Reborn in 1914: I Will Build India into a Superpower · Contents

CHAPTER 153

Chapter 153: Stock Markets (2)

10 min read·namekjin35

Nehru, who had been silent, folded his hands. "May I speak, Ram?"

"Please."

"I wish to be honest. I have listened to this with a good deal of discomfort, though not because I think you wrong on particulars. I have watched what a stock market does in other countries. In 1929, I was in Europe. I saw a man in Berlin who had lost everything weep in a café, and the same week, a man in New York jumped from a window. A stock exchange is a machine for turning other people’s savings into one man’s fortune, and the machine does not distinguish between honest and dishonest. I do not wish to build a gambling den."

"Nor do I."

"Then explain to me why this is not one."

Ram closed the folder for a moment. "Because a gambling den produces nothing, Jawaharlal. A stock exchange, rightly run, finances a plant that makes something. It lets a farmer who has a hundred rupees put it into a factory he will never see and receive a share of its earnings. That is what the Urja Bond does for the State. This does it for the private factory. The difference is whether the savings are channelled into production or into speculation. I propose to prevent the second, as far as a law can."

"How?"

"Margin: a man who buys shares on credit must put up half the price in cash, which makes it dangerous to gamble with borrowed money. Short selling: forbidden for the first five years. A man who sells what he does not own bets on a fall, and such bets ruin small companies.

"Circuit breakers: if any share rises or falls more than ten per cent in a day, trading in it is halted until the next morning. And a tax on short-term gains: a man who buys and sells within a year pays at a higher rate than a man who holds. Derivative trading: the most ruinous stock activity, banned until at least 1970, by which time I firmly believe the country’s population will have ample knowledge of financial matters."

Nehru’s eyebrows rose. "A tax on the quick profit."

"A man who holds a share for five years has helped to build something. A man who holds it for five days has merely taken. I would rather reward the first."

"That is a principle I had not expected from you," Nehru said slowly. "I shall support it."

Patel gave a short bark of laughter. "He has been listening to you since 1937, Ram, and is only just discovering that you have a conscience."

"I have always known it, Vallabhbhai. I did not know he would find it convenient."

Nehru smiled despite himself. "There is another matter. The great houses. If the sixty per cent is cut, Tata and Birla and the Marwari families will list their firms and keep control. It will enrich the already rich. I do not say that is wrong. I say it is a matter I cannot leave alone."

"What do you propose?"

"A reservation. A part of every issue reserved for small applicants. A man who applies for shares worth less than five thousand rupees should be given priority, before the large buyers. A clerk, a teacher, a petty trader."

Ram looked at Shroff. "Is it workable?"

"It is, and it is wise," Shroff said, with a twist of the mouth. "The large buyers, the insurance companies and banks, will complain. They always do. But a small investor who sees that he has been given first call will tell his neighbour, and a market built on a hundred thousand neighbours is stronger than one built on forty families. I should reserve thirty per cent of every issue."

"Thirty, then," Ram said. "And I propose a minimum public float of twenty-five per cent, not sixty, rising to thirty-five over seven years. A founder keeps control, but must in time share more of the company."

"Twenty-five is acceptable," Shroff said. "Sixty was a folly."

"Now the exchanges. I shall be brief, because I know the brokers will be unhappy." Ram turned to the second page. "Every exchange board must contain fifty per cent public governors. Not brokers. Men and women of standing, appointed by the Commission, who owe the brokers nothing. The listing rules, the disciplinary tribunal, the settlement procedure, will be governed by that board. And settlement must be standardised: all trades settled within fourteen days, with delivery of the certificates legally binding. At present a seller may promise delivery and not make it, and the exchange does nothing."

Shroff grimaced. "The brokers will fight it. I know them. They have run that club since 1875. Half of them are decent, and half of the other half cannot read a balance sheet."

"They may withdraw if they wish. A new exchange can be licensed in Calcutta, Madras, Delhi, and Ahmedabad. I should like all of them linked by telegram, so that a price in Bombay is known in Madras within minutes."

Deshmukh made a small, dry noise. "The brokers will not withdraw. They will adapt. But a word on the practical detail, Prime Minister. I have seen the settlement rooms at Bombay. A transfer of shares is done by a deed, signed in ink, with a stamp, delivered by hand. A single mistake in a signature, and the share is void. I have seen forged certificates of three companies in the last year, and one of them was sold six times before anyone noticed."

"What do you recommend?"

"A single, standard share certificate, printed on security paper at Nashik, with a serial number and a watermark, and a register of transfer agents, licensed by the Commission, who keep the master record of ownership. A clearing corporation to guarantee settlement: if a broker defaults, the corporation pays the buyer and recovers from the broker. A guarantee fund, to which every member contributes, so that the default of a small broker does not destroy a large one."

"Excellent. Add it to the Act."

Patel put down his thermos. "Now, the money. You have said nothing of it, and I notice that Ardeshir has begun to look at his hands."

"I am coming to it, Vallabhbhai." Ram took the third page. "On capital. We have just thrown off foreign rule. The public does not trust foreigners with a rupee of ours, and I do not blame it. We still keep guards on the Americans in Visakhapatnam and the Russians at Bhilai, because the villagers have thrown stones at them. If I were to throw the market open to foreign investors tomorrow, there would be a riot in a week, and an excuse for every demagogue to say we had sold the country.

"Therefore: until 1960, a complete bar on foreign institutional investors and on foreign nationals buying shares. Foreign capital may enter only as direct investment, in joint ventures with Indian partners, on terms: the foreign firm must train Indian apprentices, produce in India, and transfer its process. Between 1960 and 1970, foreign institutions may hold up to twenty per cent of any listed company. Between 1970 and 1990, up to forty-five per cent, a limit Parliament may change as the country sees fit."

Shroff nodded. "I am in favour of the bar for now. But there is an anomaly. Indians who live abroad. The Gujaratis in Kenya, the Tamils in Malaya, the Sindhis in Hong Kong. They are not foreigners. They send money home already. A bar on foreign nationals would shut out the very people who might invest the most."

"A fair point. The Indians in Mauritius, the Seychelles, Ceylon, and Burma are citizens already. For the rest, if they are sending money to India, their families may invest. The issue can be revisited at a later time."

"And the strategic sectors?" Patel said. "Defence, atomic energy, oil exploration, the rocket programme. No foreigner, at any time, for any share."

"Agreed, though whether to allow foreign investment later is best left for later governments."

"That works."

Deshmukh raised a finger. "A caution on the later stages. Twenty per cent from 1960 may be too generous. A foreign fund that holds a fifth of a company can sell it all in a week, and the price falls, and the rupee wobbles. I have seen what hot money does to a currency. I should like a lock-in for foreign holdings of at least two years, and a limit on any single foreign investor of two per cent of any company."

"Two years and two per cent. Done."

"And a reserve of foreign exchange to meet a sudden withdrawal."

"We have a billion dollars. That is your reserve."

"I should say so."

Ram turned to the last page, and for the first time, he seemed to hesitate.

"Now the liquidity. Sir Chintaman has said it already, and I wished to hear someone else say it. A market that is the size of a village fair cannot support a structure like this. We can write any laws we like, but if there is no money in the market, the laws are decoration. I therefore propose three sources of domestic institutional investment, the DIIs, which I shall name in order."

"Please," Shroff said, rather quietly.

"The first. A fixed percentage of the annual budget, two to five per cent, channelled through the Imperial Bank, which we propose to convert into the State Bank of India, to buy shares in listed companies until 1960, when the market should be mature enough to stand without it. At the present budget, that is fourteen to thirty-five crores a year."

Shroff pressed his lips together. "Prime Minister, I must say what I think. Fourteen to thirty-five crores is not a floor. It is a flood. Annual turnover on the Bombay exchange is sixty crores. A government buyer with thirty-five crores would be more than half of the market. It would not support prices; it would set them. And every broker in Bombay would know the day the State Bank began buying, and would front-run it."

"What is your alternative?"

"I do not say don’t. I say, make it a rule. Not a discretion." Shroff sat up. "The State Bank’s purchases must be governed by a board that includes the Commission and the Reserve Bank, and it must buy a fixed basket, in proportion to the market value of each listed company. No selection, no favouritism. The purchases are made at a steady rate, a little each day, so that no one can anticipate. It must hold the shares for at least five years. It may not sell in a rising market. And it should keep a part of the fund in reserve, to buy more only when the market falls by a fifth, as a buyer of last resort."

"A buyer of last resort," Ram said slowly. "To prevent a panic. Does that not curb the market’s independence? If it is falling by a fifth, it should mean that the market is overvalued; why should the bank rush to buy more? Stocks carry an inherent risk; I should hope that investors are prudent enough to acknowledge that and act accordingly."

"To prevent the ruin of the small man who sold at the bottom. But only when the fall is real, and the buying is announced, and the policy is written."

Deshmukh nodded. "The rule matters more than the amount. A Government that is known to buy by formula will not be accused of favouritism. A Government that buys by whim will be accused of it every day, and in the end, it will be right to be."

"This shall need further discussion," Ram turned. "The second source. A Unit Trust of India."

Nehru frowned. "What is that?"

"A body that takes the savings of small people and invests them in a spread of listed companies chosen by experts, in return for a share, called a unit. A clerk with twenty-five rupees may buy a unit. His twenty-five rupees are mixed with a hundred thousand others, and the Trust buys shares in sixty companies, so that if one fails, he loses a sixty-fifth part of his money, not all of it. The units are bought and sold at a price published every day, which reflects the value of the shares the Trust holds. He may sell whenever he likes."

A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.