Aurora’s words had once again plunged the tribe into a heavy silence before the murmurs inevitably began. Every beastman and female present stared at her with varying degrees of confusion, disbelief, and curiosity.
Aurora stood calmly in the center of everyone’s attention, her expression unreadable as she observed the reactions around her. She didn’t miss the way Lyria’s brows furrowed. The latter narrowed her eyes ever so slightly and a flicker of unease passed through them before she quickly masked it.
Around them, the whispers grew louder.
"Someone else did it?"
"But why would anyone burn the storage cave?"
"That doesn’t make sense."
"We all need those supplies. Who would destroy supplies meant for surviving winter?"
The more the tribe discussed it, the angrier they became. Winter was not something they could afford to take lightly. Every season, beastmen spent countless weeks hunting, gathering, and preparing enough resources to survive the brutal cold months ahead. Every piece of dried meat, every bundle of warm hides, every carefully stored root and fruit represented hard work and precious time.
The destroyed storage cave had held supplies meant to sustain the entire tribe.
Thinking that someone might have deliberately destroyed it made their blood boil. Faces darkened and claws flexed. And several beastmen looked ready to tear apart whoever was responsible.
Even the females, who normally avoided conflict, looked horrified by the possibility. If Aurora was telling the truth, then the culprit had not only endangered themselves,but they had endangered the entire tribe on purpose.
Feeling the mood of the crowd rapidly turning hostile, Lyria immediately stepped forward.
"You are lying!"
The sharp accusation cut through the whispers, and all eyes turned toward her.
Lyria pointed directly at Aurora. "You are only saying this because you are trying to escape punishment!"
Her voice carried confidence, but there was a slight edge to it that hadn’t been there before. "You started the fire, and now you are making up stories about another culprit."
Several people exchanged uncertain looks.
Lyria pressed forward. "First you claim someone else did it, and now you say you’ll reveal the real culprit? What proof do you even have?"
A few heads nodded. That was the real question. What proof could Aurora possibly possess?
But instead of becoming flustered or defensive like Lyria wanted, Aurora simply smiled. It wasn’t a large smile, nor was it a warm one. Instead, it was calm and confident. And for some reason, the sight of it made Lyria’s stomach twist.
Aurora looked entirely too relaxed and too certain.
Without answering Lyria directly, she turned toward the gathered tribe. "I need everyone to separate into two groups."
Confusion immediately appeared on countless faces. Aurora raised a hand toward the storage cave behind her as she explained - "One group will consist of everyone who got close to the fire while helping put it out."
Then she pointed toward the open area opposite them. "The second group will be those who stayed at a distance and never went near the flames."
The crowd blinked. Several beastmen frowned while others looked completely baffled. No one understood what this had to do with identifying the culprit. Even Chief Ragnar looked thoughtful. But after a brief pause, he nodded.
"Do as she says." His deep voice carried unquestionable authority.
The tribe immediately obeyed. People began moving around, sorting themselves into the designated groups. Those who had rushed forward to battle the flames gathered together, while those who had remained farther away moved into the second group.
The process took only a few moments.
Aurora silently observed.
Meanwhile, Lyria remained rooted in place. Her mind raced as she didn’t understand what Aurora was trying to do.None of this made sense. What did being near the fire have to do with anything? Why separate everyone? Her growing confusion slowly began turning into anxiety.
Then Mira’s voice suddenly rang out.
"Lyria."
The female froze.
Mira gestured toward the second group. "The people who didn’t go near the fire are over there."
For a moment, Lyria simply stared. Then realization dawned. Of course. No females besides Aurora and Mira had participated in putting out the fire. The flames had been too dangerous. The first group consisted almost entirely of beastmen while the second group contained the remaining females, including her.
Lyria immediately let out a scoff as though the entire thing was ridiculous and she hadn’t been standing frozen moments earlier. She lifted her chin and walked toward the second group.
"Such nonsense." Her voice dripped with disdain. But despite her words, she obediently took her place among the other females.
Aurora watched her without comment. Soon the tribe stood divided into two groups. One on her left side and the second on her right.
The crowd’s confusion only deepened. Several people shifted impatiently. Others looked between Aurora and the groups, waiting for an explanation.
Aurora allowed the silence to stretch. Then she finally spoke, "Before we continue, I want everyone to think carefully." Her gaze swept across both groups. "Make sure you are standing in the correct place. Because once this begins, no one will be allowed to change groups."
That immediately drew attention. A few people frowned while glanced around uncertainly. Even Chief Ragnar’s eyes sharpened slightly. The warning sounded strangely specific.
Across the clearing, Lyria felt her heartbeat quicken. Her eyes instinctively drifted toward the opposite group, the one composed of those who had been near the fire. For a brief moment, uncertainty flashed across her face.
Should she move? Was this some kind of trap?
But then reason quickly reasserted itself. No. She hadn’t gone anywhere near the flames tonight. The entire tribe had seen her and everyone could vouch for that. There was absolutely no reason for her to stand with the other group. Aurora was bluffing. She had to be. She must be trying to scare her into revealing themselves. Trying to force her into making a mistake.
The realization made Lyria feel slightly better. And slowly, her confidence returned. She straightened her shoulders and lifted her chin. And a smug expression settled onto her face.
Let Aurora play her little games. It wouldn’t matter. Because Lyria knew one thing for certain. Nobody had seen her near the fire tonight.
Nobody.
Aurora studied her for several seconds before finally turning back toward the crowd.
"Good." Her voice carried clearly across the clearing. "Now that everyone has chosen their groups, I’ll explain."
The whispers immediately died down and every eye focused on her.
Aurora pointed toward the remains of the burned storage cave. "Fire has a smell. A very distinct smell of smoke. Which means anyone who spends enough time near a fire will carry that smell on their body."
Several beastmen nodded unconsciously. That was true. After fighting the flames earlier, many of them still smelled strongly of smoke.
Aurora clasped her hands behind her back. "This also means someone who never went near the fire shouldn’t smell like smoke."
The crowd gradually began understanding.
Aurora’s gaze slowly shifted and landed directly on Mira.
"Mira."
The female immediately straightened.
Aurora’s voice remained calm as she continued, "Can you please check whether Lyria carries the smell of smoke."
The world seemed to freeze. For one brief heartbeat, nobody moved. Nobody spoke. Then every single pair of eyes snapped toward Lyria.
Her face instantly drained of color. The smugness vanished and the confidence shattered.
And for the first time that night, genuine fear appeared in her eyes.