The Morning Star:Chains of the Deep · Contents

CHAPTER 35

Chapter 34: The Nine Night

31 min read·David_B_

Kofi stood at the stern rail until the people on the clifftop began to move.

They lifted the litter. Four of them, one at each corner, and a fifth walking beside it with a hand on the old woman’s shoulder. They carried her slowly back from the edge of the cliff into the scrub, toward the place where the tunnels came up out of the rock. He watched until the bush swallowed them.

Behind him on the deck, someone cleared their throat.

Mary stood at the head of the companionway ladder. Her clothes were still wet from the sea. Her face was grey with tiredness, and her eyes were red, and she didn’t seem to care who saw.

"The tide," she said. "Theo says the passage won’t open till the middle of the morning."

"I know."

"Clementine’s sleeping. Next to Toby. She won’t leave him." Mary paused. "Yaw’s asleep on the hatch cover. Latch won’t let anybody near him."

"And Anne?"

Mary looked away, out across the cove toward the far rocks. Toward the flat boulder where her sister had left a half-drowned man for his own sailors to find.

"She’s in the bow," Mary said. "She wants to be alone."

Kofi nodded.

He didn’t ask. He wanted to. The words were in his mouth. Why did she do it? What did she mean, he’s ours? Who told you about the moon? But Mary’s face was closed like a shuttered window, and he’d learned something about secrets in the last few weeks. Mostly about how heavy they were.

"Get some sleep," he said instead.

"You first."

He almost laughed. "Later."

Mary looked at him for a long moment. Then she went forward along the deck toward the bow, where a small figure sat alone with her knees drawn up and her back against the bowsprit, staring at the sea.

Kofi turned back to the rail and waited for the tide.

The water went down slowly. It always did when you were waiting for it.

They went in at the middle of the morning, when the black arch of the cave stood clear of the sea with room for a boat to pass under. They used the jolly boat and one of the captured guard boats. Titus and Theo had brought the guard boat back out of the Hollow at first light with news that made Kofi’s stomach go cold. They rowed. Kofi sat in the stern of the first boat with Toby’s head in his lap.

Toby hadn’t woken. But he was breathing. The white flowers Clementine had grown over his wound had closed up in the night into tight green buds, and every so often one of them opened again, slowly, as if it were checking on him.

Clementine sat beside them. She hadn’t let go of Toby’s hand since the powder room. The faint green lines still showed under the skin of her wrists. She kept looking at them and then looking away.

The four Navy sailors from the Morning Star sat in the bottom of the second boat with their hands tied. Mary sat in the stern behind them with a stiletto across her knees. Nobody had decided yet what to do with them.

They came through the cave and out into the Hollow.

Kofi had thought he was ready.

He had seen the Hollow after the storm. The drowned beach, the broken houses, the rotting stores. He had walked the terraces with a stub of charcoal and counted the damage. He had thought nothing could be worse than that.

The smoke hit him first. A thick, bitter haze of it, hanging under the roof of the great cavern and drifting through the shaft of daylight from the hole above. It smelled of burned thatch and burned wood and something worse under that.

Then he saw the terraces.

Half the houses were gone. Not broken, the way the storm had broken them. Burned. Black stumps of wall and black heaps of ash where roofs had been. Some of them were still smoldering. The soldiers had set them alight on their way out, when the goats had scattered them and Titus and Theo had come up out of the passage with a cutlass and a machete. Torches thrown into thatch as they ran. Just to do it.

The gardens that the storm had spared were trampled flat. Muskets lay in the mud where they’d been dropped. A dead goat lay across the path halfway up the terraces.

And at the top, under the roof of the cavern, the breadfruit tree.

Pa Cudjoe’s tree. It had stood through the hurricane with half its branches torn away. It had stood over the drum on the first night of the old man’s Nine Night, when Kofi had played with dead hands over his own. Somebody had thrown a torch into the dry leaves at its foot.

It was black now. Every branch. Every leaf burned away to nothing. It stood at the top of the terraces like a skeleton reaching for the hole in the roof.

Nobody in the boats said anything.

Then people were coming down the path to the water’s edge, the way they had come down to meet them before. Fewer this time. Slower. Their faces black with soot.

Tanty Abba came first.

She came down the path with her iron pot in her hand, the pot Bess had broken Fenwick’s head with, and she walked straight into the water to her knees and stopped in front of the jolly boat. She looked at Kofi. Then at Toby in his lap. Then back at Kofi.

"Is he living?" she said.

"He’s living."

Tanty Abba closed her eyes. Her shoulders dropped.

"Good," she said. "Good. Somebody has to eat what I cook."

She turned around and walked back up the path. She didn’t look back. But Kofi saw her wipe her face with the back of the hand that held the pot.

They counted the dead in the afternoon.

Kofi did it himself, the way he’d done it after the storm. He walked the terraces with Quashie, who had a bruise across his chest the shape and size of a man’s open hand, and Titus, and a stub of charcoal, and the back of an old sail. He knew it was the shipwright in him. You had to find every crack.

He had never counted anything like this.

Barnaby. Struck by the cannonball on the clifftop, shielding Phibba. They had brought him down the tunnels with her in the morning.

Old Dinah, who had kept the bees on the high terrace and sold the honey to Tanty Abba for her cakes. A soldier’s bayonet on the path, before the goats came. She’d been trying to get to the children.

A young man named Bram, who mended the fishing nets. He had stood in front of his house with a fishing spear when the soldiers set the thatch alight, and he hadn’t moved, and they had shot him in the doorway.

Kitty, who was sixteen. Nobody could say exactly how. She’d been found at the foot of the second terrace when the fighting was over, under a fallen wall.

And Phibba.

Five. Five dead. Out of the forty who had come through the storm.

Kofi stood at the top of the terraces under the black skeleton of the breadfruit tree and wrote the number on the sailcloth with the charcoal, and then just stood there looking at it.

"Thirty-five," Quashie said quietly beside him.

"Thirty-five."

"Six still can’t walk from the storm. Four more from last night." Quashie’s voice was flat. "Eleven children. Fourteen with yours." He looked at the burned terraces. "Nine houses left standing. Maybe ten. The low gardens are salted. The high gardens are trampled. The store cave was half burned. Tanty Abba says six days of food. Maybe seven." He swallowed. "Phibba’s four boats. That’s all we have to fish with."

Kofi wrote it all down.

"And the prisoners," Titus said from his other side.

Kofi looked down the terraces. On the shore of the lagoon, near the water, a row of men sat on the sand with their hands tied behind them. Eleven of them. Soldiers who hadn’t run fast enough, or who’d been trampled by the goats, or who’d sneezed themselves blind on Tanty Abba’s pepper. Lieutenant Fenwick sat at the end of the row with a bloody bandage around his head and his hollow eyes on the ground.

And a little apart from the rest, not tied, sitting on a rock with a small girl beside him, a thin young man in a fisherman’s canvas shirt.

"Eleven Navy men," Titus said. "Four more on the ship. Fifteen mouths. Eating our six days."

"I know."

"What are we going to do with them?"

"I don’t know yet."

Titus looked at him. For a moment Kofi thought he was going to say something else. Something about Bell. About the man Kofi had stood over on the rocks with a blade at his throat and then let go.

Titus didn’t say it. Not yet. Kofi could see it sitting behind his eyes, waiting.

Kofi turned away and looked out over the Hollow. At the burned houses and the trampled gardens and the black tree and the children sitting in a silent row on the highest terrace, watching him.

Thirty-five people. Fourteen children. Six days of food.

Phibba had carried this for thirty years.

You don’t hide them. You keep them.

He had built ships. He had built them plank by plank, and he had known every timber, and when the ship sailed, she was somebody else’s to keep. He had never built anything that stayed his. He had never built anything that looked at him and waited to be told what came next.

The word sat in his chest like a stone. Keeper.

He looked down at the sailcloth in his hands. The numbers. The names. He folded it carefully and put it inside his shirt, against his heart, next to the dry leaf Clementine had given him before the battle.

Then he went to help Quashie dig.

They buried the Hollow’s dead under the mango tree, beside Juba.

It was the only place that felt right. The old sea-tree on the second terrace had survived the storm and the fire both. Somebody said that was a sign. Nobody argued. They dug the graves in the soft earth around its roots, and they laid Dinah and Bram and Kitty in them, wrapped in what cloth they could find, and covered them over.

Barnaby, they carried up the tunnels to the clifftop, to lie beside Phibba. He had died for her. He should be near her.

They buried her where she had died, at the top of the cliff above the Boiling Hole, looking out over the sea.

It took a long time to dig. The soil up there was thin and stony, full of roots. Kofi dug with Quashie and Titus and Quamin, one-armed, until his hands bled. Nobody spoke while they dug. The wind came up off the sea and moved in the scrub. Below, the cove lay bright and blue and empty. Not a sail on it anywhere.

When the grave was deep enough, they laid her in it.

She looked so small. Clementine had washed her face and wrapped her in a clean white cloth, and put her cold clay pipe in her folded hands. Somebody had found a few flowers in the scrub and laid them on her chest.

Clementine knelt at the edge of the grave.

She took something from her apron. A leaf. Small and green. The one Phibba had pulled from her hair on the litter in the dark, with the last of her strength, and pressed into her palm.

Plant something where they put me. Something that blooms.

Clementine didn’t throw the leaf in the grave. She knelt at its head, where the earth would cover Phibba’s face. She dug a small hole in the soil with her fingers. She took the leaf and laid it in the hole and covered it over and pressed the earth down with her palm.

Then she laid her staff across the place.

"Oka-rima," she whispered. "Oka-rima. Lo-senda ta."

The green came up in her wrists. Faint. Glowing. It ran down her fingers into the staff, into the soil.

Something pushed up out of the earth where she’d buried the leaf.

A shoot. Thin and pale green. It grew while they watched. Up, past Clementine’s knees, past her shoulders. It thickened into a stem. Leaves unfolded from it, broad and soft and grey-green, the color of fog. And at the top, as the sun came out from behind a cloud, a single bud swelled. And opened.

The flower was white. Pale and wide, with grey streaks at the heart, like smoke curling up through the petals.

Nobody had ever seen a flower like it. Not on Cat Island. Not anywhere.

Clementine sat back on her heels. She looked at the flower. Then she put her face in her hands and wept. Not quietly this time. Not without a sound. She wept the way a child weeps, with her whole body, her shoulders heaving.

Nobody touched her. Nobody needed to. They stood around the grave in the wind and let her.

After a long while, Yaw knelt down beside her. He didn’t say anything. He just put his arm around her shoulders. Latch came and lay down across her feet.

Then Kofi knelt on her other side. Then Mary. Then Quashie. Then, one by one, everyone on the clifftop, until they were all kneeling around the grave in the wind with the white flower nodding over it.

They stayed like that until the sun went down.

The Nine Night began after dark, on the highest terrace, under the black skeleton of the breadfruit tree.

It was the first night, not the ninth. But there was no question of waiting. Tanty Abba said the dead didn’t care what night it was. And the living needed it.

They built the fire big. As big as they could. They fed it with the burned timbers of the houses that had fallen, and the broken muskets the soldiers had left behind, and the splintered oars of the Navy longboats. It roared up toward the hole in the roof and threw its light across the whole cavern, and the glowing lagoon below flickered orange and blue.

Tanty Abba and Bess cooked.

They had six days of food. They spent one of them that night, and nobody said a word about it. Tanty Abba made fish stew with cinnamon in it, the way she always did. Bess made cassava bread on a flat stone at the edge of the fire, and fried plantains in a pan, and roasted the dead goat from the path with the last of the pepper Nell and Cato hadn’t thrown at the soldiers.

They didn’t speak to each other. They didn’t need to. Bess handed Tanty Abba the salt before she reached for it. Tanty Abba moved the stew off the fire before Bess’s bread could scorch.

Then somebody brought out the rum.

It was the Navy’s rum. Three casks of it, from the hold of the Morning Star, where Bell’s men had stored it for themselves. Titus rolled them up the terraces one at a time and knocked the bung out of the first with the hilt of his machete. He filled a cup. He didn’t drink it.

He walked to the edge of the terrace, to the place where you could look out over the whole Hollow, and he poured it out on the ground.

"For Phibba," he said.

He filled the cup again and poured it out.

"For Barnaby."

Again.

"For Dinah. For Bram. For Kitty."

Again.

"For Pa Cudjoe."

He stood there with the empty cup in his hand. Everyone was watching him. He didn’t seem to notice.

"For Amara," he said quietly, and poured.

Across the fire, Yaw’s head came up.

"For Juba," Titus said.

He stopped. He looked down at the cup in his hand. Then he filled it one last time and stood there holding it for a long time.

"For everybody in every hold," he said. "Every one of them. That never got a fire like this."

He poured it out on the ground.

Then he filled the cup a final time, and drank it all at once, and threw the cup down on the ground, and turned around with his face wet and his jaw clenched.

"Somebody," he said roughly, "give me something to eat."

They ate. They drank. They told stories.

Quashie told how Phibba had found him, thirty years ago, half drowned on a beach in the Exumas with a brand on his shoulder and a hole in his side. How she’d hidden him in her fog for three days while a sloop full of slave catchers searched every rock and cove around him, and he’d lain in the fog listening to them pass within ten feet and never seen him. How she’d brought him to the Hollow in her boat and said, "You’ll be my Conductor now. You know what it’s like to be hunted. That’s what makes a good Conductor."

"Thirty years," Quashie said. "Thirty years I paddled for her. Never once did she say thank you." He smiled. It broke halfway. "Never once did she need to."

Cassia told how Barnaby had courted her. Badly. For two years. With fish. He’d bring her a fish every morning, the biggest he’d caught, and leave it on her doorstep, and say nothing. She hadn’t known what it meant until he finally asked her. She’d said yes because she was tired of fish.

People laughed. Cassia laughed too, and then she was crying, and then she was laughing again, and someone put an arm around her.

Somebody told about Dinah and her bees. About the time the whole hive had swarmed into Pa Cudjoe’s drum, and he’d played it anyway, and the bees had come out humming in time. Somebody told about Bram, who’d been in love with Kitty and too shy to say it. Somebody said Kitty had known all along and had been waiting.

Somebody told about Pa Cudjoe. Again. About his drum and his neighbor and the third child.

Ezinne sat with Obi pressed against her side. Her hands were wrapped in clean cloth now, and they still hurt so much she couldn’t close them. Obi kept looking at them. He kept touching the bandages very gently with the tips of his fingers.

"I’m sorry," he whispered. "I’m sorry about your hands."

"Don’t be sorry." Ezinne put her bandaged hand on his head. "You held the drum. When I couldn’t. You held it."

"It was wrong. I played it wrong."

"You played it right enough," Ezinne said. "He came, didn’t he? The old man below. He heard you, and he came."

Obi looked down at the glowing lagoon. At the place where the great thing slept somewhere far below.

He didn’t say anything. But he leaned his head against Ezinne’s arm and stayed there.

Toby woke up halfway through the night.

They had carried him up from the boat on a litter in the afternoon and laid him on a blanket by the fire, with Clementine sitting beside him. She hadn’t left him once. She had fallen asleep sitting up with his hand in hers and her head against his shoulder.

He opened his eyes.

He lay there for a while looking up at the fire and the black branches of the burned breadfruit tree above it. Then he turned his head and looked at the cooking stones at the edge of the fire. At the stew pot. At the cassava bread. At Bess and Tanty Abba, standing side by side, ladling.

His lips moved.

"Who," Toby said hoarsely, "has been cooking?"

Bess dropped the ladle.

She turned around. She stared at him. Then she crossed the terrace in three strides and dropped to her knees beside him and threw her arms around his neck, and he grunted with pain and put one big arm around her anyway.

"You fool," Bess said into his shoulder. "You stupid, stubborn old fool. You got stabbed twice. Twice."

"In the same place," Toby said. "That only counts as once and a half."

Tanty Abba came over with the stew pot. She knelt on his other side and held a spoonful up to his mouth.

"Eat," she said.

Toby looked at the spoon. He sniffed it.

"There’s cinnamon in that," he said.

"There’s always cinnamon in it."

"It’s not right in fish."

"Then don’t eat it."

Toby looked at her. Then he opened his mouth, and she fed him, and he chewed slowly with his eyes closed.

"It’s wrong," he said. "It’s always wrong." He opened his eyes. "Eat it anyway."

Tanty Abba stared at him. Then she laughed. Loud and long and wet, with her head thrown back, and Bess laughed with her, still clinging to Toby’s neck.

Ezinne stood up when the fire was at its highest.

She couldn’t hold the fiddle. She couldn’t drum. She stood on the edge of the terrace in the firelight with her bandaged hands at her sides, and she lifted her chin, and she began to sing.

It wasn’t a song anyone had heard before. It was new. She had been making it all day, silently, while they dug the graves and counted the dead. Her voice was low and slow and rough at the edges from crying.

"Old woman on the hill with her pipe gone cold,

held the sea’s grey blanket till her hands grew old."

She stopped. She waited.

She looked out over the faces in the firelight. And they understood. They had sung with her before. They knew what to do.

The whole terrace answered her.

"Lay down, lay down, the tide will carry you."

Ezinne closed her eyes.

"Drummer by the water where the bread tree grew,

went back for the third child, and the sea took him too."

"Lay down, lay down, the tide will carry you."

Tanty Abba’s voice was the loudest. It cracked on every word. She didn’t care.

"Boatman on the clifftop, Barnaby by name,

saw the iron coming, and he stood all the same."

"Lay down, lay down, the tide will carry you."

Cassia couldn’t sing. She sat with her face in her hands. Quamin sat beside her with his good arm around her shoulders, singing for both of them.

Then Ezinne sang the last part. Alone. Very softly. So softly they had to lean in to hear it.

"Lay down your oars, the long night’s through,

the water’s warm on the other side,

and we’ll keep the fire burning for you."

She stopped.

Nobody moved. Nobody spoke. The fire crackled. The lagoon glowed below.

Then, from the back of the terrace, very quietly, someone began to sing the last part again.

"Lay down your oars, the long night’s through..."

It was Clementine. She sat beside Toby with her head bowed, and her voice was so soft it was barely more than a breath. Then Yaw joined her. Then Mary. Then Titus, his deep voice steadying all of them. Then everyone.

"...the water’s warm on the other side,

and we’ll keep the fire burning for you."

They sang it three times. Then four. The sound filled the cavern and went down into the lagoon and up through the hole in the roof into the night.

Kofi sang with them.

He didn’t know when he’d started crying. He didn’t try to stop.

The fog came while they were still singing.

Kofi saw it first. He was standing at the edge of the terrace, looking up at the hole in the cavern roof where the stars showed. And the stars went grey.

Not dark. Grey. Softly. As though someone had breathed on the glass of a window.

Then the grey came down through the hole.

It came down slowly into the Hollow. A thin, soft, pale haze, drifting down out of the night sky through the shaft where the daylight came in. It drifted over the terraces and settled on the lagoon. It curled around the black branches of the breadfruit tree and lay along the paths between the burned houses like smoke lying in a valley at dawn.

The singing stopped.

Everyone looked up.

"Fog," someone whispered.

"It can’t be," Quashie said. His voice was hoarse. "It can’t be. She’s gone. Her Binding went with her. It died with her."

But it was fog. Kofi could smell it. Sea and salt and something faintly sweet under that, like the smoke from an old clay pipe.

Down at the passage, Theo had gone to the mouth of the cave to look out. He came running back up the terraces, his face white in the firelight.

"It’s outside too," he gasped. "Over the whole cove. Over the cliffs. Over the whole island, Kofi. I can’t see the sea."

Nobody said anything.

Clementine stood up from beside Toby. She walked slowly to the edge of the terrace and held out her hand into the fog, palm up, the way she’d held it over the veve on the beach at Saint-Domingue.

"It’s hers," she said quietly. "It’s her. The last of her."

"Will it hide us?" Cassia asked. "Like before? Like it always did?"

Clementine closed her eyes. The green rose faintly in her wrists.

"It won’t hide us from everyone," she said slowly. "Not like before. She’s not holding it now. It’s holding itself." She opened her eyes. "It’s following her Law. Never hide a hunter in the fog." She looked out across the grey. "It’ll hide us from anyone who comes hunting. And it’ll open for anyone who comes running. Anyone who needs us. They’ll find the way in."

The terrace was silent.

"She left it for us," Tanty Abba said. Her voice broke. "That stubborn old woman. She left it for us."

Kofi looked up at the fog drifting down through the hole in the roof.

You don’t hide them, Phibba had said. You keep them. Out in the light.

He had thought, that morning, standing at the rail, that nothing would hide the Hollow now. That the whole weight of it was his alone.

It was still his. But she hadn’t left him to carry it all by himself.

Somebody started the drum again.

It was Obi. Ezinne’s hands were too hurt. He sat behind Pa Cudjoe’s drum under the burned breadfruit tree and laid his small hands on the split skin, and he played. Not the rhythm he’d played in the battle, the angry one, the wake up, come and see. The other one. The old one. Slow. Steady. The heartbeat Pa Cudjoe had played for twenty years so that the old man below would know they were still there.

Boom. Boom. Boom.

People began to dance.

Slowly at first. Then faster. They danced in the fog around the fire, laughing and crying at the same time, the way people dance at a Nine Night, for the dead and for the living, for the ones who were gone and the ones who were left. Tanty Abba danced with Quashie. Bess pulled Theo up off the ground by both hands and made him dance, and he was terrible at it, and she laughed until she had to sit down. Cato and Mingo and Nell and Hetty danced in a ring with the children of the Hollow. Mary danced with her eyes closed and tears on her face. Titus didn’t dance. He stood at the edge of the firelight with a cup in his hand and watched, and for the first time since Kofi had known him, his face looked soft.

Kofi didn’t dance either.

He stood at the edge of the terrace with his back to the cavern wall, and he watched them, and his eyes went white.

He didn’t mean them to. It just happened. The fog had come down and the drum was beating, and something in him had opened like a door, and his eyes went white the way they had in the deep water. And he saw.

She was standing at the edge of the firelight.

Small. Grey. Thin as fog. Wrapped in a blanket, the way she had been on her litter. Her clay pipe in her teeth. Smoke curling up from its bowl, though there was nothing in it, and there had never been.

She was watching them dance.

She watched Tanty Abba, spinning in Quashie’s arms. She watched Cassia laughing through her tears. She watched the children in their ring around the fire, Hetty’s small scarred shoulder flashing in the light. She watched Obi at the drum.

Then she turned her head and looked across the fire, through the dancers, at Kofi.

Their eyes met.

She took the pipe out of her mouth. And she smiled at him. A slow, wide, crooked smile, with all her missing teeth, the smile of an old woman who has been very tired for a very long time and has finally been allowed to sit down.

Kofi couldn’t breathe.

Across the terrace, Yaw had stopped. He was standing beside the fire with Latch at his feet, and he’d gone very still, and he was staring at nothing. At a door nobody else could see. His hand was raised a little, palm out, the way you hold a door for someone with their arms full.

When I go through mine, you hold it open a little while, she had said. So I can look back at them.

He was holding it. He’d been holding it all day.

Phibba looked back at all of them one last time. At the fire, and the dancers, and the fog lying soft over her Hollow. Then she put the pipe back between her teeth.

She turned around. And she walked away into the fog.

Not fading. Walking. Upright and easy, without her litter, without anyone to carry her, the way she must have walked when she was young. She walked into the grey at the edge of the firelight, and the fog closed around her, and she was gone.

Across the terrace, Yaw’s hand dropped.

He felt the door close. Softly. The way a door closes behind someone you love who has gone home.

He sat down very suddenly on the ground. Latch climbed into his lap.

Kofi’s eyes went brown again.

He stood with his back against the cavern wall and found his face was wet. He didn’t remember starting to cry. He didn’t try to stop.

Later, much later, when the fire had burned down and the fog lay thick and soft over everything, Theo told the story.

He hadn’t meant to. Somebody had asked him what he’d seen from the guard boat, out at the cave mouth, in the night. And he had looked into his cup for a long time, and then he’d started to talk.

"I saw him on the ship," Theo said. "On the stern. Just standing there. Then he went over the rail into the sea." He turned his cup in his hands. "And I thought, that’s it. He’s drowned. The tide’s running, the water’s cold, it’s two hundred yards to the rocks, he’s barely standing. He’s drowned."

Kofi was sitting across the fire. He didn’t say anything.

"Then the water," Theo said. He stopped. Started again. "The moon had come out. The fog had gone. I could see everything. And the water around him lit up. Pale. Like there were lanterns under the sea. And then I saw them."

"Saw who?" Bess asked.

"People," Theo said. "In the water. Hundreds of them. Pale. Grey. Like they were made of moonlight. They came up out of the sea all around him. And they took hold of him. Under his arms. His legs. And they carried him." His voice went thin. "Across the water. Faster than any boat. Faster than anything. Like a road. A road of people under the sea. And he went along it, standing up, with his eyes white, all the way to the rocks."

Nobody said anything.

"I saw it too," Titus said quietly.

Everyone turned to look at him.

"I was rowing." Titus was looking at Kofi across the fire. "I stopped. I saw it. Every bit of it."

Kofi met his eyes. Titus held them. He didn’t look angry. He didn’t look afraid. He looked like a man who’d seen something he would spend a long time trying to understand.

Then a voice spoke from the edge of the firelight.

"Where I come from," Jonah Lightbourn said, "the old fishermen have a saying."

He was sitting on his rock, where he’d been sitting all night. Nobody had tied him. Nobody had told him to sit apart from the rest of the prisoners, either. He just had. Hetty was asleep against his side with her head on his knee.

Everyone looked at him.

He swallowed. "When a man goes under," he said. "When he goes down off a boat in a storm, in deep water, and everybody gives him up for dead. And then he comes up again. Alive. The old men on the docks, they say the sea gave him back." He looked across the fire at Kofi. "Not many do. Not many the sea gives back."

He was quiet a moment.

"I watched them pull your captain out of the water this morning," Lightbourn said. "Half drowned. Burned." He shook his head. "The sea didn’t give him back. Somebody else did." He looked at Kofi again. "But you went into that water twice last night. Once in chains and once on your own. And both times you came back up."

He touched Hetty’s hair, very gently.

"You’re the man the sea gave back," he said.

The words went around the fire. Kofi heard them go. Somebody repeated them, softly, under their breath. Then somebody else. Quashie said them. Then Cassia. Then a child.

The man the sea gave back.

He looked at Yaw across the fire. Yaw was looking back at him. His face was very still. He knew. Of all the people around that fire, Yaw knew exactly how true it was. Clementine, sitting beside Toby with her eyes half closed, knew too.

Nobody else did.

The words kept going around anyway.

Somebody had brought out the last cask of rum.

Kofi was drinking it. He didn’t remember starting. He just found there was a cup in his hand, and it was full, and then it was empty, and then it was full again. The rum was harsh and raw and he loved it. He had never liked rum in either of his lives. He couldn’t get enough of it now.

Someone said something funny. Kofi didn’t even hear what. He just heard the laughter around the fire, and then he was laughing too.

He laughed too loud.

It came up out of him the way it had on the rocks. Booming. Rolling. Echoing a little off the cavern walls, the way laughter echoes in an empty place. It went on too long. Past the point where the joke was funny. Past the point where anyone else was still laughing. Heads turned. The children by the fire stopped and stared at him.

He stopped.

He sat there with the cup in his hand and the echo of his own laugh dying away, and he felt it. Under his ribs. In his chest. Something grinning. Something enjoying itself.

Yaw had moved around the fire. He was sitting beside him now.

"That wasn’t you," Yaw said quietly. Low enough that nobody else could hear.

Kofi looked down at the cup.

"I know," he said.

Yaw didn’t say anything else. He took the cup out of Kofi’s hand. He set it down on the ground between them. He didn’t pick it up again, and neither did Kofi.

They sat there together in the fog.

Pockets was crowned a little before dawn.

It was Obi’s idea. He’d spent half the night telling every child in the Hollow about the monkey with the sword, and how it had stuck in the rock, and how Pockets had bitten the soldier on the nose. By the end of the night, the story had grown. Pockets had fought six soldiers. Ten. A whole company.

So the children made him a crown.

It was a scrap of blue cloth tied in a ring, with a long grey feather stuck through it that Cato had found on the cliff path. They put it on his head while he was asleep in Toby’s lap. He woke up and found it there and was outraged. He tried to pull it off. Then he caught sight of his own reflection in a puddle and stopped.

He looked at himself for a long time.

Then he left the crown on, climbed out of Toby’s lap with enormous dignity, walked across the terrace to the last cask of rum, put both arms around Kofi’s abandoned cup, and ran.

"Thief!" Titus roared.

Pockets went up the black trunk of the breadfruit tree with the cup clutched to his chest, rum slopping over its rim. He sat on the highest burned branch with his feather crown tipped over one eye and drank.

The whole terrace dissolved.

The drum changed at dawn.

Obi had been playing the slow heartbeat for hours. His hands had blistered. He hadn’t stopped. Now, without anyone telling him to, he changed it. Faster. Lighter. A rhythm they all knew. The children knew it first. They began to clap between the beats without being told, the way Pa Cudjoe had taught them.

Ezinne stood up.

She stood at the edge of the terrace in the grey light coming down through the fog, with her bandaged hands at her sides, and she sang.

"There’s a man called Kofi Brook,

built the ship that the lord took..."

The whole Hollow came in at the chorus. They didn’t need to be asked. Thirty-five people of the Hollow and the whole crew of the Morning Star. Even Jonah Lightbourn, who’d only heard it once. Even the Navy prisoners at the bottom of the terraces, some of them, quietly, under their breath.

"Ring, Bell, ring, you won’t ring long,

the sea don’t carry a chain that strong.

Ring, Bell, ring, till your bell runs dry,

Kofi Brook don’t die!"

They sang every verse. The Building. The Arm. The Theft. The Name. The Mermaid Queen. Amara, sung slow, with Yaw’s eyes closed. The Reef. Juba, with Cato’s head bowed.

Then Ezinne stopped.

Everyone stopped with her. The drum went on. Obi’s small hands, steady.

Ezinne looked across the fire at Kofi.

Then she sang a verse nobody had heard before.

"Iron chain across the door,

Bell came hunting to the shore.

Sea gave back what the sea once took,

the old man rose for Kofi Brook."

There was a moment of silence.

Then the whole terrace came in on the chorus. Louder than any of them had ever sung it. Louder than they’d sung it in the storm, or at Pa Cudjoe’s first night, or in the cove at Saint-Domingue. The sound went up through the hole in the roof into the fog and out over the sea.

"Ring, Bell, ring, you won’t ring long,

the sea don’t carry a chain that strong.

Ring, Bell, ring, till your bell runs dry,

Kofi Brook don’t die!"

Kofi stood at the edge of the terrace in the grey dawn and listened to them sing it.

It wasn’t about him. Not really. It had never really been about him. It was about all of them. Every person in this cavern. Every person who’d run, and every one who’d been carried, and every one who’d stayed behind in a cane field or a hold and never gotten to sing at all.

He looked out over the faces in the firelight. Thirty-five of the Hollow. Fourteen children. His crew. A Navy deserter with a sleeping girl against his side.

All of them his now. To keep.

The weight of it sat on his chest like a hoof. Like a chain.

He stood under it in the grey light and sang.