I spread my hands over Percy’s notebook like a general looking over a battlefield, which I found privately hilarious, because three months ago I’d been an Unmarked kid whose most dangerous tactical decision was picking an instant ramen flavor.
"The original teams treated this like a siege," I said. "Four squads taking turns breaching through predictable entry points, and every one of them got displaced the second they walked into his sight line. They were playing his game by his rules."
"Obviously," Camille said, without looking up from her tablet.
"So we don’t play his game. We don’t breach at all."
That got her attention. Her brown eyes came up off the screen and locked on mine. She wanted to confirm it was as wrong as it sounded before she started taking it apart.
"You don’t breach," she repeated, flat.
"We don’t breach. We deny." I pointed at Percy’s floor plan. "His Aspect needs line of sight. Every window and every open corridor is a firing lane for him. So we take the firing lanes away. We seal the building."
Percy’s pen stopped. Felicity leaned forward in her chair.
"Think about it," I went on, warming up to my own brilliance in the way that usually comes right before somebody tells me I’m wrong. "If we block every ground-floor window and kill every sight line from his documented spots on the third floor to anything outside, his Aspect’s useless against our approach. He can’t swap what he can’t see."
Felicity’s eyes lit up, and she wound a strand of hair around her finger while she put the compliment together.
"That’s actually kind of genius," she said.
"Genius is a strong word. It’s environmental denial. Dravid literally covered this in his first lecture. Take away the conditions that make the threat work, and the threat shuts itself down." I was on a roll now. The words came out smooth and confident, in the register Diane had taught me for selling an idea to a room full of people who hadn’t decided whether to buy.
"We send a team to the parking structure, which Percy’s blind spots say has no sight lines to the third floor. They use Aspects to block every window from outside. A second team goes through the ground-floor maintenance corridors and seals the interior sight lines on the first and second floors. When we’re done, he’s sitting in a box with no way to see anything past his own floor."
"And then?" Camille asked. Her tone hadn’t moved. Still flat. Still waiting.
"Then we send Percy up the service elevator shaft on the east side. It’s one of his blind spots, with no line of sight from any documented position. Percy runs Analyze on the floor, finds exactly where the Villain and all seventeen hostages are, and feeds it back to us live. We breach from below, straight up through the floor with structural disruption, which skips every door and window he’s watching, and we pull the hostages out the same way."
I sat back with the satisfaction of a guy who’d just solved in fifteen minutes what four licensed Hero teams couldn’t solve in six hours.
"Questions?"
Percy’s pen still hadn’t moved. He was staring at his own floor plan with the unfocused look that meant Analyze was running faster than his mouth could keep up.
"Oh, that’s so good," Felicity said. She actually clapped once, a quick little pop that got a glance from Maribelle’s group two rows over. "The environmental denial thing is straight out of Dravid’s lecture. Steele’s going to love that we’re cross-referencing the curriculum."
"Steele’s going to love that we have a plan that doesn’t involve charging the front door and getting teleported into a wall," I said. "The cross-referencing is a bonus."
Felicity grinned and bumped her shoulder into mine. The contact lasted about half a second longer than friendship called for, but I’d quit tracking how long Felicity’s touches lasted, because the numbers kept going up and the data was making my life worse.
Camille hadn’t smiled, and she hadn’t clapped. She was looking at my plan the way her Aspect looked at stress fractures in a load-bearing wall, which is to say she was finding the spot where the whole thing was going to come down.
"You’re wrong," she said.
The two words landed on the desk and stayed there. Felicity’s enthusiasm cooled several visible degrees. Percy’s pen started moving again.
"About which part?" I asked, keeping my voice even.
"The important part." Camille put her tablet down and leaned in. It brought her closer to the middle of the group, and closer to me, which I noticed, because my brain never stopped clocking how close Camille was no matter how many professional boundaries she laid down. "You said we seal the building so he can’t see out. Block the windows. Kill the sight lines."
"That’s the plan, yeah."
"And what happens to the seventeen hostages when you seal every exit in a building with a Villain who has a combat-grade Aspect and nowhere left to run?"
The question just hung there.
I opened my mouth.
I closed my mouth.
Camille watched me do it and waited for me to catch up.
"You just locked seventeen civilians in a box with the threat," she said. "Your environmental denial plan takes away his ability to push his Aspect outward. Great. It also takes away every way out those seventeen people would need if this escalates. If your breach from below goes wrong, or if anything drifts five percent off your plan, you’ve got seventeen people trapped in a sealed building with a guy who can rearrange everything he can see."
She picked her tablet back up and opened the incident timeline. "The original Hero teams failed because they couldn’t coordinate. Your plan fails because you forgot the civilians are anything more than extraction objectives. You’re treating them like packages that need to get picked up and moved to a safe zone. Packages don’t panic. People do. They run, and they open the doors you sealed and bring back the sight lines you got rid of."