Reborn in 1914: I Will Build India into a Superpower · Contents

CHAPTER 154

Chapter 154: Stock Markets (3)

10 min read·namekjin35

"Why not simply buy shares himself?"

"Because he knows nothing of companies. And because if he buys one, and it fails, he is ruined. This way he owns a tiny piece of the whole country."

"A risk," Nehru said. "The poor will take their savings and put them into it, and when the market falls, they will curse the Government."

"Which is why I propose a cap. No family may invest more than twenty per cent of its declared savings in units in any year, and no single unit-holder may hold more than five thousand rupees’ worth. A family that loses a fifth of its savings has been wounded, not destroyed. And I propose that the first issue be small, a few crores, so that the Trust may learn to walk before it is asked to run."

Shroff cleared his throat. "I support the principle. I wish to raise a difficulty about a guarantee. I assume you do not intend one."

"No guarantee. A unit has no promised return. It may rise or fall."

"The people will not understand it. The name, ’Unit Trust of India,’ will be read as ’the Government’s Trust.’ A peasant who buys a unit and sees its value fall will say the Government has cheated him. It is the nature of the thing. I should require that every certificate carry, in large type and in the holder’s own language: This unit may lose value. The Government does not guarantee its price. And I should ask Radhakrishnan’s people to make the money programme on the radio explain it every evening for a month before the first sale."

"The money programme exists already. I shall instruct it. And the name can be changed."

"And I should add one thing," Deshmukh said quietly. "A unit should not be sold by a salesman who is paid by the sale. Every salesman of a financial product has an interest in telling a man it is safe. I should have the units sold only by post offices and licensed banks, where the clerk has no commission, and the form of sale is a plain application."

"Very good. Done."

"And the third source?"

"The third source is the one I am least sure of." Ram looked at Deshmukh. "Sir Chintaman, you will tell me where it fails."

"I shall try."

"Fifteen per cent of the long-term deposits of the agricultural cooperative banks, and of the pension funds of Government and railway employees, to be invested in a fund that buys listed shares. At present, they hold nothing but fixed deposits and Government bonds. A pension fund has money that will not be needed for thirty years. It is a pity to let it earn three per cent."

Deshmukh set down his pencil with great care. "Prime Minister, I must object. Strongly."

"Go on."

"The cooperative banks were established, at your own instruction, as narrow institutions. You said at the time that they were to accept local deposits and make agricultural loans, and be banned from speculation. I remember the day. I drafted the clause. It is the safest thing we have done.

"A peasant who deposits twenty rupees in a cooperative bank is a different kind of man from the man who buys a share. He believes his money is as safe as a stone in the ground. If you tell him that fifteen per cent of it is in the stock market, and the market falls, and the bank cannot pay him on the day he comes for it, you will have a run on every cooperative in the Union. It will take a decade to rebuild the trust."

"I did say that."

"You did."

"Then I have contradicted myself, and I should like to find a way out." Ram’s voice was level. "What would you suggest?"

Deshmukh thought for some time. "Not direct investment. If the cooperative banks may buy units of the Trust, and only units, up to ten per cent of their long-term deposits, that is, the 10-year Fixed Deposits, and only after the Trust has been running for three years and has shown a record, that is a different matter. The risk is spread across sixty companies. The units are valued daily. The bank can sell them if it needs cash. And the Reserve Bank can inspect the holdings, and cap it if the market becomes dangerous."

"Ten per cent, units only, after three years."

"For the pension funds, I am less troubled. The money is not on call. A pension fund that holds twenty per cent of its assets in a diversified fund, over a thirty-year horizon, will do very well. But I should like an independent trustee, a body of actuaries, to approve the allocation, so that no Minister can decide to put the pension of a railway clerk into the shares of a friend’s mill."

"Done. Ten per cent for the cooperatives, units only, after three years. Twenty for the pension funds, with an independent trustee."

Patel spoke very quietly. "I should like to say something about the pensions. There is a thing in them that I do not like to see passed over. A man gives his life to the railway and expects, at the end, a small sum to live on. That sum is the reward of his labour. If we put it into the market and the market falls, he will lose it.

"I should require that the principal be protected: that the pension fund hold a portion in Government bonds, which cannot fall, sufficient to cover the minimum pension, and that only the surplus be invested."

"A floor," Ram said.

"A floor under the old man. Everything above it may rise or fall."

"That is the remaining eighty per cent, or perhaps ninety, like the cooperatives’ long-term deposits. Mr. Shroff and Deshmukh can set the exact numbers when they draft the act."

Shroff rubbed his temples. "We have discussed the buyers, Prime Minister. I wish to say a word about the market as a whole, because I suspect that, even with all these, we are building a very large roof on very thin walls."

"Say it."

"The market capitalisation is nine hundred crores. If the State Bank buys twenty-five a year, and the Trust takes perhaps ten in its first year, and the pension funds and cooperatives another fifteen, we have fifty crores of new demand. That is almost the annual turnover. It will raise prices. It may raise them very quickly. I do not say it is bad.

"I say that a sudden rise on thin trading is a bubble, and bubbles have a habit of bursting. The Commission must watch it. When prices rise by more than a third in a year, the State Bank must stop buying, whatever the rule says, and the Reserve Bank must raise the margin."

"A brake," Ram said. "I agree. I should rather have a slow market than a mad one."

"And it must be supplemented by supply. New companies must list. The whole structure fails if there are not enough shares to buy. I should like a provision that every State enterprise earning a profit above a threshold must offer a tenth of its equity to the public in the first five years. Bhilai, Visakhapatnam, the Indian Oil Corporation, Bharat Petroleum, Hindustan Aircraft. A tenth of each. It would double the size of the market in one stroke."

Nehru stirred. "I would not oppose that. It would give the people a share in what they own."

"It will also put the State in the same room as the investor," Ram said. "The Corporation’s directors will have to explain their accounts to a hundred thousand shareholders. I should like that very much."

There was a brief pause. Ram turned to the final matter, and his tone altered, as if he were setting down a weight.

"The last item concerns the new entrepreneur. A market for shares helps the man who already has a factory. It does nothing for the man who has an idea and no money. I should like something for him. A scheme of medium-term loans, three to seven years, at a low rate of interest, for anyone with a sound business plan and some security. The collateral may be land, a house, a guarantee from a landowner. At present, such loans exist on a very small scale, in the cooperatives."

Deshmukh nodded. "I have the same difficulty with it as I have with every such scheme, Prime Minister. It is the collateral. The man who has a house to pledge is, by definition, a man of some means. The man with no property and a good idea has nothing to offer, and the banks will not lend to him. You will fund the sons of the rich and starve the sons of the poor."

"Then what?"

"A guarantee fund. The Government guarantees seventy-five per cent of any loan made to a first-time entrepreneur under a plan approved by a district industrial officer. The bank bears only a quarter of the risk. It will lend where it would not otherwise. And the district officer, a trained man, not a clerk, reviews the plan for competence, not for connection."

"A guarantee fund of what size?"

"Twenty crores, to begin. If the default rate is ten per cent, a reasonable figure, it will support two hundred crores of loans. It is a considerable lever."

"Shroff-ji?"

Shroff closed his eyes for a moment, and opened them again. "Twenty crores. I shall find it. I will say, as I always say, that it is the cheapest thing in this whole proposal and probably the most valuable. And I should like it reserved, in the first instance, for graduates of the vocational institutes and polytechnics. A man who has learned a trade and wants to practise it deserves the first call. It would give the institutes a reason for existence beyond the certificate."

"A very good provision. I accept it."

"And the Cooperative," Nehru said, from the head of the table. "I should add one more thing. For the very small man, the weaver, the potter, the carpenter in a village, a loan of a few hundred rupees is a lifeline. Dr. Kurien’s cooperatives know how to administer it. Let a fifth of the guarantee fund be set aside for them, with no collateral at all except the endorsement of the village cooperative."

"Done."

The room was silent. Outside, a typewriter clattered, was silent, and clattered again. Shroff had written steadily throughout, and now laid down his pen.

"Prime Minister. I have raised my objections, and you have answered each. I have said I am a cautious man. I should now like to say something that is not a caution."

"Please."

"I have watched a good many reforms in my time. The Bombay Plan, the sterling settlement, the oil company. This one frightens me more than any of them, because it asks the people to trust a thing they have never seen. A man will lend to the Government because the Government is a thing he can see. He will put money into a market only if he can believe the market is honest. If one broker defrauds one widow, in the first year, the whole edifice may fall. I do not say that to discourage you. I say it because I want the first year to be perfect."

"It will not be perfect."

"No. But it must be very good. I should therefore like a delay. Not a long one. Six months, in which the Commission is established, the exchange boards are reconstituted, the settlement corporation is built, and a pilot is run on a single exchange. Then the Act comes into force. Not before."

"The Act is passed in the autumn session. It takes effect on the first of April, 1952."

"That is, I think, enough."

A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.