Felicity’s cheerful agreement had drained off her face. She’d backed a position that was getting taken apart piece by piece. She looked at me, then at Camille, then back at me.
"I mean," Felicity said, "the core concept still works though, right? The environmental denial part is solid, even if the execution needs some adjusting."
"The core concept is fine in a vacuum where civilians don’t exist," Camille said. She said it plainly, the way she said everything, without padding or apology.
"Halloran doesn’t grade in a vacuum. Steele told us any brief with more civilian casualties than the real outcome means extra miles on Thursday. Your plan seals the building, right? So what happens when civilian number seven on the second floor hears us banging around blocking windows, panics, and runs for the stairwell that puts him right in the Villain’s line of sight?"
I didn’t have an answer for that one.
I hadn’t thought about it. I’d been so busy designing a clever way to control the environment that I’d forgotten the environment had living people in it, and nobody could predict or control what they’d do when the adrenaline started spiking.
The plan looked clean on paper. It looked significantly less clean when you factored in the part where human beings under pressure did things that didn’t make sense from a tactical standpoint.
"Displaced," Percy said quietly. It was the first word he’d said since I finished my pitch. His voice carried the specific texture of someone who had already run the math and was delivering the result without softening it. "The civilian walks into his sight line and gets displaced to a random spot on another floor. Maybe into an area we’ve already sealed. Maybe into structure we’ve already broken for the breach from below. Injury probability goes from seven percent to roughly thirty-one percent per displacement event, based on the Villain’s documented control under stress. Which is to say he panics like everyone else. And when he panics, his Aspect fires faster than his decision-making process."
"Which means my plan could cause more casualties than the original outcome," I said.
I said it before anyone else could. The room needed to hear it from me, not from someone else delivering the verdict on my behalf. I’d put the plan on the table. I got to be the one who acknowledged it didn’t hold.
Percy looked at me with brown eyes that held zero judgment and a lot of sympathy. "Yes."
Felicity winced. "Okay. So we need a different approach."
"We need a different approach," Camille said. She hadn’t taken her eyes off me through any of this, and what was on her face surprised me. It was respect. I’d put a plan on the table and taken the correction without dodging or making excuses, and she’d clocked it.
That look did things to me that I was not about to examine in a classroom full of witnesses.
"His Aspect swaps the positions of objects in his line of sight," Camille said, pulling us back to the problem. "Percy, your Analyze. Can you get his range limit out of the data we’ve got?"
Percy’s focus shifted, subtle, as Analyze kicked in. His eyes went distant for a second and a half and came back with something new.
"Based on the displacement distances in the incident report, his maximum effective range looks like about forty meters. He moved one Hero team member from the ground floor atrium to the third floor, which is roughly twelve meters vertical and twenty-eight horizontal. A combined vector of about thirty meters. But he failed to displace a second Hero who was standing behind a support column with only partial visibility. Um, that suggests line of sight has a minimum visual threshold. A glimpse isn’t enough. He has to see enough of the target to lock on."
"Partial cover breaks his targeting," Camille said right away. "That’s the weakness. We don’t need to seal the whole environment. We need partial visual cover."
"Mobile cover," I said, and I felt the idea snap into place with a clarity my first plan never had, because this one remembered the thing I’d forgotten. "Forget sealing the building. We give the hostages cover that moves with them."
Camille’s head tilted. "Keep going."
"Felicity’s illusions hit multiple senses and look completely real up close. So instead of sealing his sight lines, what if we fill the building with visual noise? Fake hostages, fake Hero teams coming in from fake positions. Walls and barriers that don’t exist, but that he has to look at and sort through before he can target anything behind them."
"His Aspect needs a line-of-sight confirmation," Felicity said, and the cheerleader had dropped out of her voice. She was thinking now, and talking faster.
"If I flood his vision with false targets, every swap he tries is a gamble. He can’t tell which hostages are real and which are projections. He wastes his Aspect on illusions that don’t move when he swaps them, because they aren’t physical objects."
"While we use Percy’s blind spots to get the real hostages out on routes that never cross his field of view," Camille said. She was leaning forward now, tablet forgotten, her hands tracing invisible approach lines in the air over Percy’s notebook. "The illusions keep him busy on floors one and two while the real extraction runs through the service areas."
"And civilians who panic and run for the stairwell see my illusions of Hero teams already in position, which calms them down instead of sending them into his sight line," Felicity added. "Crowd control through feeling safe. I’ve been using Mirage for crowd control since I was fourteen."
Percy’s pen was flying again, copying the plan onto his floor plan as it grew and noting where each piece sat and when it moved.
"I can feed real-time information over an earpiece on which hostage positions are real and which are illusions, so the extraction team can get through the true blind spots without bumping into the illusions. The information load is manageable if I, um, if I can focus on one floor at a time instead of running the whole building at once."
"So we partition. Floor by floor, bottom up." Camille drew a horizontal line across Percy’s third-floor schematic.
"Clear the ground floor first while Felicity fills the upper floors with visual chaos. Move to the second floor once the ground-level hostages are out. Third floor last, after he’s already burned most of his swaps on illusions and the real targets are down to a manageable number."