The Morning Star:Chains of the Deep · Contents

CHAPTER 34

Chapter 33: Keeper of the Hollow

31 min read·David_B_

On the clifftop above the Boiling Hole, Phibba was dying, and she knew it.

She sat on her litter with her back against Clementine’s chest. She couldn’t hold herself up anymore. She hadn’t been able to for an hour. Clementine had crawled across the burning clifftop on her blistered hands and knelt behind her and taken the old woman’s weight against her own body, and held on.

Barnaby’s body still lay across Phibba’s legs. Nobody had moved him. Nobody could bear to.

Yaw knelt beside the litter with Phibba’s hand in his. It was cold. Colder than the night. So thin he could feel every bone.

The fog was still coming out of her. But slowly now. A thin grey thread, rising from her lips and from the bowl of her cold pipe, drifting down over the edge of the cliff. The last of it.

"Kofi Brook," Phibba whispered again.

Her voice went out on the fog. Yaw watched it go. A breath of grey carrying the words down the cliff, out over the black water, across the cove.

"Shipwright," she said. "You hear me?"

In the powder room of the Morning Star, Kofi heard her.

The voice came out of the planks. Out of the air. Out of the faint grey haze that still hung in the lead-lined room. It was so close she might have been kneeling beside him.

"I hear you," he said.

Toby’s head was in his lap. Toby’s blood was on his hands, hot and wet, pouring through his fingers no matter how hard he pressed. Toby’s eyes were half open.

"Thirty years I hide them." Phibba’s voice was the faintest thread. "In the fog. In the dark. In the rock. Hiding was all I knew to do."

A breath. A long pause. So long Kofi thought she was gone.

"You don’t hide them. You hear? You keep them. Out in the light, where anybody can see, and nobody can take."

"Phibba—"

"Keeper of the Hollow," she whispered. "It’s yours now."

Kofi pressed his forehead against Toby’s.

"I’ll keep it," he said. "I promise."

He felt her smile. He couldn’t have explained how. He felt it the way you feel the sun come out behind you.

On the clifftop, Phibba turned her head. Slowly. It took her a long time. She looked at Yaw kneeling beside her with her hand in his.

"Legba’s boy," she said.

Yaw’s throat closed. He couldn’t answer. He nodded.

"You open a door for an old woman tonight." Her eyes drifted shut. "When I go through mine, you hold it open a little while. So I can look back at them."

Yaw bowed his head over her hand.

"I’ll hold it as long as you want," he said. "As long as you want, Grann."

Phibba’s fingers moved in his. Then she let go.

She reached up instead, slowly, slowly, past her own shoulder, to where Clementine’s face was pressed against the back of her head. Clementine was crying without a sound. Her tears ran down into Phibba’s grey hair.

The old woman’s thin fingers found Clementine’s hair. They moved through it, the way a mother’s fingers move through a child’s hair at night. And they found something. A leaf. Small and green and fresh, tangled in among the grey.

Phibba held it up in the moonlight that wasn’t there yet.

"Hush, root woman," she said. "Don’t cry."

Clementine made a sound like something breaking.

"All your life you give back," Phibba whispered. "Every drop of blood. Every seed. Everything you take, you pay for." She turned the leaf in her fingers. "Now let somebody give to you."

She pressed the leaf into Clementine’s palm and closed her fingers over it.

"Plant something where they put me," she said. "Something that blooms."

Then her hand dropped.

The pipe fell out of her mouth. It rolled across the litter and onto the rock with a small clay click.

The last thread of fog rose from her lips and drifted away over the edge of the cliff, thin and grey and slow, and went out over the water. And there was no more behind it.

Clementine held her. Yaw held her hand.

Her eyes were open. They were looking out over the cove. Toward the water. Toward the Hollow. Toward all of them.

The silence came over the whole cove at once.

Everyone felt it.

In the Hollow, under the broken breadfruit tree, Obi’s hands stopped on the drum. He didn’t know why. He just stopped. Beside him, Ezinne stopped singing. They looked at each other.

On the terraces, Bess lowered Tanty Abba’s iron pot. Tanty Abba stopped laughing at the goats. Quashie, sitting on the path where he’d fallen, put his hand over his mouth.

On the Morning Star, Kofi lifted his head.

In the guard boat that had slipped back out toward the cave mouth to help, Titus stopped rowing, and Theo lowered Persuasion.

Even the Navy men felt it. The soldiers on the terraces, sneezing and stumbling, went still. The sailors in the last guard boat, bailing and shouting, stopped. Out on the crippled Vigilant, Bosun Pike lowered his match from the touchhole of a gun and stood there without knowing why he’d done it.

Something had gone out of the world.

On the rocks below the cliff, Bell had stopped too. He stood with one hoof raised over Anne, his chains burning around him. He turned his heavy head and looked up at the cliff.

For one long breath, there was no sound in the whole cove but the sea.

Then the fog began to lift.

It went all at once.

It didn’t drift away. It didn’t thin slowly, the way morning fog does. It simply let go. The great grey blanket that had covered the cove all night, that had hidden the ships and the cave mouth and the rocks and the water, rose up off the sea in a single long breath. It went up the face of the cliff. Up past the clifftop. Up into the night sky. And there, high over Cat Island, it came apart into wisps and was gone.

Behind it, the moon was waiting.

It had climbed high while the fog hid it. Past full and waning, lopsided, silver-white, riding in a sky so clear that every star stood out around it. Its light came down over the cove like a white sheet thrown over a bed.

It lit the black water. The rocks. The cave mouth. The wreckage of the guard boats. The Morning Star at anchor, her patched sails grey in the moonlight. Far out on the sea, the crippled Vigilant, wallowing.

It lit Captain Edmund Bell.

He was still standing over Anne on the rocks, one hoof raised. The moonlight touched his black bull’s shoulder.

His skin began to smoke.

Bell screamed.

The smoke poured off him wherever the moonlight touched. Off his back. His arms. His thick neck. His skin blistered and split. The black hide of the bull, the part of him that was the Rolling Calf, cracked open like burned bread, and underneath it was a man. Ordinary skin, raw and burning.

He staggered back off Anne. He threw his arms over his face. The chains around his shoulders flickered. Went dim. Faded. They hung off him grey and lifeless, as though someone had poured water on a fire.

The hoof came down, and it wasn’t a hoof anymore. It was a boot. Torn and blackened, but a boot.

Bell fell to his knees on the rocks, human again, his arms over his face, the moon burning down on him. He was screaming.

Anne lay on the rocks a few paces away, staring at him.

"The moon," Mary breathed. She had dragged herself up out of the water. "Beneba used to say. When we were small. The Rolling Calf won’t come out when the moon is bright."

Anne didn’t answer. She was staring at her father on his knees in the moonlight with smoke rising off his skin.

He was still screaming.

On the Morning Star, Kofi felt the fog go.

He felt the moon come out. He felt something in the cove change. And under all of it, faint, coming up out of the water through the hull, the drowned.

He’s burning, shipwright. The chain man. The moon is burning him.

But he’ll get up. He’ll get up again. And the girls can’t hold him.

Kofi looked down at Toby.

Toby’s eyes were open. He was looking up at Kofi, and his lips were moving.

"Go," Toby said.

"You’re bleeding out."

"I been bleeding out for two days." Toby tried to smile. It didn’t work. "Go on, Kofi. I’ll keep."

Kofi took Toby’s own hand and pressed it over the wound. Hard.

"Hold that," he said. "Don’t let go. Not for anything."

He looked at Toby. And with his white eyes, he saw something hanging in the air above Toby’s chest. Faint. Round. A clock face drawn in pale light. And around its edge, small marks. Some of them already dark.

Not many. But some.

Kofi made himself look away.

"Hold on," he said again.

Then he was up the ladder. Across the dark deck. Past the four tied sailors, who shrank back against the mast when they saw his eyes. To the stern rail.

He looked out across the moonlit water toward the rocks below the cliff. A cable’s length. Two hundred yards of open water. Too far to row in time. Too far to swim.

He didn’t have time to think about it.

He went over the rail.

The water closed over his head.

It was cold. As cold as it had been in the deep, when Bell’s chains had dragged him down and the sea came in. He came up gasping.

And they were there.

The drowned. All around him. Rising up out of the black water under the moon, pale faces, pale hands, weed in their hair. More than he could count. Sailors and fishermen and men with iron rings rusted around their ankles. The woman with her long hair floating. A boy.

Where, shipwright? they said. Where do you want to go?

"There," Kofi gasped. "The rocks. Quickly."

The hands closed around him.

Under his arms. Around his legs. At his back. At his feet. Dozens of them, cold and soft and strong. They lifted him. Not out of the water. Through it. Along it. He felt himself begin to move, faster than any man could swim, faster than a boat could row, skimming along the surface of the moonlit sea on a current of the dead.

The water hissed past him. The Morning Star fell away behind.

The Drowned Road, something deep in him whispered. A voice that laughed. That’s what it’s for, shipwright. That’s your road. Every soul the sea ever took, they all walk it. And they carry who they choose.

He felt the cost.

Every hand that held him took something from him. Warmth. Breath. A little piece of the life in his chest. He felt it draining out of him into the cold hands of the dead. His fingers went numb. Then his arms. Frost formed on his eyebrows and his beard. His breath came out white and froze on his lips.

The rocks came closer. He could see them now in the moonlight. Bell on his knees, screaming. Anne lying on the stone. Mary crouched beside her.

And far away, under everything, he remembered that the Baron’s gift had already saved him once tonight. The Undug Grave. He’d felt it go, down in the deep, when his body turned to coffin wood. He knew without knowing how that it wouldn’t come again. Not for a long time.

If Bell struck him once, he would die. For good. For real. And the sea would not give him back again.

The drowned set him down on the rocks.

He landed on his feet and nearly fell.

His legs wouldn’t hold him. He caught himself against a boulder. He was shaking so hard his teeth rattled. Frost crusted his beard and his hair. His breath smoked in the moonlight.

Bell was getting up.

The moonlight still burned him. His skin was still smoking. But he was getting up. He was on one knee, then the other foot. He’d lost his saber in the water. He reached out blindly beside him and his hand closed around something in the wreckage of a guard boat that had drifted against the rocks. A boarding pike. Eight feet of ash with an iron head.

He came up holding it. His face was a ruin. Blistered and raw and black with soot. But his eyes were still burning. Not red now. Human. Grey. Cold. And they found Kofi standing at the edge of the rocks.

"Brook," he said. His voice was hoarse with screaming.

Kofi didn’t answer. He couldn’t. It took everything he had just to stand.

Bell came at him.

He wasn’t a Rolling Calf anymore. The moon had taken that. But he was still a Navy captain who had been fighting with blades since he was a boy, and the pike was eight feet long, and Kofi could barely lift his arms.

The pike came at his chest. Kofi got the sheath up and turned it. Barely. The iron head scraped past his ribs. Bell reversed the pike and swung the butt at his head. Kofi ducked. Too slow. The ash shaft clipped his skull and he went down on one knee, the world flashing white.

Bell raised the pike over him.

From the rocks behind Bell, a voice cut across the cove.

"Your left hand!"

Anne. On her knees on the stone. Blood on her face. Her burning blade lying beside her.

"Kofi! Strike with your left! Your left hand!"

Kofi didn’t understand. He didn’t have time to understand. But he heard it in her voice, the same certainty he’d heard when she’d taught him to let the fog come, back on the deck of the Morning Star in the cove at Saint-Domingue.

Trust me, she’d said then. My spirit’s married to yours.

The pike came down.

Kofi laughed.

It came up out of him without warning. From somewhere deep, deeper than his chest, deeper than his bones. It wasn’t his laugh. He had never laughed like that in his life. It was huge. Booming. It rolled out of him across the rocks and the moonlit water and the cave mouth and up the face of the cliff, and it echoed. It echoed off everything, the way a laugh echoes in an empty tomb. It rattled like old bones in a sack.

It was the Baron’s laugh. It came out of Kofi’s mouth.

And everything that heard it lost its mind.

Bell’s pike stopped in mid-swing. His arms jerked. His whole body jerked, as though someone had pulled strings tied to his limbs. His mouth fell open. And out of it came a laugh. Thin, high, hysterical, horrified. He couldn’t stop it. He stood on the rocks with the pike frozen over his head and laughed, and his feet began to move under him, shuffling, twitching, a horrible jerking dance on the wet stone.

Out on the water, in the last guard boat, six Navy sailors dropped their oars and stood up and began to dance. Laughing. Weeping. Their arms flailing. One of them fell over the side and came up laughing, still dancing in the water.

On the deck of the Vigilant, far out, Bosun Pike sat down hard on a gun carriage and laughed until he couldn’t breathe, tears running down his face, his match falling from his fingers.

Kofi rose to his feet.

The laugh was still coming out of him. He couldn’t stop it. He didn’t want to stop it.

That was what frightened him.

It felt good. It felt so good. He stood on the rocks in the moonlight with frost in his beard and blood on his face and watched Captain Edmund Bell jerk and dance and laugh like a puppet on a string, and something in Kofi was enjoying it. Grinning. Delighting in it. The way a man delights in a joke at a funeral.

Yes, something whispered inside him. Yes, shipwright. Look at him dance. The great man. The chain that hunts. Look at him dance for us.

Kofi felt the grin on his own face. He hadn’t put it there.

He stopped laughing.

It took everything he had. He clenched his teeth on it. He swallowed it. He felt it fight him, like a horse fighting the bit. Then it was gone.

The echoes rolled away across the cove.

Bell stood in front of him, gasping, his arms still jerking. The pike hung loose in his hands. His guard was wide open.

Kofi held out his left hand.

The sheath had fallen when the pike clipped him. It lay on the rocks two paces away. He didn’t look at it. He just held out his hand.

Come here.

It flew into his palm.

He swung it.

Left-handed. The grave-cross sheath, black wood and iron-capped, in a short, hard arc. He had swung a mallet left-handed ten thousand times in the shipyard, driving treenails into keels. He knew exactly how to put a man’s whole weight into a blow from the left.

The sheath hit Bell in the chest.

There was a sound like glass shattering.

Something broke around Bell. Something Kofi hadn’t known was there until he felt it go. A shell. A ward. An invisible armor of iron and chain that had been wrapped around the man the whole night, turning blades, turning fire, turning the drowned away. It cracked under the black wood and exploded outward in a burst of grey fragments that faded into the moonlight.

Bell flew backward.

He hit the rocks hard on his back. The pike went spinning away into the water. He lay there on the wet stone in the moonlight, gasping, his chest caved where the sheath had struck him.

He didn’t get up.

Kofi walked across the rocks to him.

Every step was a fight. His legs were ice. His hands were ice. He came and stood over Bell and looked down at him.

Bell looked up.

His face was burned and blistered. Blood ran from his nose and the corner of his mouth. His chest heaved. His grey eyes met Kofi’s white ones, and for the first time, there was something in them Kofi had never seen there.

Fear.

Kofi set the point of the dark blade against Bell’s throat.

Yes.

The voice was inside him. In his chest. In his skull. Deep and rough and laughing, the voice from the gravestone at the Baron’s cross.

Go on, shipwright. Finish it. He took the old woman’s fog. He chained you in the water. He’ll come back. You know he’ll come back. You know what he did to the boy in the rigging. You know what he’s done to every name in that book of his.

Kofi’s hand was steady on the blade.

Finish it. One push. Put him in the ground. Give me another one for my yard.

He looked down at Bell. At the man who had hunted him across the whole Caribbean. Who had killed Amara through Cross’s whip. Who had strangled a ship’s boy for singing. Who had a book full of names.

He could do it. The blade was already at the man’s throat. One push.

Do it.

He thought about Sterling. Standing up out of his own body in the dark of the powder room, lost and small and frightened. Take me home. He thought about carrying that grey, thin shape home, his master, and how the Baron had laughed. Almost proud.

He thought about what the Baron had said on the gravestone. The dead don’t eat guilt.

The dead didn’t eat revenge, either. Only the living did. And it ate them.

"No," Kofi said.

Shipwright—

"No." He said it out loud. To the voice inside him. To the grin still trying to creep back onto his face. To Bell. "I’m not you."

He didn’t know which of them he meant. Maybe both.

He lifted the blade away from Bell’s throat.

The voice inside him went quiet. Not angry. Not pleased. Quiet. Watching. The way a man goes quiet when someone he’s been underestimating does something he didn’t expect.

Bell stared up at him from the rocks.

"Why," he whispered.

Kofi looked down at him for a long moment.

"Because I’m not finished building," he said. "And you’re not worth the time."

He turned away.

The water beside the rocks bulged.

Kofi heard it before he saw it. A long, deep, rushing sound, like the sea drawing breath. He turned. The black water at the edge of the rocks was rising, swelling, a great hump of it coming up out of the moonlit sea.

The arms came out of it.

Grey-purple, the color of old bruises. Thick as a mast at the base. Lined with pale round cups. They rose up out of the water higher than Kofi’s head, dripping, gleaming in the moonlight.

The old man below had followed the drum all night. He had dragged the black sloop down. He had chased the Vigilant out to sea. And now he had come back, to the place where the cold iron had lain across his door. To the man who had put it there.

The arms came down.

They wrapped around Bell where he lay on the rocks. Around his legs. Around his chest. Around his arms. Bell screamed once, a short, choked sound. The arms lifted him off the stone. Held him up in the moonlight, twisting, struggling.

Then they pulled him under.

He went into the black water with barely a splash. The arms went down after him. The swell rolled across the rocks and slapped against the cliff, and then the surface was flat and black and silver under the moon, and there was nothing there.

Kofi stood at the water’s edge.

He hadn’t killed him. He’d chosen not to. And now the sea had taken him anyway.

He didn’t know what he felt.

Behind him, someone moved.

Anne. She’d been kneeling on the rocks with Mary beside her, watching. Now she was on her feet. She was staring at the flat black water where Bell had gone under.

Her face was white. Even under the stain on her skin, Kofi could see it.

"Anne," Mary said quietly.

Anne didn’t answer. She took two steps to the edge of the rocks. She let her cutlass fall from her hand. It clattered on the stone.

And she dove in.

She went into the black water in a clean arc, the way a fisherman’s child dives off a dock. The surface closed over her. The ripples spread out in the moonlight.

Kofi stood frozen at the water’s edge.

Mary had come to stand beside him. She didn’t move. She didn’t shout. She just stood there with her stilettos hanging from her hands, staring at the place where her sister had gone in.

"What is she doing?" Kofi said.

Mary didn’t answer.

The ripples faded. The water went flat again.

Nothing came up.

Kofi’s heart was pounding. He looked at Mary. She was still staring at the water. Her eyes were wet. Her face was perfectly still.

Then, far down the rocks, a hundred paces away, at the place where the cliff met the sea and a few flat boulders stood out of the water, the surface broke.

Anne came up.

She was gasping. Choking. Her arm was hooked under the arm of a man, holding his head above the water. A man in a burned and tattered Navy coat, with a blistered face. His eyes were closed. His head lolled against her shoulder.

She swam to the flat boulders, dragging him. She heaved him up onto the nearest one. It took her three tries. She climbed up after him and rolled him onto his side. She pressed on his back, hard, once, twice, three times.

He coughed. Sea water poured out of his mouth. He coughed again.

He didn’t open his eyes.

Anne knelt beside him on the boulder. She looked down at him for a long moment.

Then she reached out. Slowly. And brushed the wet hair off his forehead with her fingers. The way you’d brush the hair off a sleeping child’s face.

Out on the water, beyond the rocks, oars were splashing. A boat was coming. A longboat from the Vigilant, with a lantern in its bow and men shouting a name.

"Captain! Captain Bell!"

Anne stood up.

She dove off the far side of the boulder and was gone, swimming hard through the black water back along the rocks.

Kofi turned to Mary.

Mary was still standing beside him. She had seen all of it. Every moment.

"Why?" Kofi said. "After everything. Why would she save him?"

Mary didn’t answer for a long time. She was watching the Vigilant’s longboat reach the boulder. Watching the sailors haul the limp, burned man up off the rock and into the boat.

"Because we’re not him," she said finally. Very quietly. "That’s all. We’re not him."

She turned and walked away along the rocks toward the place where her sister would come out of the water.

Kofi stood alone at the edge of the sea and watched the longboat pull away toward the Vigilant, carrying Captain Edmund Bell. Alive.

He didn’t understand. He knew he didn’t understand.

But he’d heard Anne shout your left hand, and he’d heard Mary say Beneba used to say. And for the first time, standing in the moonlight with frost in his beard, he wondered who these two women really were.

On the clifftop, the sky was turning grey in the east.

Yaw had held Phibba’s hand until it went cold. He’d held it open, the door, the way she’d asked. He didn’t know if he’d done it right. He didn’t know if she’d looked back. He held it anyway, until Clementine finally touched his shoulder and he let go.

Now he stood at the edge of the bush with his pistols in his hands and Latch at his side.

Something was coming out of the Boiling Hole.

He’d been watching it for an hour. A small, guttering ball of fire, half drowned, dragging itself up out of the black salt water onto the rocks at the lake’s edge. It had been crawling toward the clifftop ever since. Slowly. Painfully. Leaving a trail of steam behind it in the scrub. Toward the place where it had left its skin.

The skin still lay on the rock where Cross had torn out of it hours ago. Crumpled. Empty. Its face still Cross’s face.

Clementine was kneeling beside it.

She had a little leather pouch open in her blistered hands. She’d carried it for twenty years to clean wounds and draw out poison. Coarse grey salt. She’d spent the last half hour pouring it, handful by handful, over every inch of the empty skin. Into its face. Down its arms. Into its open mouth.

She stood up and stepped back as the fire came out of the scrub.

It was so small now. No bigger than a man’s head. Dim and flickering, blue barely showing at its heart. The hunger had eaten almost all of it. Yaw could hear the thin dry voice underneath the crackle, the spirit inside, starving.

Skin. Skin skin skin. The sun. The sun is coming. Must get in. Must get in before the sun.

The fire stopped.

It hung in the air above the salted skin. Trembling.

In the east, over the sea, the grey light was spreading. A thin pale line along the edge of the world. Getting brighter.

Before the sun. Before the sun. Must. Must.

"It’s salted, Cross," Clementine said. Her voice was hoarse. "Every inch of it."

The fire didn’t answer.

"If you go back in, it’ll burn you. And if you don’t go back in before the sun comes up, you’ll turn to ash."

Still nothing.

Yaw raised his pistol. He didn’t fire. He’d learned that much tonight. You don’t waste a shot.

The grey line on the horizon turned faintly pink.

The fire screamed and dove into the skin.

The skin came alive.

It sat up off the rock with a jerk. Its arms flailed. Its legs kicked. Its face, Cross’s face, contorted. Its mouth opened wide. And out of the open mouth, out of its eyes, out of every pore, smoke poured. Black and stinking. The salt was burning it. Burning it from the inside, everywhere the fire touched.

Cross screamed.

He was inside his own skin again, and his own skin was killing him. He rolled across the rock, clawing at himself. His fingernails tore at his own arms. He got to his knees. To his feet. He staggered, smoking, toward the edge of the cliff. Toward the sea. Toward the only thing that might wash the salt off.

"Latch," Yaw said quietly.

The dog grew.

He grew faster than he ever had, grey-gold and burning-eyed, horse-sized. And as he grew, something else happened. Yaw felt it tear through his chest like a knife. The dog’s head split. A second head pushed out of his neck beside the first. Two heads. Two sets of jaws.

It nearly killed Yaw to make it. He went down on one knee, gasping.

But he’d made it.

Latch hit Cross at the edge of the cliff. Both heads at once. One caught his arm. The other caught his leg. Cross screamed and fought, thrashing, smoking, burning with salt. The sky behind him was going from pink to gold. The first edge of the sun was about to break the sea.

Cross looked at it.

Yaw saw his face. His real face, inside the burning skin. Terror. Pure terror. The sun was coming, and he was half in and half out of his own skin, and the salt was burning him, and a two-headed dog had him by the leg.

He tore free.

He didn’t pull his leg out of Latch’s jaws. He couldn’t. He pulled himself out of his leg. The skin of it tore off him at the knee, salted and smoking, and stayed in Latch’s mouth. And underneath it, where his leg should have been, there was nothing. Just smoke. Just a trailing wisp of blue-orange flame where the skin had been.

He threw himself off the cliff.

Yaw ran to the edge.

Below, far below, the sea was gold with the first light. He saw Cross hit the water in a great burst of steam and spray. He saw him come up. A man’s head, a man’s arms, thrashing. Half a man, with one leg gone at the knee. He saw a longboat from the Vigilant, already turning toward him.

Yaw raised his pistol.

He had a clear shot. The light was good now. Cross was in the water, helpless, a hundred feet below.

He thought of a girl under a mango tree, smiling at him. The scar on her chin. The faded blue cloth that was tied around his pistol grip right now, stirring in the dawn wind.

Carry me. But don’t use me.

He lowered the pistol.

"Amara," he said. Quietly. Just her name.

He watched the longboat pull Cross out of the sea. He watched it row away toward the Vigilant. He didn’t fire.

The sun came up over the edge of the world.

On the clifftop behind him, Latch had shrunk back down to a small yellow dog with one floppy ear. He trotted over to Yaw and sat down at his feet and dropped something on the rock beside his boot. Something limp and grey and still smoking faintly.

Yaw looked down at it.

"Thank you," he said to the dog. "I don’t want that."

Latch wagged his tail.

Yaw turned from the edge of the cliff.

The clifftop looked different in the daylight. The old silk-cotton tree at the edge of the Boiling Hole was black and smoking, half its branches burned away. Quamin sat against a rock with his shoulder bound. Cassia knelt beside Barnaby’s body with her face in her hands.

Phibba lay on her litter where she’d died. Somebody had closed her eyes. Somebody had put her cold pipe back in her hand.

Clementine was standing at the edge of the cliff, looking down at the cove.

Yaw went and stood beside her.

Below them, the whole cove lay open in the morning light. The black rocks at the foot of the cliff. The cave mouth. The Morning Star riding at anchor, her patched sails gold in the sun. Far out, the Vigilant limping south under her one good mast, her boats pulling for her, the last of Bell’s men aboard. Going away.

And on the rocks below the cliff, a man was sitting with his back against a boulder.

He was very still.

"Kofi," Clementine breathed.

"He’s alive," Yaw said. "He’s alive. Look, he’s moving."

Kofi had lifted his head. He was looking up at the cliff. Up at the two of them. He raised one hand. Very slowly. And let it fall.

"Toby’s on the ship," Clementine said suddenly. Her voice had changed. "Kofi was on the ship, before he came across. Toby’s on the ship, and something’s wrong. I can feel it." She turned to Yaw. "Can you get me down there? Fast?"

Yaw looked down at the cliff face. A hundred feet of sheer rock. Then he looked at the rock under his own boots.

He was so tired. He’d spent more tonight than he’d ever spent in his life. The doors through the stone. The door into the Boiling Hole. The two-headed dog.

He knelt and laid his hand flat on the rock.

Open, he thought. Just once more. Please. And open there.

He looked down at the flat boulder at the foot of the cliff, the one beside the place where Kofi sat.

The veve flared under his palm. Faint. Flickering. But there.

The rock opened.

Clementine came out of the stone at the foot of the cliff and dropped to her knees beside Kofi.

He was grey. Frost was still melting out of his beard. He looked up at her with eyes that were brown again, ordinary brown, red-rimmed and exhausted.

"Toby," he said. "On the ship. He’s bleeding out. I left him. I had to leave him—"

"I know."

Yaw came out of the rock behind her and fell flat on his face on the boulder and didn’t get up.

Mary was already pulling the jolly boat in along the rocks. Anne was in it, soaked and shivering, her cutlass back in her belt. Her face was white and set, and she didn’t look at anyone.

They got Kofi into the boat. They dragged Yaw in after him. Clementine climbed in last with her staff across her knees. Mary rowed.

Nobody said anything the whole way across the cove.

Toby was still holding the wound.

He was lying on the floor of the powder room where Kofi had left him, among the spilled black powder and the open keg and Sterling’s body. His hand was still pressed to his side. His eyes were closed. His face had gone the color of ashes.

Clementine knelt beside him.

She took his hand away from the wound. Gently. She looked at what was under it.

Her face didn’t change. But Kofi, standing in the doorway, saw her hands begin to shake.

He looked at Toby with eyes that were ordinary brown now. He couldn’t see the clock anymore. He didn’t need to.

"Can you?" he said.

Clementine didn’t answer. She laid her staff across Toby’s chest. She put both hands over the wound. She closed her eyes.

"Oka-rima," she whispered. "Oka-rima. Lo-senda ta."

The staff stirred. A green shoot pushed out of the burl at its head. Then another. They curled down onto Toby’s chest and across to his side. They found the wound and laced across it, thin and green and soft. And along them, one by one, small white flowers began to open.

But they were slow. So slow. Clementine had been drained by Cross’s mouth on her arm and the burning roots and the long night. She had almost nothing left to give.

She gave it anyway.

Kofi saw it happen. The green light rose in her veins, faint at first, then brighter, glowing under the skin of her hands and her wrists and her forearms. Brighter than he’d ever seen it. It ran down her arms into the vines. Into the flowers. Into Toby.

And it didn’t fade when she stopped.

Faint green lines stayed under the skin of her wrists. Like veins full of sap. Glowing softly in the dim powder room. She looked down at them and didn’t seem surprised.

Under the white flowers, the bleeding slowed.

Then it stopped.

Toby drew a long, shuddering breath. His eyes didn’t open. But his chest rose, and fell, and rose again.

Clementine sat back on her heels. She was so tired she couldn’t hold herself up. Kofi caught her before she fell.

She looked up at him. Her eyes were wet.

"He’ll keep," she said. "He’ll keep."

Then she reached into her apron and took out something small and green. A leaf. The leaf Phibba had pressed into her palm on the clifftop, in the dark, with her last strength. She held it for a long moment.

"She told me to plant something," Clementine said. "Where they put her."

"We’ll plant it," Kofi said. "Something that blooms."

The sun was well up when Kofi finally came up on deck.

He stood at the stern rail of the Morning Star in the morning light and looked out at the cove.

It looked so small in daylight. The black rocks at the foot of the cliff, where he’d fought all night. The cave mouth, open now, with no chain across it, the morning tide running in and out of it. Somewhere beyond it, deep in the rock, the Hollow. He didn’t know yet how much of it was left.

Far out on the sea, the Vigilant was a small grey shape limping south, getting smaller.

Bell was aboard her. Alive. Because Kofi had chosen to let him live, and because Anne had dived into the sea after him for reasons Kofi didn’t understand. Cross was aboard her too, with one leg gone.

They would come back. He knew they would come back.

Up on the clifftop, small figures were moving. People had come up through the tunnels from the Hollow. He could see them gathering around a litter at the edge of the cliff. Standing very still.

He thought of Phibba’s voice in the dark. You don’t hide them. You keep them. Out in the light, where anybody can see, and nobody can take.

The fog was gone. For the first time in thirty years, Cat Island stood bare in the sun for anyone to see. Every ship that passed. Every captain with a glass.

Nothing would hide the Hollow now.

Only him.

He put his hand on the skull of his cane and looked up at the small figures on the cliff in the bright morning light.

"Keeper," he said quietly, to no one. Trying the word.

It was heavier than the cane. Heavier than anything he’d ever carried.

He didn’t put it down.