The cold came first, and then the dark.
Kofi hung in the black water with Bell’s chains wrapped around his arms and his legs, and they pulled him down. He couldn’t tell how far. There was no up anymore, no down, only the weight dragging at him and the cold pressing in on every side. The faint grey glow of the fog above had gone out a long time ago.
His lungs were burning. They had been burning for what felt like an hour. He knew it couldn’t have been that long. He knew that in a moment, his body was going to do what every drowning body does. It was going to open its mouth and breathe in the sea.
He knew because he had felt it once before.
Ninety years old, wading out off the black rocks at Brook’s Reach with his trousers rolled to the knee and then not rolled, and then nothing rolled at all, because the water was at his chest and then his chin. He remembered the moment his body had stopped obeying him and drawn its breath. He remembered the cold rushing in. He remembered the relief.
There was no relief this time. There was only Phibba, grey on her litter at the top of the cliff. Toby tied to a mast. Bess with her cleaver in the doorway of the last house, and eleven children behind her. Clementine’s dry leaf, still tucked inside his shirt against his heart.
I counted you out, and I’m counting you back in.
His mouth opened.
The sea came in.
It filled his throat and his chest, cold and heavy and salt, and the burning stopped, and the dark grew darker, and he felt himself begin to come apart at the edges the way the dying come apart. Slowly. Softly. Like sugar in water.
Somewhere close, somebody laughed.
It was a deep laugh. Rough. Delighted. The sound of dirt falling on a coffin lid, and he knew it, and he had heard it before, sitting on a gravestone in the starlight above Grann Rose’s village with a cigar in its teeth.
Oh no, shipwright. The voice came from everywhere and nowhere, from the black water and the bones of his own skull. No, no, no. Not tonight. I ain’t dug your hole yet.
Something happened to Kofi’s body.
He felt it begin in his chest, where the sea had rushed in. A hardness. A stiffening. It spread out from his heart along his ribs, down his arms, into his hands. His skin went rigid. His fingers locked. For one long, terrible heartbeat, he couldn’t feel his flesh at all, only grain. Wood grain, running the length of his bones. Dark and close and hard, the color of old mahogany, the smell of new-cut timber and grave dirt in his nose.
He had turned to coffin wood.
The sea couldn’t drown wood. The cold couldn’t stop a heart that had stopped being a heart.
There it is, the Baron said, very pleased. Now wake up, shipwright. You got work.
And Kofi woke.
His eyes opened, and he could see.
There was no light in the black water. There couldn’t have been. But he could see anyway. The world had gone white at the edges, pale and bright, as though he were looking at everything through a sheet of frost. And the water around him was full of people.
The drowned.
Hundreds of them. They hung in the dark all around him, near and far, as far as his new eyes could reach. Sailors with weed in their hair. Fishermen. A woman in a long dress whose hair floated around her head like smoke. Men with chains on their ankles. Children. They were all looking at him.
Before, they had been whispers. Voices without shapes. Now he could see every one of them clearly, their faces, their hands, the expressions in their eyes. And they could see him.
Shipwright, they said. Not whispering anymore. Speaking. Shipwright. You came back.
The wood went out of his body. It drained away as quickly as it had come, and his flesh was his own again, cold and aching. His chest heaved. And impossibly, terribly, there was air in it. He didn’t know how. He didn’t ask.
Bell’s chains were still around him. Grey and ghostly, wrapped around his arms and his legs and his chest, and they were still pulling him down, deeper.
He looked at them with his white eyes, and he could see them now for what they were. Not iron. Spirit. The chains of the Rolling Calf, the ghost of a dishonest man, dragging behind it everything it had ever claimed was its own.
He needed his blade.
He didn’t know where it was. Somewhere on the ledge, far above him in the fog. He’d felt it slip out of his hand when Bell’s chains dragged him across the rock. The sheath had fallen even before that. Both halves, lost.
He thought about them. The black cane. The bone skull with its tiny top hat. The grave-cross sheath that his left hand had learned to swing like a club. He thought about the night they had risen out of the grave dirt at the foot of the Baron’s cross, and how cold the wood had been in his palm, and how it had felt like something that belonged to him and always had.
He stretched out his right hand into the black water.
Come here, he thought.
On the ledge at the mouth of the cave, in the fog, the dark blade was lying in a crack in the rock where it had fallen.
It moved.
It trembled first, rattling against the stone. Then it lifted. It rose straight up off the ledge into the fog, point down, hanging in the air. Then it turned, slowly, until its point aimed at the black water below the cave mouth.
And it flew.
Six paces away, the grave-cross sheath lay on the rock where Kofi’s left hand had dropped it. It lifted too. It spun once in the air and shot after the blade.
Bell was standing at the edge of the ledge looking down at the water where Kofi had sunk. He felt them go past him. Two dark streaks through the fog, faster than musket balls, hissing past his shoulder close enough to stir his hair. He spun. They were gone. Two small splashes in the black water far below, and nothing.
Bell stared at the water.
For the first time in a very long time, he felt something cold move in his own chest.
The blade hit Kofi’s right palm so hard it nearly took his arm off at the shoulder.
His fingers closed around the bone skull. A heartbeat later, the sheath slammed into his left hand, and the cold of the wood went up through his arms and into his chest and out along his spine, and every part of him came awake at once.
He swung the blade.
It went through Bell’s chains like they were cobwebs. The links didn’t break. They tore, the way smoke tears when you pass your hand through it, and the chain around his right arm came apart into grey wisps and was gone. He cut again. The chain around his chest. The one on his legs. The one on his left arm, which had burned him on the ledge. He cut it last, and as it tore away, the burn underneath went cold.
He was free.
He hung in the black water with the blade in one hand and the sheath in the other, and the drowned all around him, watching.
Then something below him moved.
He felt it before he saw it. The whole sea shifted. A pressure came up from beneath, slow and enormous, as though the bottom of the cove itself was rising toward him. The drowned around him drew back. Not in fear. They drew back the way people step aside when someone important walks into a room.
Up out of the deep dark below, something came.
It was bigger than the Morning Star. He couldn’t see all of it at once. Only pieces, rising out of the black one after another. A long grey flank, scarred and pale, sliding past him like the hull of a ship. A great fin, ragged at the edges. Then arms. Many arms, long and thick and curling, the color of old bruises, each one lined underneath with pale round cups the size of dinner plates. They uncoiled slowly in the water all around him. Surrounding him.
Then the head.
It rose up in front of him until it filled the whole of his white sight. A shark’s head, blunt and huge and pale, with a mouth that could have swallowed a longboat whole. Rows of teeth, white and jagged. And an eye. One great dark eye, as wide across as he was tall, ringed with pale gold, staring at him from an arm’s length away.
The old man below.
The Lusca.
Kofi didn’t move. He couldn’t have, if he’d wanted to. He hung there in the water in front of that eye, and it looked at him, and the arms curled slowly around him without touching.
The eye moved.
It went from his face, slowly, down to his chest.
Under his torn shirt, something was glowing. Warm and gold, faint at first, then brighter, shining through the cloth. A small round light in the shape of a sun.
The compass.
It had never glowed like this. In the graveyard, when the Baron saw it, it had shone softly through his shirt for a heartbeat and gone dark. Now it blazed. Gold light poured out of it into the black water, lighting up the Lusca’s pale face and its great dark eye and the drowned all around, turning the water around Kofi the color of honey.
The Lusca stopped moving.
All of it. The arms stopped curling. The great flank stopped sliding. The whole vast body went still in the water, as if it were holding its breath.
Then the eye closed. Slowly. And opened again.
Kofi didn’t know how he knew. He couldn’t have explained it to anyone. But it was the slow blink of something very old looking at something it remembered. Something it hadn’t seen in a long, long time.
Weeks ago, on the way into the Hollow for the first time, this same great thing had risen under their boat and paused at Kofi longer than at anyone else. He had never understood why.
He understood now. It hadn’t been looking at him.
It had been looking at what he carried.
The arms drew back. The great head turned, slowly, in the water. The eye left him. And the Lusca looked up. Toward the surface. Toward the faint, far-off shadows of hulls riding on the water above. The longboats. The black sloop. And far out, the crippled shape of the Vigilant.
Toward the men who had stretched cold iron across its door.
Somewhere far above, Ezinne’s drum was still beating. Hard and fast. Wake up. The door’s open. Come and see.
The Lusca rose.
It went past Kofi in a long grey rush, so close that the wash of its passing spun him over in the water. Arms trailing. Fin slicing. Up toward the surface and the ships and the sound of the drum.
The drowned turned back to Kofi.
Up, shipwright, they said. Go up. They need you up there.
He kicked for the surface.
On the clifftop above the Boiling Hole, Yaw was on his knees, and the fire was coming down.
It filled his whole sight. A ball of flame as big as a man, blue at the heart, orange at the edges, roaring like a furnace with the door thrown open. The heat of it hit his face and dried his eyes. His pistols were empty. The veves on their frames had gone dark. Latch flickered beside him, thin and pale as smoke, barely a dog at all.
There was a voice in the fire.
It came out of the roar. Laughing. Cross’s voice, and not Cross’s voice, both at once.
"You spent it all, boy." The fireball dropped lower. "Every bit. Every shot. Every dog. You threw it at me like a drunk throwing coin across a tavern floor, and now you’ve got nothing left in your purse."
Yaw couldn’t argue. It was true. He’d fired every Hound Shot he had at the decoy and the fire. He’d sent Latch in twice. And now the rope around his heart was pulled so tight he could barely breathe.
"That’s your first lesson," the voice in the fire said. "Power isn’t a pistol you fire till it’s empty. It’s a well. And you just drank yours dry."
It came down.
Yaw didn’t think. He threw himself sideways, hit the rock on his shoulder, and his hand slapped flat against the stone of the clifftop.
Open, he thought. Please. Open.
The veve flared. Not on his pistols this time. On the rock under his palm. A crossed staff and a gate, drawn in orange light on the bare stone, and the rock went soft under his hand. He fell into it.
He fell through.
It was like stepping through a doorway in the dark. One moment he was on the clifftop with the fire coming down on him. The next he was tumbling out of the stone on the far side of a boulder ten paces away, rolling across the scrub, coming up on his knees with his heart hammering.
Behind him, the fireball hit the place where he’d been and blew apart the rock.
He stared at his own hand.
He’d opened doors before. The wall in the tunnel. The gate on the fourth road. But he had never thought of it like this. A door was a way through. A door was a way out. Anywhere he could put his hand on something solid, he could make a way out of where he was.
"Interesting," said the voice in the fire. It had risen back into the air and was turning slowly, looking for him. "Very interesting. Legba’s boy has a trick."
Yaw kept low behind the boulder. His whole body was shaking. That had cost him too. Less than a Hound Shot, but not nothing. He could feel it, the rope around his heart drawn a little tighter.
A well, he thought. Not a pistol. A well.
Across the clifftop, Clementine was lying on the rock where Cross had dropped her. She was grey. Her arm was bleeding where his mouth had been. But she was moving. She had rolled onto her side and was dragging herself, very slowly, toward the scrub where her staff had fallen.
Beyond her, the old silk-cotton tree was still burning. Flame ran up its trunk into the branches, and burning leaves drifted down across the clifftop like orange snow.
And beyond that, at the edge of the cliff, Phibba sat upright on her litter with the cold pipe in her teeth and fog pouring out of her mouth. Barnaby knelt in front of her with a machete. Cassia knelt behind her, holding her up. Quamin lay on the rock beside the litter with his shoulder soaked in blood, a musket across his knees.
The fireball turned toward them.
Yaw saw it. He saw it turn in the air, slow and considering, and he saw what it was looking at. Not him. Not Clementine. The old woman on the litter, who couldn’t move, who couldn’t defend herself, and who was the only thing on the whole island keeping the fog over the cove.
He didn’t have enough in him for a Hound Shot. He knew it. He could feel it.
He whistled.
Latch came. The yellow dog came out of the smoke and the scrub, flickering, half there and half not, and stopped in front of the litter with his legs braced and his hackles up. He didn’t grow. There wasn’t enough in Yaw to make him grow. He just stood there, a small yellow dog with one floppy ear, between the fire and the old woman, and he snarled.
The fireball stopped.
It hung in the air, roaring, looking down at the dog.
"A puppy," said the voice in the fire. "You’ve sent a puppy."
"He’s not a puppy," Yaw said. His voice cracked. "He’s a door. He’s standing in the door."
The fireball laughed.
Then, under the laugh, Yaw heard something else.
It came from inside the fire. From underneath Cross’s voice. Thin and dry and ancient, like old paper rustling, a voice with no throat and no breath. It wasn’t English. It wasn’t any language he’d ever heard. But he understood it the way he understood everything now, since the crossroads. Every tongue, every word, even the ones nobody had spoken aloud in a thousand years.
Hungry, the voice was saying. Hungry hungry hungry. Burning. Burning it all. Burning him. Too long out of the skin. Too much spent. Hungry.
Yaw went still.
Fed on the root woman, the thin voice went on, but not enough, not enough, never enough. Need more. Need the old one. The old one is full. Full of smoke and years. Feed on the old one.
It was the Ol’ Higue. The spirit. Inside the fire. And it was starving.
Yaw stared up at the fireball.
Cross was laughing. Cross was mocking him, turning slowly in the air, enjoying himself. But underneath all of it, the thing that gave him his power was eating him alive from the inside. Every moment he stayed out of his skin. Every working he spent. The hunger was burning through him, and he couldn’t stop it.
He needed to feed. Soon. And there was only one meal on this cliff that would fill him.
"You’re hungry," Yaw said out loud.
The fireball stopped laughing.
"What did you say, boy?"
"You’re starving." Yaw got slowly to his feet behind the boulder. His knees shook. He made them stop. "I can hear it. Your spirit. It’s eating you. Every breath you’re out of that skin, it’s eating you." He took a step out from behind the rock. "That’s why you went for the auntie first. That’s why you want the old woman. You can’t hold that fire much longer."
The fireball turned toward him.
For a long moment, it didn’t say anything at all.
"Clever," it said finally. The mocking was gone from the voice now. It was quieter. Colder. "Clever boy. Second lesson, then. Free of charge." It drifted closer. "Knowing what’s killing your enemy doesn’t help you if he kills you first."
It came at him.
In the Hollow, the soldiers were halfway up the terraces.
Quashie lay on his back on the path with his hands clawing at his chest and his face gone dark. He couldn’t breathe. He couldn’t move. He could only stare up at the glowing roof of the cavern and make small, terrible sounds.
At the foot of the path, Lieutenant Fenwick hadn’t moved. He stood with his spontoon in one hand, perfectly still, his hollow eyes fixed on Quashie. He didn’t blink. He didn’t turn his head. He didn’t watch his men climbing past him. He only watched the old man on the path.
Tanty Abba knelt over Quashie, pulling at him, trying to drag him up the path. He didn’t budge. It was as though someone had laid a millstone on his chest.
"Let him go," she shouted down at Fenwick. Her voice was shaking with fury. "Let him go, you devil!"
Fenwick didn’t even look at her.
Three soldiers were coming up past them. Then five. Bayonets fixed, faces set, climbing toward the roofless house against the cavern wall.
In the doorway of that house, Bess stood with her cleaver.
She had never fought anybody. Not really. She had fought for rations, and for her galley, and for the right to tell Toby when his stew needed more salt. She had swung a cleaver at a boarder once at the cove and missed. Her hands were shaking so hard she was afraid she’d drop it.
Behind her, packed into the little house, fourteen children were crying. Some of them loudly. Most of them silently, which was worse.
She looked down the path at the soldiers climbing toward her. At the bayonets.
Then she looked at Fenwick at the bottom of the path, standing so very still, staring at Quashie with those hollow eyes.
He hasn’t looked away, she thought. Not once. Not even to see where his men are going.
Behind her, a small hand caught at her skirt.
She looked down. It was Nell. Her face was wet. She was holding something out. A sack. A small one, stained and floury, that she had dragged out of the corner of the house where Tanty Abba had stored the last of the dried cassava flour they’d saved from the flood.
"Bess," Nell whispered. "The man at the bottom. He keeps looking."
Bess stared at the sack.
On the ledge at the mouth of the cave, the black water exploded.
It came up in a geyser, a tower of white spray and grey fog, rising twenty feet into the air out of the place where Kofi had gone under. The fog roared up with it, pouring out of the sea in a column so thick it blotted out the cliff. And out of the top of the column, as the water fell back, something came flying.
Kofi landed on the ledge on his feet.
He landed hard. The rock jarred up through his knees and into his teeth. Water streamed off him. The blade was in his right hand, the sheath in his left. His shirt had been torn half off him by the chains, and under its rags the compass hung on its cord against his bare chest, still glowing. Gold. Bright as a lamp.
His eyes were white.
Bell stood ten paces away.
He had his saber up. The ghostly chains still wrapped his body, trailing onto the rock behind him, and in the fog at his back, the great shape of the Rolling Calf loomed, its burning eyes fixed on Kofi.
But Bell wasn’t looking at Kofi’s eyes.
He was looking at his chest.
At the small round thing hanging there on its cord, pouring out golden light. At the little sun worked into its face.
Something changed in Bell’s face. Kofi saw it. Saw the cold, flat, careful mask crack, just for an instant, and something underneath it show through. Something hungry. Something almost like awe.
"So it’s you," Bell said softly.
Kofi didn’t know what he meant. He didn’t care.
"A compass bearing the mark of a sun on its face," Bell murmured. He didn’t seem to be talking to Kofi at all. His eyes hadn’t left the gold light. "Every officer on the Jamaica station has heard the rumors. The Chancery has been tearing the islands apart looking for it for months. And it’s been hanging around the neck of a runaway shipwright the whole time."
He looked up. Met Kofi’s white eyes.
"Do you even know what you’re carrying, Brook?"
"I know what it brought me," Kofi said.
His voice came out strange. Deep. Echoing a little at the edges, as though something else were speaking it with him.
"Then you know more than the Crown does." Bell’s saber came up, and the chains around him began to rattle. "But it doesn’t matter. Hand it over and I’ll make your end quick. Or don’t, and I’ll take it off your body."
The clanking came again. From every side. The terrible dread of it crawled up out of the rock and closed around Kofi’s throat. His hands began to shake.
Then, from the black water below the ledge, a voice.
Don’t listen, shipwright. It’s only chains. Only noise.
And another. And another. The drowned, rising up in the water around the ledge, their pale faces turned up toward him in the fog.
It’s only chains. We know chains. We wore them.
The dread didn’t go away. But under it, something else was rising. Something steadier. A hundred voices in the water below him, and every one of them unafraid.
Kofi’s hands stopped shaking.
He smiled.
Bell came.
One step was a hammer blow. The rock under his boot cracked, and fire spat out of the crack. The next was a dancer’s step, quick and light. He was moving the way he’d moved before, impossible to read, slow-fast-slow, coming at Kofi from three directions at once.
But Kofi wasn’t watching Bell anymore.
He was watching the ledge.
He had worked in a shipyard for sixty-seven years. He knew wood and he knew stone, and he knew what happened to a man’s feet when he put them in the wrong place. The ledge in front of him was wet. Half of it was covered in black weed from the tide. There was a crack running across it, where Bell’s first stomp had split it. There was a hollow, near the edge, where the sea had worn a bowl in the rock. There was a lip of loose stone where the ledge met the cliff.
Bell’s heavy step had to land on solid rock, or it would break through.
Bell’s quick step couldn’t land on weed, or it would slide.
There were only so many places on that ledge a man could put his feet.
Kofi watched the rock, and when Bell’s heavy foot came down, he was already moving to where the quick step had to land.
The blade came across, low. Bell twisted, and the dark steel opened his coat and the skin underneath it across his ribs. Bell grunted. It was the first sound of pain Kofi had ever heard him make.
The saber came back at Kofi’s head. He threw up the sheath. The blow rang off the black wood and drove him a step back, but he held it.
Bell stamped.
The rock split open right between them, and fire poured up out of the crack. A wall of it. Orange and white and hellish, roaring up as high as a man’s head. The heat hit Kofi’s face like a fist.
He thrust the sheath out in front of him with both hands.
He didn’t know what he was doing. His body did. Something rose up in front of him out of the grey fog. A wall. Grey and cold, like a slab of old headstone, square-shouldered and solid, with a cross cut into the middle of it. He felt the cold of it go out of his hands and into the stone. Grave cold. The cold of a cellar where the dead are laid.
The fire hit the wall and broke against it.
It poured around both sides of the grey stone, roaring and hissing. But where the fire touched the stone, it guttered and died, as if it had been thrown on wet earth. Behind the wall, Kofi stood in the cold and the fog, untouched.
On the far side of the fire, Bell stared.
"Cimetière," Kofi breathed. He didn’t know where the word came from. It was in his mouth, the way the language of the dead had been in Yaw’s.
The wall faded. The fire died with it.
Bell breathed out.
The black smoke came again. Thick, oily, stinking of sulfur, boiling out of Bell’s mouth and across the ledge toward Kofi. It had blinded him last time. It had choked him. It had filled his head with Thorne and Sabina and the hold of the Deliverance.
This time, Kofi breathed out too.
The fog came out of him. Not out of the blade this time. Out of his mouth. Grey and cold and sweet-smelling, rolling out across the ledge to meet the black smoke.
They hit in the middle.
The grey and the black twisted around each other, churning, boiling, neither giving ground. Where they met, the air crackled. Kofi felt the poison of the sulfur pushing against him. He pushed back. Not hard. The way Anne had taught him. Don’t shove. Hold the door.
The black smoke thinned.
It thinned and frayed and came apart into wisps, and the grey fog rolled over it and swallowed it. Bell staggered back a step out of the cloud, coughing.
Kofi didn’t wait.
He drove the iron-capped tip of the sheath down into the rock at his feet and dragged it toward Bell in one long stroke. The tip carved through the stone like a plough through wet earth. A trench opened in the ledge, as long as a man and as deep as a grave, black and cold and smelling of turned soil.
Out of it, hands came.
Bony hands. Grey and skeletal, dozens of them, clawing up out of the trench like the dead climbing out of an open grave. They reached across the rock toward Bell.
Bell launched himself forward in one of his impossible bursts. Heavy step. Quick step. Heavy—
The hands caught him mid-stride.
They wrapped around his ankles. Around his mismatched feet. One around a heavy boot that came down like a hoof, one around a quick boot that touched the stone like a dancer’s. They held on.
Bell went down.
He hit the ledge on his face with a crash that Kofi felt through his feet. His saber skittered across the wet stone. The ghostly chains around him rattled and jangled, tangled in the bony fingers.
For the first time since Kofi had known him, Captain Edmund Bell was lying on the ground.
The fog swirled. The drum beat. The hands held.
Kofi stood over the open grave with the blade in one hand and the sheath in the other, breathing hard. His nose was bleeding. He could feel it running down his lip, warm and salt. His hands were cold, colder than they’d ever been, a cold that went all the way into his bones.
Every working cost something. He’d known that. He hadn’t known how much.
On the ledge, Bell lifted his head.
He looked back at the grey hands wrapped around his ankles. At the trench. At Kofi, standing over him with white eyes and blood on his lip.
Then Bell began to laugh.
It was a low sound. Quiet. Almost gentle.
"Good," he said. "Good, Brook. That’s very good." He pushed himself up on his hands. "Now let me show you what I am."
The fire in the cracks in the rock flared up.
Behind Bell, in the fog, the shape of the Rolling Calf moved. It didn’t loom anymore. It came down. The great black shoulder, the chain collar, the burning eyes, all of it came down out of the fog and into Bell, the way water pours into a cup.
Bell changed.
His shoulders swelled. His back hunched and thickened, his coat splitting along the seams. His neck grew short and massive. His head lowered. When he lifted his face again, it wasn’t quite a face anymore. It was too broad. Too heavy across the brow. His nose had flattened and widened, and his eyes had gone red as coals in a forge, and the breath that came out of him smoked.
The bony hands around his ankles snapped like dry twigs.
Bell rose to his feet. He stood taller than he had before. Heavier. His heavy foot came down on the ledge, and it wasn’t a boot anymore. It was a hoof. Black and cloven and huge. The rock cracked under it in a star, and fire ran out along every crack.
Chains rattled around his neck, a collar of them, rusted and heavy.
He lowered his head.
Kofi had seen bulls charge in the pens at Brook’s Reach. He knew what it looked like when a bull lowered its head and planted its forefeet and the muscle bunched across its shoulders.
He raised the sheath and set his feet.
Bell charged.