The fear in Lyria’s eyes lasted only a moment before desperation forced her into action.
"No!"
Her voice came out far louder than she intended, and the sudden outburst made several people flinch.
As Mira stepped forward, Lyria immediately retreated a step, her heart pounding violently against her ribs.
"This proves nothing!" She shouted, pointing toward Aurora with a trembling finger. "Anyone could smell like smoke after standing this close to the cave!" The words rushed out of her mouth as panic threatened to overwhelm her. "We have all been here for so long! The smell is everywhere!"
She turned toward the crowd as if seeking support. "And even if I do smell like smoke, that doesn’t mean I started the fire! It just means I was nearby!"
The more she spoke, the more frantic she became.
Her eyes snapped back to Aurora. "You are doing this because I exposed your true colors! You are targeting me because I didn’t blindly believe your lies!"
The accusation echoed through the clearing. And once again, uncertainty flickered across a few faces for a moment. However, Aurora remained completely unmoved. But the calm expression on her face only made Lyria feel even more unsettled.
Without saying a word, Mira continued walking toward her. "Lyria." She spoke in a gentle voice. "Stand still."
"No!"
Lyria instinctively tried to move away again. Unfortunately for her, Mira was already close enough. The latter reached out and firmly grabbed both of Lyria’s shoulders before she could escape. And while the movement wasn’t aggressive, it was enough to stop her retreat.
"L-Let go of me!"
Ignoring the protest, Mira leaned forward slightly.
The entire tribe watched and silence descended once more as Mira inhaled. Once. Twice. A third time. The longer she sniffed, the paler Lyria became.
Finally, Mira straightened and her gaze shifted toward Chief Ragnar, then toward Aurora. And slowly, she nodded.
The collective intake of breath from the crowd was impossible to miss.
"She smells like smoke."
The simple statement struck the gathering like thunder. Immediately, murmurs erupted everywhere.
"What?"
"Really?"
"She does?"
"I thought she never got close to the fire."
Lyria’s eyes widened. And for a brief second, genuine panic flashed across her face. But then she quickly recovered. "How would you even know that?" She practically shouted at Mira. The desperation in her voice was becoming harder to hide. "How can you say it’s smoke?"
She pointed accusingly at the other female. "How do you even know what smoke smells like?"
The question made several people exchange odd looks. And Lyria immediately latched onto that reaction. "See?" She turned toward everyone. "You are all just believing whatever Aurora says!"
But before Mira could answer, another female suddenly spoke up from the crowd, and she looked genuinely confused by Lyria’s reaction.
"We know what smoke smells like because Aurora taught us."
Lyria froze.
The female continued. "She taught us days ago."
Aurora remained silent as the females began speaking among themselves. Another one of them stepped forward. "Lyria, you always skipped Aurora’s lessons."
A few people chuckled. Everyone knew it was true. Lyria had spent past weeks loudly declaring Aurora’s teachings useless.
The female continued, "So maybe you don’t know." She pointed toward the burned cave. "Aurora taught us how to recognize the smell of smoke."
More heads nodded.
"She said if we ever smelled it unexpectedly, then there might be fire nearby. That we should stay alert."
Several females and the beastmen remembered the lesson clearly. Aurora had spent considerable time explaining how dangerous uncontrolled fire could be. At the time, many of them thought she was simply being overly cautious. But now, standing before the burned remains of their storage cave, nobody thought so anymore.
The color drained further from Lyria’s face. She hadn’t expected that. She had never attended those lessons and had dismissed them as pointless and beneath her.
How was she supposed to know Aurora had already prepared everyone for this exact moment?
Once again, uncertainty appeared in her eyes. Still, she refused to surrender. She clenched her fists tightly. "No," she said shaking her head. "No, this still proves nothing." Her voice rose again. "A smell isn’t evidence!"
She looked around desperately. "You can’t call me a culprit just because I smell like smoke!"
Several people hesitated since there was some truth in that statement. Smoke alone wasn’t enough.
Lyria immediately noticed the hesitation and pushed harder. Her confidence began returning. "I never went near the fire tonight. Everyone saw that." She then pointed toward the crowd. "Every single person here can confirm it."
No one argued because it was true. Lyria had remained far from the flames throughout the entire incident.
Her lips curved upward as she added, "And even if I somehow smelled like smoke, I still couldn’t have started the fire." Her smile grew larger. "Because I don’t know how." Her gaze shifted triumphantly toward Aurora. "I don’t know how to make fire."
The crowd looked toward Aurora. As for Lyria, she finally appeared somewhat relieved.
But then Aurora chuckled. It wasn’t amused, nor was it kind. The humorless sound immediately made the smile on Lyria’s face falter.
Aurora slowly stepped forward, taking one step and then another toward Lyria. The clearing fell silent once more.
"I agree." Her voice was calm as she spoke, "You never participated in any of my lessons."
The smile immediately returned to Lyria’s face and she unconsciously lifted her chin as if finally gaining the upper hand.
Aurora continued walking. "Not the fire lessons. Not the tool-making lessons. Not any of them." With every word, she drew closer. And strangely, the closer she came, the more uncomfortable Lyria became and her smile began weakening once again.
Aurora stopped only a few feet away. Close enough for Lyria to clearly see the cold certainty in her eyes. Then she spoke again, "But you were always present during the evening gatherings."
Lyria’s smile disappeared entirely while Aurora continued, "You stood on the sidelines. And though you never joined, you watched everything closely while pretending otherwise. You listened to all my directions and teachings."
The crowd slowly began understanding where Aurora was going.
Aurora’s voice remained steady. "You paid attention while I taught everyone how to control fire."
Lyria swallowed and a flicker of panic crossed her face.
"You listened while I explained how to safely transport burning coals and wood. You listened while I demonstrated how to start a new fire from an existing one."
The clearing became deathly silent.
But then Lyria forced herself to scoff. "That means nothing." Her voice sounded weaker than before. "You think I could learn simply by watching?" She demanded. "Just because I was nearby doesn’t mean I understood any of it."
Aurora actually nodded to everyone’s surprise. "I agree."
Lyria blinked.
Aurora took another step closer. "If someone watched once or twice, they probably wouldn’t learn much. But after watching every day for two entire weeks? Only a fool would fail to learn anything."
A ripple spread through the crowd. Several beastmen exchanged glances. The logic was difficult to argue against.
Lyria opened her mouth, desperately trying to think of another excuse. Another lie. Anything. But before she could speak, Aurora suddenly reached forward. The movement was so fast that she barely had time to react.
Aurora seized her right wrist.
"What are you-" Lyria’s protest died instantly.
Aurora raised Lyria’s right hand high enough for everyone to see. The crowd immediately leaned forward and confusion appeared on countless faces before realization struck and gasps erupted everywhere.
Several females covered their mouths, Beastmen’s gazes hardened, and even Chief Ragnar’s eyes narrowed sharply.
Aurora held Lyria’s hand steady for all to see, while her voice cut through the stunned silence. "You say you never started the fire." She slowly turned the hand so the fingertips faced the crowd. "You say you never went near the flames tonight."
The damaged skin was impossible to miss now - the reddened fingertips, the small blisters, and the unmistakable signs of recent burns.
Aurora’s gaze locked onto Lyria’s horrified face. Then she asked the question that instantly made the entire clearing erupt into shocked whispers. "Then how do you explain the burns on your fingers?"