Reborn in 1914: I Will Build India into a Superpower · Contents

CHAPTER 150

Chapter 150: A Dream Starts

19 min read·namekjin35

South Block

14 February 1951

The monthly report from Bangalore came to Ram’s desk on the fourteenth, as it did on the fourteenth of every month: a bound folder of fifty-odd pages, typed in triplicate, with a summary at the front and the detailed returns of each division at the back. He read the summary at breakfast. The returns he read in the evenings, in the quiet hour between the last visitor and the last telegram, with a pencil. It was a habit he had cultivated ever since he thought of pulling off something akin to Operation Paperclip during the war.

The jet-engine programme was on schedule. The 10-kilonewton competition had been announced, and both bureaus had begun. The metallurgical group reported the first successful casting of a cobalt-nickel turbine blade, imperfect, but whole. The gas-process team under Brandt and Mori had a pilot absorber running at Bangalore. The rocket group had burned a motor for forty seconds without a failure. The atomic establishment filed a single line: Progress satisfactory.

On page forty-one, in a section headed Miscellaneous Physics Group: Dr. K. S. Krishnan, Superintending Scientist, there was a footnote.

It was a small section, headed Miscellaneous Physics, and it consisted of seven items in a typed list. The first four were about glass. The fifth was a report from a laboratory in the crystal group, signed by a German named Dr. Heinz Ebel, and it was three lines long.

Item 5. A team of the crystal group (Ebel, Matsuda, with six Indian apprentices) has reproduced the American solid-state amplifier described in the Bell Telephone Laboratories paper of July 1948. A germanium crystal, two fine wire contacts. Gain of approximately 18 observed on the bench. Unstable, sensitive to temperature, irreproducible between specimens. No obvious application. Work to continue at low priority.

He read it once and passed on to the sixth item, which was about quartz. He had turned a page before something stopped him, and he turned back.

A solid-state amplifier.

It was a plain phrase. It said nothing remarkable. He sat looking at it with a vague unease, as if he had walked past a familiar face in a crowd and not yet placed it. Amplifier. Gain. A crystal and two wires.

His degree at Allahabad had been in chemistry, with a little physics in the second year. He had studied the vacuum tube in a laboratory course, the glass bulb with its glowing filament and its grid and plate, the thing that made the radio loud enough to hear. A small signal came in at the grid. A large one came out at the plate. That was amplification. That was what a valve did, and every wireless set in the country was full of them: glass, hot, fragile, hungry for power.

And the item said that a crystal of germanium, with two wires touching it, could do the same.

He read the line a third time. Then, very slowly, he put the report down on his desk.

A transistor.

The word came whole, unbidden, from a part of his memory he had not touched for three years. It was in no textbook he had read in this life. It had come from the other one: the corporate towers, the glass offices, the endless rows of identical machines. He had never learned how they worked. He had never needed to. He had known only that every device in his old life, every phone, every computer, every car, every light switch, had been full of them, billions of them, each one a tiny crystal smaller than a grain of rice, switching on and off a billion times a second.

Everything he had ever used, every spreadsheet that had stopped making sense at seven-fifteen in the evening, had been built out of this. The thing in the report was the first of them. It was, at this moment, a crude, unstable, almost useless lump of germanium, which a roomful of scientists had made to review the Americans’ process and partly to satisfy their own curiosity and filed under Miscellaneous.

He stood up; there was an excitement in his chest rising in contrast to the silent room. Through the window he could see the long, dark line of Rajpath, and beyond it the black shape of India Gate, and the sky. He did not move for several minutes.

Shaktidas, he thought. Then he thought: No. Not tonight.

He sat down again and wrote one line on a clean sheet. Bangalore. Ebel. This week. He underlined it twice and went to bed, and could not sleep.

Bangalore

18 February 1951

The Avro York landed at BAL in a light drizzle. Dr. Krishnakant Sharma met him at the foot of the steps. He had come alone, as requested, without Patel or Nehru, with only Shaktidas and a single case of papers.

"The crystal group is in the old physics wing," Sharma said, as they drove. "Dr. Ebel’s laboratory is on the second floor. It is small. I should warn you, Prime Minister, they do not expect much interest. It is not one of the main programmes."

"I know."

"Then may I ask why you came?"

"I have a question for them."

The physics wing was a low stone building with deep verandahs and a smell of old paper and hot wire. The laboratory on the second floor was a long, narrow room with a bench down one side, a rack of instruments, and a blackboard covered in equations. At the bench sat two men in white coats. One was tall and stooped, with grey in his hair and a long, cautious face. The other was small and exact, with round spectacles, and sat very straight. Six young Indians stood behind them, like a class that had been called to attention, and one of them, a boy of about twenty-two, nearly dropped a pair of pliers.

"Dr. Ebel," Sharma said. "Dr. Matsuda. The Prime Minister."

Ebel rose. He had a dry, formal manner that reminded Ram of Brandt, and he spoke very correct English. "Prime Minister, this is an honour. I fear we have little to show."

"I should like to see what you have."

"Certainly."

On the bench, under a glass cover, sat a small apparatus on a block of wax. It was not impressive. A chip of grey metal no larger than a lentil, held in a clamp. Two wires, thin as hairs, ending in sharp points that rested on its surface a fraction of a millimetre apart. Three leads ran from it to a rack of instruments. A needle on one dial twitched faintly.

"This is the germanium crystal," Ebel said. "We purchased the raw material from the zinc smelting plant at Bhilai; it is a by-product of the refining process, and Dr. Matsuda’s group has been refining it. It is not pure, but it is purer than what the American paper describes. The two wires are of gold, which we have drawn to a diameter of about a hundredth of a millimetre. They are brought down by a micrometre screw until they touch the surface. If one then applies a small voltage to one wire and a larger to the other, a current flows through the crystal. A small change in the first produces a larger change in the second."

"I would like to see it."

Matsuda threw a switch. A low hum rose from a loudspeaker on the wall. Ebel took a tuning fork from the bench, struck it against his knee, and held it near the microphone. The hum became a clear, steady note, louder than the fork had been.

"The gain is about eighteen," Ebel said. "That means a signal of one unit comes out as eighteen. It varies a good deal. If I breathe on the crystal, it changes. If the room warms, it changes. If I move the wires a hair’s breadth, it changes. Dr. Matsuda has made twenty-three specimens. None is quite like the others."

"How long does it last?"

"A few hours, usually. Then the contact drifts."

"And the power it uses?"

Ebel glanced at Matsuda. Matsuda spoke for the first time, in a soft, precise voice. "A fraction of a watt, Prime Minister. About one-hundredth of what a vacuum tube of the same gain requires. It has no filament. It does not glow. It is quite cold."

"Cold," Ram repeated.

"Yes. That is the remarkable thing, in a sense. It is a curiosity, though."

"Why a curiosity?"

"Because it cannot be used." Ebel spread his hands. "I do not say it cannot, in principle. The American laboratory describes the effect as a general one, and suggests that it might, in time, supplant the thermionic valve. I think that is over-optimistic. A valve is a robust thing. One can hold it in one’s fist, and it will not break. This is a speck of crystal that cannot be duplicated. We tried to make a hundred, and every single one was different. I do not see how one could build a thermionic valve from it, still less a reliable one."

"Then why did you make it?"

"Because it was in the paper." Ebel smiled, a little embarrassed. "A habit. When the Americans publish something odd, we try to reproduce it. We did the same with their magnetic recording. It is how one keeps up."

"I see." Ram bent over the bench. The grey chip lay under the clamp, looking at him with dull indifference. "May I ask you something? As a layman?"

"Of course."

"Is this doing the same work as a vacuum tube?"

"In a sense, yes. It is a solid-state device that amplifies. It is not the same in principle, but it is the same in function."

"Could one make a radio set from it?"

"In principle, yes. A single stage of amplification, in a crystal receiver."

"Not a laboratory model. A set that a man could carry in his pocket and listen to. Or one a soldier could carry in the field."

Ebel was silent a moment. The six Indian apprentices had edged forward, listening with a quiet intensity that Ram found oddly moving.

"A portable receiver would need at least three or four stages of amplification," Ebel said slowly. "Today, that requires valves. A good valve set weighs several kilograms, with batteries as heavy as the set. It burns out. It needs a power supply that a soldier cannot carry. If one could replace them with crystals..." He stopped. "It would weigh a few hundred grams. It would run for weeks on a small battery. It would not break. It would be a different kind of radio."

"Then why not try?"

"Because the crystals are not reproducible, Prime Minister. I said so."

"You said that you had made twenty-three and none was alike. May I ask what you have done to find out why?"

There was a pause. Matsuda took off his spectacles, polished them, and put them on again. "We have not investigated it systematically, sir. It was a low-priority exercise."

"I understand. I am not criticising." Ram stood upright. "I should like to know what you think the cause is."

"The purity," said Matsuda at once. He had clearly been waiting to be asked. "The germanium we use is, by the standards of a metallurgist, very pure. But a crystal of this kind is sensitive to a tiny trace of foreign atoms. One part in a million, perhaps. One in ten million. A few stray atoms of some other element change the behaviour entirely. If the crystal has a different trace of impurity from the last, it will behave differently. We cannot even say which impurities matter. We cannot measure them."

"Can they be removed?"

"There are methods of purification. Repeated recrystallisation. Zone melting, which a man at Bell Laboratories is said to be working on. I have no experience of it." Matsuda looked up. "It would require equipment we do not have. A furnace with very exact temperature control, a clean chamber, instruments that can detect minute traces. And time. A great deal of time."

"Time and equipment can be provided."

"With respect, Prime Minister," Ebel said carefully, "I do not think it is the best use of them. We have the jet engine programme, the alloys, the gas processing, the rockets. This is a toy."

"I may be wrong," Ram said. "I am, I should say, rather often wrong. But let me tell you what I think, and then tell me where my reasoning fails."

He drew up a stool and sat. The apprentices pressed a little closer. Sharma, by the door, folded his arms.

"In my lifetime, the whole of electronics has been built on the vacuum tube. The radio, the telephone amplifier, the radar, the gun director, the calculating machine that Dr. Bhabha’s people use. All of them are made of vacuum tubes. And all of them have the same difficulty. A vacuum tube is large. It is fragile. It is hot. It needs a heater, which draws power. It fails. A working machine of any size requires hundreds of them, and if one fails in a hundred hours, the machine is always broken.

"What you have here is a device that performs the same function and has none of these faults. It is small. It is cold. It uses almost no power. It has no moving parts and no filament. If it could be made reliably, it would replace every valve in every machine we possess. A radio would fit in a man’s hand. A computing machine would fit in a room instead of a building. A radar set would fit in an aircraft."

"If it could be made reliably," Ebel said.

"That is the whole matter. It is not a question of whether the principle is sound. You have shown that it is. It is a question of craft. Purification. Manufacture. The same work that, in the last century, turned a laboratory curiosity called a steam engine into a locomotive." He leaned forward. "I do not ask you to believe it will succeed. I ask you to consider that if it does, the nation that has it first will not need to buy a single valve from anyone."

Matsuda had gone very still. "A national industry."

"A national industry. And the thing it makes, a transistor, I am told is the American word, can be put into any machine."

"The American paper calls it a transistor," said one of the apprentices, a thin boy with large ears who had been staring at the floor. He coloured at once and stopped.

"Thank you," Ram said. "What is your name?"

"Venkataraman, sir. Of Madras."

"Do you think I am talking nonsense, Venkataraman?"

The boy swallowed. "No, sir. I have been thinking the same, sir. For six months. I did not like to say."

"Why not?"

"Dr. Ebel said it was not a priority."

Ebel did not flinch. "I did. I was wrong, I think."

"You were reasonable," Ram said gently. "You judged by the evidence in front of you. I am asking you to judge by something else, which is where the evidence may lead in ten years. It is a harder thing to do." He turned back. "Now, tell me what is wrong. I want the shortcomings, all of them. I should rather hear them from you than from a failure."

For the next hour they told him. Ebel, who had been a sceptic, now spoke with the dry precision of a man who had found an interesting problem and was ashamed to have been slow to see it. The crystal had to be pure beyond anything the Indian foundries could make. The contacts had to be set by hand, under a microscope, and drifted.

The device could not be sealed, so moisture in the air changed its behaviour. It ran well at ordinary temperatures but failed when warm, and a Bangalore summer was enough. It could not handle high frequencies, which a radio would need. It could not handle much power, which a loudspeaker would need. And it made a hiss when amplifying, a faint steady noise like rain on a roof, which would drown a weak signal.

"These are all difficulties that can be reduced," Ram said, when they had finished. "Not removed, reduced. Let me say what I believe, and you will tell me if I am deceiving myself."

He took a sheet of paper from the bench and began to draw.

"The purity. You say a trace of foreign atoms spoils the crystal. Is it possible that some foreign atoms are useful? That they cause the crystal to carry current in one way or the other? I believe I read a paper some years ago that said adding group 3 elements caused the material to conduct one way and adding group 5 elements the other."

Matsuda looked at him, startled. "Yes. That is correct. Those are called donor and acceptor impurities. How did you...?"

"Merely something I remember. Then the purity must be controlled in two directions. First, remove everything. Then add exactly the right amount of what you want. It is a refining problem, and then an alloying problem. You have the chemists; Dr. Bhatnagar’s people here are the best in Asia."

"It would require measurements of a kind that no one has made," Matsuda said slowly. "A way of detecting one atom in ten million."

"A mass spectrograph, Dr. Bhabha has one."

"It is used for uranium."

"It can be used for germanium." Ram drew a line. "The contacts. You say they drift. What if the crystal were not touched by wires at all? What if the contacts were made by fusing a small bead of metal onto the crystal, a dot of indium, say, heated until it melts into the surface? It would be permanent. It would not drift."

Ebel’s eyes had gone narrow. "That would make a junction. A different structure entirely."

"Would it not work?"

"It might. A junction device, in which the two regions are formed by the impurity itself, was proposed in the American theoretical literature. A man named Shockley published a paper in 1949. It was dismissed as too difficult." Ebel sat very still. "Prime Minister, I do not think I can say whether it is possible. I should like to find out."

"The material, then. Germanium is rare and expensive. What other elements behave like it?"

"Silicon," Matsuda said at once. "It is the most plentiful element in the earth after oxygen. It is in the same family. It is harder to purify, because its melting point is higher and it reacts with everything it touches. But if it can be done, the device would work at higher temperatures. Germanium fails in the heat. Silicon does not."

"Silicon is sand."

"In a sense."

"We have a good deal of sand." Ram permitted himself a small smile. "And there may be others. Elements. Compounds. I know very little. But I think the periodic table has more to give than one element."

"A great deal more," Ebel said, and then, with an effort that cost him something, "Prime Minister, I think I must withdraw what I said an hour ago. It is not a toy."

"I did not say it was a certainty."

"No. It is the most interesting thing I have heard in three years."

Ram rose. His knees were stiff from the stool. He looked at the six Indian faces turned toward him, young, dark, intent, each of them a boy from some town where there had been no electricity four years before, and thought of the apprentices he had seen on the floor of the Babina plant, with their Sanskrit chants and their careful hands.

"Then I shall tell you what I want." Ram began to walk, slowly, along the bench. "I want a laboratory. Not a corner of this room. A dedicated laboratory, for solid-state electronics, with its own building, its own funds, its own director. The staff will be what you have now: the two of you will lead it, the same way the jet engine bureaus are being led, with the apprentices. I shall add whatever you ask for. Furnaces, vacuum pumps, spectrographs, an X-ray diffraction unit if you want one. Chemists to purify, metallurgists to grow, glassblowers to package.

"And as many Indian apprentices as you can train. The Indian Institute of Science will send you its best graduates in physics and chemistry every year. Teach them. In ten years, I want this laboratory to be run by Indians who learned here."

"And the objective?" Ebel asked, very softly.

"Is a radio."

"A radio."

"Not a laboratory device. A receiver that a family can buy, a soldier can carry, and a sailor can use. In two years. It need not be good. It need not be small. It must be real. Made from transistors, I think that is the name, and not from tubes. It must work, in an Indian summer, in a hot shed, in the rain. It must be something we can manufacture in a factory. It must be something the Army will want."

Matsuda said nothing. He was gazing at the apparatus on the bench.

"Why a radio?" Ebel asked.

"Because a radio is the simplest thing that is also useful. Everybody wants one. The Army wants a portable set that does not need a heavy battery. A tube set needs a high-tension supply, forty or sixty volts at least, and a filament battery besides. It is the weight of a rifle. A transistor set might run on a pair of torch cells. It might fit in a pocket. The Army will pay for that. The poor man will pay for it, too, if it costs less than a tube radio, which it will, once the factory exists.

"And the money from the radios, the Army’s orders, the civilian market, will pay for the next stage, and the next. I do not wish to be a patron. A laboratory that depends on a Prime Minister’s affection is a laboratory that dies when he does. I wish it to earn its way. A product, a market, a revenue, a budget that grows. That is how it will be allowed to go on."

"The commercial rationale," Ebel murmured.

"Yes. I do not say it is the noble one. It is the one that keeps a laboratory alive." Ram looked round at them. "It is the technology of the future, I believe. Radios, calculators, perhaps even beyond those. But it will begin with a radio, because a radio is the thing people will buy. When they have bought a million, you will have the money to build whatever you please. I shall not say more. It is for the future. I tell you only that this is a technology for the future, and I ask you to go on with it, patiently, even when it fails, especially when it fails."

Nobody spoke. The rain had stopped, and a pale light came in through the dusty window onto the bench, the grey chip, and the two gold wires.

The thin boy, Venkataraman, said, in a voice that was almost a whisper, "Prime Minister, may I tell you what the first thing will be? The very first thing we try."

"What would you try?"

The boy blushed again, but he did not look away. "I should try to find out why they drift, sir. I think it is moisture. If we sealed it in glass, or in wax, I think the drift would stop."

"Then begin with that," Ram said. "Begin with wax."

He said nothing more, and walked to the door. At the threshold, he turned. Ebel was already bent over the bench with a pencil, Matsuda was at the blackboard with a piece of chalk, and the apprentices were clustering round them, all talking at once, in a mixture of English, Tamil, German, and a few words of Sanskrit that someone had brought in from the Allahabad school.

The York rose out of the drizzle at four. Beneath it, the roofs of Bangalore fell away, and the long grey fence of the enclave, and the half-built sheds of the new laboratories. Ram sat with his hands folded, looking at nothing. He was thinking of a speck of crystal, and of a small boy named Venkataraman, and of the strange, silent distance between the thing that was and the thing that would be. He thought it was the loneliest knowledge he had ever carried. He also thought, for the first time in a long while, that he might be about to give it away.

A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.