Reborn in 1914: I Will Build India into a Superpower · Contents

CHAPTER 152

Chapter 152: Stock Markets (1)

9 min read·namekjin35

Ministry of Finance, North Block

22 February 1951

The room had been cleared of ledgers, and the three adding machines next door had been told to be silent. A single table stood in the middle, with six chairs and a tray of tea that nobody had touched. Shroff had put the cup with the ring under it in a drawer.

Nehru had come in last, still in his white cap, with an air of mild wariness. He had been told only that the Prime Minister wished to discuss "a question of the savings of the people." Sir Chintaman Deshmukh, the Governor of the Reserve Bank, sat beside Shroff, small, precise and unhurried, with a gold pencil. Patel occupied the end chair, with his rug, his thermos and an expression of patient suspicion.

Ram laid a blue folder on the table and did not open it at once.

"I said on Tuesday that I had been thinking about the stock market. I thought about it ever since a man named Devendra Meena, who runs Gupta Chemical Works, came to see me in January. He wished to raise capital to build new plants. He had been to the Controller of Capital Issues and been told that his shares would be priced at a figure fixed by a committee, and that he must offer sixty per cent of the issue to the public. He asked me whether this was a country that wished its factories to grow."

"Now Gupta Chemical Works is my own company; I forbade it from bidding for any government contracts to ensure no issue of conflict of interest can arise. I had no answer for him," he went on. "I looked into it instead, and I should like to lay out what I found. I shall be as plain about the faults as about the remedies. Tell me where I am wrong."

He opened the folder.

"First, the Controller of Capital Issues. Under the Capital Issues (Control) Act of 1947, a company that wishes to sell shares to the public must obtain his consent, and he fixes the price. It is a war-time instrument that we inherited intact. Second, we are, as a new nation, locked into the command framework of the Plans, and the State has rightly occupied the strategic heights. I have tried to build a balanced partnership between public and private enterprise.

"But the distrust of private capital runs deep, even in this Cabinet." He did not look at Nehru. "Some of it is justified. Third, the Bombay Stock Exchange is a club of three hundred brokers, who set the rules, judge their own disputes, and hold the keys. Fourth, the rule that sixty per cent of an issue must go to the public is, to my mind, too large. A founder who lists his firm under it must surrender control to strangers. Most will and do refuse, and so the market stays small."

Shroff nodded slowly. "I agree with the diagnosis, Prime Minister, with two reservations. The first concerns the Controller. I have not loved the Act, but I am not sure it has done only harm. In 1948 and ’49, three promoters tried to sell shares in companies that had not built a single shed. One had a prospectus with a drawing of a factory. The Controller stopped them. If price control goes, who prevents a man from selling a fiction at an inflated price to a clerk who has never seen a share certificate?"

"I shall come to that."

"I should like it recorded that I asked." Shroff took off his spectacles. "The second reservation is the sixty per cent. I agree it is too high. But I recall why it was set. The British feared the Marwari houses would list a company, sell a sliver of equity, and keep the rest in the family, so that the public became decoration. The sixty per cent was meant to ensure a real float."

"It ensured that no real family firm would list," Ram said. "Sir Chintaman?"

Deshmukh turned the gold pencil. "I concur, with a caution. The Reserve Bank has watched this market for sixteen years. Its main defect is not the Controller or the brokers. It is that it is very small and very thin. Last year, the total value of all shares listed on the Bombay exchange was about nine hundred crores. Annual turnover was perhaps sixty.

"A single large seller can move a stock by a fifth in a day. A man who wishes to sell ten thousand shares of a mill cannot find a buyer without a fall in price. In such a market, price tells us very little, and I fear that whatever structure you build will stand on a very narrow floor."

"Then the floor is what we shall discuss at the end. I should like to hear the structure first."

"By all means."

Ram turned a page.

"I propose two Acts. The first is the National Development and Public Sector Undertakings Act. It would give the PSUs a single legal form, with their own boards, accounts, and statutory duties, and, as I shall explain, a rule that every one of them lists a minority of its shares in time. Where the State builds a steel plant or an oil company, the public may own a part of it, and the company must publish what it earns."

"A good principle," Shroff said.

"The second is the Securities and Markets (Creation and Regulation) Act. It would create a body with legal power over every exchange and every public issue in the Union. I propose to call it the Bharat Securities and Exchange Commission."

Nehru stirred. "A commission. The Government already has the Controller."

"It would replace him, Jawaharlal, and that is where I expect the quarrel to be." Ram looked down the table. "The Controller is an official of the Finance Ministry. He answers to the Minister. If a Minister wishes to favour a friend, or ruin a competitor, the Controller’s pen is the instrument. The Commission would be independent.

"Statutory autonomy, on the pattern of the Reserve Bank. A chairman and four members appointed for fixed terms of five years, removable only by an inquiry before a High Court judge. A budget funded by a small levy on transactions, so that it need not beg the Finance Ministry for its staff."

Deshmukh’s pencil stopped. "A body modelled on the Reserve Bank."

"Do you object?"

"I am flattered. I am also worried." He thought for a moment. "Prime Minister, the Reserve Bank’s autonomy works because the Governor sits in a room with the Finance Minister every week and they argue, and then they settle. It is a human arrangement, resting on trust between two or three men. If you create a second such body and give it no habit of consultation, it will either be captured by the Ministry within five years, or it will go to war with it. I should like a rule that the chairman meets the Finance Minister and the Governor at least once a quarter, and that the Commission’s annual report is laid before Parliament and debated."

"Agreed."

"And I should like it to be made clear that the Commission does not regulate banks. The Reserve Bank does that. A bank that buys shares for its own account is a banking matter. A bank that underwrites an issue is a securities matter. The line is fine. I should prefer it drawn in the Act than in a quarrel."

"Draw it, Sir Chintaman. I trust your pencil."

Patel spoke for the first time. "What power would this Commission hold, apart from a salary?"

"It may license exchanges and brokers, and withdraw the licence. It may demand any record from any listed company. It may investigate fraud. And it may refer a promoter to the police."

"The police are mine," Patel said.

"Then I shall ask you to provide a unit. A small, trained body of officers who understand ledgers, attached to the Commission but under your Ministry’s discipline. A man who forges a balance sheet has stolen from a hundred thousand people. He should be treated as a dacoit."

Patel’s eyes brightened a little. "I have not thought of it that way. The Lahore bank failure in ’47. I remember a woman in the camp at Jullundur who had put her husband’s whole pension in it. She sat on a charpoy and said that a man who robbed her with a pen was worse than a man who had killed her son, because the second was an act of war and the first was an act of business." He tapped his cane. "I shall give you the unit, and I should like the penalties to be heavy. Not fines. Imprisonment."

"Up to seven years for fraud on investors, and a lifetime bar from any directorship."

"Ten years."

"Ten, then."

Shroff gave a dry, wincing smile. "I hope no promoter is listening."

"I hope they all are," Ram said. "Now, the substance. The rules the Commission must enforce. First, mandatory audited disclosure. Every listed company must publish audited accounts every six months, in a prescribed form, with the names and holdings of its directors, its loans, its related-party transactions, and its major contracts.

"The prospectus must carry the same. No company may issue shares without disclosing everything a prudent buyer would wish to know. Second, the abolition of price-fixing. The promoter and his bankers will set the price. The Commission will not. Third, the Commission may refuse registration if the prospectus is misleading, though not merely because it dislikes the price."

Shroff leaned forward. "Prime Minister, there is the gap I mentioned. If the price is free, and the promoter is clever, he may set it absurdly high, and sell to a public who cannot judge. Disclosure helps the man who reads the prospectus. Most of our buyers cannot read."

"What would you add?"

"Three safeguards. First, an independent valuation for any company that has not yet earned a profit: a firm of chartered accountants, appointed by the Commission, not the promoter, who examines the plan and states a range of fair value. The prospectus must print it in plain type on the first page.

"Second, an underwriter of standing, a bank or a financial house, which commits its own money to the issue. If the underwriter will not buy, the public should wonder why. Third, a period of six months after each issue in which the promoter may not sell any of his own shares. A man who has priced a company honestly will not fear to hold it."

"A lock-in," Ram said, writing. "I accept all three."

A/N: Let me know your thoughts in the comments and reviews. Add the story to your library/collection to receive update notifications. Power stones are welcome as always.