declare the poll at that booth null, and order it again, whatever the Government’s wishes, and whoever the candidate may be. If I am not given that authority in writing, I should prefer not to hold the post."
"You shall have it."
"I should like it in the Representation of the People Act."
"It will be there."
"Thank you, Prime Minister." Sen’s face did not change, but his shoulders dropped, very slightly, as a man’s will after carrying a load for some time. "I have been waiting to ask someone for that for two years."
A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.
Happy Bhai Dooj to everyone. Seen some debate on the need of a prolonged holiday for Diwali on social media lately; do you agree?