The Morning Star:Chains of the Deep · Contents

CHAPTER 36

Chapter 35: The Next Verse

30 min read·David_B_

The song ended the way all songs end, slowly, voice by voice, until only the drum was left.

Then Obi’s hands stopped too. He sat behind Pa Cudjoe’s drum with his palms flat on the split skin, breathing hard, his fingers blistered. He looked up at Ezinne. She nodded once. He took his hands away.

The silence after it was a different kind of silence than the one after Phibba died. It was a tired silence. The kind that comes over a room when everyone in it has laughed and wept and sung until there’s nothing left, and nobody wants to be the first to stand up and start the day.

Grey light was coming down through the hole in the roof. Fog drifted in it, soft and pale.

Kofi stood at the edge of the terrace and looked out over them. Children asleep in heaps. Tanty Abba sitting with her back against a wall, her iron pot in her lap, her eyes closed. Toby on his blanket with Clementine asleep against his shoulder and Bess asleep against his other side. Pockets asleep in the burned branches of the breadfruit tree with his feather crown over one eye and Kofi’s empty cup in his arms.

And at the bottom of the terraces, on the shore of the glowing lagoon, eleven men sitting in a row with their hands tied behind their backs.

The Navy prisoners hadn’t slept. Kofi could see that from here. They’d sat on the sand all night and watched the fire and listened to the singing and the drum. Some of them had their heads bowed. Lieutenant Fenwick, at the end of the row, sat upright with his bandaged head and his hollow eyes fixed on the water. Not looking at anything.

Six days of food. Five, now, after the Nine Night. Fifteen of those mouths were theirs.

Kofi had been putting it off. He couldn’t put it off any longer.

They held the vote on the terrace in the middle of the morning, after everyone had slept a little and Tanty Abba had made the last of the plantains into a thin porridge and stood over every single person until they ate it.

Everyone came. That was the first thing Kofi decided. Not just the crew. The Hollow too. All of it. Every grown person who had lived through the storm and the battle and buried their dead under the mango tree. If they were going to decide what to do with the men who’d come to drag them back into chains, then everyone who’d been dragged had a say.

They sat in a wide ring on the terrace around the cold remains of the Nine Night fire. The Hollow’s people on one side. The crew on the other, mixed in among them. Jonah Lightbourn sat a little apart again, on his rock at the edge of the terrace. Hetty sat beside him, holding his hand, and wouldn’t let go.

Kofi stood in the middle of the ring.

"There are fifteen of them," he said. "Eleven down there on the shore. Four more on the ship. Navy sailors and soldiers. Lieutenant Fenwick, who led them in here." He looked around the ring. "We have five days of food. Maybe six if we fish. We have to decide what to do with them. All of us."

Nobody said anything for a moment.

Then Titus stood up.

"Kill them," he said.

He didn’t shout it. He said it the way he said everything, flat and direct and quiet. But it went around the ring like a stone dropped into a pond.

"They came in here with bayonets," Titus said. "They burned the houses. They killed Dinah on the path with her hands up. They shot Bram in his own doorway. They’d have taken every child in this Hollow back to Brook’s Reach in irons and sold them off the row like goats." He looked down the terraces at the men on the shore. "We let them go, they go back to Jamaica and tell every officer and every planter on the island exactly where we are and how many of us are left."

Several people in the ring were nodding. Quamin, with his arm in a sling. Two of the Hollow’s young men who had dug Bram’s grave. Kitty’s mother, who sat with her hands in her lap and her face like stone.

"Kill them," Titus said again. "Fifteen less to feed. Fifteen less to come back."

He sat down.

The ring was silent.

Then, from the Hollow’s side, an older man named Cuffy cleared his throat.

"Or keep them," he said.

Everyone looked at him.

"We need hands," Cuffy said. "Nine houses standing. Gardens trampled. Store cave burned. Fifteen strong men, Navy men, they can dig and build and haul timber same as anybody. Keep them tied at night. Work them by day. Let them build back what they burned." He shrugged. "Seems only fair."

Several more heads nodded.

Kofi felt something go cold in his chest.

"No," he said.

Cuffy looked at him.

"No," Kofi said again. "Not that. Not ever." He looked around the ring, at every face. "Nobody here owns anybody. Not on my ship. Not in this Hollow. Not even them." He pointed down the terraces. "We put them in chains and work them till they drop, and what are we? What did we run from? What did Phibba hide us from for thirty years?"

Cuffy opened his mouth. Closed it. Looked down at his hands.

"I didn’t mean—"

"I know you didn’t," Kofi said. More gently. "I know. But that’s how it starts. It starts with fair. With only a few. With just till the houses are built." He shook his head. "Not here. Not ever."

The ring was quiet.

"Then what?" Titus said. "If we don’t kill them and we don’t keep them?"

"We let them go," Kofi said.

Nobody spoke for a long moment.

"Let them go," Titus said slowly. "Back to Jamaica. To tell every officer in the Navy where we are."

"Bell already knows where we are," Kofi said. "He saw the cave. He saw the cliffs. He saw my ship at anchor in broad daylight. He’s on the Vigilant right now, and he’s going to tell them all whether we kill these men or not." He looked out at the fog drifting through the shaft of light. "And there’s this."

Everyone followed his eyes.

"Phibba’s fog won’t hide a hunter," he said. "That was her Law. Clementine felt it last night. It’ll hide the way in from anyone who comes hunting. And it’ll open for anyone who comes running." He turned back to the ring. "So let them tell. Let them tell every captain in the Caribbean exactly where Cat Island is. Let them sail right up to these cliffs. They’ll find fog and rocks and nothing else. Not the cave. Not us."

"And if you’re wrong?" Titus said.

"Then we fight," Kofi said. "Same as we did last night. But we fight as what we are." He looked down at the men on the shore. "We give them water, and a boat, and enough food to reach Eleuthera. And we let them go."

Titus looked at him for a long time.

"I’ll put it to the vote," Kofi said. "Everyone. The Hollow too. Hands up for killing them."

Titus raised his hand.

He looked around. Quamin’s hand went halfway up, wavered, and came down again. Kitty’s mother sat with her hands in her lap and her face like stone and didn’t move. Nobody else raised a hand.

Titus’s arm stayed up, alone, for a long time. He didn’t seem embarrassed by it. He just held it there so everyone could see.

Then he lowered it.

"Hands up for keeping them to work," Kofi said.

Nobody. Not even Cuffy.

"Hands up for the boat."

The hands went up around the ring. Slowly at first. Then more. Tanty Abba. Quashie. Cassia. Bess and Toby, from his blanket, raising one big hand off his chest. Clementine. Ezinne. Yaw. Mary and Anne. Theo. Every hand in the ring except one.

Titus didn’t argue. He didn’t stand up again. He just looked at Kofi across the cold fire, and then he got up and walked to the edge of the terrace and stood there with his back to them, looking out at the fog.

They untied them on the shore of the lagoon in the early afternoon.

The tide was low. The cave passage stood open. One of the captured guard boats sat at the water’s edge, loaded with two small casks of spring water and a sack of cassava bread and a bag of salted fish. Enough for three days at sea. Bess had counted it out herself and complained about every mouthful.

Titus and Yaw untied the men one at a time. They didn’t speak. The Navy men didn’t speak either. They stood up slowly, rubbing their wrists, looking around at the burned terraces and the black breadfruit tree and the people standing silent on the slope above them. Several of them couldn’t meet anyone’s eyes. One of them, a young sailor not much older than Obi, was crying.

Lieutenant Fenwick was the last.

Yaw cut the rope on his wrists. Fenwick stood up. He was taller than Kofi had realized, thin and stooped, his face grey and gaunt under the bloody bandage. His hollow eyes moved across the Hollow. Across the burned houses. The people on the slope. And settled on Kofi.

They looked at each other for a long moment.

"Your captain will come back," Fenwick said quietly.

"I know."

"No." Fenwick shook his head slowly. "I don’t think you do." He looked up at the fog drifting through the shaft of light. "He doesn’t forget. He doesn’t forgive. He never once in his life has let a thing go that he’d decided was his." His hollow eyes came back to Kofi. "You had him. On those rocks. Every man on the Vigilant will hear that. That you had him and let him live."

"Let them hear it."

"They will." Fenwick almost smiled. It didn’t reach his eyes. "But so will he. And a man like Captain Bell will not be able to bear it. That a runaway shipwright held his life in his hand and gave it back like a coin to a beggar." He stepped toward the boat. "You’ve made him something worse than an enemy, Brook. You’ve made him owe you. And he’ll spend the rest of his life trying to pay that debt in the only coin he knows."

He climbed into the guard boat and sat down in the stern and didn’t look back.

Kofi stood on the shore and watched the boat pull away across the lagoon and into the cave mouth and out of sight.

He didn’t say anything. But he felt Fenwick’s words settle in his chest beside the word Keeper. Heavy. Cold.

On the Morning Star, the four sailors tied to the mainmast were let go the same way, and rowed across the cove in the jolly boat to join the others. Clementine stood at the cave mouth with her staff as the guard boat pulled away from the cliffs. Out into the fog.

It swallowed them in a heartbeat.

Then it did something strange. It drew apart in front of the boat. A long, narrow gap opened through the grey, a channel of clear air running straight out from the cliffs toward the open sea. Toward the east. Toward Eleuthera. Behind the boat, the gap closed again.

Clementine watched until the fog was whole.

"It’s taking them out," she said quietly. "It wants them gone."

"Will they be able to find their way back?" Theo asked from beside her.

Clementine looked at the fog for a long time.

"Not if they’re hunting," she said.

When they came back up from the shore, Jonah Lightbourn was standing in the middle of the terrace waiting for them.

He hadn’t gone with the boat. Nobody had told him to go, and nobody had told him to stay. He’d watched the others climb into it without moving from his rock. Now he stood on the terrace with his knitted cap in both hands, turning it around and around, and Hetty standing beside him holding a fistful of his canvas shirt.

"I’d like to ask," he said. His voice shook. "If I could. I’d like to ask to stay."

The terrace went quiet.

"I’m not Navy," Lightbourn said. "Not really. I was a fisherman. In Nassau. A week ago. Ten days. I don’t even know anymore." He turned the cap in his hands. "The press gang took me off the dock with clubs. I woke up in the hold of a cutter with blood in my mouth. Nobody asked me. They read me the Articles and told me I belonged to the King now." He swallowed. "I don’t want to go back to that. And I don’t have anything else to go back to. The girl I was courting will have heard I’m dead by now."

Nobody said anything.

"I can fish," Lightbourn said. "I can mend nets. I can sail a boat in any weather. I know the waters from New Providence to the Turks like my own hand." He looked down at Hetty. "And I’d like to stay where she is."

Hetty looked up at him with her serious eyes. She didn’t say anything. She held onto his shirt.

Kofi looked around the terrace.

"Hands," he said.

They went up. Every hand. Even Titus’s, last of all, after a long look at the little girl with the scar on her shoulder.

Lightbourn stared at all those hands. His face crumpled. He put his cap back on his head and pulled it down low over his eyes and stood there, and Hetty leaned her head against his leg.

"Welcome to the Hollow," Quashie said.

Titus found Kofi at the passage mouth that evening.

The tide was coming in. The water was rising slowly up the walls of the cave, the black arch at the far end narrowing as the sea came up into it. Kofi was sitting on the ledge with his feet in the water, watching it rise. He’d been sitting there for an hour.

Titus sat down beside him. He didn’t say anything for a long time.

"You had him," he said finally.

Kofi didn’t pretend not to know who he meant.

"Bell," Titus said. "On the rocks. You had a blade at his throat. I saw it. Everybody on the water saw it. You had him, and you let him go."

"Yes."

"He’ll come back."

"I know."

"Then why?" Titus’s voice was quiet. It wasn’t angry. That was the worst of it. It would have been easier if he’d been angry. "Why let him go? After Amara. After Juba. After Phibba and Barnaby and Dinah. After the boy in the rigging. After every name in that book of his. You had him, Kofi. You could have ended it."

Kofi looked down at the black water rising around his feet.

He thought about the voice inside him, on the rocks. Go on, shipwright. Finish it. He thought about the grin he hadn’t put on his own face. The laugh that wasn’t his. The way his hand had been perfectly steady on the blade, and how good it had felt. How easy.

He thought about Sterling in the powder room, standing up out of his own body, small and lost and terrified. Take me home.

"I’m not him," Kofi said.

Titus waited.

"That’s all I have," Kofi said. "I know it isn’t enough. But that’s all I have. I’m not him. And if I’d done it, if I’d put that blade in him on the rocks while he lay there broken, I’d have been a little more like him than I was the day before." He looked at Titus. "I don’t want to find out how much more."

Titus was quiet for a long time.

"Fenwick said something on the shore," he said finally. "About a debt."

"I heard."

"He’s right. You know he’s right." Titus looked out at the black arch of the cave and the fog beyond it. "Bell will come back. And next time, he’ll come with more than one frigate and a chain. And people will die. People in this Hollow. People on your ship." He paused. "Maybe me."

"Maybe."

"And you’ll have chosen that. When you lifted that blade off his throat."

Kofi didn’t answer. There was nothing he could say that was true and would help.

Titus stood up. He stood on the ledge with the tide rising around his feet and looked down at Kofi.

"I don’t agree with you," he said. "I want you to know that. I think you were wrong. I think you’ll find out you were wrong." He looked away, out at the fog. "But I watched you carry two hundred people home in a hurricane. And I watched a dead man play his drum through your hands. And I watched you send your own master home in that powder room, when you could have let him wander in the dark forever and nobody would ever have known."

He was quiet a moment.

"You’re keeping something," Titus said. "I still think that. But I don’t think it’s that you’re cruel. I don’t think it’s that you’re weak, either." He turned to go. "I just think you’re carrying something heavier than the rest of us know."

He walked back up the passage into the Hollow.

Kofi sat on the ledge with his feet in the rising sea and watched the arch close.

He found Anne on the clifftop the next morning.

She was sitting beside Phibba’s grave. Beside the white flower that had grown out of it, the strange pale flower with the grey streaks at its heart like smoke. It had opened wider in the night. A second bud had appeared on its stem. She sat with her knees drawn up and her arms around them and looked out at the fog lying over the sea.

She didn’t turn when he came up through the scrub. She knew it was him.

He sat down beside her. Not too close.

For a long time, neither of them said anything. The wind came up off the sea and moved in the bush. Down the slope, the old silk-cotton tree stood black and smoking at the edge of the Boiling Hole.

"Your left hand," Kofi said finally.

Anne didn’t move.

"On the rocks. You told me to strike with my left. And then Mary said something about the moon. That the Rolling Calf won’t come out when the moon is bright." He looked at her. "How did you know? Both of those things. How did you know how to beat him?"

Anne didn’t answer for a long time. She was looking at the white flower.

"An old woman told me a story once," she said. "When I was small."

Kofi waited.

She didn’t say anything more.

He knew she wouldn’t. He’d seen it in her face, on the deck of the Morning Star the morning after the battle, and again on the shore when they let the prisoners go. Something closed. Something locked. Something she carried that weighed as much as his own secret did.

Everybody on this ship has something they won’t say, she’d told him once, at the mainmast in the dark, before the storm. Me included.

He looked at her in the grey morning light. Her profile against the fog. The dark stain on her skin, faded a little at the edges of her jaw from the sea and the sweat and the fire. Her black hair, which he’d only ever seen wrapped and was loose now around her shoulders, catching the wind.

And something came up out of the deep of him.

Not from this life. From the other one. From the sixty-seven years at Brook’s Reach. A memory. Old. Faded. Half forgotten.

He was thirty-one. Thirty-two. Working on the keel of a merchant brig in the yard at Brook’s Reach. Two sailors from the brig’s crew sat on a stack of timber nearby, smoking their pipes, gossiping, the way sailors always gossiped in the yard. And one of them was talking about the trial.

"In Spanish Town. Rackham and his whole crew. Hanged at Gallows Point, every man of them. But you’ll never guess. Two of his crew were women. Dressed as men. Fought like the devil. Bonny and Read, their names were. Anne Bonny and Mary Read."

"They hang them too?"

"Couldn’t. Both said they were with child. Court had to spare them till they’d delivered. The Read woman died of fever in the jail not long after. Never even got to her hanging."

"And the other one?"

"Nobody knows. Vanished. Like she’d never been."

The sailors had laughed. Kofi had kept working on the keel. He hadn’t thought about it again for forty years.

He was sitting on a clifftop in 1712, beside a woman who called herself Anne Bonny, with a woman who called herself Mary Read somewhere in the Hollow below him.

In his first life, that trial had been eight years away.

He knew how their story ended. Mary in a jail cell in Spanish Town, dying of fever. Anne vanishing into nothing, like she’d never been.

Anne was still looking at the white flower. She didn’t see his face change.

He didn’t tell her. He didn’t know how he ever could.

Not this time, he thought. Not this time.

He didn’t know yet what he would do. He didn’t know if he could do anything. He’d changed so much already. Saved people who’d died in his first life. Lost people who’d lived. Maybe that trial would never happen now. Maybe it would happen anyway, some other way, some other year.

But he knew one thing. He’d already died once in this life and come back. He’d stood over a man with a blade at his throat and chosen not to. He’d carried his own master home.

He was not going to stand in a shipyard and listen to the end of her story as gossip.

"Anne," he said.

She turned her head. Her grey eyes, pale as ash, looked at him.

He didn’t know what he’d meant to say. He opened his mouth and closed it again.

"Thank you," he said instead. "For the left hand."

Something moved in her face. Something softer, just for a moment.

"Anytime, Captain," she said.

She looked back at the flower. He sat beside her, and they watched the fog together until the sun came through.

Theo was at the Morning Star’s rail when Kofi came back aboard that afternoon.

He was fitting a new length of timber into the broken rail where the French cannonball had smashed it in the cove at Saint-Domingue, a lifetime ago. He’d measured it badly. It was half an inch too long. He was trying to force it in anyway, with a mallet, swearing quietly in Creole.

Kofi took the mallet out of his hand without a word. He took the timber out of the gap. He laid it across a sea chest and took out his knife and shaved half an inch off one end in long, curling strips. He fitted it back into the gap. It slid in like a hand into a glove.

Theo watched him do it.

"Show-off," Theo said.

Kofi almost smiled. He picked up the mallet and drove the first treenail home.

They worked side by side on the rail for an hour without saying much. Theo held the timbers. Kofi shaped them and set them. The sun went down the sky. Somewhere below, in the galley, Toby and Bess were arguing about salt.

"You were right," Theo said suddenly.

Kofi looked up.

"About the storm." Theo wasn’t looking at him. He was looking at the timber in his hands. "About the day. About the course. About all of it. If we’d held for Cat Island like I wanted, we’d be on the bottom right now. Every one of us."

"Theo—"

"I know you won’t tell me how you knew." Theo’s voice was quiet. There was no joke in it. "I’ve stopped asking. I’m not going to ask again." He turned the timber over in his hands. "I just wanted you to know I know. That you were right. And I still don’t know how."

Kofi set down the mallet.

He looked at Theo. At the young navigator who had given a dying girl water from a copper cup in the hold of a slave ship, and spent every day since trying to deserve that he hadn’t done more. Who’d sworn he wouldn’t swim out at night under a frigate’s guns, and then done it. Who’d pulled the pin on a hundred fathoms of cold iron with his bare hands, terrified and laughing.

Who had told Kofi his worst secret, in the hold of the Morning Star, because he’d believed that on this ship, nobody had to carry anything alone.

"One day," Kofi said slowly, "I’ll tell you."

Theo looked at him.

He didn’t make a joke. He didn’t say when. He didn’t say anything at all for a long moment. He just looked at Kofi, steadily, the way he looked at a chart when he was working out a course through dangerous water.

Then he nodded once and handed Kofi the next timber.

They held a council that night in the Hollow, around the rekindled fire under the black breadfruit tree. All of them. The crew and the Hollow together.

Bess had the numbers. She stood by the fire with a slate in her hands and read them out, the way she’d read out the water casks before the storm.

"Five days of food," she said. "Four if we’re honest. One cask of water left on the Morning Star. The spring’s still running in here, thank God. Thirty-five of the Hollow. Twelve of us. One Nassau fisherman." She glanced at Lightbourn, who looked at his feet. "Fourteen children. Phibba’s four boats. The Morning Star, half mended. Two Navy guard boats." She lowered the slate. "And no gardens worth the name till the next rains."

Nobody said anything.

"Fish," Lightbourn said quietly from the edge of the firelight. Everyone turned. He flushed. "Sorry. But there’s fish. The banks off the south point of the island. I fished them every season for six years. Snapper. Grouper. Conch in the shallows. With Phibba’s four boats and the two Navy boats, six boats, and a crew who know what they’re doing..." He trailed off. "Nobody here needs to go hungry. Not if we fish."

Bess looked at him. Then she wrote something on her slate.

"He stays," she said.

"He’s already staying," Quashie said.

"I know. I’m saying it again."

They talked late into the night. Fishing crews. Who would go out with Lightbourn, and who would stay to rebuild. Which houses to raise first. Where to plant the next gardens, high on the terraces where the salt couldn’t reach. How long before the Morning Star could sail again, and where she should sail to.

Kofi listened more than he spoke.

He was thinking about something Phibba had said to him once, in her house in the Hollow, before any of this. About her routes. About the boats she’d run through the fog for thirty years, from island to island and cove to cove, bringing people in.

Spanish Florida. Jamaica’s mountains. A hidden cove on Saint-Domingue, where Grann Rose’s people drew a veve in the wet sand to welcome strangers.

One woman with four boats and a clay pipe had done that. For thirty years.

He thought about what it could be with more. More boats. More coves. More people who knew the way.

"A road," he said out loud.

The fire went quiet. Everyone looked at him.

He hadn’t meant to say it. He looked around the ring, at all the faces in the firelight.

"Phibba ran her boats from cove to cove for thirty years," he said slowly. "She brought people here from every island in the Bahamas. From Jamaica. From Saint-Domingue." He looked down at the glowing lagoon. "What if there were more? More coves like this. More places to hide. More people like Quashie to bring them in. Hidden all over the islands, from here to the Main. And boats running between them, in fog and in the dark, where no hunter could follow."

Nobody said anything.

"A road across the sea," Kofi said. "That nobody can follow. That no ship can chase."

"Not across it," Ezinne said softly.

Everyone turned to her. She was sitting beside Obi with her bandaged hands in her lap, looking at the glowing water.

"Not across the sea," Ezinne said. "Under it. Like a current. Running under the water where nobody can see it. Taking everybody who falls in. Carrying them somewhere safe."

Kofi looked at her.

"A current," he said.

"Under the water," Ezinne said. "Where they can’t see it. Where they can’t chain it."

Nobody spoke for a long time.

Then Quashie laughed. Low and soft and wondering.

"Phibba would’ve liked that," he said. "Lord, she’d have liked that."

Ten days later, on the Vigilant, in the Windward Passage.

Captain Edmund Bell sat alone in his cabin.

The ship was barely holding together. They had jury-rigged a mast where the mizzen had been and pumped her day and night since Cat Island, and still she leaked like a basket. They would make Port Royal, the carpenter said. If the weather held. Barely.

Bell’s face was wrapped in bandages. Where the moonlight had burned him, the skin had blistered and cracked and was healing slowly, red and raw. His chest was bound tight. Two ribs were broken where the black wood had struck him. When he breathed, it hurt.

He didn’t remember the water. He remembered the rocks. The blade at his throat. The white eyes. The voice. I’m not you. And then the arms. And the cold. And nothing.

His men said they’d found him on a boulder at the edge of the sea, half drowned, coughing up water. Alone.

Nobody knew how he’d gotten there.

He had spent ten days writing his report.

It lay on the desk in front of him now, finished, sealed, addressed to Vice-Admiral Sir Lucius Wraythe, Jamaica Station. Seven pages. Every detail of the battle at Cat Island, from the first sight of the cave to the last. The fog. The chain. The drum. The thing in the water. The runaway shipwright with a cane-sword and white eyes, who had come up out of the sea after being drowned.

And on the last page, in his neat, careful hand, the thing that mattered most.

I have seen it with my own eyes. A compass bearing the mark of a sun on its face. It hangs around the neck of the escaped slave Kofi Brook, late of Brook’s Reach, Jamaica. It is real. It is in his possession. I would stake my commission on it.

Beside the report lay his ledger. The heavy leather book he had carried for fifteen years. Open to a fresh page.

He had written one name on that page. Kofi Brook. Underneath it, where he always wrote the word recovered, the space was blank.

Bell looked at the blank space for a long time.

Then he reached into the ledger and slid out something he’d kept tucked between its back pages for almost a year. A letter. Folded. Its wax seal unbroken. Addressed in a hand he knew. Two hands, actually. Both of them his daughters’.

He had never opened it.

He sat in his dark cabin on his sinking ship with his face in bandages and his ribs in pieces, and he turned the letter over in his hands.

Then he broke the seal.

He unfolded it. He began to read.

The lantern swung on its hook above the desk. The ship groaned around him. Outside, the sea hissed past the hull.

Bell read the letter once. Then again.

His face didn’t change. Not at first. Then something moved in it. Something under the bandages and the burns, around the eyes. It moved, and then it was gone, and his face was as still and cold as it had ever been.

He folded the letter. Very carefully. Along its old creases.

He put it back inside the ledger, between its back pages, where it had been. He closed the ledger.

Then he sat in the dark with both hands flat on its leather cover and didn’t move for a very long time.

Three weeks later, at the Chancery of the Deep, Port Royal, Jamaica.

Vice-Admiral Sir Lucius Wraythe read the report standing at his window, looking out over the harbor.

He was a tall man, broad and heavy, gone grey early. He had the look of a man who had been handsome once. He read slowly, all seven pages, while the sun went down over the harbor and the rebuilt walls of Port Royal turned gold.

When he reached the last page, he stopped.

He read it again.

Behind him, in the shadows of his great dim office, something moved. Something low and wet, that dragged across the floorboards. A smell of brine and deep water filled the room. A sound like a heavy chain sliding across stone.

Wraythe didn’t turn around.

"Yes," he said quietly. "I know. I read it too."

The thing in the shadows made a sound. Low. Long. Hungry.

"A sun on its face," Wraythe murmured. He set the report down on his desk. "Out of the Locker. Just as the Chancery said." He looked out the window toward the sea. "And Bell had it within arm’s length, and let a runaway walk away with it."

He rang a small bell on his desk. A clerk appeared in the doorway.

"Have the printers in the town make up new notices," Wraythe said. "Brook. His crew. Every one of them, by description. Raise the bounties. And send word to the Governor." He looked down at the report again. "And to London."

The clerk bowed and was gone.

Wraythe stood alone at his window as the dark came down over the harbor. Behind him, the chained thing in the shadows dragged itself closer across the floor. He could feel the cold of it on the back of his neck.

"Patience," he said to it softly. "Patience. We’ll have it soon enough."

A month after that. Somewhere at sea, far to the east, off the coast of a small island whose name no one would remember.

The prize had struck her colors without a fight. They usually did, when they saw who was coming.

She was a small merchant brig out of Port Royal, carrying sugar and rum and mail for the islands. Her crew sat in a terrified row on her deck. Her captain was weeping. Pirates in rags and gold went through her hold, laughing, rolling out the casks.

One of them came up the side of the big black ship anchored alongside her with a bundle of papers in his hand.

"Captain," he called. "Found these in her mailbags. Fresh from the printer in Port Royal. Thought you’d want to see."

The man on the quarterdeck turned.

He was huge. Broad as a door. A black beard hung to his chest, braided with ribbons. Even standing still on his own deck in the afternoon sun, there was something in the air around him that made the sailors on the captured brig look away. A charge. A pressure. The feeling the sky gets before a storm.

He took the papers.

They were wanted posters. Freshly printed. The ink barely dry.

He leafed through them without much interest. A Dutch smuggler. A pair of Spanish privateers. A runaway gang from a Barbados plantation.

He stopped.

The poster on top was bigger than the rest. Heavier paper. The type was bold and black.

BY ORDER OF THE ADMIRALTY OF THE JAMAICA STATION

WANTED, DEAD OR ALIVE

FOR PIRACY, MURDER, THEFT OF HIS MAJESTY’S PRIZE, AND THE MAIMING AND DEATH OF A GENTLEMAN OF THIS COLONY

KOFI BROOK

called THE MAN THE SEA GAVE BACK

escaped slave, shipwright, late of Brook’s Reach, Jamaica. Carries a black cane.

5,000 POUNDS

AND HIS CREW:

YAW, gunman. 1,500 pounds.

A WOMAN called the Root Witch. 800 pounds.

TITUS, field hand. 500 pounds.

A navigator, of French extraction. 500 pounds.

All other members of the crew of the ship MORNING STAR, formerly HMS DELIVERANCE. 200 pounds each.

Believed to sail in company with the notorious pirates known as BONNY and READ.

The big man read it once.

Then he read it again, more slowly.

His eyes went down the poster to the bottom. To a line set in small type, almost an afterthought, that the printer had been told to add at the last moment by a clerk from the Chancery.

The Admiralty is particularly interested in a COMPASS in the said Brook’s possession, bearing the mark of a SUN upon its face. It is to be recovered intact at all costs.

Blackbeard looked up.

He looked out across the sea, to the west. Toward Jamaica. Toward the Bahamas. Toward the islands where a runaway shipwright with a black cane and a sun around his neck was sailing.

High above the black ship, in a sky with no cloud in it anywhere, thunder rolled.

The pirates on the captured brig froze. Every head came up. The terrified merchant sailors on her deck pressed themselves flat against the rail.

Blackbeard didn’t look up at the sky.

He looked down at the poster in his hands. At the name. At the five thousand pounds. At the little line about the compass at the bottom.

And slowly, through the black beard, he began to grin.

"The man the sea gave back," he said softly.

He folded the poster once, carefully, and tucked it inside his coat, over his heart.

"Let’s see if it’ll give him back twice."

The thunder rolled again, out of a clear blue sky, and went echoing away across the sea toward the west.