Bell hit him like a falling mast.
Kofi had the sheath up and his feet set. It didn’t matter. The charge came across the ledge in three strides, the first a hammering hoof that cracked the rock, the second a lunge so fast Kofi only saw the blur of it, the third a wall of black shoulder and rusted chain and heat. It struck the sheath dead center. The black wood held. Kofi didn’t.
His feet left the ledge.
He went backward through the fog with the world turning over around him, sky and rock and black water and sky again. He saw the mouth of the cave go past, upside down. He saw the red coals of Bell’s eyes, already far away. Then he hit something hard with his shoulder and something harder with his hip, and he was sliding down a slope of wet stone in a tangle of weed and spray, and then cold water closed over his legs.
He lay in the shallows below the cliff and couldn’t breathe.
The rocks here were broken and tumbled, a slope of great black boulders running down from the foot of the cliff into the sea. The tide had pulled back off them and left them slick with weed. Between them, in channels of black water, three empty longboats knocked and drifted, the ones Bell’s men had rowed in to lay the chain. Lanterns still burned in two of them, shuttered and swinging, throwing jumping light across the rocks.
He still had the blade. He still had the sheath. His left hand had locked around it so tightly he couldn’t have let go if he’d wanted to.
Above him, on the edge of the ledge, the fog swirled. Something heavy came down out of it.
Bell landed on the rocks ten paces up the slope. His hooves struck the stone, and two boulders cracked, and fire ran out of the cracks and hissed into the wet weed. He straightened. The chain collar rattled around his thick neck. The red eyes found Kofi in the shallows and fixed on him.
Kofi rolled to his knees in the water.
His ribs screamed. He thought one of them might be broken. He thought about the rib on the Deliverance, the doubled timber, the knots clustered too close.
Weak point. Reinforce it.
He got up.
Bell came down the slope.
He didn’t charge this time. He walked, heavy hoof and quick boot, and the rocks broke under one and barely felt the other. The ghostly chains trailed behind him, clanking across the stone, and the dread came with them. It crept up out of the water into Kofi’s legs and up his spine.
Kofi backed into the channel between two boulders, up to his thighs in black water. A longboat bumped against his hip, empty, a lantern swinging in its bow.
He knew boats.
He knew how they sat in the water and how they moved. He knew that a longboat in a narrow channel, with no one aboard and no weight in her, would roll as easily as a barrel if you put your shoulder under her gunwale and heaved.
Bell reached the edge of the channel. He stepped down onto the nearest boulder above the water, his heavy hoof raised for the next step, ready to come down on the boat’s gunwale and across her to Kofi.
Kofi put his shoulder under the near gunwale and heaved.
The longboat rolled. It turned right over in the narrow channel, her bottom coming up out of the water black and slick, and the lantern in her bow tumbled out and went into the sea with a hiss. Bell’s hoof came down where the gunwale should have been. It came down on the boat’s upturned keel instead. Wet, curved, rolling.
His hoof skidded.
He went down on one knee on the overturned hull, and the boat rolled again under his weight. He threw out an arm and caught a boulder to keep from going into the water.
Kofi was already over the hull. The blade cut down at Bell’s neck.
The saber caught it. Somehow, half fallen, with one knee on a rolling boat, Bell caught it. The two blades scraped together, and Bell’s red eyes stared into Kofi’s white ones from a hand’s width away, and his breath came out smoking.
"Clever," Bell said.
He heaved. Kofi went flying backward off the boat into the channel.
He came up spitting seawater. Bell was coming across the overturned hull at him, both feet on the keel now, balanced. Learning. Kofi saw it. He had tricked Bell once with the boat, and Bell had watched, and Bell would not be tricked that way again.
Kofi waded backward into deeper water, up to his waist, his chest. The cold went into him.
And under him, in the black water, he felt the drowned.
They had followed him down the cliff. He could feel them all around his legs, pale shapes in the dark water, crowding close. Waiting. They had waited for him in the cove, and in the deep where he had sunk, and now they were here, gathered in the channel between the rocks, looking up at him with their patient faces.
He had never asked them for anything. He had only ever carried them.
"Help me," he whispered.
They came up out of the water.
Bell had stepped off the boat’s hull onto the rocks at the channel’s edge. He was gathering himself to spring. And the water around his hooves boiled, and hands came up out of it. Pale hands. Grey hands, with weed tangled in their fingers. Dozens of them. They closed around his ankles and his hocks and the heavy black hoof and the quick human boot. Then faces came up after the hands, pale faces with empty eyes, and arms wrapped around his legs and his knees, and they pulled.
Bell roared.
It wasn’t a man’s sound. It came out of the bull’s chest that he’d grown, deep and furious. He staggered. The drowned held on. Sailors in rotted shirts. Fishermen. A woman with her hair floating loose. Men with iron rings still rusted around their ankles, dragging at the legs of the man whose spirit had been made of chains.
For a moment, Kofi thought they would pull him down into the sea.
Then Bell’s chains caught fire.
The ghostly chains wrapped around his body and trailing from his shoulders flared up red. Then white. They burned with the same hellfire that had burned Kofi’s arm on the ledge. Bell flexed his huge shoulders, and the burning chains whipped out in a circle around him, low across the water, through the drowned.
They burned away.
Not like flesh. Like paper thrown on a fire. One moment, a drowned sailor had his arms around Bell’s knee. The next, there was a flare of white light and a wisp of grey smoke drifting away over the water, and nothing.
Kofi felt it.
He felt every one of them go. It went through him like a thread pulled out of his chest. Ten threads. Twenty. Every one of the drowned who had come up out of the water at his asking, and every one of them gone, burned up by Bell’s chains, and every one of them taking a little piece of Kofi with it.
He doubled over in the water.
Something warm was running down his face. He touched his lip and his fingers came away dark. His nose was bleeding. Not a trickle. A steady stream. His hands had gone numb from the fingers to the wrists. When he lifted his head, he saw frost on the water around him, a thin white skin of ice spreading out from his body across the black channel, in the tropics, in August.
Every working cost something. He had never paid so much.
Bell stood on the rocks above the channel with smoke rising off his burning chains. The drowned were gone from around his legs.
He looked down at Kofi in the water.
"They were dead already, Brook," he said. His voice had gone deep, rough, half a bellow. "You can’t win a war with the dead."
On the clifftop above the Boiling Hole, Yaw rolled through the rock again.
He didn’t think about it anymore. The fire came at him and his hand was already on the stone, and the veve flared under his palm, and the rock opened and swallowed him and put him out on the far side of a boulder twelve paces away. He came up on one knee with his pistol up.
That was the fourth time. Each one had cost a little less than the last.
He’d figured out why on the second one. The first time, he’d fought the door. He’d shoved at it, begged it, forced it open with everything he had, the way he’d forced his Hound Shots out at the cove. It had nearly emptied him.
The second time, he’d just asked.
Open. That was all. The way you’d knock on the door of a friend’s house. The rock had opened like it was glad to.
A well, he thought. Not a pistol. A well. And you don’t drain a well by asking it for a cup of water.
The fireball wheeled in the air above the clifftop, roaring, looking for him. It was smaller than it had been when it first tore out of Cross’s skin. He could see that now. Smaller, and dimmer at the edges. The blue heart of it flickered.
Hungry, whispered the thin, dry voice underneath the roar. Hungry hungry. Burning him up. Too long. Too long out. Need. Need. Need.
"You’re shrinking, Cross," Yaw called. He kept his back to the boulder. "Did you notice?"
The fireball stopped turning. It hung there, crackling.
"Your spirit’s eating you," Yaw said. "I can hear it. Every breath you’re out of that skin, it’s eating you alive. You spent so much killing your decoy and chasing me through the rock, you’ve got almost nothing left." He swallowed. "You told me I spent my strength like a drunk. Look at yourself."
For a long moment, the fire didn’t answer.
Then it laughed. But it was thin now. Strained.
"Third lesson, boy," it said. "When you’re losing, find something weaker than you."
It turned toward the litter.
Clementine had reached her staff.
It had cost her everything to do it. She had dragged herself across the rock on her elbows with Cross’s bite burning in her arm, the green light in her veins so faint she could barely see it. Her fingers closed around the twisted mangrove wood. The trees of the island were still whispering to her, all of them, the gumbo limbo and the mahogany and the poisonwood. And the old silk-cotton, burning at the edge of the Boiling Hole, screaming.
She hadn’t been able to help it. She knew that. Something older than her had taken hold of her when Cross set that tree alight. It had dragged her across the clifftop at him, away from Phibba, away from everything. She’d known while it was happening that she was being baited. She had gone anyway. She’d had no choice.
Now the fire was turning toward Phibba, and she was not going to let it.
She drove the staff into a crack in the rock.
"Oka-rima," she breathed. "Mara-vek."
Roots came up out of the clifftop. Thick ones. Old ones. The roots of every tree within fifty paces came heaving up out of the thin soil and the cracks in the stone. They wove together in the air in front of the litter into a net, a wall, a cage of living wood between the fireball and the old woman.
The fireball hit the roots.
They caught. Of course they caught. Roots were wood, and wood burns. The fire ran along them in an instant, every root flaring up orange, and Clementine screamed. She felt every one burn. She felt them through her staff, through her hands, through her veins, as though it were her own flesh on fire.
She held on as long as she could.
Then the roots fell apart in burning pieces, and the fire came through.
Clementine collapsed against her staff. Her lungs heaved. Her hands were blistered where she’d gripped the wood. She lay on the rock and stared at the burning roots and understood something she should have understood from the start.
You don’t fight fire with wood.
Her hand went, without her thinking, to the little leather pouch at her belt. Coarse grey salt. She’d carried it for twenty years, to clean wounds and draw out poison and scrub the blood off her hands after a birth.
Across the clifftop, in the firelight, she could see Cross’s empty skin lying crumpled on the rock where he’d torn out of it. Its face was still Cross’s face. Its mouth was still open.
She stared at it.
The ball came out of the fog with a sound like the sky tearing.
Nobody saw it coming. Far below, out on the water, Bosun Pike was firing the Vigilant’s guns blind into the fog at the cliffs, gun after gun, because he couldn’t see anything and his captain was somewhere in that grey and he had to do something. Most of the balls hit the cliff face and threw up rock. One went high.
It came over the edge of the clifftop at the height of a man’s chest.
Barnaby saw it. Nobody ever knew how. Maybe he heard it. Maybe he was just looking the right way. He was kneeling in front of Phibba’s litter with his machete in his hand, watching the fire, and he turned his head toward the edge of the cliff, and something changed in his face.
He threw himself backward across the litter, across Phibba.
The ball took him.
It didn’t make a sound when it hit him. There was only the sound of it hitting the rock beyond the litter and shattering, and stone chips flying, and a great puff of dust. Then Barnaby was lying across Phibba’s legs and the litter and the rock beyond, very still. His machete had flown out of his hand and lay ten paces away.
Cassia screamed his name.
Phibba didn’t move. She was still sitting upright on the litter, the cold pipe in her teeth, fog pouring out of her mouth and her nostrils and the empty bowl. She didn’t look down. She didn’t stop.
But her eyes were wet.
Under the fog, under the roar of the fireball and the drum and the guns, Yaw heard her voice. It was very thin. It was barely there.
"Rest easy, boy," Phibba whispered. "Rest easy. I’ll see you soon."
The fireball came down on the litter.
It came slowly now. Not the dive it had made at Yaw. A slow descent, like a hawk settling onto a kill, roaring and crackling, dimmer than it had been, smaller, but hungry. So hungry. Yaw could hear it. The thin voice underneath the roar wasn’t even words anymore. Just a long, dry, endless whisper. Need need need need need.
Latch stood in front of the litter.
He had grown again. Not much. Not to his full height. He was the size of a big hound now, grey-gold and flickering, his hackles standing up all down his back. Between his front paws lay Barnaby’s body. Behind him, Phibba. He bared his teeth at the fire coming down, and the sound that came out of him wasn’t a dog’s growl. It was older than that.
The fireball stopped.
It hung in the air above Latch, just out of reach of his jaws. It looked down at the dog standing between it and the old woman. And then it looked across the clifftop, through the smoke and the falling burning leaves, at Yaw.
When the voice came out of it this time, it was quiet. Almost polite.
"Legba’s boy," Cross said. "You know your own Law, don’t you?"
Yaw went cold.
"I know the old stories too, boy. I’ve been hunting runaways on these islands for twenty years. I know Legba. Opener of the way. Keeper of the crossroads. Never closes a door on anyone seeking passage." The fire flickered. "Not the good ones. Not the bad ones."
Yaw’s hands were shaking on his pistol.
"Not even," Cross said softly, "the one you want dead."
The fireball drifted lower. Over Latch’s head. Toward the old woman on the litter, who sat with her eyes closed and the fog pouring out of her mouth.
"So I’m asking you, gatekeeper," Cross said. "I’m seeking passage. Let me pass."
The words went into Yaw like a knife.
He felt his Law tighten around him. It wasn’t something he had to think about. It was in his chest, in his hands, in the veves burned into his pistols. Never close a door on someone seeking passage. He had said I keep it to an old man on a rock at a crossroads with his whole heart. And the Law heard Cross asking.
Latch heard it too.
The dog’s snarl faltered. His hackles went down. He looked back over his shoulder at Yaw, and his ears were flat against his head, and his eyes were confused and sorry, and he began, slowly, to step aside.
"No," Yaw said. "Latch. No."
The dog stopped. Halfway. Trembling. Caught between the Law and the boy he belonged to.
Yaw stood up from behind the boulder.
He didn’t know what to do. He knew that if he broke his Law, something would come for him. Grann Rose had told them all on the mountain. A slip weakens you. A real breaking costs you something you can’t get back. And a betrayal brings the spirit itself to collect.
He thought about the old man on the flat rock at the crossroads. The crooked cane. The yellow dog. The four roads.
Now you know my name, boy.
He thought about the gate on the fourth road. He’d opened it for the family running from something in the dark. And then for Cross, bleeding and afraid, limping through. He’d held it open and watched him go down the mountain.
He had never asked where the gate led. He had only opened it.
Yaw walked across the clifftop toward the litter.
He didn’t hurry. He walked through the falling burning leaves and the smoke and the drum, past Clementine on her knees with her staff, past Cassia sobbing over Barnaby. He came to the edge of the litter and stopped beside Latch.
He looked up at the fire.
"All right," he said. "Pass."
He knelt and laid his palm flat on the rock between Latch’s front paws.
Open, he thought. Not begging. Not shoving. Asking. The way you knock at the door of a friend’s house.
And open there.
The veve blazed under his hand. Brighter than it had ever burned, a staff and a gate drawn in fire on the stone. And the rock in front of Latch’s paws didn’t go soft. It went away.
A doorway opened in the clifftop. A dark square, the width of a man, the height of a man, lying flat on the stone like a trapdoor. And through it, instead of rock or dark tunnel or the far side of a boulder, there was water.
Black water. Salt water. Churning and heaving and bubbling, the way it had churned and heaved and bubbled every day for a thousand years. The Boiling Hole, a hundred paces inland, seen through a door in the stone. As though the doorway were a window looking straight down on it from above.
The fireball had already started to move. It had heard pass. It came down at the old woman on the litter, roaring, starving.
And the door was in its way.
It went through.
It couldn’t help it. It had asked for passage, and passage had been given. It went down through the door in the clifftop like water going down a drain, the whole roaring ball of it. And it came out on the other side, a hundred paces away, above the black salt water of the Boiling Hole.
Falling.
It hit the lake with a sound Yaw would hear in his dreams for the rest of his life. A shriek. Not Cross’s voice. Not even the thin dry voice of the hungry spirit. Something older and worse, a scream of pure agony. A column of white steam blasted up out of the Boiling Hole, higher than the trees. The salt water heaved and churned around it.
Yaw lifted his hand off the rock.
The door closed. The clifftop was solid stone again.
Across the bush, at the edge of the Boiling Hole, the steam was still rising, and in the middle of it, something was thrashing on the surface. A ball of fire, half drowned, guttering and sputtering, dragging itself through the salt water toward the shore.
Yaw sat down hard on the rock beside Latch.
He was shaking all over. The dog was pressed against his side. He put his arm around Latch’s neck and held on.
He had kept his Law. Cross had asked for passage, and Yaw had given it, and he had not closed the door. He had only chosen where it went.
Legba open the door, Phibba had said, back in the Hollow. That’s all he ever do. Open the door and stand in it.
But that wasn’t all. He understood that now. The old man at the crossroads didn’t just open the way. He decided which way.
Behind him on the litter, Phibba laughed. It was a tiny sound. A breath. But it was a laugh.
"Good boy," she whispered around her pipe. "Good boy, Legba’s boy."
The fog kept pouring.
In the Hollow, Bess took the flour sack.
She didn’t think about it. She looked at Nell’s wet face and the sack in her small hands. Then down the path at Fenwick. Standing so still at the bottom of the terraces with his eyes fixed on Quashie. Not blinking. Not looking anywhere else. Not even at his own men climbing past him.
He keeps looking, Nell had said.
Bess handed her cleaver to Tanty Abba. She took the sack in both hands. It weighed about as much as a small child. She had carried a hundred sacks like it down the galley ladder.
She walked out of the doorway onto the terrace.
The soldiers coming up the path saw her. Two of them raised their muskets. One of them shouted something. She didn’t hear what. She was looking past them, down the path, at Fenwick.
She swung the sack back over her shoulder, and she threw it.
It wasn’t a good throw. It went high and wobbled and nearly hit the soldier in front. But it went far enough. It came down at Fenwick’s feet, and hit the rock, and burst.
Flour went up in a white cloud.
It hit Fenwick full in the face. In his eyes, up his nose, in his open mouth. He staggered back, coughing, blinded, clawing at his face.
Up the path, Quashie sucked in a breath so deep and so loud it sounded like a man coming up from under water. His back arched off the stone. His hands, which had been clawing at his chest, flew out and hit the ground. He breathed. And breathed. And breathed again.
Bess was already running down the path.
She didn’t know she was going to do it until she was doing it. She went past the soldiers before they understood what was happening, past Quashie gasping on the path, down the terraces in a flat run, and on the way she snatched something off the ground by the old cook fire. Tanty Abba’s iron pot. The one the fish stew had been made in. Still black with soot.
Fenwick had got his eyes clear. He was blinking, white-faced with flour, tears streaming. He saw her coming. His spontoon came up.
His eyes found hers, and he stared.
Bess felt the weight come down.
It hit her in the chest like a falling sack of meal. Her breath went out of her. Her legs went heavy. Her arms went heavy. The pot was suddenly the weight of an anchor.
She didn’t stop.
She didn’t know how. She was two steps from him, and the weight was crushing her, and she couldn’t breathe, and she just didn’t stop. She took one step. Then the other. She swung the pot.
It hit Fenwick across the side of the head with a sound like a ship’s bell.
The weight vanished.
Fenwick folded up and went down on the rocks at the foot of the path, his spontoon clattering away across the stone, and didn’t move.
Bess stood over him with the pot.
Her hands were shaking. Her whole body was shaking. She looked down at the pot in her hands and then at the man lying on the ground, and she couldn’t make her fingers let go.
Behind her, up the path, Tanty Abba started to laugh. It was a high, wild, crying laugh.
"That’s my pot," Tanty Abba shouted down. "That’s my pot, girl!"
Bess looked up at her. She tried to say something. Nothing came out. Her hands were still locked around the iron handle, and her knees were trembling, and she realized she was crying.
She didn’t let go of the pot. She turned around and walked back up the path toward the soldiers with it.
At the shore of the lagoon, in the stern of the third boat, Jonah Lightbourn saw it all.
He saw the girl with the flour. He saw the old man on the path suck in his breath. He saw the lieutenant go down under the pot. And he saw the soldier halfway up the terraces, Corporal Haines, lift his musket and lay its barrel on the stone wall of a ruined house and aim it at the doorway of the last roofless hut against the cavern wall.
At the doorway full of children.
There was a little girl in front. Small. Thin. A scar on her shoulder, a ring of iron burned into the skin. She was holding the edge of the doorframe and staring down the path at Bess.
Lightbourn was out of the boat before he decided to be.
He had been a fisherman on the Nassau docks a week ago. He had been mending a net and talking to a girl he hoped to marry and thinking about nothing at all. Then a press gang had come out of an alley with clubs. He’d woken in the hold of a cutter with blood in his mouth, and a man had read him the Articles of War, and he’d understood that he belonged to the Navy now.
He hadn’t fired his musket all night. He’d held it and stared at it and stared at the children in the doorway.
He ran up the path.
Corporal Haines had his eye down the barrel. His finger was on the trigger.
Lightbourn reached him and swung his own musket like a club and knocked the corporal’s barrel up into the air. It went off. The ball cracked into the cavern roof high above and brought down a little shower of stone.
Haines spun around, his face purple.
"You—what in God’s name—"
"They’re children," Lightbourn said. His voice shook. "They’re only children, Corporal."
"They’re runaways! They’re property!" Haines threw down his empty musket and grabbed for the hanger at his hip. "You’re a deserter. You’re a mutineer, you Nassau bilge rat—"
He came at Lightbourn with the blade.
Lightbourn had never fought with a sword. He had fought with his fists on the docks, over fish and over girls and once over a dog. He ducked under the first swing because Haines was angry and swung too wide, and he got inside, and he drove his fist into the corporal’s belly with all the weight of a man who’d hauled nets every day of his life.
Haines folded over. Lightbourn hit him again, in the jaw. The corporal went down on the path and lay there groaning.
Lightbourn stood over him, breathing hard, staring at his own fist.
He never saw the musket butt coming. Another soldier, behind him, one who’d been coming up the path and seen it all. It caught him across the back of the head. The glowing cavern tilted and spun and went dark.
The last thing he saw before he hit the ground was the little girl with the scar on her shoulder, still standing in the doorway, staring at him.
Under the broken breadfruit tree, Ezinne never stopped drumming.
Not when the soldiers came up the terraces. Not when Bess threw the flour. Not when Quashie gasped, or Fenwick fell, or the shot from Haines’s musket cracked off the cavern roof.
Her hands were bleeding. The split skin of the drum had worn through the pads of her fingers an hour ago, and every stroke left a smear of red on the hide. She didn’t stop.
Boom-boom. Boom. Boom-boom. Boom.
Wake up. The door’s open. Come and see.
Obi knelt beside her with his small hands on the drum’s rim, feeling the rhythm, mouthing it.
A soldier came over the edge of the terrace. Big. Bloody-faced. A bayonet on his musket. He saw the drum and the woman playing it, and something in his face twisted.
"Stop that noise," he snarled. "Stop that bloody heathen noise—"
He reached for her.
Obi threw himself at the man’s legs.
He hit him around the knees with his whole small body, the way he’d seen Titus tackle men in the fight at the cove. The soldier was three times his size. It didn’t matter. He wasn’t expecting it. His knees buckled. He staggered sideways and lost his footing at the edge of the terrace and went over it, crashing down onto the terrace below.
Obi lay on the ground at Ezinne’s feet, panting, his eyes huge.
Ezinne hadn’t missed a beat.
She looked down at him over the drum. Her face was wet. Her bloody hands kept moving.
"Onye aghana nwanne ya," she said.
Obi didn’t know all the words yet. But he knew what that one meant.
He got up, and put his hands back on the rim of the drum, and kept listening.
Out in the black water at the mouth of the cave, Theo had decided that he hated the Royal Navy, the sea, the night, cold iron, and most of all himself.
He and Titus had dragged themselves out of the water onto the nearer guard boat just as the drum started. The six men aboard had been staring at the fog, and at the place where the chain had dropped, and shouting at each other, and they had not expected two half-drowned men to come up over the gunwale out of the dark.
Titus had taken the first two before they’d turned around. Theo had taken one. Possibly. He had swung his cutlass at the man and the man had fallen over the side, and whether it was from the cutlass or from the boat rocking, Theo honestly couldn’t say.
Now there were three soldiers left, and one of them was standing in the stern with his musket aimed at Titus’s back.
Theo didn’t have time to think. He didn’t have time to draw. His hand went to his belt, to the curved, weighted hardwood throw-stick he’d spent four months carving and balancing and testing until it came back to his hand every time.
He threw it.
Persuasion spun through the fog end over end, humming. It struck the musket barrel just as the soldier’s finger closed on the trigger. The barrel jerked up. The shot went into the fog. The musket flew out of the soldier’s hands and over the side.
Persuasion kept spinning. It curved away into the fog, turned, and came back, spinning, out of the grey, straight into Theo’s waiting palm with a smack.
He stared at it.
"Did you see that?" he gasped. "Titus. Did you see that? It came back. It’s never come back in a real fight. Ever. Four months I’ve been—"
"Theo."
"—carving and sanding and throwing it at fence posts and it always comes back on the beach, but it’s never—"
"Theo." Titus had the last soldier by the collar. "I’m a little busy."
"Right. Yes. Sorry." Theo tucked Persuasion back in his belt with great tenderness. "Carry on."
Titus threw the soldier over the side.
Then the boat lurched.
Something had passed under it. Something enormous. The whole guard boat lifted on a long, slow swell and dropped again. Theo grabbed the gunwale. Titus braced his feet.
The water around them had changed. Theo could feel it. It had been cold and still in the shelter of the cliff. Now it was moving, all of it, a deep, slow current pulling out from the cave mouth toward the open sea. Out toward the ships.
And Titus had gone very still.
He was standing in the middle of the guard boat with his hand on the gunwale, staring down at the water. His face had gone strange. Not frightened. Not angry. Something Theo had never seen on Titus’s face before.
"Titus?"
"Do you hear it?" Titus said softly.
"Hear what?"
Titus didn’t answer. He was staring past the cave mouth, past the rocks, out toward the open water beyond the cove. Out toward where the fog met the sea and the sea went on forever, past every island and every coast and every chain.
There was a sound out there. Under the drum. Under the guns. He had heard it for a long time now, ever since they’d left Brook’s Reach. He’d thought it was only the sea.
It wasn’t. It was a voice. Very deep. Very far. Calling from the open water beyond the land, where no island stood.
Not yet, it seemed to say. Not yet, son of the Gold Coast. But soon.
Titus gripped the gunwale.
"Titus," Theo said. "You’re scaring me."
Titus blinked. The voice was gone. There was only the sea, and the fog, and the drum.
"It’s nothing," he said. His voice was hoarse. "It’s nothing. Let’s go."
The black sloop had been working her way in toward the cave mouth for an hour.
She was all Bell had left besides the crippled Vigilant. Shallow-draft. Ten guns. Twenty men. Her captain had his orders: get in close, block the cave, and fire on anything that came out of it. In the fog, he’d been creeping in by lead line, foot by foot, until he could see the black shape of the cliff looming over his bowsprit.
He was standing at the rail with the lead in his hand when the arms came out of the water.
They came up on either side of the sloop at once. Long. Grey-purple, the color of old bruises. Thick as the sloop’s mainmast at the base, tapering to points as thin as a whip. Lined on their undersides with great round pale cups. They rose up out of the black sea higher than the sloop’s rail. Higher than her yards. They hung there, dripping, in the fog.
The man at the helm screamed.
One of the arms came down across the sloop’s deck.
It came down like a falling tree. It smashed the quarterdeck rail to splinters. It wrapped around the helmsman before he could run, around his chest and his legs, and lifted him off his feet, screaming. Then it pulled him back over the side and down into the black water.
The scream stopped.
Another arm took the captain. Another wrapped around the mainmast and pulled. The mast groaned. The shrouds snapped one after another like gunshots. Men were running across the deck, throwing themselves over the side, clinging to the rigging. The arms took them out of the rigging one by one.
Then the arms wrapped around the hull.
All of them. A dozen. They coiled around the sloop from stem to stern like a fist closing around a toy. And they pulled.
The sloop went down by the head. Her bow went under. Her stern rose up out of the water, her rudder in the air, her stern lantern swinging wildly. Men were screaming in the fog.
Then she went under, and the fog closed over the place where she had been, and there was only the sound. Splashing. Screaming. A long, deep, bubbling roar. And then the sound of something enormous turning in the water, and swimming away.
Out toward the Vigilant.
On the Morning Star, Anne heard the screaming from the sloop and didn’t let it stop her.
There were six of them left on the deck now. Bell’s men. The ones he’d told to hold the ship and kill the women. They’d given up on killing the women some time ago and were concentrating on holding the ship, and they weren’t doing that very well either.
Anne had her back to the mainmast and her blade burning. Mary was on the quarterdeck, two stilettos in her hands and three men lying around her, not moving. Toby was at the galley hatch with a meat cleaver Bess would have been proud of, bleeding from his side through a bandage Mary had torn from a sailor’s shirt, and grinning.
"How many’s that?" Toby called.
"Doesn’t count if you just hit them with the flat," Anne called back.
"It counts if they fall down."
"Fine. Seven."
"Eight."
"You did not get eight."
Mary came down the quarterdeck ladder. She was looking past Anne. Past the fight. At the black water off the starboard side, where the sloop had gone down.
"Anne," she said quietly.
Anne turned.
Something was moving out there in the fog. Something huge, sliding through the black water just below the surface. She could see the swell it pushed ahead of it. A long, grey back broke the surface for a moment, scarred and pale, longer than the Morning Star. Then it was gone again.
Going away from them. Out toward the open sea. Toward the Vigilant.
"Good," Anne whispered.
Neither of them noticed the companionway hatch behind them. It had been closed when the fight started. Now it stood a hand’s width open. And beyond it, down the ladder, in the dark below decks, something was moving. Dragging itself along. Slow and painful, with one arm and a pair of cracked ribs.
Toward the powder room.
There was a lantern in its hand.
On the rocks below the cliff, Kofi was losing.
He knew it. He’d known it for some time. Bell had stopped charging. He didn’t need to charge. He was walking Kofi down, slowly, across the broken black boulders at the foot of the cliff. Every time Kofi found a place to stand, Bell took it away from him. A hoof cracked the rock and fire spat up. A chain whipped out and wrapped a boulder and pulled it out of the slope. And Bell learned. That was the worst of it. He watched Kofi’s feet, and he learned. Every trick Kofi tried, Bell saw, and the next time it didn’t work.
Kofi tried the trench again. Bell leaped it.
He tried the grave-cold wall. Bell went around it.
He tried the fog. Bell breathed out his black sulfur smoke, and the two clouds fought, and Kofi was so tired now, so cold, that the grey fog lost.
His nose had not stopped bleeding. He couldn’t feel his hands at all now. He held the blade and the sheath by habit alone. Frost had formed in his eyebrows and on his beard. When he breathed, the breath came out white.
He backed up against the foot of the cliff. Rock behind him. The sea to his left. Broken boulders to his right.
Nowhere left to go.
Bell came at him one more time.
The saber came at his head. Kofi got the blade up. The sheath. Both. The saber beat them both aside, and Bell’s heavy hoof came up and slammed into Kofi’s chest, and drove him back against the cliff, and pinned him there.
It was like being crushed under a falling beam. Kofi felt his ribs bend. Felt the air go out of him and not come back.
The chains came. They whipped out from Bell’s shoulders and went into the rock on either side of Kofi’s head. Into the rock behind his back. Into his shadow on the cliff face, where the lantern from a drifting longboat threw it, black and long against the stone. They locked him there. He couldn’t move his arms. He couldn’t move at all.
Bell leaned on him. The bull’s breath smoked in his face. The red eyes burned a hand’s width away.
"I’ll have that compass now, Brook," Bell said softly.
He lifted the saber.
Kofi didn’t look at it.
He was looking past Bell’s shoulder. Past the rocks and the drifting boats and the black water. Up. Up the face of the cliff, into the fog.
The fog was everywhere. It filled the cove. It hid the ships. It had hidden them all night, pouring down off the cliff from somewhere high above.
And Kofi’s white eyes could see something in it.
A shape. Not a person. Not a ghost. Something drawn in the grey of the fog itself, very faint, high up on the cliff, where the fog was thickest. It was round, like a clock face. And around its edge, one by one, small marks were going out. Going dark. Like candles being pinched between two fingers. Most of them were already gone. Only a few left. A handful.
He knew whose fog it was.
He knew whose clock it was.
Up top, there’s no iron, she’d said. Just sky and bush. Up top, I can make the fog. All of it. Every bit I got left.
Another mark went dark.
Kofi hung on the cliff in Bell’s chains with Bell’s hoof on his chest and Bell’s saber raised over his head. He didn’t look at the saber. He looked at the clock in the fog.
There were three marks left.
Then two.