The Morning Star:Chains of the Deep · Contents

CHAPTER 50

Chapter 49: The Evening Tide

24 min read·David_B_

The Spaniard’s boat touched the stone quay below the governor’s house, and Mondragón stepped out of it onto the steps without once looking back.

Kofi stood at the windlass with his hands still on the bar. All around him the crew had gone still, half-crouched over the cable they’d been heaving, as though somebody had stopped a clock.

"Let it go," he told them. "Pay it back out. We’re not going anywhere."

The cable rumbled back through the hawse. The Morning Star settled on her anchor again under the grey walls of the Castillo, and the gulls came back to her rail.

Theo still had the glass in his hand. He was staring at the bar, at the white line of broken water across the inlet that had been deep enough to cross an hour ago and was getting shallower with every wave.

"Twelve hours," he muttered. "The next high water is at dusk."

"Then we have till dusk." Kofi turned to look across at the sloop. Hilaire still stood by her mast with his hands bound behind him, looking back at them. He didn’t signal again. He only looked.

Two fingers. A fist on the thigh, once, slow.

Kofi turned it over in his head, and couldn’t make it mean anything.

The sargento mayor came out to them at noon.

He came in a big boat with ten soldiers at the oars and ten more sitting in the stern with their muskets upright between their knees. He was a tall, stooped, tired-looking man with a grey moustache and a sword that had seen better years. He climbed the side as though his knees hurt him, and stood on the Morning Star’s deck looking around him with no expression at all.

Mondragón came up the side behind him.

He wasn’t carrying anything. He had no dogs with him, and no weapon Kofi could see. He stepped onto the deck and folded his hands in front of him over his rosary and stood one pace behind the officer’s shoulder, like a priest at a wedding.

Clementine was sitting under her sailcloth. Kofi saw her go rigid.

The Spaniard’s eyes went over the deck the way they always did, low, along the planks, to the feet and the hands. They found Clementine’s bare feet beneath the sailcloth and stayed there.

"Madre," he murmured. "You look tired."

Clementine said nothing. Kofi moved without deciding to, so that he stood between them.

"Capitán Marchand." The officer looked at Theo. He spoke in Spanish, taking his time, and Theo answered him, and for a few moments the two of them went back and forth while Kofi stood with his hands at his sides and understood one word in four. Then the officer gestured at Mondragón, and Mondragón spoke.

He spoke in Spanish too. But halfway through, he turned his head a little toward Kofi, and switched to English, and Kofi knew he did it so that every soul on the deck would understand him.

"The captain says this is a French ship," Mondragón told the officer, soft as a priest. "From Martinique. He shows a French paper with a French seal. He flies a French flag." He let his eyes drift up to it, to the gold paint, and back down. "Very well. Let us say it is a French ship."

He turned his palm up, toward the crew.

"Then these are French slaves."

The deck went silent.

"The King of France is our King’s ally," Mondragón went on, in the same soft voice. "Allies return each other’s property. That is the law between friends. If this is a French ship, then every one of these people belongs to some French master in Saint-Domingue or Martinique, and it is my duty to hold them for him." He bowed his head a little to the officer. "And my pleasure."

Theo had gone white to the lips.

Kofi looked at the French flag at the masthead, with its runny gold lilies, that Theo had sewn with his own hands so they could sail in here safe. He looked at the Spaniard’s folded hands. He understood, all at once, why the man had smiled at it from his boat that morning.

The flag that was supposed to protect them was the chain.

"It’s not a French ship."

Kofi heard himself say it before he had decided to. Theo turned and stared at him. The officer’s tired eyes moved to Kofi’s face for the first time.

He made himself speak one plain word at a time, so that Theo could put it into Spanish. "She was built at Brook’s Reach, in Jamaica. By me. I stole her. Everybody on her deck ran from an English master. Jamaica, Saint-Domingue, the Turks. We’re runaways. Most of us English runaways." He took a breath. "And I hear the King of Spain has a law about English runaways."

Theo closed his eyes for a moment. Then he opened them and began to translate, his voice flat.

The officer listened. When Theo finished, he looked at Kofi for a long time. Then, for the first time, something moved in his tired face that might have been amusement.

He spoke. Theo translated.

"He says that is true. Any slave who flees the English and comes to Florida and asks for baptism is free under the King’s law. He would not send any of you back to the English. He hates the English." Theo swallowed. "But he says if this is an English ship, then it’s an enemy ship in a Spanish harbor in time of war. She’s a lawful prize. The ship belongs to the King of Spain."

"And the people on her?"

Theo asked. The officer answered.

"Free." Theo’s voice had gone hoarse. "If they stay. If they go ashore and ask for baptism and live here under the King. Free, and safe, and Florida’s." He looked at Kofi. "Without the ship."

Mondragón smiled.

He didn’t say a word. He didn’t have to. Kofi could see it all laid out in the man’s folded hands. If they were French, he took them all. If they were English, they lost the ship and stayed here on this sandbar of a colony, and the Current died, and the Hollow starved. And Clementine would sit in San Agustín with the Leash on her shoulder for the rest of her life, free, with a black dog lying in the street outside her door, waiting for the day she set foot on a ship again.

The officer spoke again, to Theo, and then turned toward the side.

"He says decide by the evening gun," Theo told the deck. "French, or English. If we haven’t sent a boat ashore by then, he’ll come back and decide for us."

The officer went down into his boat. Mondragón paused at the top of the side and looked, not at Kofi, but at Clementine’s feet under the sailcloth.

"There is no hurry, Madre," he told her. "There never is."

Then he followed the officer down, and the boat pulled away toward the town.

Kofi called them to the mainmast in the heat of the afternoon. Every soul aboard came, even Clementine, on Toby’s arm.

"I’m not deciding this," he told them. "I can’t. It isn’t mine."

He laid it out in plain words, so nobody could say afterward that they hadn’t understood. Stay, and ask for baptism, and be free in Florida, free by the King of Spain’s own law, with a paper to prove it and soldiers to protect it. Or sail at dusk on the high water, under the guns of that fort, with the hunter behind them, and go on running.

"If you stay," he told them, "nobody here will think less of you. I mean that. You’ll be free. Free in truth, today. I can’t promise anybody that on this ship."

Nobody spoke for a while. The water slapped against the hull.

Then Pompey stood up.

He was a quiet man, square and grey at the temples, who had pulled an oar at Kofi’s back since the night of the provision sloop and almost never spoke. He looked at Kofi, and then at the deck, and then out over the rail toward the market where the free fishermen were hauling up their boats.

"I’m forty-four years old." Pompey’s voice was low and rough. "I’ve been owned since I was born. I never once in my life walked down a street where nobody could stop me." He wiped his mouth. "I want to walk down a street, Kofi."

July stood up beside him. He was younger, thin, with a scar through one eyebrow. He didn’t say anything. He only nodded, and put his hand on Pompey’s shoulder.

Kofi felt something tighten in his chest. He made himself nod back.

"Then walk down it," he told them. "Walk down every street in this town."

He went over and took Pompey’s hand. It was hard and calloused, a rower’s hand. Pompey held on longer than he needed to.

"You’ve pulled an oar for me since the provision sloop," Kofi told him.

"You broke my brand," Pompey answered. "That’s a fair trade."

When Kofi turned to July, July hugged him, quick and hard, and then stood back looking embarrassed. Titus was behind Kofi. Kofi heard him step forward, and braced himself for something hard.

Titus held out his hand to July.

Titus’s voice came out gruff. "Mend your own net. You hear me? Every day. Mend your own net."

July took the hand and nodded, his eyes wet.

Kofi looked around at the rest of them.

"Anybody else?"

He looked at Bess. Bess was standing by the galley hatch with her arms crossed tight, looking at the deck. She didn’t look up.

Nobody else spoke.

Bess went ashore in the boat that carried Pompey and July. She watched them climb out onto the sand with their bundles over their shoulders and stand there a moment, looking up the street, as though they couldn’t believe nobody was going to stop them. Then Pompey took the first step, and July followed him, and they walked up into the town without looking back.

Bess found Ma Abla where she’d left her, at the end of the market under the thatch, sorting shrimp into baskets by size.

The old woman looked up at her and didn’t seem surprised. She moved over on her bench to make room.

"You come back."

"You said you’d teach me the rest of the words."

They sat in the shade while the afternoon went on around them, and Ma Abla sang the cradle song line by line, and Bess sang it back, and stumbled, and sang it again. The words were round and strange in her mouth. Each one felt like a stone she’d carried in her pocket all her life without knowing what was in it, and now somebody was showing her how to open it.

When she had it all the way through, Ma Abla patted her knee.

"You stay." It wasn’t a question. "Your mother’s people are here, child. Not many. A few. Old, like me. But here. You stay, and I teach you everything. All the songs. How we cook the fish, how we plait the hair. I make you a Popo woman."

Bess looked out across the bay at the Morning Star lying at anchor under the fort, with her bad flag hanging limp in the heat.

She thought about Toby washing his mother’s leaves six times till the water ran clear, and putting them in her hands. She thought about Clementine, who couldn’t go home. Ezinne with no voice. Kofi bent over his chalk letters on the deck. The bowl Ti Lune had set out for Quashie, steaming in the dark until there was no more steam.

"My people are on that ship," she told Ma Abla.

The old woman looked at her a long while. Then she nodded, as though Bess had said what she’d expected all along.

She reached up behind her own neck with both hands, and fumbled with a knot, and took off a thin cord that had been hanging inside her shirt. On it was a single small cowrie shell, worn smooth and pale as a tooth.

"My mother put this on me. On the beach at home, before the ship. She tell me, this is the sea that takes you, child. Now you carry a little of it, so it can carry you back." She put the cord over Bess’s head and settled the shell at the hollow of her throat. "I never go back. I am too old now. You carry it."

Bess put her hand over the shell. It was warm from the old woman’s skin.

"Dada," she whispered.

"Dada," Ma Abla agreed, and patted her cheek, and went back to sorting her shrimp.

The sun was going down behind the town when Kofi worked it out.

He was standing at the rail watching the sloop, the way he’d been watching it all afternoon. Hilaire was sitting at the foot of her mast now, his head down. Two of the Spaniard’s men lounged near him. The five black hounds lay along her rail, and every now and then one of them lifted its head and looked across the water at the Morning Star and laid it down again.

Theo came and stood beside him with a cup of water.

"High water in an hour," Theo told him. "Then the evening gun. Then they come."

"Two," Kofi muttered.

"What?"

"Two fingers." Kofi held them up. "He showed us two fingers. And then he hit his leg with his fist." He was still looking at the sloop. "Two. Theo, what’s two?"

Theo frowned. "Two men guarding him?"

"There are two men guarding him. But he didn’t know that this morning." Kofi watched the bar, where the water was beginning to rise and smooth over the shoals. "This morning we’d just missed the tide. What was he looking at? The tide. We missed the first tide. He was telling us—"

"The second tide," Theo breathed. "The evening tide."

"Two. The second tide." Kofi made a fist and struck it once, slow, against his own thigh. "And this. He’s going to fight. When we run, he means to come with us."

Theo stared at the sloop.

"How? He’s tied to a mast with five dogs on the rail."

Kofi turned around. Han was sitting cross-legged on the hatch cover in the shade with his tall black hat on his knee, eating an orange, watching them both with great interest.

"Han," Kofi called. "How many dogs can your fire lead?"

Han finished chewing. He spat out a seed.

"As many as you’ve got," he answered. "If they’re following a trail. Dogs that follow trails, they’re the easiest of all. My fire’s nothing but a trail." He tossed the orange peel over the rail. "And it’s nearly dark, Kofi Brook. In the dark, my goblin’s not homesick at all."

They went at the last of the light.

The evening gun hadn’t fired yet. The water over the bar had come up smooth and dark. In the bay, the Spaniard’s sloop lay quiet at her anchor, her two guards squatting by the mast with a lantern between them, and on the quay below the governor’s house a lantern burned too, and a slight figure in a dark coat stood beside it with his hands folded.

Han crouched in the bow of the Morning Star with his hat on his knee and his hand out flat over the water.

The light came up out of his palm, cold and blue-green, and drifted down onto the bay.

It didn’t go toward the sloop. It went past her, low over the water, bobbing, and as it went, it split, and split again, until there were five of them, drifting toward the open water on the far side of the bay, toward the dunes. They left a faint, silvery shimmer behind them on the surface, like the wake of a swimming thing.

On the sloop’s rail, a black head came up.

Then another. Then all five were standing, rigid, their coal-red eyes fixed on the drifting lights.

The first one went over the rail without a sound and into the black water. The other four went after it. They swam after the lights with their heads low and their backs barely breaking the surface, five dark shapes cutting five dark lines across the bay, away from the sloop, away from the ship, toward the far dunes where the goblin fire bobbed and danced.

On the quay, the slight figure took one step toward the edge.

"Now," Han breathed. He put on his hat.

He vanished.

Kofi heard the creak of the boat’s falls and a soft splash, and then nothing at all, though he stared at the dark water between the ship and the sloop until his eyes ached. Nobody could see the boat. Nobody could see Han. There was only the faint ripple of oars on the water where nothing was rowing.

On the sloop, one of the guards stood up and peered out at the bay after the dogs, puzzled, and called something to his friend.

Then Hilaire came up off the deck.

He came up from the foot of the mast with the cut ropes falling off his wrists, and he drove his fist into the side of the standing guard’s head with his whole weight behind it, and the man went over sideways and lay still. The second guard was halfway to his feet with his musket when something invisible hit him across the back of the knees, and he went down on his face, and Hilaire kicked the musket away into the scuppers.

Hilaire went over the rail. He dropped into the dark water beside the sloop, and was hauled up out of it by nothing, into a boat that wasn’t there.

On the quay, the lantern swung. A voice rose, sharp, in Spanish.

The evening gun fired from the Castillo.

"Weigh!" Kofi roared. "Weigh now, all of you! Theo, take her out!"

The windlass clanked and the cable came roaring in. The Morning Star swung on it, and broke free of the bottom, and Titus and Toby and Yaw hauled the topsail up hand over hand while the anchor was still coming dripping out of the water. The sails filled with a crack.

The boat came alongside out of nothing. Han pulled off his hat and appeared in the stern, grinning, with Hilaire collapsed in the bottom of the boat in front of him, soaked and gasping. Mary and Anne hauled them both up the side. Hilaire fell on the deck on his hands and knees, retching seawater.

"You took your time," he gasped.

"You told us the second tide," Kofi answered. "We came on the second tide."

Hilaire laughed, and choked, and kept laughing.

Up on the fort, a bugle was blowing. Lights were moving along the walls. On the seaward bastion, Kofi saw men running to the guns.

"Fog," he muttered. "Now."

He put his hands flat on the rail and called it.

It came up out of the bay around them, grey and cold, thickening by the breath, rolling out across the water toward the fort, until the lights on the walls were blurred smudges and then nothing. He felt it draw the warmth out of him, out of his fingers, out of his chest. The Castillo’s first gun went off somewhere in the grey, and the ball went howling over the masthead and threw up a column of water off the starboard bow.

At the helm, Theo turned his head toward the bow.

"Han!" he shouted. "I’ll make you a bet!"

Han looked up from the deck, where he’d sat down with his back against the rail and his hat in his lap.

"Now?"

"Now. Persuasion. My club against your hat." Theo’s hands were tight on the wheel. "I’ll take her over that bar in the dark, in this fog, and she won’t go aground."

Han’s face went still. Kofi saw the Law catch him, the way it had caught Yaw.

Han’s voice came out thick. "That’s a stupid bet, Frenchman."

"Do you take it?"

Han closed his eyes.

"I take it," he groaned. "God damn you, I take it. I can’t not."

"Mary!" Theo shouted. "Get in the chains with the lead. Call it loud!"

Then, from the quay behind them, across the water, through the fog, came the Howl.

It rose up out of the grey like the tide coming in, low and long and rising, and Kofi felt it take him.

His hands locked on the rail. His legs locked. His jaw locked. The fog around him wavered, and thinned, and began to drift apart, because he couldn’t hold it anymore, couldn’t hold anything, couldn’t even turn his head.

All along the deck, the crew froze where they stood. Titus at the main sheet, with the rope running out through his hands. Toby at the galley hatch. Yaw at the mast, with Latch rigid at his feet. Bess, with her hand still at her throat over the cowrie shell. Clementine on her pallet, her eyes wide and wet. Ezinne with her mouth open on a song she couldn’t sing. Obi. Han, against the rail, frozen with his hat in his hands and his eyes open.

The Morning Star leaned, and her sails began to shiver, and she started to come up into the wind with nobody to stop her.

Then Theo moved.

He moved at the wheel, the only thing moving on that whole deck. He spun the spokes, and caught her, and held her, and his face was grey and his teeth were bared.

"Anne!" he screamed. "The main sheet! Titus can’t hold it!"

Anne came off the quarterdeck in one leap. She tore the running rope out of Titus’s frozen hands, and braced her feet against the deck, and hauled, cursing, until the mainsail filled again and the ship leaned and gathered way.

And Mary was already in the forechains with the lead line, as though nothing had happened at all.

"By the mark, three!" she sang out, high and clear. "And a half, three! By the mark, three!"

There were three of them sailing the Morning Star. Theo, who had been born free and never owned by anyone. Anne and Mary, who had never been owned at all. Three, while everyone else stood carved out of wood on the deck around them.

The fort’s guns went off again. With the fog breaking up, they had a mark now. One ball went screaming through the rigging overhead and parted a backstay with a crack like a whip. The next one hit the larboard rail amidships.

It smashed the rail to splinters. A long jagged spar of oak went spinning across the deck, and Titus, frozen at the main sheet with his empty hands still held out in front of him, couldn’t move out of its way. It took him across the side. Kofi saw it hit. He saw the blood come through Titus’s shirt, and saw that Titus couldn’t even fall down.

He couldn’t move. He couldn’t move. He stood at the rail with his hands locked and screamed inside his own skull.

"And a half, two!" Mary sang out. Her voice had gone thin. "By the mark, two! Theo, two!"

"I know!" Theo shouted.

The bar was under them. Kofi could hear it, the hiss and rumble of the swell breaking across the shoals on either side. Theo stood at the wheel with his eyes shut, steering by Mary’s voice and the feel of the deck under his feet, and every time she called, he moved the wheel a spoke, or half a spoke, or a finger’s width.

"A quarter less two!" Mary’s voice cracked. "Theo—"

The keel touched.

It wasn’t a crash. It was a whisper, a long soft hiss under the hull, sand on wood, and the whole ship shuddered, and slowed.

Theo laughed. It was the high, breathless, terrified laugh Kofi knew from the banks of Cat Island, from the coral off Jamaica, from every time the sea had tried to kill them and Theo had laughed in its face. He threw the wheel over one full spoke and held it.

The swell came under them, lifted the Morning Star off the sand, and set her down again in deep water.

"By the deep, four!" Mary sang. "By the deep, five! Theo, five! We’re over! We’re over!"

And the Howl was gone.

It didn’t stop. It faded, the way a voice fades into distance, lost in the roar of the surf on the bar behind them, and Kofi’s hands came off the rail and he fell down on the deck.

All around him, people fell. Clementine was sobbing. Yaw was cursing. Hilaire lay where he’d fallen when they hauled him aboard, half-drowned, too spent to lift his head through any of it. Han sat against the rail breathing hard with his eyes still fixed on one place, on the forechains, where Mary was climbing back over the rail with the lead line coiled over her shoulder.

Titus lay on his side by the main sheet with blood soaking his shirt.

"Bess!" Kofi was on his knees beside him before he knew he’d moved. "Bess, Toby, here!"

Titus’s eyes were open. He was grey under his dark skin. He looked up at Kofi, and his mouth twisted.

"I couldn’t even fall over," he whispered. "All this time free, and that dog’s voice put me right back in the field."

"Don’t talk."

"I’ll talk if I want."

Bess knelt on his other side with her sewing kit already open and her mouth set. Toby brought the rum. The splinter had torn across Titus’s ribs on the left side, a long ugly gash, but it hadn’t gone in deep. Bess pulled the last of the oak out of it with her fingers while Titus cursed her, and Toby poured the rum in, and Titus cursed them both, and Bess began to sew.

Kofi held Titus’s hand until it was done.

Han came aft when the stitching was finished. He was holding Theo’s club.

Theo was still at the wheel. His hands hadn’t let go of it. He stood there with the ship running out into the open sea under the stars, and the fort’s lights dwindling behind them, and he looked as though he might never let go of anything again.

Han held out Persuasion.

"You touched," he told Theo.

"I touched," Theo agreed. "I didn’t go aground. She never stopped moving. Aground means stuck."

Han stared at him. Then a laugh began to shake out of him.

"That’s a dirty, filthy, lawyer’s argument, Frenchman."

"Is it wrong?"

Han looked down at his own chest, as though listening to something inside it. Then he laughed again, harder.

"No," he admitted. "It isn’t. My goblin says you win. My goblin likes you." He pushed the club into Theo’s hands. "Damn fine sailing, Frenchman. Damn fine."

Theo took Persuasion. He held it for a long moment. Then he tucked it back through his belt where it belonged, and his hands came off the wheel at last, and Kofi saw that they were shaking.

Han turned away. Halfway along the deck, he stopped.

Anne and Mary were standing together at the broken larboard rail, looking back at the last of the fort’s lights. Han looked at them. He looked for long enough that Anne felt it and turned around.

Han tilted his head. "You two didn’t freeze."

The deck went quiet.

Anne’s hand moved to the hilt of her cutlass and rested there, easy, the way a hand rests on a dog’s head.

"Neither did Theo," she answered.

"Theo was born free. He tells everybody who’ll listen." Han’s nose wrinkled. "You two weren’t born in any field. You don’t smell like it."

Mary had gone very still beside her sister.

Han looked from one of them to the other. Then he shrugged, and his grin came back, and he put his hat on his head.

"Not my business. I’m only the goblin." He walked on toward the bow. "But I’ll bet you somebody makes it his business, someday."

Anne didn’t answer him. She stood at the broken rail with her hand on her cutlass, and Mary beside her, until he’d gone below.

They found Hilaire in the bow an hour later, wrapped in a blanket, with Ezinne sitting beside him. She couldn’t talk to him. She had only sat down next to him and put her shoulder against his, and he’d let her.

He looked up when Kofi came forward.

"I’m sorry," Hilaire told him. "About the dog. About Grann’s village. About all of it."

"You came on the second tide," Kofi answered. "That’s enough."

Hilaire shook his head.

"Listen. There’s something else. I heard it on the sloop." He pulled the blanket tighter. "Two days ago, a boat came alongside off Cuba with a letter for the Spaniard. From the rider. The one with the horse. The Spaniard read it out loud to his men at supper, smiling the whole time." He swallowed. "It was about your man Quashie."

Kofi crouched down in front of him.

"Tell me."

"The rider’s had him a week. He’s been asking him where the Morning Star takes on water. Quashie wouldn’t say. Then, on the sixth day, he said." Hilaire looked up at him. "Mayaguana. The spring on the north side of Mayaguana. He said the Morning Star waters there every time she passes, regular as church."

Kofi stared at him.

Behind him, Theo had come forward from the wheel, with Persuasion back in his belt.

"Mayaguana?" Theo repeated. "We’ve never watered at Mayaguana. Not once. There’s barely any water there worth the name."

Kofi kept his voice low. "I know."

He looked out past the bow, south, toward the long empty sea and the islands somewhere beyond it, the scatter of them on Theo’s chart, Inagua at the bottom, Mayaguana just above.

"He lied to them," Theo breathed. "Quashie lied to the rider’s face."

"The rider’s taking his sloop to Mayaguana," Hilaire told them. "To wait. With Quashie aboard her, the letter said. In case he needs to ask again."

Kofi stood up.

Somewhere out there, on the empty north shore of Mayaguana, a patient man with a cough and a ledger was waiting by a spring nobody ever used, for a ship that was never coming. And sooner or later, he would understand that.

"And when the rider finds out he lied—" Kofi stopped.

Nobody answered him. Nobody needed to.

"Theo." Kofi didn’t take his eyes off the dark sea to the south. "How fast can you get us to Mayaguana?"