Ministry of Finance, North Block
20 February 1951
The Budget for 1951-52 was to be presented in twelve days, and the Finance Minister’s room in North Block had acquired the look of a besieged fort. Ledgers stood in towers on the floor. A slide rule lay across a map of the Union. Three adding machines, borrowed from the Reserve Bank, clattered in an adjoining office, operated by clerks who had not been home since Sunday.
Ardeshir Darabshaw Shroff stood at the window in his waistcoat with his spectacles pushed up on his forehead. He had a cup of Darjeeling in his hand and had forgotten it. When Ram came in, with Shaktidas a step behind, Shroff turned and set the cup down on a pile of Burmah accounts, where it would leave a ring.
"Prime Minister. I had meant to send for you tomorrow, when the tables were finished. They are not finished. I am not sure they will be by the budget."
"Then show me what is not finished."
"That is a rather large part of it." Shroff gestured to the long table, where a single sheet lay squared in front of two chairs. "But I have the summary. I prepared it last night, because I find that a man who has not slept will tell the truth more readily than one who has."
They sat. Shroff put his spectacles on, and for a moment, Ram saw the accountant vanish, and the Bombay Plan’s co-author appear in his place, a man who had spent his life believing numbers were a form of courtesy.
"You asked what our financial status is. I shall begin with the whole, and then the parts. The national income of the Union, for the year just ending, is estimated at thirty-eight billion dollars at the pegged rate. That is thirty-seven point nine, if you wish precision. In 1947-48, as I told the House, it was twenty-eight and a half. The growth is thirty-three per cent over three years, and it is a great deal better than the Planning Commission dared predict."
"Thirty-three per cent in three years. About ten per cent a year, allowing for compounding?"
"Exactly, Prime Minister, that the figure conceals a great deal. Agriculture, which is a little over half of everything we produce, has barely moved. Two good monsoons, a bad one, and no sign yet of Dr. Swaminathan’s seed. Industry has grown by about forty-two per cent over the period, but from so small a base that it is still only a sixth of the whole. Services, which are largely government, have grown fastest of all, which I do not count as an unmixed blessing. We employ more clerks than we did in 1947. That is by design. I do not defend it forever."
"Per head?"
"The population is three hundred and seventy million, including Burma, Ceylon, and the hill states. A little over three hundred rupees a year in the old currency, a little over ninety-five dollars at our rate. In 1947, it was seventy-two. Britain has about eight hundred. The United States, fourteen hundred. We are a poor country, Prime Minister, and the figure says so plainly." He paused. "It also says we are poor in a different direction from the one we began in. Three years ago, the line was flat. Now it is rising. I would rather say that than anything else."
Ram nodded. "Prices."
"The cost of living, on the Reserve Bank’s index, with 1947 as a hundred, stands at a hundred and thirty-one. Eight per cent a year, near enough. Food is worse: a hundred and thirty-eight. Wheat has risen the most, because of the Punjab. Rice has been held down by the Burmese surplus and the Ceylon contracts. Other items, cloth, fuel, metals, a hundred and twenty-four. Rents in the big cities have doubled, because six million refugees want rooms, and we have not built enough of them." He tapped the sheet. "It is not alarming, but something to keep an eye on regardless. A man whose wage has not risen with the price of wheat is poorer today than he was in 1947, and he knows it."
"What is the cause?"
"Two. The first is the one I spoke of before, that we create rupees to buy the dollars the British pay us, and the rupees chase a limited supply of goods. I have tried to keep that in check. The second is the Punjab war. We fed four million refugees from our own granaries, and that cost us nine lakh tons of wheat we should otherwise have sold. A famine in the north would have been cheaper, in a sense, but I should not say so aloud."
"And the steel?"
Shroff’s face lightened a little. He turned the page. "This is where I am almost cheerful. In 1947, the Union produced about a million tons of finished steel, nearly all of it at Jamshedpur. In the year just ending, two million and three hundred thousand. Bhilai’s two blast furnaces were blown in last August, and its third will follow in April. By 1953, if the Russians keep their schedule, we shall make four million. By 1957, seven, if the second complex at Rourkela comes in as planned."
"Coal?"
"Thirty-one million tons in 1947. Forty-six this year. A great deal of the increase comes from the Bengal and Bihar fields, and from the Soviet deep-shaft machinery, and from Burma’s Kalewa. The new fields in Madhya Pradesh will give us another ten by 1954. We are no longer short of coal, Prime Minister. We are short of wagons to carry it."
"Electricity?"
"A little more than seventy per cent of what the plans require." Shroff sighed. "Installed capacity in 1947 was one million seven hundred thousand kilowatts. Today it is two million eight hundred. The Hirakud temporary line, the Damodar thermal stations, Neyveli’s first unit, the German turbines at Bangalore, and the diesel generators we bought from the American surplus.
"Generation, in 1947, was five and a half billion units. This year, nine and a half. It is not enough. Every new factory wants power, and the old ones have no more to spare. Mr. Savarkar tells me that the great dams will change it, but they are a ways off, and the plants they supply are being built now. We shall have power cuts in the summer. I have told the Cabinet. They have not enjoyed hearing it, but the plants will run fine."
"Our trade?"
"Exports at six hundred and fifty million dollars, imports at seven hundred and ninety. A deficit of a hundred and forty. It would have been worse but for the Soviet barter, which accounts for nearly a third of our imports and pays for itself in jute and cotton. Our dollar earnings from the maritime fees, the American and French shipping, have risen to nineteen million. The sterling interest, two hundred and forty million dollars a year, arrived on the due date in January and in July, and I shall say what I have not said in public: that the British have not once been late since last April."
"They are frightened."
"They are punctual, which is the same thing in a Treasury." Shroff turned a page. "Foreign exchange reserves, which I know interest you. At the end of 1947, a hundred and forty million dollars, free, after the American package had been committed. Today, nine hundred and eighty million. The sterling payments account for most of it. The remainder is from the American credit, which we have drawn only in part, and the trade surplus with the Soviet Union in rupee-ruble, which I cannot convert."
"Nearly a billion."
"If I include the gold, which the British returned in part, fifteen tonnes, and which we have added to from the Burmese and Ceylon mints, the figure rises to eleven hundred and thirty million. It is a comfortable sum. It would buy us a year of imports. I do not wish to spend it, but you have asked me to, and I shall."
"The Government’s own accounts."
"Here I am less comfortable." Shroff took a fresh sheet. "Revenue for 1950-51, in round figures, is five hundred and ten crores. That is customs, excise, income tax, the railways’ surplus, the Burmese and Ceylon royalties, and the profits of the state enterprises. It was a hundred and seventy in 1947. Expenditure is five hundred and ninety. The deficit is eighty crores, which is a good deal more than I should like."
"The war."
"The war accounts for a third of it. Defence is a hundred and ninety crores, nearly a third of all we spend. The rest is the welfare you have asked for: the school meals, the stipends, the health programme, the refugee rehabilitation. And, I must add, the capital expenditure. Hirakud, Bhilai, Babina, Visakhapatnam, the Soviet loans’ interest. I do not call that waste. But I do not call it free, either."
"How do you cover it?"
"By borrowing. From the Reserve Bank, which means creating money. From the public, through the post office savings and the National Savings Certificates, thirty-eight crores last year. From the provident funds. From the American and Soviet credits, which carry no cost until 1952. And from the sale of the sterling interest." He permitted himself a very thin smile. "As you know, I do not call it inflation if the dollars are real."
"Next year?"
"With the Urja Bond, the new oil company, the gas plants, the Hirakud, the AIIMS buildings, the tunnel machines you have so kindly ordered, the stadiums, the leagues, and the sewers which Mr. Gadgil wants, expenditure will rise to about seven hundred crores. Revenue will rise to perhaps five hundred and sixty. The deficit will be one hundred and forty. I could narrow it by eighty crores if I closed the Visakhapatnam yard for a year, and I am told by the Admiral that this would be unwise."
Ram did not speak. Shaktidas, who had been taking notes, looked up.
"I have given you the whole," Shroff said, more quietly. "I am a Parsi, Prime Minister, and a banker, and I am not afraid of a deficit if it buys a dam. I am afraid of a deficit that buys nothing. Seventy per cent of what we spend is real: iron, cement, grain, wages, a school meal that is eaten. Thirty per cent is the machine of the State itself, the clerks and offices and stationery. I should like to bring that thirty per cent down. I have not yet found a way."
"You will."
"I should be glad to share the credit." He took off his spectacles. "Now, you asked a second question. The private sector."
"Yes."
"I shall answer it as I should answer the Governor of the Reserve Bank, and I ask you not to be angry, because I do not know whether I am describing a success or a worry."
"Go on."
"It is a boom, Prime Minister, of a particular kind." Shroff folded his hands. "Industrial production in the private sector has risen by thirty-eight per cent since 1947, faster than the State’s. The Tatas have doubled their steel capacity at Jamshedpur. Birla has opened two new textile mills, a cement plant at Rewa, and a paper mill in Orissa. Walchand’s shipyard is running three shifts, and Kirloskar has begun making diesel engines at Poona that, I am told, are better than the English ones. Dalmia is putting up a sugar mill in every second district of the United Provinces.
"The Marwari houses are investing at a rate I have not seen since 1941. The profits are real, the dividends are rising, and the share prices in Bombay and Calcutta have gone up by sixty per cent in two years, even though you have not yet permitted a proper exchange."
"There is no licensing. No central limit on production."
"That is correct, and I shall say it in your favour. A man who wishes to build a mill may build it, if he can find the capital, the machinery, and the labour. We have not forced him to ask a hundred clerks for permission. I know of countries where a manufacturer waits two years for a licence to make a bicycle. We are not one of them." Shroff paused. "But there is another side."
"Which is?"
"Capital controls. You have kept them, and I have enforced them, and I do not say wrongly. The rupee is pegged at three-thirty. We cannot allow capital to flow out as it pleases, nor to flow in as a flood. Every foreign remittance requires the Reserve Bank’s consent. Every import of machinery requires a permit, to be paid for in dollars from the Bank’s reserve.
"A manufacturer who wishes to buy a lathe from Sheffield or a loom from Chemnitz must apply, and wait, and sometimes wait for months. I have tried to speed it. I cannot do it quickly, because the dollars are finite, and I must allocate them. A man who needs a hundred thousand dollars of machinery is competing with the Army, the railways, the Ministry of Industry, and Dr. Ghatage’s jet engines."
"So, the private sector is constrained by foreign exchange."
"Largely. It is its single greatest constraint. A second is the money market. We have no proper capital market. The Bombay Stock Exchange is a club of three hundred members, and a company that wishes to raise a crore must find a dozen rich men who will subscribe. There is no public issue on any scale. The banks lend for six months to a year, because they do not trust longer, and a factory needs ten.
"The Industrial Finance Corporation, which you set up, has lent nearly forty crores, and it is a good institution, but it cannot meet more than a tenth of the demand. A manufacturer in Coimbatore with a good plan and no connections cannot find money. A manufacturer in Bombay with a rich uncle can."
"That is a bias."
"It is a bias, and I do not like it. The old houses have an advantage, and the new men have none, and the thing we most need, a hundred small factories in a hundred small towns, is the thing we are least likely to get. I have seen the figures by region. Eighty per cent of new private industrial investment is in Bombay, Calcutta, Madras, Ahmedabad, and Kanpur. In Bihar, Orissa, the Central Provinces, the Burmese plains, the figure is five per cent. Capital goes where capital already is."
Ram was silent for a time. Then he said, "You have told me what is wrong. What is the cause?"
"I have thought about it; I find these reasons." Shroff counted. "First, as I say, the money. A private manufacturer cannot borrow long, and cannot easily raise equity. Second, foreign exchange. Third, skilled men: the foundries and mills want foremen and fitters, and your vocational institutes will not produce them until 1953. Fourth, and I raise this carefully, the State itself."
"The State?"
"A man who is thinking of building a steel mill looks at Bhilai, and thinks: if the Government wishes to make steel, will it let me make it too? A man who is thinking of a refinery looks at Visakhapatnam and the Indian Oil Corporation, and thinks the same. A man who is thinking of a turbine factory sees English Electric’s twenty-five per cent in Government hands, and thinks it prudent to wait. It is not that you have forbidden them. You have not. It is that a private man can never be sure when the State will arrive in his line."
Ram did not look surprised. "I had hoped it was not so."
"It is a perception, Prime Minister, rather than a fact. But in business, a perception is a fact. A cautious man will wait to see what you do."
"What would reassure them?"
"A statement. In the budget. That there are fields the State will occupy: defence, atomic energy, heavy electrical equipment, railways, oil exploration. That there are fields it will share: steel, shipping, fertiliser, chemicals. And that there are fields it will leave alone altogether: textiles, consumer goods, cement, sugar, light engineering, paper, food processing, anything a man with a good idea and a little money may do. And a promise that it will not nationalise anything that is not in the first list, for ten years." Shroff said it all in one breath. "I should like to say it from the Treasury Bench with your authority."
"You have it."
"I thought I might."
"You said you would also ask for the capital market."
"I did not say that." He permitted himself a very small smile. "But since you mention it. A proper stock exchange, with a regulator, a code of disclosure, and a rule against insider trading, such as the Americans put in after 1929. A body to supervise public issues. And, in time, something I have been thinking of: a Unit Trust, in which a clerk may put twenty-five rupees and own a share in forty companies. It would put the savings of the middle class to work. I know you said not yet. I only say that it will have to come, and I should like to be there when it does."
"I have some thoughts about the stock exchange myself; let’s table the discussion for the day after tomorrow. It will give me time to structure a decent enough proposal, that you can poke holes in. And the foreign exchange?"
"I should like to be permitted to release a part of the reserve for private industrial imports: two hundred million dollars over three years, under a simple scheme. No more than a month for a decision. A single list of the machinery we are willing to allow without question. The rest by exception. It would be, I think, the single most useful thing we could do."
"A hundred million out of nine hundred and eighty."
"It is a tenth. I think we can bear some more, hundred and fifty?"
Ram sat for some moments with his hand on his chin. Outside the window, a clerk was crossing the courtyard with a stack of files, and a train whistled in the distance.
"You will have it," he said at last. "But under conditions. Every importer must undertake to train apprentices from the new vocational institutes, ten for every hundred workers. And each must report production, exports, and employment to the Ministry once a year. I wish to know what is being built, and whether we cannot reduce our dependence on imports of that particular kind."
"They will grumble."
"They will be glad of the machinery."
Shroff almost laughed. He stood and went to the window, with his hands behind him, and looked for a while at the red sandstone. When he turned, his face was grave.
"Prime Minister, I have said I am a cautious man. I have shown you the facts, and I have told you what I think they mean. I would add one thing, and ask you to forgive it. In my profession, there is a saying: a country is rich when it can afford to waste. We are not yet that rich. We cannot yet afford a bad harvest, a bad war, or a bad idea. A single one of the three would cost us two years. I have watched you take risks that I would not have taken, and I have been wrong about nearly every one of them. I am therefore inclined to doubt my own caution."
"That is generous."
"It is not generosity. It is arithmetic." The corner of his mouth moved. "But I ask you to remember, when I come before you with my long face, that I am doing my duty. Somebody must be the man who says the money is not there. It is the least welcome post in any government, and I have grown rather fond of it."
"I should be uneasy without you, Shroff-ji."
"Then we are agreed." Shroff took up his cup, found it cold, and set it down again. "Would you care for tea? The cup I was holding is, I am afraid, past recovery."
A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.
Do you guys want more of such Chapters depicting the financial situation in the future? I was undecided about this Chapter but decided to go ahead with it, let me know.